Domin kusan shekaru 50, abin da ke da mahimmanci New York Times dan jarida, Donald G McNeil, Jr. "ya yi duka:" daga kwafi yaro zuwa wakilin kasashen waje zuwa mai ba da rahoto na kimiyya; A ƙarshe ga linchpin lafiya na duniya: nasarorin aikinsa sun haɗa kai tare da ƙwararrun ƙwararrun yanki da aka ambata akai-akai, tsoffin shugabannin NIAID- da CDC, Drs. Anthony Fauci da Tom Frieden; ciniki samun damar sanyawa. Sai Covid.
Barkewar cutar ta mamaye yawancin mulkin McNeil (2002-2021) duk da haka ta kasance abin takaici: faɗakarwar lafiyar jama'a ta numfashi wanda (sa'a a gare mu) ya fashe: SARS, Ebola, alade, mura. Babban abin tsoro na ƙarshen karni na 20, HIV, ya kawo kanun labarai na duniya kamar "Bayan Dogon Bincike na Kimiyya, Har yanzu Babu Maganin AIDS. McNeil ya rubuta (2010), "Duk da ƙoƙarce-ƙoƙarce shekaru da yawa, ba a ƙirƙiro harsashin sihiri don AIDS ba."
A ƙarshen 2015, tsarinsa ya canza, daga m purveyor zuwa annoba m. Donald McNeil ya “gano” Zika; inda kuma profile dinsa da duniya suka canza.
Kuma tabbas Zika ce? "Babban tambaya ce,"
Na aika dogon rubutu zuwa Tom Skinner, babban mai magana da yawun Dr. Thomas R. Frieden, darektan CDC. …Daga wannan lokacin, The Times ya jagoranci labarin gaba. Mun rubuta game da shi akai-akai, kuma yawancin labaran sun kasance a shafi na gaba kuma an nuna su sosai.
Littafin farko na Donald McNeil, Zika, Cutar da ke Faruwa daga baya ya kawo masa yabo, kulawa, mahimmanci, da magana shawarwari. Ko da kamar yadda wannan cutar ta yi "tushe" - nan da nan ta ɓace a tsakiyar 2016, babu wani koma baya a cikin cibiyar sadarwar kiwon lafiyar jama'a/farfaganda ta gaske, kuma ba a taɓa soke saurin yanke hukunci na McNeil ba.
Don haka, an ƙirƙiri hubris, kuma ana maimaita sake zagayowar a farkon 2020 bayan sakin coronavirus na China - tare da fargabar fargaba a tsakiya kuma Mr. Times mimbari na zalunci: misali"Ku tafi Medieval akan Shi."
Ba zato ba tsammani Deus ex machina (wake soke al'ada) ya haifar da saki 2021 daga rayuwarsa NY Times post, amma ya ci gaba da raguwa tare da alamun hayaki na biri, ta hanyar Medium.com. Ta yaya Mista McNeil ya zo ya ɗauki irin wannan muhimmiyar rawa wajen shelar annoba?
A cikin 2012, Editan Jama'a Arthur Brisbane masu karatu masu tambaya "ko ya kamata 'yan jaridu su kalubalanci" gaskiya" (sic) 'Yan jarida sun tabbatar da hakan. ”… Henry Blodget, Shugaba na Insider ya kasance mai ban mamaki: "Watau jami'in yada labarai na Times (yana) tambayar masu karatu ko suna son ta fada musu gaskiya. Da gaske? Wani zabin, zai zama alama, shine takarda ta zama farfaganda kawai ga duk wanda ke son tallata." Wani mai karatu yayi sharhi "Kazafi ne a kira 'bidin gaskiya'' 'firgita'."
Riko da gaskiya ba shi da wani rahoto game da batun "labarai masu taushi:" tana ba da labarai kan nishaɗi- salon rayuwa da batutuwan nishaɗi."Labari mai zafi” a fili yana da mahimmanci: rufe siyasa, tattalin arziki, ayyukan aikata laifuka, da al'amuran jama'a - samar wa masu karatu fahimta da bayanai masu mahimmanci don yanke shawararsu.
