Kusan shekaru hudu kenan tun bayan bullar cutar da kuma tabarbarewar manufofin jama'a don gudanar da ita, mutane da yawa sun nuna shakku kan irin martanin manufofin da jami'an kiwon lafiya, gwamnatoci, da masu kula da magunguna ke yi.
Duk da haka, lambobi masu yawa sun tabbata cewa yayin da za a iya yin kurakurai, ayyukan sun kasance mafi nasara kuma gabaɗaya an yi niyya sosai a cikin yanayin ƙalubalen da ba a taɓa gani ba na sabuwar ƙwayar cuta mai saurin yaduwa.
Masu shakka suna jin cewa an tabbatar da su a kan abubuwa uku: nauyi da kuma duniya na barazanar cutar an yi karin gishiri, sau da yawa da gangan; an wuce gona da iri kan tasirin manufofin siyasa; kuma an yi watsi da illolinsu da haɗarinsu.
Tozarta, yin shiru, da kuma tona asirin masu adawa da gaskiya da gaskiya sun ba da gudummawa ga haɓakar rashin amincewa da kyakkyawan imani da cancantar hukuma. A taƙaice, sama da shekaru uku mun shaida girman kan ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun gwamnatoci, da kuma abin mamaki na rashin kunya da bin mutane.
Mantra na 'Bi kimiyya' ya kasance yana buɗewa. Da yake ba da shaida a gaban Majalisa a ranar 8-9 ga Janairu, Anthony 'Ni kimiyya ce' Fauci ya shaida cewa hukumomin kiwon lafiya' dokar tazarar ƙafa shida (mita 1.5-2.0 ga ƙasashen da ke bin tsarin awo) ba 'da yuwuwa ya dogara da bayanan kimiyya ba.' da'irin kawai ya bayyana.' Ya kuma yarda cewa rigakafin Covid ya wajabta 'zai iya ƙara jinkirin rigakafi zuwa gaba.' Babban abin da ke da kyau shi ne cewa umarni ya ba da gudummawa ga asarar amincin jama'a ga lafiya da sauran cibiyoyi.
A cikin wani bincike mai ban sha'awa game da manufofin Covid da Drs. Fauci da Deborah Birx, Scott Atlas ne, wanda ya yi aiki a matsayin mai ba da shawara ga Shugaba Donald Trump, ya rubuta a cikin Newsweek Maris da ya gabata cewa manufofin 'sun kasa dakatar da mutuwa, sun kasa hana kamuwa da cuta daga yaduwa, kuma sun yi mummunar barna da lalata musamman ga iyalai masu karamin karfi da kuma kan yaran Amurka.' Ya lissafta wasu karairayi guda goma wadanda shugabannin lafiya da jami’ai da malamai suka yada.
Francis Collins, tsohon shugaban Cibiyar Kiwon Lafiya ta Kasa, ya yarda a watan Yulin da ya gabata cewa jami'an kiwon lafiyar jama'a sun nuna rashin tausayi a cikin tunaninsu guda daya kan Covid ga watsi da sauran la'akarin lafiya, zamantakewa, da tattalin arziki. A ciki nasa kalmomi:
Don haka kuna haɗa ƙima mara iyaka don dakatar da cutar da ceton rai.
Kuna danganta darajar sifili ga ko wannan a zahiri gaba ɗaya yana tarwatsa rayuwar mutane, yana lalata tattalin arziƙin kuma ya sa yara da yawa ba su zuwa makaranta ta hanyar da ba za su taɓa murmurewa ba.
The UK Covid tambaya Shugaban Baroness Hallett ya yi kama da zai zama mafi tsada a tarihin Birtaniyya, tare da ƙiyasin ɗaya daga ƙungiyar masu biyan haraji ta sanya jimillar farashi a £ 156 miliyan. Hakanan ta tabbatar da ta'addanci, tana ba da lokaci mara iyaka akan kwatankwacin jita-jita akan kungiyoyin WhatsApp, da kuma nuna kyama ga jami'an kiwon lafiya da manyan mashawartan kimiyya da rashin kulawa ga fitattun masu sukar labarin.
Ko da nasa ƙanƙara, nadir ya zo da shaida daga Firayim Minista (PM), na dukan mutane. Gabatar da binciken a ranar 11 ga Disamba, Rishi Sunak ya ja hankali ga wani bincike wanda ya nuna cewa ƙarin ingantattun shekarun rayuwa (QALY) za a rasa ta hanyar kullewa ta farko fiye da cutar ta Covid.
