A farkon Janairu na 2024, Amurkawa sun koyi game da buga labarin daga Elsevier's Journal of Biomedicine da Pharmacotherapy kulawa da Dr. Danyelle Townsend, farfesa a Jami'ar South Carolina College of Pharmacy's Sashen Gano Magunguna da Kimiyyar Halittu. A matsayin Babban Edita, Dokta Townsend ya bita, ya amince, kuma ya buga labarin mai taken: “Mutuwar da ta haifar ta hanyar tausayi ta amfani da hydroxychloroquine a lokacin tashin COVID-19 na farko: kimantawa. "
Labarin ya kasance wani kiyasi ne na mutane wanda iya samun ya mutu, amma har yanzu kimantawa ya kasance koma. Dalilin ja da baya shi ne cewa bayanan Belgian da ke ɗaya daga cikin tushe na yanki an gano shi ne "unreliable” (amma a zahiri ya kasance zamba). Labarin kuma akai-akai nuni da New England Journal of Medicine's 2020 Gwajin FADAWA. Gwajin SADAUKI sanannen abu ne a nazari mai zurfi wanda, ban da aiwatarwa jinya a cikin rashin lafiya mai tsanani An yi amfani da marasa lafiya na Covid musamman high allurai na HCQ.
Mawallafin da aka janye a yanzu duk Faransanci ne ko Kanada, tare da marubucin farko masanin harhada magunguna da sunan Alexia Pradelle ne adam wata. A cewar wani bincike na intanet, Dr. Pradelle bai taba bugawa ba. Daga baya, marubutan da aka jera an basu digiri a matsayin likitoci, masu harhada magunguna, da/ko farfesoshi na fannonin karatun su. Babban, marubucin da ya dace, Jean-Christophe Lega, gudanar da Evaluation da Modeling of Therapeutic Effects tawagar a Jami'ar Lyon.
Tarihin Tsaro na Fabled Hydroxychloroquine ya bambanta bayanai
Baya ga kasancewa kiyasin hasashe, labarin ya kuma kai hari ga amintaccen amincin HCQ, wanda ya saba wa ƙarni na amincin quinolines a matsayin aji.
HCQ, chloroquine da quinine suna da alaƙa da tsari da magunguna / injiniyoyi, suna raba iri ɗaya. ƙungiyar tsarin quinoline. Asalin sake fasalin quinine wani bincike ne mai matukar sa'a wanda ya samo asali tun shekarun 1600 (akalla) a matsayin tipple din magani da ake amfani dashi. Masu mishan Jesuit a Kudancin Amirka. An samo shi ta dabi'a a cikin haushi na Cinchona itace (kuma ana kiranta itace "Quina-Quina").
Quinine har yanzu yana samuwa a yau duka biyun a matsayin magani magani, ga alamomi masu kama da HCQ ciki har da zazzabin cizon sauro…kuma a matsayin Covidien-19 magani.
Quinine yana da lafiya sosai don yana iya zama na musamman a cikin cewa FDA a lokaci guda ta ba da izinin amfani da shi ba tare da takardar sayan magani ba, azaman sinadari a ciki ruwan tonic.
Schweppes tonic ruwa "Ya ƙunshi Quinine" kamar yadda duk ruwan tonic ke yi. Winston Churchill ya taba bayyana, "Gin da tonic sun ceci rayuka da tunanin Ingilishi fiye da duk likitocin da ke cikin Daular. "
Hakanan HCQ yana da aminci idan aka yi amfani da shi daidai kuma ƙarƙashin kulawar likita.
CDC ta bayyana HCQ a matsayin "wani in mun gwada da kyau jure magani"Kuma"Ana iya rubuta HCQ ga manya da yara na kowane zamani. Hakanan za a iya ɗauka ta hanyar lafiya ta mata masu ciki da masu shayarwa” yana nufin ta dogon lokaci amfani da cututtuka na kullum.
Ma'anar asali tana nufin cewa, idan magani yana da aminci ga dogon lokaci amfani, zai kuma zama lafiya ga gajere amfani, duk da (kuma musamman) a ciki Maganin farko na Covid-19Alamun nau'in prophylaxis pre-exposure.
Waɗannan su ne tushen ilimin ilimin harhada magunguna waɗanda yakamata a san su da su wani Pharmacist ko likita - balle kuma ga farfesa dake aiki a matsayin Babban Editan Jarida a jihar mai biyan haraji Kwalejin Magunguna.