Na sake tunanin wannan "Gaskiya Vigilante" -kerfuffle lokacin da ake kimanta dogon oeuvre wato na Mista Donald McNeil. Wasa Times ' (mai son kansa) "Babban mai ba da rahoto game da lafiyar duniya," aiki a karkashin labari mai tsanani' wajibcin kalubalantar "gaskiya" da masu yin labarai suka tabbatar - ko, McNeil ya ba da kansa labarai masu taushi' jin daɗin marubutan da ke ba da labarin nishaɗi? Fatan mu na al'umma tare da abubuwan da za su iya yin muni kamar "lafin duniya" shine gabatar da ɗan jaridan na gaskiya kamar yadda aka sani - duk da ko hakan na iya sa shi rashin amincewa da jami'an gwamnati.
Shin aikin Donald McNeil yana goyan bayan yanke shawarar cewa shi ɗan jarida ne "labari mai wuyar gaske" a sahun gaba na annoba da annoba: ƙalubalantar jami'an kiwon lafiyar jama'a a kan gaskiyarsu; sauke nauyin da ya rataya a wuyan dan jarida na gargajiya na mu’amala da jami’an gwamnati: da kuma kafa tarihi Times masu karatu kamar yadda suka yi tsammani daga gare shi? Tare da keɓaɓɓun keɓaɓɓun- babu, ba ya.
McNeil mai tawali'u ya yi hayar shi Times a 1976 zuwa "nepotism" (amma ya cancanci haka tare da UC/Berkeley BA a cikin Rhetoric). Fitowar sa ta kusan rabin karni na yau da kullun yana samar da sakamako kusan 3,000 a kan Times ' yanar. Bajintar rubuce-rubucen sa ne (ba shi da wani ilimin kimiyya) ya ba shi matsayin wakilin Kimiyyar Kimiyya, 2002. Daga nan, Mista McNeil ya rufe dukkan cututtukan da jami'an kiwon lafiyar jama'a suka yi magana akai - Flu Alade, Ebola, H5N1, Avian Flu, MERS, SARS, Smallpox, Monkeypox, Seasonal Influenza, Covid-19, tare da Zina-XNUMX, tare da Ziyara-XNUMX, tare da Zina-XNUMX. WHO da NIAID.
McNeil ya ba da rahoto da yawa (kuma ba a taɓa yin zazzaɓi) akan furci da tunanin Dr. Tom Frieden ba, a cikin labarai sama da 50 da suka mamaye na Frieden masu girma a matsayin Kwamishinan Lafiya na NYC (2002-2009) da Daraktan CDC (2009-2017) - da raguwa bin Dr. Frieden's "groping"/kamun cin zarafi da jima'i (2018) da laifin aikata laifi (2019). Wannan haɗin gwiwa ya kasance bayan kowannensu abin kunya: Jami'ar Columbia ta karbi bakuncin duka a cikinta #VaccineSymposium, 2022.
Dr. Frieden's ya ci gaba da ɗaukar hoto mai kyau da ƙayyadaddun bayanai a cikin New York Times watakila ya ba shi damar fitar da wani kyakkyawan tsari bayan abin kunya, dabarar sana'a. Ga duk maganganun da Frieden ya yi game da rigakafin rigakafi, ya sami wasu “babban rigakafi” daban-daban - ci gaba da yanke hukunci. $400,000 a kowace shekara "Shugaba" sinecure a nonprofit, Yanke shawara don Ajiye rayuka, - wanda aka rubuta ta mafi girman trifecta na ginshiƙan taimakon taimakon biliyoyi: Bloomberg's, Zuckerberg's, da Gates'. Mai hangen nesa"Ɗaukar Ka'ida” ban taba jin dadi haka ba. Don haka, babu wani rahoton McNeil guda daya da ya kalubalanci "gaskiyar" da Dr. Tom Frieden ya tabbatar, ba sau ɗaya a shekara goma sha biyu ba.
Hakazalika babu wani rahoton McNeil da ya kalubalanci "gaskiyar" da Dr. Anthony Fauci ya tabbatar (wanda aka ambata a cikin ~ Labarai 150ko WHO (nuni ~ 900x). Misali, a lokacin SARS na 2003. McNeil ya goyi bayan WHO kan Taiwan, yin watsi da ikon PRC akan WHO - wanda (ko da a cikin 2003, a ƙarƙashin dokar China) ba zai sa ƙafa a Taiwan ba.
