Ya danganta da matakin sanin ku game da labarin kulle-kulle na duniya na bazara 2020, mai yiwuwa ko ba ku ji labarin Tomás Pueyo ba. Pueyo MBA ne kuma mai tunani wanda ya shahara kwatsam don labarinsa na Maris 10, 2020 Coronavirus: Me yasa Dole ne ku Yi aiki Yanzu, inda ya roki shugabannin siyasa a duniya da su yi koyi da "nasara" da kasar Sin ta samu kan coronavirus ta hanyar aiwatar da tsauraran matakai.
Pueyo ba shi da wasu takaddun shaidar da suka dace ko kuma sha'awar ilimin cututtukan cuta - kuma babu kaɗan don nuna inda ya sami ra'ayoyinsa game da ƙwayar cuta - amma, abin mamaki kamar yadda ake iya gani, labarin Pueyo ba da daɗewa ba ya zama ɗayan labaran da aka fi rabawa a duk shekara, kuma yana ɗaya daga cikin manyan abubuwan da ke haifar da kulle-kullen duniya na bazara 2020, musamman a Turai. Yanzu, kasancewar ya yi shuru tsawon shekaru uku da suka gabata, Pueyo ta dawo da wata sabuwa zaren hoto ko bidiyo mai zagaya yanar gizo da sauri zargin karya kwanan nan Cochrane sake dubawa Ƙarshe cewa umarnin abin rufe fuska ya yi "kadan zuwa babu bambanci" wajen hana COVID ko mura.
A matsayin malami ɗaya a Jami'ar Sheffield taƙaitaccen Labarin Pueyo a cikin 2020:
Masana sun dawo cikin salon. Don haka labarin ya tafi a farkon farkon rikicin COVID-19… Wannan ya zama matsayi mara dorewa… Pueyo bai yi da'awar ƙwarewa ta musamman ko takaddun shaidar da suka dace ba, kuma kallo a Matsakaicin bayanin martabarsa bai nuna wani sha'awar ilimin cuta a baya ba, sai dai nau'ikan rubutu da lakabi kamar Abin da Tashi na Skywalker zai iya Koyarwa Game da Labarun Labari da Abin da Na Koyi akan Facebook. Wannan duk ya yi kama da rashin dacewa don sabon shekarun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun da ya kamata mu fuskanta, amma… [Coronavirus: Me ya sa Dole ne ku Yi aiki Yanzu] ya sami ra'ayoyi miliyan 40 masu ban sha'awa a cikin kwanaki tara na farko tun bayan bugawa kuma an fassara shi cikin harsuna sama da 40.
A cikin labarin nasa na 2020, Pueyo ya bukaci shugabannin da su yi amfani da hanyoyin dakile kwayar cutar ta China.
Adadin kararrakin ya karu sosai har sai da China ta dauke shi. Amma a lokacin, ya yo waje, kuma yanzu annoba ce da ba wanda zai iya dakatarwa.
Labarin na Pueyo ya yadu cikin sauri mai ban mamaki kuma masu tasiri da mashahuran mutane da yawa sun raba shi. Amma halayen sun bambanta. Manyan masu sharhi da yawa sun bayyana kaduwa da rashin cancantar Pueyo, kuma sun zarge shi da kasancewa "maƙaryaci da zamba."
Wasu kuma sun yi tambaya kan yadda wani wanda ba shi da gogewa ko sha'awar cutar ta baya ya zama ɗaya daga cikin muryoyin da suka fi tasiri a cikin gaggawar lafiyar jama'a.
Lokacin da aka tambaye shi game da takardun shaidarsa, Pueyo ya amsa: "Wataƙila kun lura da MSc na biyu da aikace-aikacen ƙwayoyin cuta da yawa da na gina waɗanda suka tattara miliyoyin masu amfani - tare da haɓaka iri ɗaya - yana kiran kwarewarsa game da aikace-aikacen kafofin watsa labarai na hoto a matsayin cancanta don tattauna yaduwar ƙwayoyin cuta a cikin ilimin halitta.
Ba tare da damuwa ba, a cikin kwanaki, Pueyo ya sanya hanyoyin haɗi zuwa fassarorin masu inganci na labarinsa a cikin harsuna da dama. Labarin Pueyo mai kalmomi 6,000 ya shahara sosai, don haka labarin ya ci gaba, cewa masu karatu cikin kwanaki, sun samar da fassarori marasa kyau a kusan kowane harshe.
Daga nan sai Pueyo ya ci gaba da rangadi yana ba ‘yan majalisar dokoki na jihohi da shugabannin kasa shawara kan aiwatar da ayyukan kulle-kulle.
