Kwanan nan na buga sau biyu akan lamarin Missouri da Biden, wanda jihohin Missouri da Louisiana - tare da masu gabatar da kara hudu masu zaman kansu (Jay Bhattacharya, Martin Kulldorff, 'Yancin Lafiya ta Lafiya ta Louisiana, da naku da gaske) ke wakilta. New Civil Liberties Alliance - suna karar Hukumar Biden saboda zargin keta hakkin fadin albarkacin baki. Musamman ma, bangaren zartarwa na gwamnatin tarayya ya kasance yana hada baki da kafofin watsa labarun don tantance duk wani abun ciki a dandalin sada zumunta - Twitter, YouTube (mallakar Google), da kuma LinkedIn (mallakar Microsoft), Facebook da Instagram (dukkan su mallakin Meta) - duk wani abun ciki da ke tambaya, kalubale, ko kuma ya saba wa manufofin gwamnati.
Yayin da kamfanoni masu zaman kansu za su iya yin zaɓe da gardama don tantance abun ciki a kan dandamali, gwamnati ba za ta iya matsawa ko tilasta wa kamfanoni masu zaman kansu su tantance abubuwan da ba su so ba. Duk wani irin wannan mataki a bayyane yake cin zarafi ne na 'yancin faɗar albarkacin baki da gyare-gyaren farko na Kundin Tsarin Mulkin Amurka ya tabbatar. Kamar yadda muke gabatarwa a cikin taƙaitaccen shari'ar mu: "A karkashin kwaskwarimar farko, gwamnatin tarayya ta kamata ba ta da rawar da ke haifar da yin wajan yin tunani a cikin kasuwannin. Amma wannan shine jami'an tarayya."
Mu sanarwar hadin gwiwa kan takaddamar ganowa taƙaitaccen shari'a, wanda aka shigar da shi a gaban kotu kuma aka bayyana a fili a yau, ya bayyana da yawa daga cikin jami'an gwamnatin tarayya a cikin akalla hukumomi goma sha daya na tarayya sun yi magana a asirce tare da kafafan yada labarai na soshiyal midiya don tantancewa da murkushe maganganun sirri na jami'an tarayya. Wannan haramtacciyar sana'a ta yi nasara sosai. Anan ga kaɗan kaɗan daga wannan takarda, wanda ya haɗa da maƙallan ɗaruruwan shafukan imel da sauran hanyoyin sadarwa na cikin gida na gwamnati da na Big Tech a matsayin shaida. An samo waɗannan takaddun bayan mun nemi bayanai masu zuwa akan ganowa:
Masu gabatar da kara sun ba da tambayoyi da buƙatun buƙatun ga waɗanda ake tuhuma na Gwamnati waɗanda ke neman asalin jami’an tarayya waɗanda suka kasance kuma suke sadarwa tare da dandamali na kafofin watsa labarun game da ɓarna, ɓarna, ɓarna, da / ko duk wani takunkumi ko danne magana a kan kafofin watsa labarun, gami da yanayi da abun ciki na waɗannan hanyoyin sadarwa. Har ila yau, masu gabatar da kara sun yi amfani da sammaci na ɓangare na uku akan manyan kafofin watsa labarun biyar - Twitter, Facebook da Instagram (dukansu na Meta), YouTube, da kuma LinkedIn. A ranar 17 ga Agusta, 2022, Wadanda ake tuhuma na Gwamnati sun ba da ƙin yarda da martani ga buƙatun gano Jihohin Masu ƙara, kuma sun fara samar da takaddun da aka kammala a ranar 26 ga Agusta, 2022.