Misalin McNeil na maimaita yarda da biyayya ga (waɗannan masu tambaya) hukumomi yana da ban sha'awa ga dalili ɗaya mai kyau: watau, lokacin (summa cum laude rhetorician) McNeil ya yanke shawarar ƙalubalantar gaskiyar “gaskiya” da ‘yan jarida suka yi, ya kware sosai.
McNeil yana sauke aikinsa a matsayin mai ba da rahoto "labari mai wuya" ("naushi sama” a gwamnati) ya haifar da wani sanannen rahoto, kuma galibi ya yi tasiri. Wannan rahoto na musamman game da makudan kudaden da aka biya wa (mai fafutukar kare dimokiradiyya da tara kudade) Ronald Perelman's Siga Technologies ta hanyar kwangilar ba-bid don sayar da kwayar cutar sankarau (da kuma daga baya) ta hanyar binciken da aka mika kyauta daga NIAID na Dr. Fauci da ke biyan haraji, sannan a biya Siga $ 250 kowace kwaya don siya wa jarin gwamnati.
Duk da haka, McNeil ya ce, "Ko odar dalar Amurka miliyan 463 na damfara ne ko ciniki ya dogara da wane kwararre ne ke magana.” Likitoci sun yi tsammanin gwamnati za ta biya da yawa don maganin rigakafin ƙwayar cuta tunda ba su da ɗanɗano don yin kuma madadin, alluran rigakafi, sun kashe gwamnati $3 a kashi ɗaya kawai: “'Idan suna magana $250 a kwas, gungun barayi ne,'" Dokta Russell ya ce. "
Hakika da nasa Times ' Aikin da ya yi rauni, Mista McNeil na iya fatan samun wasu sa'a guda ɗaya na Dr. Frieden (ta hanyar 'pox billionaire, Ron Perelman?). Nasa Medium.com shafi yana cike da cutar sankarau- firgita:
To, yaya game da sauran rubuce-rubucen McNeil? Lokacin da yake cikin yanayi, musamman lokacin da yake rufe cututtuka masu ban mamaki a ƙasashen waje yayin da yake nuna damuwa ga matalauta, yana da kyau a haɗa labarun sirri masu ban sha'awa tare da maganganun likita. Amma a kan batutuwan labarin da ke tattare da cutar, yana bin abubuwan da za a iya faɗi:
- Jami'an kiwon lafiyar jama'a suna da kyau kuma ba shakka suna da mafi kyawun ɗan adam a zuciya.
- Duk abin da jami'an kiwon lafiyar jama'a suka sanar shine a priori gaskiya kuma dole ne a ɗauka kamar haka.
- Shakku bai dace ba yayin kimanta shawarar lafiyar jama'a kuma zai kashe mutane saboda rashin imani da girmamawa.
- Cututtuka masu haɗari na wurare masu zafi suna shiga cikin Amurka ba makawa kuma ba makawa za su kafa tafki na gida.
- Idan jami'an kiwon lafiyar jama'a suka tayar da wani ƙararrawa (cututtuka, mura, murar aladu, coronavirus, SARS, Zika, Monkeypox): to dole ne mu zama cikin gaggawa - sannan mu kasance cikin firgita.
- Tabbas, cutar Zika ta haifar da microcephaly; kuma ba shakka, Zika annoba ce ta gaske kuma mai ban tsoro.
- Bugu da ƙari, ya kasance marar fahimta cewa WHO da CDC ba su ba da umarnin dakatar da ciki ba har sai maganin Zika zai iya isa wurin.
Wannan ƙwarewar da ba ta yiwuwa ta ƙarshe ta fito ne daga littafin kansa na McNeil, Zika: Mai tasowa Cutar Kwalara - a cikinsa ya yi hira da Denise Jamieson, shugabar ƙungiyar reshen kiwon lafiyar mata da haihuwa na CDC.
McNeil ya tambaya, "Me yasa CDC ba zata shawarci mata su jira ba?"
Jamieson yayi bayani, "Ina tsammanin gwamnati ta shiga cikin yanke shawara na musamman game da lokacin da za a haifi jariri ba zai yi tasiri sosai ba. "
PS: tana iya samun ma'ana. A cikin 2015 McNeil ya rubuta: "Dala biliyan 1.3 da aka kashe tun 2005 don ƙarfafa 'yan Afirka su guje wa AIDS ta hanyar ƙauracewa da aminci..
