Jirgin ruwan da ya nutse na masu sha'awar aikin ya dauki karin ruwa a watan da ya gabata tare da buga wani gidan wutar lantarki. takarda ta wasu manyan masana ilimin halittu na duniya (daga Oxford, Harvard, Johns Hopkins, da Toronto).
Zane akan Cibiyoyin Kula da Cututtuka da Rigakafin Cututtuka da kuma bayar da rahoto game da abubuwan da ba su dace ba, marubutan sun yi iƙirarin cewa ƙa'idodin ƙarfafawa a jami'o'i ba daidai ba ne saboda illar da ake sa ran ga wannan rukunin shekaru ya zarce fa'idodin kiwon lafiyar jama'a. Marubutan sun kiyasta, alal misali, cewa 22,000 zuwa 30,000 a baya wadanda ba su kamu da cutar ba masu shekaru 18 zuwa 29 dole ne a haɓaka su tare da rigakafin mRNA don hana asibiti guda ɗaya na COVID-19. Kuma farashin hana wannan asibiti guda 18 zuwa 98 munanan munanan abubuwan da ake tsammani.
Wannan takarda ita ce tabbatacciyar manna-daga-sama da waɗanda ke yaƙin umarni suka yi ta addu'a. Alhamdu lillahi ya zo lokacin da aka yi watsi da saƙon lafiyar jama'a mai sa maye cewa allurar mRNA ita ce hanya ɗaya tilo don ceton ɗan adam daga COVID-19.
Amma, tare da duk ƙarfinsa, Ina damuwa cewa takarda ta rasa babban batu game da dalilin da ya sa umarnin rigakafi ba daidai ba ne. Har yanzu ana wasa ne a wasan fa'ida mai tsadar ra'ayi, maras kyau wanda ke da ka'idoji waɗanda ke ba ƙungiyar fifiko akan mutum ɗaya kuma ba ta ba da cikakkiyar ƙima ga haƙƙin mulkin kai ba.
Yin wasa da basira a wasan ƙwararrun ƙwararru wani nau'in shan kashi ne kawai.
Masu sha'awar sha'awar sau da yawa suna cewa umarni ya dace saboda suna hana ainihin cutarwa ga wasu yayin da ba su cutar da mutum ba ko kuma kawai ƙaramin haɗarin cutarwa (daga yiwuwar sakamako masu illa, waɗanda suke ɗauka don zama maras kyau ta kwatanta). Yin la'akari da haɗarin cutarwa ga ainihin cutarwa koyaushe yana haifar da fa'ida mai amfani, don haka wajibi, don yin rigakafin.
Amma wannan ba gaskiya ba ne. Yin alurar riga kafi a ƙarƙashin tursasawa ko saboda tilastawa ba kawai haɗarin cutarwa bane amma ainihin cutarwa ga cin gashin kansa na jiki don haka ga mutumtaka.
Babu wani abu da ya fi ma'anar rayuwar ɗan adam, kuma babu wani abu mai mahimmanci don samar da rayuwa mai daraja, a matsayin ƙarfinmu na hukuma mai ma'ana, wanda ke da kima kamar ita kanta rayuwa. 'Yancin kai na jiki - 'yancin yin mulki a kan jikin mutum - ba wai kawai "mai kyau-da-da-ba;" ma'anar ma'anar iyawa ce ta sa mu wanene da abin da muke.
Kamar yadda masanin da'a dan kasar Australia Michael Kowalik ya rubuta (pdf), "Agent-autonomy game da tsarin mulkin kai yana da cikakkiyar fifiko na yau da kullun akan ragewa ko kawar da haɗarin da ke tattare da rayuwa."
Mutumin da aka yiwa alurar riga kafi akan mafi kyawun hukuncinta ba wai kawai yana fuskantar illar illa ba; tana fama da lahani na gaske da jurewa ga iyawar da ke sa rayuwar ɗan adam ta yiwu.
Me yasa masu sha'awa ba sa ganin wannan?
Domin kawai ma'aunin amincin da muke fahimta a cikin al'adunmu masu sha'awar kimiyya shine amincin jiki: haɗin kai na aiki na jikinmu na zahiri. Al'adarmu ta fahimci yadda ƙwayoyin cuta ke yin ɓarna a cikin jiki amma ba yadda raunin ɗabi'a ke haifar da ɓarna a cikin rai ba. Don haka ba mu bar wani wuri ba don ƙaddamar da ƙima ga hare-hare kan cin gashin kai da mutunci.
Ba mu buƙatar jira don gano yadda takardar ma'auni na fa'ida za ta kasance a wannan faɗuwar ko a cikin 2023 ko…. Dokokin rigakafin ba daidai ba ne yanzu. Sun yi kuskure a farkon 2021. Kuma za su yi kuskure a kowane lokaci a nan gaba lokacin da cututtukan cututtuka ko al'adu suka sa mu sake zagaye game da wannan batu.
Dokokin rigakafin ba daidai ba ne ba don sun kasa samar da fa'ida ba ko kuma saboda haɗarin waɗanda aka yi wa alurar riga kafi sun fi fa'idodin lafiyar jama'a (ko da yake duka biyun gaskiya ne).
Ba daidai ba ne saboda sun tattake ainihin abin da ya kamata a ce mafi kyawun tsarin dimokuradiyya mai sassaucin ra'ayi ya kamata ya yi kokarin haifarwa. Idan al'ummarmu za ta kasance mai girma, dole ne ta yi burin fiye da aminci ko, mafi daidai, fahimtar aminci. Mafarinsa dole ne ya zama cikakkiyar alƙawarin samar da mafi girman yanki mai yuwuwa ga kowane mutum ya rayu tare da mutuncin jiki da tunani.
Ba mu rancen rayukanmu don rage haɗarin wasu ko haɗarin da muke gani ba. Domin farashin koyaushe yana da yawa. Kudin shine mutuntakar mu.
An sake buga shi daga Epoch.
-
Dokta Julie Ponesse, 2023 Brownstone Fellow, farfesa ce a fannin ɗabi'a wadda ta koyar a Kwalejin Jami'ar Huron ta Ontario na tsawon shekaru 20. An ba ta hutu kuma an hana ta shiga harabarta saboda umarnin rigakafin. Ta gabatar da shi a jerin Faith and Democracy a ranar 22, 2021. Dr. Ponesse yanzu ya ɗauki sabon matsayi tare da Asusun Demokraɗiyya, wata ƙungiyar agaji ta Kanada mai rijista da nufin haɓaka 'yancin ɗan adam, inda take aiki a matsayin ƙwararren masaniyar ɗabi'a.
Duba dukkan posts
