Jiya, Sakataren Lafiya da Ayyukan Jama'a na Amurka, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. ya buga wani kaifi kuma cikakke m na binciken kwanan nan da Andersson et al., wanda ya kasance wallafa a cikin Annals na Internal Medicine. Binciken ya yi kanun labarai don iƙirarin cewa allurar rigakafin aluminum da aka yi a farkon ƙuruciya ba su da alaƙa da haɓakar haɗari na cututtukan autoimmune, rashin lafiyan, ko rashin ci gaba na neurodevelopmental.
Kennedy bai yi magana ba. Ya bayyana binciken da cewa "don haka yana da ɓarna sosai yana aiki ba a matsayin kimiyya ba amma azaman farfagandar yaudara ta masana'antar harhada magunguna.” Daga cikin abubuwa da yawa masu tambaya da ya gano, wani ya yi fice a gare ni musamman Kennedy.
"Wadannan sleights na hannu suna haɓaka yuwuwar ƙyale marubutan su kai ga ra'ayinsu mara kyau cewa mafi girman bayyanar aluminum ko ta yaya yana da kariya daga cutar asma, allergies, da cututtukan haɓaka neurodevelopmental, gami da Autism."
Wannan jimlar ta dakatar da ni a kan hanyata saboda na lura da ainihin abin. Yayin da Kennedy ya bayyana wannan damuwar ta fuskar bayar da shawarwarin kiwon lafiyar jama'a, na tunkari wannan batu ta fuskar ilimi da bayanai. Abin da na gano ba wai kawai ya yi daidai da abin lura da shi ba amma yana ƙara ƙwaƙƙwaran tushe a ciki. A haƙiƙa, wannan batu shi ne tushen tsokaci na yau da kullun da na gabatar wa Annals na Internal Medicine. Marubutan binciken sun amsa - amma, a ganina, ba su magance ainihin sabani ba. A cikin wannan ɗan gajeren labarin, na ƙaddamar da cikakken labarin, wanda bayanan ke goyan bayan, don nuna dalilin da yasa ba za a iya yin watsi da wannan tsari mara kyau na tasirin kariya ba.
Misalin Yayi Kyau Don Kasancewa Gaskiya
A cikin tsakiyar su (duba hoton da ke ƙasa), Andersson et al. bayar da rahoton rabon haɗari don 34 daban-daban sakamakon lafiya, kwatanta yara masu matakan daban-daban na bayyanar aluminum ta hanyar rigakafi. A kallon farko, adadi yana da alama daidai kuma cikakke. Amma idan aka yi la’akari da ku yana nuna wani yanayi mai ban mamaki: 25 daga cikin kiyasin 34 (73.5%) sun jingina a hanya guda - yana ba da shawarar cewa Kara aluminium fallasa aka hade da m hadarin. Kuma ba kawai ta hanyar bazuwar dama ba: fiye da rabin waɗannan ƙungiyoyin "masu kariya" sun kasance masu mahimmanci a ƙididdiga (tare da tazarar amincewa 95% ban da 1.0). Abin sha'awa, yaran da suka karɓi allurai mafi girma na aluminium sun bayyana suna da ƙananan haɗarin haɓaka yanayi kamar rashin lafiyar abinci, Autism, da ADHD.
Wannan tsari ba shi da tabbas a fuskarsa sai dai idan aluminum magani ne na mu'ujiza babu wanda ya gaya mana game da shi. Ko da a karkashin Magana marar kyau cewa aluminum ba shi da wani tasiri, irin wannan rarraba gefe ɗaya na mahimman binciken da ba zai yiwu ba. Amma bayan hasashen kididdiga, sakamakon shima ya sabawa epidemiological gaskiya.
Yin watsi da Jagorancin Tarihi
Kodayake Andersson et al. a taƙaice yarda da yiwuwar saura rikice (watau, ɓoyayyun sauye-sauyen da ba a ƙididdige su a cikin bincike ba), sun kasa fuskantar wannan baƙon abin ban mamaki kuma mai tsananin asymmetric na sakamakonsu. Madadin haka, suna ba da shawarar cewa haɓakar ƙididdigar ƙima a cikin lokaci na iya haifar da ƙididdige ƙididdige haɗarin haɗari ga yaran da aka haifa daga baya, waɗanda kuma suka sami ƙarin aluminium saboda canje-canjen jadawalin rigakafin.
Amma wannan bayanin yana zurfafa wasan ne kawai! Idan da gaske cututtukan cututtuka sun karu a kan lokaci, kamar yadda suka lura da kyau, to, za mu sa ran ƙungiyoyin haihuwa na gaba (tare da mafi girman bayyanar aluminum) don nunawa. mafi girma an lura da ƙimar ci gaban neurodevelopmental da yanayin rashin lafiyan, ko da aluminum ba shi da wani tasiri ko kaɗan. Ya kamata alkiblar son zuciya ta karkatar da sakamakon zuwa kasada, ba kariya ba.