In ba haka ba Mr. McNeil's in ba haka ba yana da kusanci sosai, ɗan jaridar kimiyya Laurie Garrett (marubucin Bala'in da ke zuwa: Sabbin Cututtukan da ke Bullowa a Duniyar da Ba ta da Ma'auni), ya kira shi a ciki ta bita na littafinsa Zika:
- "Mr. McNeil ya yarda da a shirin gujewa ciki na duniya ga kasashen da ke fama da Zika, da ya yi tir da kusan duk tausayawa ga matan da ke fuskantar yanke shawara ta tsarin iyali a matsayin "masu kula" na mata."
- "An sace muhawarar," in ji McNeil. "An hana miliyoyin mata matalauta shawarwarin ceton rai saboda ta zama ba daidai ba a siyasance. Ban ga dalilin da ya sa kungiyoyin mata ba su dauki wani mataki na gaba ba" - wato, hana haihuwa da rashin samun ciki a kasashen da Zika ta shafa. Yarda da cewa hana haihuwa da zubar da ciki zai ceci mata daga wahala (sic), da za su yi amfani da hakan a matsayin ƙulli don ƙoƙarin ganin gwamnatocin masu ra'ayin mazan jiya su yi watsi da matsin shekaru 50 na coci."
Kuma a nan muna da admission a kan sha'awa. Wannan ba duka bane game da "kimiyya" ko kowane ma'auni na "lafin duniya" na Mr. McNeil. Yana da game da yin amfani da (da cin zarafi) "gaskiya" don manufofin siyasa, a wannan yanayin don kawar da ƙuntatawa na Latin Amurka (addini da na gwamnati) game da zubar da ciki. Mista McNeil ya yi iƙirarin soke siyasa, yana gujewa ko da yin rajistar jefa ƙuri'a - don ci gaba da ƙin yarda, amma a bayyane yake son zuciyarsa.
Ta yaya mutum zai bayyana cikakken imanin McNeil ga jami'an kiwon lafiyar jama'a: mandarin da ba a zaɓa ba, boffins, ƙwararrun fararen riguna - waɗanda kalmominsu ko ta yaya suka cancanci fifiko fiye da gaskiyar ƙasa? A wannan shekarar, Brazil ta sami karuwar ZERO a cikin microcephaly, duk da haka McNeil ya bukaci 'yan Latin Amurka su daina haihuwa, suna jiran wasu rigakafin Zika na gaba (har yanzu ba a nan a wurin shekaru takwas, ta hanyar). Sadaukar da ya yi ga furucin nan na ma’aikata na iya zama wasu hade da su
- rashin tabbas na ilimin kimiyya na kansa
- cikakkiyar yarjejeniya, duk da yawan wuce gona da iri daga waɗannan ɓangarorin
- daidaita siyasa, tare da wagon nasa zuwa ga tauraronsu a hankali don ci gaba da burin ci gaba, cf. Bukatar zubar da ciki na gaggawa na Zika.
- fatan wani Dr. Tom Frieden-type kama tsari / "Golden Handshake" mai zuwa.
Fitowar kaina cikin nazarin fitowar kwatsam na 2015 na Zika microcephaly wanda ba a taɓa gani ba ya haifar da akasin tsarin, ɗaya daga cikin shakku na kimiyya, kulawa da hankali ga hanyar kimiyya a kowane mataki, da kuma ƙarshe da ya dogara da ƙayyadaddun bayanai masu wuyar gaske, kuma ba tare da cikakken imani ko girmamawa ga masana a cikin fararen riguna.
"(Dr. Bock) yayi nazarin shaidun da suke a tsaye, ya kwatanta wannan a cikin tsarin kimiyya kuma yayi nazarin wasu daga cikin sojojin zamantakewa da na kafofin watsa labarun da ke aiki wanda ke kunna wuta. Gaskiya mai sauƙi shine cewa an danganta shari'ar microcephaly zuwa Zika ba tare da gunaguni na shaida cewa Zika ne sanadin ba." Roger Watson, PhD
Kuma na sami cewa a can har yanzu babu hujja a ko'ina da Zika ke haifar da microcephaly, cewa Zika ya haifar da waɗancan takamaiman lokuta na microcephaly, cewa waɗannan takamaiman shari'o'in sun cika ma'auni na haƙiƙa don a lissafta su azaman microcephaly, da kuma cewa akwai annoba ta gaske a ko'ina - koda kuwa WHO da CDC da Dr. Fauci sun faɗi haka.