Ga wasu daga cikinmu da aka samu kawo yanzu a cikin takardun da aka mayar da su, kamar yadda aka bayyana a sabuwar shigar da muka yi na shari’a zuwa kotu:
Sakatare Mayorkas na DHS [Sashen Tsaron Cikin Gida] yayi sharhi cewa ƙoƙarin da gwamnatin tarayya ke yi na yin magana da ‘yan sanda na sirri a shafukan sada zumunta yana faruwa “a cikin kasuwancin tarayya.” Doc. 45, fa. Ƙayyadadden binciken da aka samar ya zuwa yanzu yana ba da hoto mai ban sha'awa a cikin wani babban kamfani na "Censorship Enterprise", wanda ya haɗa da yawancin jami'an tarayya a cikin akalla hukumomin tarayya goma sha ɗaya da abubuwan da aka gano ya zuwa yanzu, waɗanda ke sadarwa tare da dandamali na kafofin watsa labarun game da rashin fahimta, ɓarna, da kuma murƙushe maganganun masu zaman kansu a kan kafofin watsa labarun - duk tare da niyya da kuma tasirin da ake yi wa jami'an gwamnatin tarayya.
Binciken da aka bayar ya zuwa yanzu ya nuna cewa wannan Kasuwancin Tace yana da faɗi sosai, ciki har da jami'ai a Fadar White House, HHS, DHS, CISA [Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency], CDC, NIAID, da kuma Ofishin Babban Likitan Likita; da kuma wasu hukumomi kamar su Ofishin ƙidayar jama'a, FDA, FBI, Ma'aikatar Jiha, Ma'aikatar Baitulmali, da Hukumar Taimakawa Zaɓen Amurka. Kuma ta haura zuwa manyan matakan gwamnatin Amurka, ciki har da jami'an fadar White House da dama. Ana buƙatar ƙarin bincike don buɗe cikakkiyar fa'idar wannan "Kamfanin Takaddama" don haka ba da damar masu shigar da kara damar samun cikakkiyar taimako na umarni. Wadanda ake tuhumar sun ki samar da wasu muhimman bayanai da suka fi dacewa a hannunsu-ie, asali, da yanayi da kuma abubuwan da ke cikin sadarwa, na jami'an Fadar White House da jami'ai a wasu hukumomin tarayya da ba su kasance masu tuhuma ba a cikin wannan shari'ar saboda ba a san lokacin da masu gabatar da kara suka yi bincike ba makonni shida da suka wuce. Wadanda ake tuhuma sun ki amincewa da samar da binciken da zai bayyana duka tsayi da faɗin "Kamfanin Tace Tace" na tarayya. Ya kamata Kotu ta soke waɗannan ƙorafe-ƙorafen kuma ta umarci waɗanda ake tuhuma da su ba da wannan mahimman bayanai masu mahimmanci, masu amsawa, kuma masu fa'ida.
Takaitacciyar mu ta ci gaba da cewa:
Na farko, faɗin da girman ayyukan tauhidin waɗanda ake tuhuma na tarayya yana da yawa. A martanin farko da suka yi game da tambayoyin, waɗanda ake tuhumar sun fara gano arba'in da hudu jami'an tarayya a DHS, CISA, CDC, NIAID, da Ofishin Babban Likitan Surgeon (duk a cikin hukumomin tarayya guda biyu kawai, DHS da HHS), waɗanda ke sadarwa tare da dandamali na kafofin watsa labarun game da kuskuren bayanai da kuma tantancewa. Ex. 1 (Marssoshin Tambayoyi da aka Sake Gyaran Wanda ake tuhuma), a 15-18.
[...]
Kafofin watsa labarun na ɓangare na uku, haka kuma, sun bayyana cewa ƙarin hukumomin tarayya suna da hannu. Meta, alal misali, ya bayyana cewa aƙalla jami'an tarayya 32-ciki har da manyan jami'ai a FDA, Hukumar Taimakawa Zaɓen Amurka, da Fadar White House-sun yi magana da Meta game da daidaita abun ciki akan dandamalin sa, waɗanda yawancinsu ba a bayyana su ba saboda amsa tambayoyin masu gabatar da kara ga waɗanda ake tuhuma. YouTube ya bayyana wasu jami'an gwamnatin tarayya goma sha daya da ke irin wannan sadarwa, ciki har da jami'ai a Ofishin Kidayar Jama'a da Fadar White House, wadanda kuma wadanda ake tuhuma ba su bayyana su ba. Twitter ya bayyana wasu jami'an gwamnatin tarayya guda tara da suka hada da manyan jami'ai a ma'aikatar harkokin wajen Amurka wadanda a baya wadanda ake tuhumar ba a bayyana su ba.