Ci gaba da ADHD, ganewar asali da na yi nazari kuma na yi tambaya sosai, a matsayin misali. Dangane da littafin Diagnostic da Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM), an kiyasta yawan cutar ADHD a kusan 3% a cikin 1980 kuma ya tashi zuwa 7.2% ta 2022 (a cikin sabon bugu na littafin). A gaskiya ma, ana ɗaukar waɗannan alkaluma a matsayin masu ra'ayin mazan jiya; Yawancin karatu sun ba da rahoton hauhawar farashi mai ban mamaki, wani lokacin wuce 20%. A cikin wannan mahallin, gano cewa ƙarin ƙungiyoyin haihuwa na baya-bayan nan [waɗanda suka sami mafi girman bayyanar aluminum] sun bayyana Kadan Wataƙila za a iya gano shi tare da ADHD ya ƙi duka dabaru da gaskiyar tarihi.
Wannan sabani ya sa na gabatar da ra'ayin jama'a akan gidan yanar gizon mujallar (comment #3), tada yiwuwar lafiyayyen rigakafin son zuciya- wani sabon labari mai kyau a cikin binciken alluran lura. Lokacin da iyalai waɗanda ke bin jadawalin alluran rigakafin suma sukan sami ingantacciyar rayuwa, matsayi mafi girma na zamantakewar al'umma, da samun damar samun lafiya, 'ya'yansu na iya zama mafi koshin lafiya saboda dalilan da ba su da alaƙa da allurar kansu.
Martanin Marubuta
Ga godiyarsu, marubutan sun amsa. Amma martanin da suka bayar bai yi cikakken bayani kan ainihin sabani da na kawo ba. Sun rubuta:
"Yaakov Ophir ya ɗaga damuwa game da rashin lafiyar allurar rigakafi. Yawancin iyakoki na sama na 95% tazarar amincewa sun dace da ko kusa da babu wani tasiri… Tun da wannan bincike ne na lura, ba za a iya kawar da rikicewar rikice-rikice ba, amma kamar yadda bincikenmu ya kwatanta da yaran da aka yi wa alurar riga kafi, rashin lafiyar alurar riga kafi ba bayani ba ne.. "
Tare da girmamawa, wannan amsa ta gaza yin aiki tare da rashin bin ka'ida da na haskakawa. Kawai lura da cewa binciken da aka kwatanta "yaran da aka yi wa alurar riga kafi kawai" baya kawar da haɗarin son zuciya. Bambance-bambance a cikin lokacin rigakafin, riko da jadawalin, halayen lafiyar iyaye, da samun damar kula da lafiya na iya haifar da ruɗani, har ma a cikin al'ummar da aka yi wa alurar riga kafi.
Mafi mahimmanci, mawallafa ba su magance rashin daidaituwa na tsakiya ba: daidaito da mahimmancin ƙididdiga m Ƙungiyoyin da aka lura a faɗin sakamako da yawa (duba hoton da ke sama). Wannan ba lamari ba ne na hayaniyar bazuwar ko wasu abubuwan da ba su dace ba; tsari ne na tsari wanda ke nuni zuwa alkibla mara kyau.
Tsarin Madaidaici Don Amincewa
To, a ina hakan ya bar mu? Idan rashin lafiyar allurar rigakafi ba ta da alhakin waɗannan sakamako masu ban mamaki, to an bar mu da yuwuwar yuwuwar damuwa: cewa an lalata bayanan da kanta (ko da ba da gangan ba), ko ta hanyar lahani da ba a gane ba, ɓarna, ko kayan tarihi.
A cikin wannan haske, rashin lafiyar alluran ƙiyayya ta zama m dangane da bayani. Yana ba da sananne, tushen kuskure marar niyya. Amma ƙin yarda da shi ya bar mu mu fuskanci gurɓataccen kimiyya-daidai abin da Sakatare Kennedy ya yi gargaɗi a kai. Kokarin sa, kamar nawa, ba game da zama “pro-” ko “anti-” maganin rigakafi ba ne. Yana da game da riko da kimiyya zuwa nasa ma'auni. Kuma idan binciken ya yi kama da ya yi kyau ya zama gaskiya, muna bin jama'a su tambayi ko ba wai kawai ba ne, amma a zahiri yaudara ne.
Shiga cikin tattaunawar:
An buga ƙarƙashin a Commonirƙirar Commonabi'a Mai Creativeayatarwa 4.0 Licenseasashen Duniya
Don sake bugawa, da fatan za a saita hanyar haɗin yanar gizo zuwa asali Cibiyar Brownstone Labari da Marubuci.