Kuma wannan hanya tawa ita ce ainihin hanyar da Dokta Barry Marshall na Australia ya bi lokacin da ya gano mafi yawancin cututtukan cututtukan peptic ulcer suna haifar da kwayoyin cuta mai suna. Helicobacter pylori, wanda ya saba wa rinjaye "ijma'i na kimiyya" a lokacin. Hanyar Dr. Marshall, daidai da kishiyar hanyar McNeil zuwa "gaskiya" da masana masana fararen kaya suka tabbatar, ya haifar da wani magani mai sauƙi wanda nan da nan ya ƙare "abincin mara kyau" (kuma mafi muni) - kuma ya lashe kyautar Nobel a magani.
To ina wannan ya bar mu? Tare da ƙarasa da ba za a iya musantawa ba, a cikin shekaru ashirin na McNeil a matsayin mai ba da rahoto na Kimiyya ga New York Times:
- Bai yi hidima a matsayin a Gaskiya Vigilante, Kalubalen "gaskiya" da 'yan jarida suka tabbatar.
- Jagorancin edita na Times ya yi la'akari da bugun Kimiyya kamar yadda ya fi dacewa da sassan salon rayuwar "lalatai mai laushi" na takarda.
- Kuma (ta hanyar zance da rashin korafe-korafe), haka ma masu karatun ta.
Amma ga Times edita jagoranci ta capitulation ga ma'aikacinta-'yan zanga-zangar suna tafiya ba zato ba tsammani kamar Mao's Red Guards (an ba wannan abincin; daga baya ya saba da McNeil), wannan tsari na farin ciki tsakanin McNeil, da Times (da masu karatunsa) da sun ci gaba da canzawa.
Mr. McNeil's Bio cikin alfahari ya sanar da cewa: samunsa "ya samu lambobin yabo na labaran da suka shafi garuruwan da suka yi nasarar yaki da cutar kanjamau; game da ikon mallakar mallaka wanda ke sa farashin magunguna ya yi tsada a Afirka; game da cututtukan da ba za a iya kawar da su ba; game da masu fama da ciwon daji a Indiya da Afirka suna mutuwa ba tare da jin zafi ba; da kuma game da Juji mai guba na Soyayya. "
"Ya kamata in bibiyi muhimman alamu na duniya da kuma rufe kowace annoba da annoba da ke sauka a kan pike, don haka cikin damuwata akwai AIDS, tarin fuka,…, ehrlichiosis, babesiosis, leishmaniasis ...[et alia, 40 sauran cututtuka masu yaduwa]
(Masanin kimiya ba ne) McNeil kuma ya gan shi a matsayin aikinsa ne ya karyata "tatsuniyoyi da yawa da Amirkawa ke yi:" "Saboda rashin yarda da kimiyya a tsakanin Amirkawa yana da ƙarfi, na rufe wasu cututtuka masu rikitarwa da kuma tatsuniyoyi masu tsayi kamar cutar Morgellons, parasitosis na yaudara, Lyme na yau da kullum, da kuma ra'ayin cewa alluran rigakafi suna haifar da Autism.” Ganin wannan ikirari, cikakken goyon bayan McNeil na kai tsaye ga Zika-Microcephaly da kuma budaddiyar sha'awar sa na wa'adin lafiyar jama'a don hana daruruwan miliyoyin mata yin ciki.
Littafin Zika na Per McNeil (ch. 5), ya fara koya game da Zika daga Dr. Scott Weaver a Jami'ar Texas. Dr. Weaver ya sanar da shi wani labari mai ban mamaki da aka buga a cikin New England Journal of Medicine wanda ya tabbatar da cewa, ba tare da wani koma-baya daga takwarorinsu na kimiyya ba, cewa likitocin da ke tsibirin Yap sun iya a asibiti wajen tantance majinyatan dengue da majinyatan Zika, wani abu da ba a taba ganin irinsa ba a kowane wuri a duniya, kuma sun yi hakan ne a lokacin bayyanar Zika ta farko a Yap.
