A watan Janairun da ya gabata, Cibiyar Johns Hopkins don Aiwatar da Tattalin Arziki, Kiwon Lafiyar Duniya da Nazarin Kasuwancin Kasuwanci sun buga wata takarda mai aiki wacce ta nuna a sarari yadda kulle-kulle a duk duniya bai shafi mace-macen Covid-19 kwata-kwata ba. Masana tattalin arziki Jonas Herby, Lars Jonung da Steve H. Hanke ne suka rubuta takardar, wanda yanzu ke fitowa a sigarta ta karshe, mai taken:
BINCIKEN LITTAFI DA NAZARI NA ILLOLIN CUTAR CUTAR KAN COVID-19 MUTUWA - II
Amfani da kulle-kulle wani fasali ne na musamman na cutar ta COVID-19. Ba a yi amfani da kulle-kulle ba sosai a yayin kowace annoba ta ƙarni da suka gabata. Koyaya, kulle-kulle a lokacin farkon farkon cutar ta COVID-19 sun yi mummunan tasiri. Sun ba da gudummawa wajen rage ayyukan tattalin arziki, haɓaka rashin aikin yi, rage makaranta, haifar da tarzomar siyasa, ba da gudummawa ga tashin hankali cikin gida, asarar ingancin rayuwa, da kuma lalata dimokuradiyya mai sassaucin ra'ayi. Dole ne a kwatanta waɗannan farashin ga al'umma da fa'idodin kulle-kulle, wanda ƙididdigar mu ta nuna ba komai bane.
Irin wannan madaidaicin ƙididdige ƙimar fa'ida yana kaiwa ga ƙarshe mai ƙarfi: har sai bincike na gaba bisa ingantacciyar hujja na iya tabbatar da cewa kulle-kulle yana da babban raguwar mace-mace, ya kamata a ƙi kulle-kulle daga hannu a matsayin kayan aikin manufofin cutar.
Ƙarshen ba shakka ya saba wa mutane da yawa, amma ƙaƙƙarfar gaskiya ce kuma ingantaccen gardama ta zo ta hanyar tsattsauran ra'ayi, tsararru kuma ba a saba gani ba game da binciken da ake samu.
Shafi II karatu ne mai ban sha'awa musamman. Wasu masu karatu na iya tuno guguwar da kafofin watsa labarai suka yi a kan wannan takarda, wanda wasu masu ikirarin tabbatar da gaskiya suka yi. Shafi ba wai kawai ya karyata duk da'awar "masu binciken gaskiya" ba amma marubutan sun kuma nuna yadda suka dogara ba akan kowane fahimtar takarda ba (a zahiri yana kama da "masu binciken gaskiya" galibi ba su taɓa karanta shi ba), amma a kan na zahiri da kuma babban abin da ba shi da mahimmanci " zargi ", maimaitawa a makance da daya "mai binciken gaskiya" da wani.
-
Thorsteinn Siglaugsson mashawarcin Icelandic ne, ɗan kasuwa kuma marubuci kuma yana ba da gudummawa akai-akai ga The Daily Skeptic har ma da wallafe-wallafen Icelandic daban-daban. Ya yi digiri na BA a fannin falsafa da MBA daga INSEAD. Thorsteinn ƙwararren ƙwararren ƙwararren ƙwararren ne a cikin Theory of Constraints kuma marubucin Daga Alamu zuwa Dalilai - Aiwatar da Tsarin Tunanin Hankali zuwa Matsala ta Kullum.
Duba dukkan posts