Kamar yadda zan rubuta game da ƙarin a cikin rubutu na gaba, gwamnati tana ba da kariya ga Anthony Fauci da sauran manyan jami'ai ta hanyar ƙin bayyana takaddun da suka shafi shigar su. Ku kasance da mu domin jin karin bayani kan wannan batu. A yanzu, kamar yadda takaitaccen bayaninmu ya yi bayani a nan, wadanda abin ya shafa sun hada da jami’ai da dama a matakin gwamnati mai ci:
Na biyu, waɗannan ayyukan ba da izini na tarayya sun haɗa da manyan jami'ai a cikin Gwamnatin Amurka, ie"Mambobin manyan ma'aikatanmu," a cikin kalaman tsohuwar sakatariyar yada labaran fadar White House Jen Psaki. Doc. 42, sakin layi na 174. Wadanda ake tuhuma sun ci gaba da kin amsa duk wani tambayoyi ko buƙatun da aka yi wa jami’an Fadar White House, kamar Sakatariyar Yaɗa Labarai ta Fadar White House, Karine Jean-Pierre da Dr. Fauci a matsayinsa na Babban Mashawarcin Likita ga Shugaban Ƙasa. Amma samar da nasu daftarin aiki ya ba da hangen nesa game da shigar da yawa daga cikin manyan jami'an Fadar White House a cikin sadarwa tare da dandamali na kafofin watsa labarun game da cece-kuce - ciki har da Babban Mai Ba da Shawarar White House Covid-19 Andrew Slavitt, Mataimakin Mataimakin Shugaban Kasa Rob Flaherty, Shugaban Fadar White House Covid-19 Daraktan Sadarwar Dabarun da Haɗin kai Courtney Rowe, Daraktan Dijital na White House na Covid-19. Dubi Ex. 3.
Bugu da kari, shafukan sada zumunta sun bayyana kansu da kansu na manyan jami'an Fadar White House da ke da hannu a irin wannan sadarwar. Misali, Meta ya bayyana shigar da karin jami'an fadar White House a matsayin mai ba da shawara a fadar White House Dana Remus da Manajan hadin gwiwar fadar White House Aisha Shah, da mataimakiyar mataimakiyar shugaban kasa Rob Flaherty. YouTube ya bayyana sa hannun jami'an Fadar White House irin su Rob Flaherty da Benjamin Wakana, Daraktan Sadarwar Dabarun da Haɗin kai a Tawagar Amsa COVID-19 na Fadar White House. Twitter ya bayyana hannu Andrew Slavitt.
Daga nan sai lauyoyinmu suka ba da wasu ‘yan misalan yadda wannan gwamnati ta cece-kuce ke gudana, kamar yadda kafafen sadarwa na cikin gida suka bayyana:
Takaitattun hanyoyin sadarwa da aka samar zuwa yanzu daga wadannan manyan jami’ai na da matukar dacewa kuma suna da fa’ida, domin suna bayar da haske kan yadda ake sa ido sosai da kuma matsin lamba na yin katsalandan da manyan jami’an gwamnatin tarayya ke yi a shafukan sada zumunta. Misali, bayan Shugaba Biden ya bayyana a bainar jama'a (game da Facebook) a ranar 16 ga Yuli, 2021, cewa "Suna kashe mutane," wani babban jami'in zartarwa a Meta (Facebook da Instagram) ya kai ga Likita Janar Vivek Murthy don shiga cikin sarrafa lalacewa kuma ya kwantar da fushin Shugaban. Ex. 4, a 1. Ba da da ewa ba, wannan jami'in Meta ya aika da saƙon rubutu zuwa ga Likita Janar Murthy, yana mai cewa "ba shi da kyau a zarge shi da kashe mutane," kuma yana bayyana cewa "yana sha'awar neman hanyar da za ta rage da kuma yin aiki tare tare tare." Ex. 5, ku 1.