Duk wani masani na gaske da ya tashi zaune ya ce, “Kina min wasa?" Ba Donald McNeil ba. Idan mai kula da koyarwa ya buga wannan "gaskiyar" a cikin Jaridar New England, to lallai ita ce gaskiya wadda ba za a iya tauyewa ba, kuma duk wanda zai yi tambayan hakan dole ne ya zama maƙarƙashiya. Rashin fahimtar Yap da na taƙaita nan:
"A cikin 2007, mazauna Yap (Micronesia) sun sami ciwo da zazzaɓi, wanda dakin gwaje-gwaje ya tabbatar da sake dawowa. Cibiyoyin Kula da Cututtuka da Cututtuka (CDC) sun yanke shawarar yanke shawarar bayan hoc na Zika, yayin da ta yarda da giciye-reactivity na dengue. Duffy ya yi iƙirari, bisa ga tambayoyin da aka bijiro da su da da'irar dabaru: "Cutar asibiti (watakila) mai yiwuwa cutar ta Zika ce"(karya) yana mai tabbatar da cewa likitocin Yap sun lura da wasu (wani lokaci) bambance-bambance daga dengue. "
Wannan mataki guda biyu yanayin operandi An biye da shi a cikin ƙaranci da tsoro a Brazil. Likitoci na farko sun yi iƙirarin cewa sun gano tarin ƙwayoyin cuta na microcephaly - ba tare da yin daidai da ma'aunin WHO ba. Daga nan sai suka sake gano wadanda suka kamu da cutar tare da uwaye masu dauke da kwayar cutar Zika, a cikin rashin gwajin gwaji na hakika. Kuma na ƙarshe ya bunƙasa ya haɗa da watsa labarai masu mahimmanci kai tsaye ga kafofin watsa labarai ba tare da wani nazari na tsara ba, da kuma ƙwaƙƙwaran masana kimiyya na gaskiya a cibiyoyin da aka kafa don ainihin wannan dalili.
Amma ba haka McNeil ya gani ba. Ya kwatanta martanin da ya bayar nan take a matsayin abin tsoro. "A kan Google News, na ga ƙaramin labarin CNN daga Brazil. Yana da "Zika" a cikin kanun labarai. Tunawa da zancen da aka yi a baya, na buɗe ta—na karanta tare da ƙara tsoro. Brazil ta ayyana dokar ta baci. Asibitoci suna ganin guguwar jarirai masu kawukan microcephalic, fiye da 2,700 daga cikinsu (haka, a lokacin PANIC). Zika ita ce abin da ake zargi. "
Hasalima, hankalinsa na girma tsoro ya shafi mummunan tsoron cewa Zika zai isa Amurka nan ba da jimawa ba. "Na kalli gidan yanar gizon CDC. Yana da ɗan bayani kaɗan: sakin layi da ke nuna cewa cutar Zika tana Polynesia da Kudancin Amurka, kuma an sami rahoton wasu lokuta a cikin matafiya masu dawowa. Babu wani abu game da microcephaly, komai game da Guillain-Barré. Yana da wani layi mai ban tsoro: "Wadannan shari'o'in da aka shigo da su na iya haifar da yaduwar kwayar cutar a wasu yankuna na Amurka."
Saboda imani na rayuwa cikin wayewa ko da lokacin da mutane suka yi sabani a kan takamaiman batutuwa, na tuntuɓi McNeil sau da yawa don samun tattaunawa mai ma'ana game da rashin goyon bayan shaida ga iƙirarin cewa Zika za a iya bambanta ta asibiti daga dengue; cewa Zika ya haifar da microcephaly, cewa haɗarin yana da ƙarfi sosai cewa miliyoyin mata dole ne su guje wa ciki.
An rubuta martanin McNeil rubuta imaninsa a ciki wanda ya yi maganganun, don haka gaskiyar maganganun ta dogara da ita wanda sanya su. Da farko ya tabbatar da cewa "Jita-jitar cewa duk wani kuskure ne da aka haifa saboda firgici kuma ba a sami karuwa a microcephaly a arewa maso gabashin Brazil ba shekaru da yawa da suka wuce..” Kamar yadda maganganun baƙar fata ke tafiya, waccan ita ce dozy.