A cikin mayar da martani, Hugo Keith KC, mashawarcin da ke taimaka wa binciken, ya rufe shi da sauri. Bai sha'awar 'samfurin tabbatar da ingancin rayuwa' (sic), in ji shi.
Tuna, wannan shine Firayim Minista yana magana, wanda kuma shine shugaban gwamnati a karkashin Firayim Minista Boris Johnson a lokacin, yana ba da shawarar cewa da gaske maganin ya fi cutar muni. Farfesa Karol Sikora, fitaccen masanin ilimin cututtuka kuma tsohon shugaban shirin ciwon daji a WHO, ya kira wannan 'Musayar da ta fi bayyana a cikin Binciken Covid.'
Sir Patrick Vallance shi ne babban masanin kimiyyar Burtaniya lokacin da coronavirus ya buge. Kamar Collins a cikin Amurka, Vallance shima ya yarda da shaida a binciken Covid na Burtaniya a ranar 20 ga Nuwamba cewa. kimiyya da aka bai wa nauyi da bai kamata ba kan tattalin arziki: 'Kimiyyar tana nan don kowa ya gani. Shawarar tattalin arziki ba ta kasance ba.'
Cikin mamaki bude wasika ga PM Scott Morrison a ranar 19 ga Afrilu, 2020, da yawa daga cikin fitattun masana tattalin arzikin Australiya sun yi watsi da kiran masu sharhi na a gaggauta komawa bakin aiki tare da sanya ra'ayin 'ciniki' tsakanin lafiyar jama'a da tattalin arzikin 'banbanci karya'. Sun ce yayin da matakan da aka dauka don dakile yaduwar Covid-19 ya haifar da lalacewar tattalin arziki, wadanda aka ceto sun fi karfin wadanda aka ceto.
Daga karshe masana tattalin arziki 265 ne suka sanya hannu kan wasikar. Amma bai tsufa da kyau ba kuma wannan na iya bayyana dalilin da yasa rukunin yanar gizon tare da cikakken jerin sunayen masu sa hannun ba a samun damar zuwa yanzu. Wannan abin mamaki ne domin wannan ba masanin tattalin arziki ba yana cikin tunanin cewa nazarin farashi-fa'ida yana da mahimmanci ga tsarin tattalin arziki.
Don abin da ya dace, na rubuta har zuwa Maris 30, 2020 in Lu'u -lu'u da Fushi:
A wajen mayar da martani ga annoba, ana yin ciniki tsakanin lafiyar jama'a da kwanciyar hankali na tattalin arziki. Hakki ne na kwararrun kiwon lafiya su mai da hankali kan na farko kawai. Hakkin gwamnatoci ne su daidaita bangarorin biyu…
'Dole ne manufofin jama'a su kasance a kan daidaito na haɗari da fa'idodi…Kiwon lafiyar 'yan ƙasa da lafiyar tattalin arzikin ƙasa suna da alaƙa da juna.
A cikin biyo baya Labaran ranar 17 ga Afrilu, 2020, don Lowy Mai Tafsiri, Na rubuta:
Ma'aikatan kiwon lafiya suna da alhakin taswira mafi kyau- da mafi munin yanayi. Gwamnatoci suna ɗaukar nauyin daidaita manufofin kiwon lafiya, tattalin arziki, da zamantakewa. Da zarar an haɗa waɗannan a cikin lissafin yanke shawara, hujjar siyasa da ɗabi'a don dabarun murkushewa ba ta da tabbas.
Binciken Covid na Albanese
A cikin 'yan adawa Anthony Albanese da Labour sun yi alkawarin kafa Hukumar Sarauta, wacce ke da iko mai karfi na tilasta shaidu su ba da shaida tare da neman takaddun da suka dace. A cikin Satumba Firayim Minista Albanese ya ba da sanarwar iko, abun da ke ciki, da sharuɗɗan bincike na Covid na Ostiraliya. Ya gaza duk mafi kyawun gwaji na binciken jama'a mai zaman kansa. Ba shi da ikon da doka ta tanada don tattara bayanan shaida da na baka.
Tare da ƙanƙanta da ƙayyadaddun sharuddan ƙididdiga, ba za ta bincika yanke shawara da ayyukan gwamnatocin jihohi ba, waɗanda suka kafa mafi yawan manufofin sarrafa cutar. Duk wani mai daraja kansa da ya tuntube don kasancewa cikin kwamitin zai kasance cikin ladabi amma ya ki amincewa da gayyatar.