Labarin Pueyo ya ƙunshi abubuwan ban mamaki da yawa. Sau da yawa ana kiransa coronavirus a matsayin “annoba,” amma har zuwa ranar 10 ga Maris, Hukumar Lafiya ta Duniya ba ta ayyana barkewar cutar ba, kuma a cikin labarin, an tabbatar da lamuran kasa da kashi 0.0015 na yawan mutanen duniya. A cikin labarin, Pueyo ya roki shugabannin siyasa:
Amma a cikin makonni 2-4, lokacin da duk duniya ke cikin kulle-kulle, lokacin da 'yan kwanaki masu daraja na nisantar da jama'a da za ku ba da damar ceton rayuka, mutane ba za su ƙara zarge ku ba: Za su gode muku don yanke shawarar da ta dace.
Ba wai kawai coronavirus ba har yanzu ba ta zama annoba ba, amma har zuwa ranar 10 ga Maris akwai kasa da 200 da aka tabbatar sun kamu da cutar a duk duniya masu tasowa a wajen kasar Sin - kasa da shari'a daya a cikin mutane miliyan 20. Babu wani kyakkyawan dalili da za a yi imani da cewa duk duniya za ta kasance cikin kulle-kulle cikin makonni biyu zuwa hudu, idan aka ba da manufar babu wani misali a duniyar yamma ta zamani.
Labarin Pueyo ya ƙunshi wani salo na GIF wanda ke nuna yadda za a iya amfani da matakan kulle-kulle na China don "ɓata lanƙwasa," wanda yawancin masu tasiri suka haɗa yayin raba labarin.
Kwanaki bayan haka, CGTN, babbar cibiyar yada farfagandar jam'iyyar Kwaminisanci ta kasar Sin, ta yi musayar hoto iri daya a cikin wani labari. sashen labarai yana karfafa yadda duniya ta amince da manufofin kasar Sin na kulle-kullen.
A ranar 19 ga Maris, 2020, Pueyo ta buga wani Matsakaici labarin mai take Guduma da rawa, yana bayanin dabarun Pueyo mai suna "Hammer" - sauri, kulle-kulle mai tsauri lokacin da barkewar ta faru - ta hanyar "Rawan" - ganowa, sa ido, da matakan keɓewa.
Kwanaki uku bayan buga Pueyo Guduma da rawa, takardar dabarun da gwamnatin Jamus (wanda aka yi wa lakabi da "Panic Paper") ya kasance a asirce rarraba ga 'yan majalisa da wasu kafafen yada labarai - suna taka muhimmiyar rawa a cikin kulle-kullen Jamus.
Duk da cewa an buga shi kwanaki uku kacal bayan labarin Pueyo, Takardar Firgita ta Jamus ta dogara sosai kan aikin Pueyo, tana tattaunawa kan “Hammer and Dance.” Koyaya, kalmar "Hammer da Dance" ba ta da tarihi a cikin ilimin cututtukan cuta - Tomas Pueyo ya ƙirƙira ta a labarinsa na Maris 19.
Otto Kölbl, daya daga cikin mawallafin littafin firgici na Jamus, wanda ba shi da masaniya kan cututtukan cututtuka ko lafiyar jama'a, amma ya koyar da shekaru da yawa a kasar Sin kuma ya gudanar da wani shafin yanar gizo wanda ya so. aka bayyana Hongkong a matsayin "mai shan inna" kuma ya yaba da kyakkyawan shugabanci na CCP na Tibet.
Wani marubucin Takarda Firgita, Maximilian Mayer, shi ma ba shi da ilimin annoba ko asalin lafiya amma ya shafe shekaru yana aiki a Jami'ar Nottingham a Ningbo China, Jami'ar Tongji a Shanghai, da Jami'ar Renmin ta Beijing.
Daga baya, daruruwan shafuka na imel ɗin da ke ɗauke da sadarwar da ke kaiwa ga Takardar tsoro an samu ta hanyar FOIA. A cikin imel ɗaya, Mayer rubuta cewa yana ba da bayanan “asiri” game da martanin da Sinawa ta mayar, kuma a wani na musamman shawarar: “Muna ba da shawarar taken ‘tsare gaba ɗaya. Saƙonnin imel ɗin sun ƙunshi ambaton China akai-akai, amma kusan dukkanin waɗannan an sake gyara su. The bayyana dalili: "Zai iya yin illa ga dangantakar kasa da kasa."
Har wala yau, har yanzu ba a san inda Pueyo ya sami ra'ayoyin ɗaukar kwayar cutar don labaransa na 2020 ba. Zuwa wani mataki, ra'ayoyin Pueyo sun yi kama da na manyan masu goyon bayan kulle-kullen kamar Farfesa na Kwalejin Imperial Neil Ferguson- Architect na samfuran COVID marasa inganci waɗanda suka haifar da kulle-kulle a cikin duniya kyauta - wanda ya riga ya yi. amincewa matakan kulle-kullen duniya. Amma duk da haka a waje da al'ummar cututtukan cututtukan fata, waɗannan ra'ayoyin sun yi nisa da sanannun. A mafi yawancin lokuta, sai da labaran Pueyo ne waɗannan ra'ayoyin na tsauraran matakan hana ƙwayoyin cuta suka kai ga al'ada.
