Rachael Bedard's New York Magazine labarin, "Me yasa Kiran RFK Jr. 'Anti-Science' Ya Rasa Maganar, " yana ɗaya daga cikin ingantattun jiyya masu fa'ida don bayyana a cikin kafofin watsa labarai na gado game da canjin zamanin Kennedy a cikin harkokin kula da lafiyar jama'a. Mun yaba wa marubucin don gane abin da yawancin ƴan siyasa da kafofin watsa labarai suka ƙaryata ko kuma suka yi watsi da su: cewa Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. bai ƙi kimiyya ba, amma yana buƙatarsa - cikakke, daidai, kuma a bayyane.
Bedard daidai ya tsara tsarin Kennedy a matsayin martani ga rushewar amincewar jama'a ga cibiyoyin kimiyya, ba a hanyar kimiyyar kanta ba. Ta fahimce ta tana ba da ƙarin haske game da gazawar "tushen gaskiya" na al'ada don dawo da gaskiya a cikin al'adun ƙwararrun ƙwararru-inda gadon ya nemi yarjejeniya, ikon tsarawa, da martabar hukuma ba tare da ɗaukar nauyin tabbatar da kai ba. A yarda da cewa kimiyya ta shiga cikin shari'ar siyasa da ɗabi'a, Bedard ya rabu da caricature na Kennedy a matsayin mai mayar da martani ko maƙarƙashiya. Don haka muna gode mata.
Amma bincikenta a ƙarshe ya ƙare ƙasa kaɗan - ba don yana da matukar mahimmanci ba, amma saboda ya kasance mai ba da taimako ga tsarin da Kennedy ke aiki don gyarawa.
Dalilai na Jam'i Basu Daidaita Batun Jam'i
Kiran Bedard na “jam’i masu ma’ana” ana nufin yin la’akari da roƙon Kennedy a cikin duniyar da tsarin ma’ana mai gasa a yanzu ya kasance tare. Amma ta kuskure ta daidaita wannan da rungumar ta batutuwa masu yawa-wani nau'i na ƙwaƙƙwaran ƙwararru inda hujjoji dole ne su kai ga ji, kuma maganganun jama'a ana gudanar da su ta hanyar raɗaɗi mai laushi na "kwarewa mai rai." Wannan kuskuren rukuni ne.
Abin da Kennedy da Cibiyar MAHA suke maidowa ba shine ingantacciyar duk ra'ayoyi ba, amma dawo da mutuncin shaida a matsayin filin da aka raba wanda sabani zai iya faruwa bisa ga doka. Madadin fiat na fasaha ba ƙaƙƙarfan alaƙa ba ne—aiki ne na ƙaƙƙarfan ƙa'idodi a cikin sabis na sanar da jama'a, ba a bayan kofofin rufaffiyar ba amma bisa la'akari da mutanen da kimiyya ke ikirarin yin hidima.
Izinin Ba Rago Ba Ne—Tilastawa Shin
Labarin kuma ya tsallake wani muhimmin yanki na mahallin ɗa'a. Bedard yana nuna cewa lafiyar jama'a ta zama m saboda kimiyya da dabi'u yanzu sun shiga tsakani, kuma "maganin jam'i" sun sa ba za a iya cimma yarjejeniya ba. Amma ba a ƙirƙiri dambarwar ta tsarin ƙima masu gasa ba. Waɗanda suka nemi kawar da zaɓin ƙima gabaɗaya ne suka ƙirƙira shi — ta hanyar ƙaddamar da shawarwari ba tare da cikakken bayyana rashin tabbas ba, rikici, ko wasu hanyoyi.
Ƙimar haɗari yayin fuskantar rashin tabbas koyaushe yana da lalacewa; tilasta wani zaɓi tare da wani ɓangare na bayanin da aka hana don sarrafa hasashe na haɗari wata dabara ce ta tilastawa wacce dokoki da dokoki ba su yarda da yarda ba, wanda aka tsara don kare haƙƙoƙin mutum ɗaya daga hargitsi na mulkin jama'a.
Yarjejeniya ta kyauta, da ta gabata, da kuma sanarwa ba tushen rudani ba ne - sharadi ne mai tabbatarwa ga halacci. Rikicin yana tasowa ne kawai lokacin da aka ƙetare yarda, yanke, ko maye gurbinsa da tilastawa—yawanci ana samun barata ta hanyar roƙon “mafi girma” wanda ba a taɓa fayyace shi ba, auna, ko muhawara mai kyau. Haƙiƙa watsi da yarda da firgici na hukumomi ne suka biyo baya wanda ya tilasta wa hukumomin kiwon lafiyar jama'a dogaro da ƙananan ƙa'idodin shaida, zaɓen wallafe-wallafen, kuma a wasu lokuta, zamba a fili don ci gaba da bin ɗabi'a.