Irin wannan “descalation” da “aiki tare ta hanyar haɗin gwiwa,” a zahiri, ya ƙunshi ƙara yin sharhi akan dandamalin Meta. Mako daya bayan zargin Shugaba Biden na jama'a, a ranar 23 ga Yuli, 2021, cewa wani babban jami'in Meta ya aika saƙon imel zuwa Likita Janar Murthy yana mai cewa, "Ina so in tabbatar kun ga matakan da muka ɗauka. kawai wannan makon da ya gabata don daidaita manufofi kan abin da muke cirewa dangane da bayanan da ba daidai ba, da kuma matakan da aka ɗauka don ƙara magance 'disinfo dozin': mun cire ƙarin shafuka 17, ƙungiyoyi, da asusun Instagram da ke da alaƙa da dozin disinfo…." Ex. 3, a 2. Bugu da kari, a ranar 20 ga Agusta, 2021, wannan shugaban Meta ya aika da imel zuwa Murthy don tabbatar masa da cewa Facebook "nan ba da jimawa ba zai fadada manufofin mu na COVID don kara rage yaduwar abubuwan da ke da illa a dandalinmu. Waɗannan sauye-sauyen za su shafi Facebook da Instagram, "kuma sun haɗa da"ƙara ƙarfin haɓakar mu don COVID da abubuwan da ke da alaƙa da rigakafin," da kuma "saƙa da sauƙi a rage Shafuka / Ƙungiyoyi / Asusu don raba COVID da kuma bayanan da ke da alaka da rigakafin." Ex. 4, a 3. Bugu da kari, cewa babban jami'in Meta ya aika da "Facebook covid-mako-rahoton" to Surgeon Janar Murthy ga fadar White House Andrew Slavitt, a fili don tabbatar da wadannan jami'an tarayya cewa Facebook na murƙushe COVID-19 "batsa" ya kasance m isa ga abubuwan da suka zaba.
Takaitaccen bayanin ya ci gaba da yin bayanin yadda wannan ya wuce haɗin gwiwa ko haɗin gwiwa tsakanin gwamnati da Big Tech, amma tilasta yin amfani da ƙarfin ikon don matsawa Big Tech yin umarnin gwamnati:
Irin waɗannan hanyoyin sadarwa daga Fadar White House suna sanya matsin lamba ga kamfanonin kafofin watsa labarun, kuma a fili suna samun sakamako idan ana batun cece-kuce. Kuma jami'an gwamnatin tarayya suna da cikakkiyar masaniyar cewa irin wannan matsin lamba ya zama dole don haifar da kafofin watsa labarun don ƙara yin sharhi. CISA [Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency] Darakta Jen Easterly, alal misali, yayi rubutu tare da wani jami'in CISA game da "kokarin kai mu a wurin da Fed zai iya aiki tare da dandamali don fahimtar abubuwan da ba daidai ba. don haka hukumomin da suka dace za su iya ƙoƙarin yin prebunk/debunk a matsayin mai amfani,” kuma ya koka game da bukatar Gwamnati na shawo kan “jinkirin” dandali na kafofin watsa labarun na yin aiki tare da gwamnati: “Tsarin ya sami kwanciyar hankali da gwamnati. Yana da ban sha'awa sosai yadda suke shakkar zama." Ex. 5, a 4 (ƙara ƙarfafawa).
