A karshe China ta yanke shawarar yin watsi da munanan manufofinta na sifiri-Covid. Dangane da mayar da martani, manyan gidajen labarai na Yamma sun bayyana yadda gaba daya kuma ba su da ma'ana game da barkewar cutar a China tun daga farko.
Shafin farko Labari in The New York Times daga Disamba 30, 2022, kyakkyawan misali ne. Taken: "Yaya Mummunar Barkewar Covid ta China? Wasan Hasashen Kimiyya ne" da alama yana da ma'ana. Kamar yadda babban jigon ya bayyana, akwai “rashin sahihan bayanai daga gwamnatin China,” don haka yana da wahala a gano ainihin abin da ke faruwa.
Sauran labarin ya ƙaryata ra'ayin cewa duk wani abu mai kama da hankali ya sanar da manema labarai da editoci a wannan jarida mai daraja da aka taɓa gani.
Bari mu dubi da'awar a cikin labarin, farawa da sakin layi na farko:
Kamar yadda Covid ganga ta kasar Sin, masana kimiyya a duk duniya suna neman alamu game da barkewar cutar da ke da babban sakamako - ga lafiyar daruruwan miliyoyin jama'ar Sinawa, tattalin arzikin duniya da kuma makomar cutar.
Anan akwai waɗanda ba a tabbatar da su ba - kuma, bisa ga kanun labarai da ƙaramin jigo na wannan labarin ba za a iya tabbatar da su ba, - zato waɗanda ke ƙarƙashin waɗannan da'awar:
1) Covid-XNUMX yana tafiya a China. Yace waye? Idan babu tabbataccen bayanan da ke fitowa daga ƙasar, ta yaya za mu san akwai wani ganga mai gudana? Kalmar “ganga” tana da alaƙa da a New York Times labarin game da rudani da hargitsi da ke biyo bayan ƙarshen manufofin Covid. Babu tabbacin ganga.
2) Barkewar da ba a tabbatar da ita ba tana da sakamako mai yawa - me yasa? Sauran kasashen duniya sun koma ko kadan zuwa al'ada, bayan barkewar cutar, kuma kasar Sin na kokarin yin hakan. Ko da akwai daruruwan miliyoyin shari'o'in Covid a China, mun san cewa gabaɗaya Covid Yawan mace-mace ya yi ƙasa sosai a cikin duka sai tsofaffi da marasa lafiya, da kuma kamar yadda Kafofin watsa labarai na Yamma (ciki har da NYT) ya ruwaito ad gidan kayan gargajiya a shekarar 2020, kasar Sin ta gina karin karfin iko da yawa, don haka babu wani dalili da za a yi tunanin asibitocinta za su mamaye.
Sakin layi na gaba:
Amma idan babu sahihan bayanai daga gwamnatin kasar Sin, wani babban wasa ne na kimiya na kimiya don tantance girman da tsananin karuwar yawan jama'a a kasar da ta fi kowacce yawan jama'a a duniya.
Babban zato a cikin wannan sakin layi, kuma a cikin duka labarin, shine cewa akwai “rashin sahihan bayanai daga gwamnatin China.” Har ila yau, wannan zato yana da ma'ana, idan aka ba da abin da muka sani game da shi yadda gwamnatin kasar Sin ta yi amfani da bayanan sirri don aiwatar da manufofinta daban-daban. Yana nufin cewa duk abin da shugabannin China suka ce game da cutar a cikin ƙasarsu ba abin dogaro ba ne.
Duk da haka 'yan sakin layi kaɗan, labarin ya yi waɗannan da'awar masu ban mamaki:
Har zuwa wannan watan, da alama duniya tana da cikakkiyar fahimta game da abin da ke faruwa da kwayar cutar a China. Jam'iyyar gurguzu mai mulki ta yi alfahari da buga ƙananan lambobi na yau da kullun da mace-mace a matsayin shaida ga tsauraran manufofinta na 'sifili Covid'. Tsarin kulle-kulle a cikin ƙasa baki ɗaya, keɓewa da gwajin jama'a ya sa kwayar cutar ta kasance a waje.
Amma a farkon Disamba, gwamnati ba zato ba tsammani ta yi watsi da 'sifili Covid,' ta bar al'ummar kimiyya a cikin duhu.
Jira, menene?
Lokacin da suke bin manufofin Covid da ba za a iya cimma su ba, marasa kimiyya kuma masu ɓarna mai ban mamaki, Jam'iyyar Kwaminisanci ta Sin (CCP) ta kasance da aminci gaba ɗaya, kuma duk bayanan da suka buga sun dogara 100 bisa ɗari? Misali, wannan bayanin, kamar yadda aka gabatar a ciki Babban labarin Michael Senger akan wannan batun:
Idan akwai shakku: Wannan jadawali, bisa bayanan da CCP ta bayar, ya nuna cewa ba a sami mutuwar Covid a China tsawon shekaru biyu ba, tun daga watan Maris na 2020. Hakan na nufin, yayin da duniya baki daya ta kamu da kwayar cutar kwayar cutar numfashi mai saurin yaduwa wacce ta yi sanadin mutuwar miliyoyin mutane, wata kasa mai mutane biliyan 1.4 ta yi nasarar kauce wa gaba daya. Wannan shine bayanin da The New York Times da kuma al'ummar kimiyyar da aka yi imani da su.
Bayan haka, ba zato ba tsammani, lokacin da CCP ta yanke shawarar tsayawa tare da munanan manufofin, ɓarna, da ɓarna, bayanan da aka ruwaito ba su da aminci kuma masana kimiyya suna "cikin duhu" game da abin da ke faruwa a China?
Rashin hankali na waɗannan ikirari yana da haske sosai, ya kamata ya bata sunan duk wani abu da kowa zai ce game da bayanan daga China a yanzu, idan ba su yarda cewa hakan abin mamaki ba ne tun daga farko. Mutum ba zai iya taimakawa ba sai mamaki: ina masu binciken gaskiya suke lokacin da aka buga irin wannan matakan rashin fahimta da kuma firgita a fili a shafin farko na The New York Times?
-
Debbie Lerman, 2023 Brownstone Fellow, yana da digiri a Turanci daga Harvard. Ita marubuciyar kimiyya ce mai ritaya kuma ƙwararren mai fasaha a Philadelphia, PA.
Duba dukkan posts