Idan da an sanar da jama'a da gaskiya - game da iyakokin gwajin rigakafin Covid, gazawar kariya daga watsawa, matsalolin tsari a cikin tsarin sa ido na VAERS da VSD, ko ƙwarewar hana rigakafi, da munanan abubuwan da suka faru - da yawa har yanzu sun yarda. Amma da sun yarda da yardar rai. Wannan 'yancin, ba jigon jigon jama'a ba, shine abin da Kennedy ya nace a kai. Kuma shi ne abin da jama'a ke bukata a yanzu.
Bar Kennedy: Ba Sabuwa ba, Kawai An Yi watsi da Shi
A jigon wannan sauyi shi ne abin da muka gane yanzu a matsayin The Kennedy Bar-komawa ga ma'auni na shaida, bayyana gaskiya, da ilimin halitta wanda bai kamata a taɓa samun annashuwa da fari ba. Wannan ma'auni ya haɗa da:
- Dogaro da shaidar daidaitattun zinari
- Tabbatar da injina tare da ƙididdigar ƙididdiga
- Cikakken lissafin rikice-rikice na sha'awa
- Ware bayanan fatalwa da aka buga da zaɓin da aka buga
- Ingancin-duniya ta gaske fiye da ingancin sakin labarai
- Bayyana gaskiya game da cinikin siyasa da hanyoyin da ba a ɗauka ba
Wannan ba sabon salo ba ne. Yana da tsarin ƙwaƙwalwar ajiya na kimiyya, tunawa da ƙarfafawa.
Yi la'akari, alal misali, daidaitaccen haɗin gwiwa da dogon lokaci Kennedy tare da Burbacher et al. (2005) Nazarin farko akan thimerosal. Wannan binciken ya nuna dawwama, ainihin jigon mercury daga thimerosal a cikin nama na kwakwalwa, amma duk da haka an cire shi gaba ɗaya daga kimanta haɗarin da hukumomin kiwon lafiyar jama'a suka fi sha'awar kiyaye daidaiton labari fiye da gano alamun da ke fitowa. Har yanzu ana dogara da shi kuma ana yin kuskure akai-akai. Kennedy ya ambaci binciken ba a matsayin harsashi na furucin ba, amma a matsayin kira zuwa ga dawo da mutuncin hukumomi bisa ga shaida, ba batun batun ba. Cibiyoyin sun faɗi wannan gwajin-ba don ba su da damar samun ilimin kimiyya mai kyau, amma don sun ƙi sa'ad da ya zama da wahala.
Maƙalar Bedard tana wakiltar ci gaba mai ma'ana a cikin fahimtar jama'a game da tsarin Kennedy. Amma don kammala binciken, dole ne a faɗi a sarari: Kennedy ba ya ɗaukaka batun batun. Idan akwai jam'i, yanzu an sanya shi a cikin DNA na buƙatun jama'a na yawan dabarun likita don rigakafin mutum. Suna da hakki, kuma Kennedy yana girmama shi.
Yana sake tabbatar da haƙiƙanin kimiyya inda aka danne shi bisa tsari. Kuma rawar da gwamnati ke takawa a cikin wannan danniya-musamman ta hanyar tilastawa da kuma dogaro ga magudanan bayanai marasa lahani—ba za a iya ɓoye su cikin ka'idar zamantakewa ba.
Bar Kennedy ba game da maye gurbin tsoffin akidu da sababbi ba. Yana da game da maido da babban shaida domin manufar ta sake kasancewa aikata, ba a dora ba.
Muna maraba da dukan waɗanda suke a shirye su cika wannan ƙa’idar—kuma muna ƙalubalantar waɗanda ba su yi hakan cikin ladabi ba.
-
Dokta James Lyons-Weiler masanin kimiyya ne na bincike kuma ƙwararren marubuci tare da fiye da 55 binciken da aka yi nazari da su da littattafai uku ga sunansa: Ebola: Labari Mai Sauya, Magani vs. Riba, Da kuma Abubuwan Muhalli da Halitta na Autism. Shi ne wanda ya kafa kuma Shugaba na Cibiyar Tsabtace da Ilimi (IPAK).
Duba dukkan posts