Watakila wadannan kamfanoni sun yi shakku ne saboda sun san cewa matsin lamba da tilastawa gwamnati ya saba wa doka, balle a ce kamfanoni masu zaman kansu da masu buga littattafai ba sa son a gaya musu abin da za su buga kuma ba sa son manufofinsu su karkata ga jami’an gwamnati. Takaitaccen bayaninmu na doka ya ci gaba:
A haƙiƙa, irin wannan matsin lamba daga jami’an gwamnati kan kamfanonin sadarwar zamani, tare da yawancin maganganun jama’a da ake zargi a cikin Ƙorafi, sun yi nasara sosai. Binciken da aka samu ya zuwa yanzu ya nuna cewa ingantacciyar runduna ta jami'an gwamnatin tarayya suna da hannu a ayyukan tantancewa "a cikin kamfanonin tarayya." Sun hada da manyan jami’an tsaro guda 45 da aka bayyana a cikin amsa tambayoyin da masu gabatar da kara suka yi ya zuwa yanzu, jami’an gwamnatin tarayya 32 da Facebook ya tantance, jami’ai goma sha daya da YouTube ya bayyana, sai kuma XNUMX da Twitter ya gano (da yawa daga cikinsu ba sa haduwa, ko dai da juna ko kuma bayanan wadanda ake tuhuma). Kuma har yanzu wadanda ake tuhuma ba su sami amsa tambayoyin da ke nuna masaniyar wadanda ake tuhuma da jami’an tarayya a sauran hukumomi waɗanda ke sadarwa tare da dandamali na kafofin watsa labarun game da cece-kuce - amma a fili akwai da yawa. Da yawa, a zahiri, cewa Daraktan CISA Jen Easterly da wani jami'in CISA a fili sun koka, a cikin saƙon rubutu na cikin gida, cewa "hargitsi" zai haifar da idan duk jami'an tarayya sun kasance "kai tsaye" suna tuntuɓar dandamali na kafofin watsa labarun game da abin da ake kira rashin fahimta: "Ba manufarmu ba amma tana neman taka rawar gani don haka ba kowane D / A ke kai kansa ga dandamali wanda zai iya haifar da rudani ba. Ex. 5, ku 4.
Wadannan ma’aikatan gwamnatin tarayya suna da zurfi sosai a cikin wani kamfani na hadin gwiwa tare da kamfanonin sadarwar jama'a don sayo bayanan bayanan kafofin watsa labarun. Jami'ai a HHS na yau da kullun suna tuta abun ciki don tantancewa, misali, ta hanyar shirya tarurrukan "Ku Kasance Akan Duba" mako-mako don nuna alamar abubuwan da ba su so, Ex. 6; aika dogayen jerin misalan abubuwan da ba a so a tantance su, Ex. 6, a 21-22; yin aiki a matsayin “masu duba gaskiya” masu gata waɗanda dandamalin kafofin watsa labarun ke tuntuɓar su game da tantance maganganun sirri, Ex. 7; da kuma karɓar cikakkun rahotanni daga kamfanonin kafofin watsa labarun game da abin da ake kira "lalata" da ayyukan "ɓartarwa" akan layi, Ex. 4; da sauransu. CISA, haka nan, ta rungumi “tabbatacciyar manufa” ta nuna korafe-korafen watsa labarun kafofin watsa labarun sannan kuma “damuwa da damuwa” zuwa dandamalin kafofin watsa labarun, Doc. 45, ¶ 250-251. CISA akai-akai na karɓar rahotannin da aka sani na "ɓarnawa" kuma tana tura su zuwa kamfanonin kafofin watsa labarun, tare da sanya nauyin ikonta a matsayin hukumar tsaro ta tarayya a bayan bukatun wasu jam'iyyun na murkushe maganganun sirri. Ex. 8.