Ko mutum daya bai mata ba kwamitin edita na sama da 50 "masu bita-tsawo" da ma'aikata Yi la'akari da tarihin HCQ (da magabatan sa) da kuma yadda binciken wannan binciken ya kasance bai dace ba kafin zabar buga bayanan da ke lalata lafiyar HCQ?
Madaidaicin amsar wannan na iya kasancewa: "a'a"…
Bugawa ginin edita duk da alama masana kimiyya ne na binciken benci (ba na asibiti ba), bisa ga tarihin rayuwarsu. Kodayake hukumar ta inganta kanta a matsayin biyan bukatun DEI na kasancewa "bambancin jinsi, "Mahimmin tambaya na iya kasancewa shine idan suna da daidaitattun takaddun shaida da gogewa don yin nazari da ra'ayi akan batutuwan da suka shafi lafiyar magunguna/cututtukan cututtukan da ke da alaƙa da farko.
Shin akwai wani yanzu da aka yarda ya ba da ra'ayi akan abubuwan da suka shafi lafiyar magunguna na musamman na asibiti?
A cikin wasu mujallu/waɗanda labarai, amsar tambayar da alama ita ce: “Ee”…
Waɗannan “Mutuwar 17,000” Ba su taɓa faruwa ba
Wani batu na ruɗani ya kewaye fassarar da haɓaka wannan ɗan jarida da ba a san shi ba.
Don zama ainihin: akwai faufau "Mutuwar 17,000;" ya kasance ko da yaushe wani hasashe extrapolation na mutane cewa iya samun ya mutu, bisa “marasa dogaro” (misali, a zahiri, zamba) bayanan bayanai a saman abubuwan da aka ambata a baya, matsala na ƙarshen mataki na CIGABA-nau'in gwaji da lokaci.
Duk da haka, Josh Cohen, a Forbes.com Babban marubucin fannin kiwon lafiya na PhD, ya yi amfani da wannan littafin don ba da labarin wani zaɓe na nuna son kai ga HCQ, yana mai cewa shawarar HCQ ta Trump ita ce "Yana da alaƙa da Mutuwar 17,000. " Forbes ' Tufts, Harvard, da Jami'ar Pennsylvania- horarwa "Kiwon lafiya Analyst" ba da labari ko bayyana rashin fahimtar hanyoyin binciken da aka ja da baya ko tsinkaya.
Ya gangara daga can. 'Yan sa'o'i kaɗan bayan littafin, masu kama da juna, yanzu ba daidai ba ne, an siyasantar da su sosai, kuma da alama an haɗa kai hari kan HCQ da Trump: The Hill, POLITICO, Labaran Gaba, Labaran Scripps, da Guardian, Labaran Lafiya KFF, Labaran Kasa, Newsweek, AOL.com, Yahoo News, Da kuma Daily Kos, ban da a taron na shahara yanki, kasa da kasa, da Amurka tarayya Zafi kantuna, da yawa sun yi kiyasin cewa an riga an kashe mutane 17,000 kuma jinin wadanda abin ya shafa ya riga ya kasance a hannun Donald Trump.
Tun daga Satumba 15, 2024, abubuwan da ke sama da sauran labaran har yanzu suna nunawa sosai (a shafi na farko) na Binciken Google don "hydroxychloroquine mutuwa”… bai taba faruwa ba.
Anan ga wasu hotunan kariyar kwamfuta na kanun labarai da ke magana game da mutuwar da ba a wanzu ba bisa wani binciken da aka janye yanzu:
Kusan nan da nan bayan fitowar Janairu 2, 2024, manyan kurakuran sa ciki har da kuskuren asali a tsakanin sauran kasawa da yawa aka kawowa Dr. Townsend ta Xavier Azalbert da BonSens.org mai zaman kansa lauyoyi farawa daga Jan 7, 2024. Haƙiƙa, jimillar hanyoyin sadarwa guda 9 waɗanda na sama suka aiko, amma babu daya daga cikinsu Dr. Townsend ya taɓa raba su azaman "Wasiƙu zuwa Edita" da kyakkyawar niyya don sanar da masu karatu takamaiman gazawa, kamar yadda aka saba yi.
Dokta Townsend ya yi kama da manta cewa munanan bayanan likita da wallafe-wallafe na iya yin cutar da majiyyaci na ainihi, kuma ta ci gaba da yin la'akari da mahimmancin binciken da kanta. Maimakon daukar nauyi da yanke shawarar jagoranci, ta wuce da kudi zuwa a Kwamitin da'a na Wallafa, jinkirta ja da baya da ake bukata.