A cikin shekaru masu zuwa, tsauraran kulle-kulle na 2020 ya zama ɗayan manyan bala'o'in siyasa na ƙarni da suka gabata. Kamar yadda Wall Street Journal saka shi: "Kullewar cutar ta kasance matsala ce ta siyasa ga shekaru, kuma sakamakon tattalin arziki, zamantakewa da kiwon lafiya har yanzu suna ci gaba." Kuma kamar yadda UK ke Daily tangarahu rubuta: "Basket-case Biritaniya ita ce tabbatacciyar hujjar kullewa kuskure ne babba." Ko da tsakiya-hagu London Times bayyana damuwa: "Na goyi bayan kulle-kullen gaba ɗaya (kuma na ji daɗinsa sosai) amma ni kawai ƙwanƙwasa ne?"
Kuma har ma da New York Times a hankali amince da wani binciken yana nuna cewa martani ga COVID ya haifar da mutuwar sama da 170,000 tsakanin matasan Amurkawa waɗanda suka kasance ba wanda ake dangantawa da cutar: "Duk wannan yana nuna cewa manyan canje-canje masu dorewa a cikin halaye na rayuwa waɗanda aka tsara don guje wa ƙwayar cuta guda ɗaya ba wai kawai tsadar damar 'tattalin arziki' bane, har ma da asarar rayukan matasa masu ban tsoro."
Ko da waɗannan ƙima mara kyau na iya zama babban rashin fahimta. A ƙarshe, kulle-kulle da takunkumin da gwamnatoci suka sanya don mayar da martani ga COVID-19 ya kashe miliyoyin, tura Dubun-dubatar miliyoyin mutane cikin matsanancin talauci, sun tabarbare lafiyar kwakwalwar biliyoyin, da kuma tura dala tiriliyan na dukiya daga matalautan duniya zuwa masu arziki, duk tsawon lokacin. kasawa don samun wani tasiri mai ma'ana akan yaduwar cutar coronavirus.
Tun lokacin da yake fafutukar hana kulle-kulle a cikin 2020, Pueyo ya yi shuru kan batun matakan COVID. Pueyo ya yi magana don tallafawa "Zero Covid," amma gabaɗaya ya mai da hankali kan abubuwan da ke faruwa a wasu lokuta kan wasu batutuwa. Mutum zai iya yin hasashe game da ma'anar wannan shiru. Wataƙila ya yi kuskure kawai, ko ma ya yi nadama?
Amma yanzu, Pueyo ya sake yin ruri a wurin tare da sabon zaren hoto ko bidiyo mai zagaya yanar gizo da sauri Cochrane sake dubawa wanda ya kammala da cewa umarnin abin rufe fuska ya yi "kadan zuwa babu bambanci" wajen hana COVID ko mura, da kai hari rahoton na bitar Cochrane ta New York Times da sauransu.
Kamar labaransa Matsakaici na 2020, mashahurai, masu tasiri, har ma da masana kimiyya sun raba zaren Pueyo.
Kamar yadda New York Times kuma wasu sun lura, ana ɗaukar sake dubawa na Cochrane a matsayin ma'auni na zinariya na sake dubawa na tsari. Duk da haka baya ga waɗannan kurakurai da yawa, waɗanda ke kan zaren Pueyo sun rasa mafi kyawun ma'anar duka. Ko da za su iya yin kama da wasu ramukan dabaru a cikin bita na Cochrane, hakan har yanzu yana barin su da abin da suke da shi a baya: daidai RCTs ɗin da ke nuna cewa umarnin abin rufe fuska yana da wani tasiri mai mahimmanci wajen rage yaduwar COVID.
Amma duk da haka abin da ya fi haskakawa duka yana iya kasancewa cikin abin da wannan sabon zaren ya gaya mana game da manufar Pueyo. Dangane da barnar da ba za a iya misalta ba ta hanyar kulle-kulle wanda labarin nasa na 2020 ya taka rawar gani, mai yiwuwa mutum ya yi tunanin cewa Pueyo na iya ɗaukar wasu ra'ayoyi game da yin la'akari da lamuran manufofin jama'a a wajen filin sa. Yunkurin kunyar Pueyo na jefa inuwa ga Cochrane da kuma New York Times ya kamata ya gaya mana duk abin da muke buƙatar sani: Duk da miliyoyin rayuka da aka lalata, ɗaya daga cikin manyan masu fafutukar kulle-kullen duniya da alama bai yi nadama ba game da ayyukansa.
Sake bugawa daga marubucin Mayarwa
-
Michael P Senger lauya ne kuma marubucin Man Maciji: Yadda Xi Jinping Ya Rufe Duniya. Tun daga Maris 19 ya kasance yana binciken tasirin jam'iyyar kwaminisanci ta kasar Sin game da martanin da duniya ke bayarwa game da COVID-2020, kuma a baya ya rubuta kamfen yada farfagandar kulle-kulle ta duniya da The Masked Ball of Cowardice a cikin Mujallar Tablet.
Duba dukkan posts