Bugu da ƙari, da yawa daga cikin waɗannan mahimman hanyoyin sadarwa daga jami'an tarayya waɗanda ke nuna takamaiman rubutu da abun ciki don tantancewa da alama suna faruwa ta hanyar wasu hanyoyin sadarwa waɗanda Masu gabatar da kara ba su samu ba tukuna (kamar yadda ƙungiyoyin kafofin watsa labarun na uku suka ce suna da kariya daga ganowa ta Dokar Sadarwar Sadarwa). Misali, Facebook ya horar da jami’an CDC da Ofishin Kididdiga kan yadda ake amfani da “tashar bayar da rahoton misinfo na Facebook.” Ex. 9. Twitter ya ba wa jami'an tarayya damar samun dama don nuna rashin fahimta ta hanyar "Partner Support Portal." Ex. 9, a 69. YouTube ya bayyana cewa ya ba da matsayin "amintaccen tuta" ga jami'an Ofishin Kidayar Jama'a, wanda ke ba da damar gata da kuma hanzarta yin la'akari da iƙirarinsu na cewa ya kamata a tace abun ciki.
A gaban waɗannan da sauran bayanai da yawa, waɗanda ake tuhuma sun ƙi bayar da wasu daga cikin mafi dacewa kuma mafi mahimmancin shaida na mafi munin cin zarafi na Gyaran Farko.
Tawagar mu ta lauyoyinmu za ta ci gaba da matsa lamba don bayyana cikakkun abubuwan da gwamnati ta ki mikawa kotu. Kuma a, mun kawo rasit na duk waɗannan zarge-zarge - duk takaddun yana samuwa nan, kuma an haɗa da shaidun da ke goyan bayan a shafuffuka na 142 – 711 ga waɗanda suke so su tona cikin cikakkun bayanai masu ban tsoro. Ga waɗanda suke son guntun sigar, ana samun sakin latsawa na NCLA nan.
Na yi zargin cewa duk wannan yana faruwa amma ban yi tunanin iyakar girman ba - faɗin, zurfin, da haɗin kai - wanda aka ba da shawarar ta hanyar shaidar da ƙungiyar lauyoyin mu ta gano ya zuwa yanzu yayin binciken shari'ar. Don ganin wannan shaidar akan shafin, wanda muka sani shine kawai ƙarshen ƙanƙara, abin ban mamaki ne kawai - kuma ni ba mutum bane mai sauƙin girgiza. Hakazalika, zurfin shigar da yawa daga cikin hukumomin tsaronmu na ƙasa yana da ban mamaki da damuwa, har ma ga marubucin nan da ya rubuta wani littafi mai taken, "Tashi na Tsaron Halittu."
Haushi da wuce gona da iri sun kasance fasali gama-gari a bangarorin biyu na takaddamar manufofin covid. Amma zan iya cewa da dukkan hankali da sanin ya kamata (kuma ku, masu karatu masu kyau, za ku gyara ni idan na yi kuskure a nan): wannan shaidar tana nuna muna fallasa mafi tsanani, daidaitawa, da kuma babban cin zarafi na 'yancin faɗar albarkacin baki na Farko ta hannun reshen zartarwa na gwamnatin tarayya a tarihin Amurka. Lokaci, cikakken tsayawa. Ko yunkurin farfagandar yakin basasa bai kai irin wannan matakin ba, haka nan gwamnatin a kwanakin baya ba ta da karfin da kafafen sada zumunta na zamani ke amfani da su.
Ku kasance da mu don samun ƙarin sabuntawa yayin da wannan shari'ar ta bayyana.
An sake bugawa daga marubucin Mayarwa
-
Aaron Kheriaty, Babban mashawarcin Cibiyar Brownstone, masani ne a Cibiyar Da'a da Harkokin Jama'a, DC. Shi tsohon farfesa ne na ilimin hauka a Jami'ar California a Makarantar Magunguna ta Irvine, inda ya kasance darektan da'a na likitanci.
Duba dukkan posts