Abin ban tsoro ya ɗauki kwanaki 234 (~ watanni 7, daga fitowar Janairu 2nd zuwa Agusta 26th) don Dr. Townsend's Jaridar Biomedicine da Pharmacotherapy to a karshe janye labarin "marasa amintacce". Amma a wannan lokacin, miliyoyin mutane a duniya sun riga sun kasance (kuma ci gaba da kasancewa) gurɓatacce da bayanan da ba daidai ba game da mutuwar HCQ da ba ta wanzu ba.
Wannan ya haifar da wasu tambayoyi game da Dokta TownsendAyyuka da nauyin da ke kansa a matsayin Babban Editan:
- Wane ƙoƙari ne aka yi don gyara kanun labarai da labaran da jaridu suka buga ba daidai ba, waɗanda ke tsoratar da marasa lafiya, masu harhada magunguna, da likitocin da ba daidai ba, ta hanyar rura wutar tropes na ƙarya game da HCQ?
- Wane ƙoƙari ne aka yi don sanar da ƙungiyoyin labarai cewa bayanai daga littafin da aka yi bita na ɗan adam ana tambaya? (Ta na nufin "da dama wasiƙu zuwa ga Edita da wasiƙun masu karatu. ")
- Wane ƙoƙarin da ake yi nan take don sanar da ƙungiyoyin labarai da/ko ƙara haɓaka sakamakon injunan bincike game da littafin da aka janye yanzu?
- Abin da tushen kuɗi/mutum ya biya $3,490 ("ban da haraji da kudade") kudin bugawa? (Lura: sanannun mujallu na ilimi ba sa cajin buga labarai.)
- Ya da Elsevier Journal of Biomedicine da Pharmacotherapy saduwa da wasu ma'anoni na abin da aka sani da a m mawallafi?
- Shin wannan Hukumar Edita ta cancanci yin bitar tsari/amincin magani/cututtukan cuta/wasu batutuwa na asibiti?
- Shin an san ginshiƙan fitowar wannan Jarida da ja da baya da ta biyo baya Jami'ar South Carolina gudanarwa, jami'o'i, da duk wanda ya yanke hukunci a sashensa Code of Ethics & Standards of Practice?
- wannan ba shine karo na farko da Townsend ke buƙatar janye labarai ba – al’amarin da ba kasafai yake faruwa ba ga manyan mujallu. Will Elsevier, wanda yana buga jaridu sama da 2,700, ba da izinin ƙarin ra'ayi ko bugawa akan batutuwan asibiti ta wannan ginin edita? Shin za a iya aminta da Babban Editan da/ko hukumar edita don kau da kai daga yin ra'ayi kan kowane batutuwan da ba su cikin ƙwararrunsu?
- Me ya kamata a yi don hana sake afkuwar wannan lamari a Jami'ar South Carolina da sauran cibiyoyin masu biyan haraji?
Bayan haka, menene ramuwa / azabtarwa (idan akwai) zai faru ga sauran fitattun Covid-19 Lancet da kuma New England Journal of Medicine marubuta/marubuta wanda labarin ya kasance kuma ja da baya bayan an same su bisa abin da ake kira "unreliable” (misali, babu) bayanan bayanai?
Masana kimiyya na ɗabi'a waɗanda suka yi imani da gaskiya, gaskiya, da lissafin ilimi suna tsaye, suna jiran shari'ar likita da ilimi.
Masana kimiyyar da ba su da da'a suma suna kallon wannan yanayin da ke faruwa, suna murza gashin baki, suna koyon abin da wata rana za su iya tserewa.
RA'AYI: Wannan labarin ba shawara ba ne na likita. KADA KA fara ko dakatar da kowane magani ba tare da fara tattaunawa da likitan kantin magani ko likitan da ka sani kuma ka amince da shi ba.
-
Dokta David Gortler masanin ilimin harhada magunguna ne, likitan harhada magunguna, masanin kimiyyar bincike kuma tsohon memba na Babban Jami'in Gudanarwa na FDA wanda ya zama babban mai ba da shawara ga Kwamishinan FDA akan al'amuran: Al'amuran ka'idoji na FDA, amincin magunguna da manufofin kimiyya na FDA. Shi tsohon jami'ar Yale ne da kuma jami'ar Georgetown didactic farfesa a fannin harhada magunguna da fasahar kere-kere, tare da sama da shekaru goma na koyar da ilimin kimiyya da bincike na benci, a zaman wani bangare na kwarewarsa ta kusan shekaru ashirin a ci gaban muggan kwayoyi. Shi babban ɗan'uwa ne a fannin kiwon lafiya da manufofin FDA a Gidauniyar Heritage a Washington DC da 2023 Brownstone Fellow.
Duba dukkan posts
