Tauraron wasan Tennis Novak Djokovic sanannen (ko kuma, dangane da ra'ayin ku, rashin mutunci) ya ƙi yin allurar rigakafin Covid-19 a matsayin sharadi na shiga Australia don buga gasar Australian Open.
Kin amincewar Djokovic ya sa National Review's Hoton Kevin Williamson da kuma Charles Cooke don shiga tsakani a muhawara ta yanar gizo game da cancantar allurar rigakafin Covid da gwamnati ta ba da izini. Williamson ya ga irin waɗannan umarni ba su da ƙarancin ƙima fiye da Cooke. Musamman saboda kowane mutum yana da tunani da ka'ida, karanta musayar su yana da amfani. Wannan batu lamari ne mai mahimmanci kuma dole ne a magance shi yadda ya kamata, kamar yadda Williamson da Cooke suka yi.
Musayar Williamson-Cooke ta sa masanin tattalin arziki na Jami'ar Washington Ian Fillmore ya raba min tunaninsa game da wajibcin rigakafin. Ga wani ɓangare na imel ɗin da na karɓa kwanan nan daga Ian (wanda na raba tare da irin izininsa):
Na ga hujjar "Ba ku yi adawa da umarnin rigakafin HepA a baya ba, don haka me yasa kuke jin haushin ba da umarnin rigakafin Covid?" Maganar gaskiya ce, kuma amsar dana bata gamsarwa ita ce, yayin da suka sa ni cikin damuwa, sai na yi shiru da bakina domin kowa yana tafiya da shi. Yaya illar wa'adin da babu wanda ya damu da biyayya? Da ya zama kamar abin ban mamaki ne a dau tsayuwar ka'ida a kan wa'adin da kusan babu wanda ya ke tunani (kuma 'yan ƴan adawa yawanci ana keɓe su ta wata hanya ko wata). Rikicin ba zai cutar da yarana ba saboda mun saba kan allurar rigakafinmu. Kuma ban yi masa tunani da yawa fiye da haka ba.
To, yanzu muna da adadi mafi girma na yawan mutanen da ba sa son shan maganin. Ina tsammanin allurar rigakafin suna da ban tsoro (a ajiye masu haɓakawa a gefe) kuma yakamata su kasance tikitin mu don komawa ga al'ada a farkon 2021. Yawancin mutane sun yarda da ni kuma sun sami rigakafin watanni da suka gabata. Wasu sun saba kuma hakan bai dame ni ba ko kadan. Suna ɗaukar haɗari mafi girma na rashin lafiya ko mutuwa daga Covid kuma zabin su ke nan! Tunda ana yi min alluran, zabinsu na barin allurar bai shafe ni ba. Wannan gaskiya ne musamman a yanzu da ya nuna cewa alluran ba su da tasiri sosai wajen hana yaɗuwar. A matsayina na masanin tattalin arziki zan iya cewa alluran rigakafin sun kawar da abubuwan da ke waje na Covid. A matsayina na ɗan adam, zan ce alluran rigakafin sun ba mu damar yin zaɓin kanmu kuma mu tuna da namu kasuwancin.
Gabaɗaya, Ina mamakin yadda mutane suke saurin watsar da lallashi don neman tilastawa. Wasu ba a lallashinsu su sha maganin, kuma muna daukarsa kamar laifinsu ne don rashin lallashinsu. Wataƙila yana da ka laifin rashin lallashinsu! Amma a'a, mun ba ta tsohuwar kwalejin gwadawa tare da wasu saƙon lafiyar jama'a, sannan mu fara zubar da guduma tare da umarni.
Ian ta imel yana haskaka hikima. Ina matukar yaba sha'awar da ya yi na amincewa da rashin tabbas game da hujjar tilasta yin rigakafin Covid-19 bisa la'akari da cewa gwamnatocin da suka rigaya, a cikin nau'o'i da yanayi daban-daban, suna buƙatar wasu rigakafin.