Mahalarta taron uku duk mata ne da ke da bayanan jama'a na ba da shawarar kulle-kulle, abin rufe fuska, da alluran rigakafi. Angela Jackson ta yana da alaka a baya da jam'iyyar Labour. A cikin watan Yuni 2021 ta yi tweet cewa kulle-kullen Melbourne ya taimaka 'don kiyaye sauran Ostiraliya Covid 'yanci,' ta kara da cewa: 'Lokacin da za a zubar da jini a Sydney.' A wata mai zuwa ta ce Victoria na bukatar 'tsaron kulle-kulle' don shawo kan cutar.
Catherine Bennett ne adam wata Hakanan ya kasance mai goyan bayan kulle-kullen Melbourne a cikin 2020-21. Wakilin na uku shine Robyn Kruk, darekta-janar na Sashen Lafiya na New South Wales.
Masu kare tsarin Albanese ba su da yawa. Jam'iyyar adawa ta kai hari a matsayin 'rabin gasa' binciken da zai yi aiki kamar 'rakitin kariya' ga galibin gwamnatocin jihohin Labour da suka kafa wasu tsauraran matakan rashin ilimin kimiyya a duniya. Ya kamata a fadada iyakokinta ko dai a wargaje, in ji su.
Jikin Peak Tsabtace-Kula da Jiki mawakan suka na yanke shawarar ware ayyukan gwamnatocin jihohi. Hatta wasu 'yan majalisar dokokin jam'iyyar Labour sun bayyana kunkuntar binciken a matsayin 'abin mamaki.'
Kwamishiniyar Kare Hakkokin Dan Adam Lorraine Finlay ya ce binciken zai gaza yin adalci ga tsadar dan adam na manufofin Covid, gami da rabuwar dangi, rufe makarantu, da kuma Australiya da ba a ba su izinin dawowa gida daga ketare ba. The Australian Mawallafin marubuci Peter Van Onselen ya ce binciken da Albanese ke da iyaka da rashin hakora shine 'tushen siyasa a mafi muni' kuma PM ya aro littafin wasan daga jerin talabijin na Burtaniya na satirical Haka ne, firaministan kasar. Paul Collits ya soki tsarin da dukkan mata na kwamitin binciken a matsayin ba bincike 'farce mace.'
Saboda aikin da na yi kan batutuwan Covid tun daga Maris 2020, mutane da yawa sun tambaye ni in gabatar da gabatarwa (ranar rufewa ita ce 15 Disamba), aƙalla 'don rikodin.' Na ƙi. Kasancewa cikin wannan motsa jiki na yaudara zai cika shi da wani matakin da bai cancanta ba.
A ranar 21 ga Satumba, a sakin kafofin watsa labarai daga Sanata Malcolm Roberts ya yi izgili da 'cin amanar 'yan Australiya na yau da kullun da ƙananan 'yan kasuwa' tare da "gudu daga Hukumar Mulki." Ya yi alkawarin neman kwamitin majalisar dattijai da kwamitin shari’a da tsarin mulki ya gudanar da bincike don ba da shawarar ingantattun sharuddan sharuddan da za a kafa kwamitin na Covid Royal a shekarar 2024. Majalisar dattawa ta amince a ranar 19 ga Oktoba.
Kwamitin zai bayar da rahoto nan da ranar 31 ga Maris. Kungiyoyi da dama, ciki har da wasu da nake da alaka da su, sun shagaltu da shirye-shiryen gabatar da shawarwari ga kwamitin majalisar dattijai da aka rufe ranar 12 ga watan Janairu.
Ana iya samun ƙoƙarin haɗin gwiwa don tsara cikakkun sharuɗɗan sharuɗɗan mutane nan, tare da masu sanya hannu 45,000 kamar yadda a ranar 17 ga Janairu. Ya haɗa da ƙungiyoyi biyu waɗanda ke kusa da su, Tsaron Lafiya na Yara Ostiraliya da Australiya don Kimiyya da 'Yanci. (Cikakken bayyanawa: Ni ɗaya ne daga cikin mawallafin marubucin Daftarin aiki.)
Yana buƙatar amsoshi ga tushen kimiyya don wasu matakan da suka fi dacewa da kuma tilastawa matakan kulawa da cutar, ƙididdigar fa'ida ta fa'ida a bayan manufofin ciki har da nazarin illolin da za a iya samu daga magungunan magunguna da marasa magani; da kuma bayanin aiwatarwa da aiwatar da umarnin rigakafin duk da sanin cewa ba su daina kamuwa da cuta ko yadawa.
-
Ramesh Thakur, Babban Babban Masanin Cibiyar Brownstone, tsohon Mataimakin Sakatare-Janar na Majalisar Dinkin Duniya ne, kuma farfesa na farko a Makarantar Siyasa ta Crawford, Jami'ar Kasa ta Australiya.
Duba dukkan posts