Shi, ba shakka, ya ci gaba a cikin imel ɗin sa don ba da wasu kyawawan dalilai don adawa da allurar rigakafin cutar Covid.
Bari in ba da wasu ƙarin dalilai a nan.
Tun daga farkon Covid, masana kimiyya da ma'aikata waɗanda kafofin watsa labarai suka yi la'akari da su a matsayin kusan ma'asumai, kuma mafi yawan gwamnatoci, sun fara tafiya tare da nuna wasu manyan juzu'ai. Anthony Fauci's 180-digiri flipperoo kan shawarar sanya abin rufe fuska shine mafi shaharar wadannan. Dangane da irin wannan juye-juye, wa zai iya zargi mutane da nuna shakku game da tabbacin da aka bayar game da inganci da amincin alluran rigakafin irin su Fauci?
Matsalolin da ke da alaƙa da ita ita ce rikodin ha'inci, ɓatanci, da rabin gaskiya waɗanda yawancin waɗanda ke kan mulki ke aikatawa. Fauci da Francis Collins a fili ba su fito ba game da rawar da NIH ta taka wajen bayar da tallafi, in dai a kaikaice, binciken da aka yi a Cibiyar Nazarin Virology ta Wuhan..
Mafi muni shine ƙoƙarin da aka yi Fauci da Collins don shirya wani shiri don bata sunan masana kimiyyar wanda ya rubuta Babban Sanarwa na Barrington. Me yasa ya kamata ba jama'a su yi hattara da shelar da jami'an gwamnati suka yi game da alluran rigakafin da ke fargabar muhawarar kimiyya a fili? Me yasa ya kamata ba Jama'a su yi farin ciki da bin shawarar jami'an da ke yin izgili a matsayin malamai na "gefe" waɗanda ke aiki a sassan kimiyya a Harvard, Oxford, da Stanford - ba'a da wani abin ba'a da ya motsa shi face Collins da Fauci tsoron waɗannan fitattun malamai na ƙin yarda da jama'a game da amfani da ba a taɓa gani ba na kulle-kulle da sauran matakan mulki?
Sannan akwai nau'ikan munafunci da yawa da za a kirga ta waɗanda suka dage da ƙarfi kan hani na Covid. Filin liyafar firaministan Biritaniya Boris Johnson wanda yanzu ya yi kaurin suna; Gavin Newsom's soiree a wurin wanki na Faransa; Ziyarar sirrin Neil Ferguson tare da uwargidansa; Matt Hancock's not-sally-nesade m rungumar a cikin lif na ya farka; Tafiyar Muriel Bowser zuwa Delaware don murnar zaɓen Joe Biden; Ziyarar Godiya ta Deborah Birx 2020 tare da danginta; Labarin salon salon gashi Nancy Pelosi; Bikin ban rufe fuska na magajin garin San Francisco na London Breed; Magajin garin New York Bill de Blasio yana rawa a dandalin Times tare da matarsa a Sabuwar Shekarar 2021…. Ana iya tsawaita wannan jerin sunayen manyan ‘yan siyasa da masu ba gwamnati shawara na kin bin umarninsu da shawarwarinsu. Dangane da irin wannan jerin sunayen, shin yana da mamaki cewa ba wasu ƴan jama'a ba ne suka ƙi amincewa da jami'an gwamnati da masu ba su shawara game da aminci da ingancin allurar rigakafin Covid?
Kuma mafi girma a gare ni wasu abubuwa uku ne da ke ba da labari a cikin shekaru biyu da suka gabata.
Daya shine ijma'in jama'a-kiwon lafiya-masana har zuwa karshen 2019 don magance cututtuka an kusan watsar da su nan take a farkon 2020. Bugu da ƙari, waɗanda suka ci gaba da amincewa da wannan yarjejeniya kafin 2020 a bainar jama'a. aka zagi. Ta yaya abin da ya kasance ra'ayi yarjejeniya a ƙarshen 2019 zai iya zama camfi mai haɗari a farkon 2020? Ko da wane matsayi ne daidai - wanda ya yi nasara a gaban Covid-19 ko kuma wanda ya yi nasara tun - kusantar da ilimin 'aiki' (da kuma sakamakon shawarwarin manufofin) shine kadai isashen dalili ga mutane da yawa suyi tambaya game da shawarwarin hukuma na yau game da allurar rigakafin Covid.
Na biyu, yawancin gwamnatoci da manyan mashawarta suna matsawa don yin rigakafin kamar idan sakamakon Covid ba shi da takamaiman tarihin shekaru. Zan iya fahimtar dalilin da yasa shakkun rigakafin ke tashi lokacin da jama'a suka haɗu da manyan jami'ai da masu ba da shawara waɗanda ke matsa lamba don yin allurar kamar Covid yana da haɗari ga ƴan shekara goma sha biyar kamar yadda yake ga masu shekaru saba'in da biyar. Saboda wannan ƙi na rashin kimiyance na yarda da keɓaɓɓen bayanin shekarun Covid, me yasa za a ɗauki shawara game da alluran rigakafin da mutanen da suka ƙi yarda da wannan bayanan shekaru suka bayar a matsayin na kimiyya?
Ana iya yin irin wannan batu game da da Covidocracy ta ci gaba da tozarta rigakafi na halitta.
Na uku, an sha gaya mana mu Amurkawa tun shekaru 60 da suka gabata cewa kamfanoni masu zaman kansu ba su da amana idan gwamnati ta bar su ba tare da wani tsari ba. Musamman, an koya mana rashin amincewa da magunguna da na'urorin likitanci waɗanda Hukumar Abinci da Magunguna ba ta yi nazari sosai ba kuma ta amince da su kuma an gano suna da aminci da inganci. Kuma tsarin bita yawanci yana ɗaukar lokaci mai tsawo - a matsakaita, shekaru goma.
Duk da haka tun lokacin da Covid-19 ya isa, jama'a sun shaida ci gaba cikin sauri da kuma amincewa da rigakafin don yaƙar sabon coronavirus. Duk da yake na dade na yi imani cewa sojojin kasuwa da dokar azabtarwa sun isa don kiyaye kamfanonin harhada magunguna masu gaskiya da kuma amsawa - ma'ana, babu buƙatar FDA - ra'ayi na kuma an daɗe ana izgili da rashin hankali. Ko da yake nawa bincike (kamar yadda yake) ya tabbatar mani da cewa allurar Moderna da na karɓa tana da ƙima a gare ni (dan shekaru 63), ba zan iya soki mutane da yawa waɗanda, bayan sun lura da saurin haɓakar alluran da amincewar da ba a taɓa gani ba, suna damuwa cewa waɗannan magungunan ba su da isasshen lafiya don yin allurar cikin jikinsu da na ƴaƴan su.
Alurar riga kafi na duniya a yau an nanata shi da irin wannan zafin da masu kishin addini ƙarni da suka gabata suka nuna yayin dagewa kan gaskiyar aƙidarsu. Mutane masu hankali a zahiri suna shakkar irin wannan aƙidar kuma za su ƙi zama waɗanda abin ya shafa.
Idan gwamnatoci da jami'an kiwon lafiyar jama'a suna neman mutanen da za su zarga da shakkun rigakafin, suna buƙatar duba madubi kawai.
An rubuta wannan shafi don AIER
-
Donald J. Boudreaux, Babban Malami a Cibiyar Brownstone, Farfesa ne a fannin Tattalin Arziki a Jami'ar George Mason, inda yake da alaƙa da FA Hayek Shirin FA don Advanced Study a Falsafa, Siyasa, da Tattalin Arziki a Cibiyar Mercatus. Binciken nasa ya mayar da hankali kan cinikayyar kasa da kasa da dokar hana amana. Ya rubuta a Kafe Hayak.
Duba dukkan posts