McNeil ya bi hakan da Likitocin ICU na Brazil ba wawa ba ne, sun san abin da ake kira microcephaly, sun taba gani a baya, sun saba ganin lokuta daya ko biyu a shekara - kuma ba zato ba tsammani suna ganin dozin ko fiye a asibitocinsu a lokaci guda..” Don haka, an sami karuwar shari'o'in microcephaly saboda 'yan asalin Brazil na ICU ba wawa ba ne kuma Donald McNeil ya yi hira da su kuma wannan, 'yan mata da maza, shine yadda ake yin kimiyya.
A cikin 2021, bayan McNeil ya karanta na Juyar da Zika -book on Google Docs, na isa gare shi cikin girmamawa saboda kyawawan tunaninsa. Jawabinsa: “Na karanta sosai don ganin cewa ka'idodin ku na Zika, waɗanda na ɗauka ƙarya, ba su canza ba. Amsoshin nawa daga Fabrairu 2020 ba su canza ba. … An kore ni.” NB ad hominem, yana magana ne akan ikirari na karya, da bacewar da aka yi akan aikina na likita, duba nan da kuma nan; ba matsala a gare shi vis-à-vis Dr. Frieden ya ayyana laifin.
Kalmomin McNeil na kansa sun nuna cewa tsoronsa da son zuciya sun taka rawar gani sosai a cikin jimlar goyan bayan sa na tura duk abin da shugabancin lafiyar jama'a ke so a yanzu. A cikin 2020, son zuciyarsa ya shiga cikin buɗaɗɗen ikon mallaka, lokacin da tsoron kansa na kamuwa da cuta ya ba da hujjar kawar da ainihin haƙƙinmu na ɗan adam.
Don haka, ga abin da McNeil ya rubuta a ranar 28 ga Fabrairu, 2020, a farkon abin da ake zaton Covid-19: "Don Kamu da Cutar Coronavirus, Tafi Medieval akan Shi:""Keɓewa da matakan ƙuntatawa sun yi amfani da manufa a zamanin da. Za su iya yanzu, kuma. "
McNeil kuma da zuciya daya ya amince da shugaban "ci gaba" na kasar Sin da kuma manufofinsa na kulle-kulle - "Shugaban kasar Sin, Xi Jinping, ya sami damar rufe birnin Wuhan, inda aka fara barkewar cutar numfashi ta COVID-19, saboda kasar Sin wuri ne da shugaba zai iya tambayar kansa cewa, "Me Mao zai yi?" kuma yi shi kawai! Hukumar za ta bi, har zuwa kwamitocin unguwanni da ke hana duk wanda ya dawo daga Wuhan shiga gidajensu, koda kuwa yana nufin yin barci a kan tituna..” Duk wani abu da aka yi wa biliyoyin sauran mutane abin yarda ne, idan hakan ya sa Donald McNeil ya sami kwanciyar hankali.
Agusta 2020, Mista McNeil ya yi nasarar cin nasara don la'anar Corona. Babu yuwuwar babu wani “bindigogi mai shan taba” don yawan fushin Amurka, firgita, da fargaba a farkon 2020 fiye da kukan yaki na “tafi na tsaka-tsaki” na McNeil, wanda ya rubuta kafin a sami shari'ar New York guda daya. Mr. McNeil - bai taba tsawatawa game da wuce gona da iri na cutar ta Zika ba, ya canza matsayinsa na "mai ba da rahoto" na labarai zuwa "mai halitta" na labarin. McNeil, ba a tantance shi ba, ba a zaɓe ba, ba a tabbatar da shi ba ya zama (Halin Baban Amurka na Roger) “MAI YANKEWA.” Mr. McNeil ya yanke shawarar zabar rufaffiyar bayanan China a kan na'urar “cikakkiyar gwaji” abin gani a bayyane daga cikin jirgin ruwan da aka keɓe a lokaci guda, Gimbiya Diamond, wanda ke da fiye da tsari na ƙarancin kisa: 10 ne kawai suka mutu daga cikin fasinjoji 3,711; tare da matsakaicin shekaru 82.
Aikin Donald McNeil misali ne mai kyau na abin da Ben Franklin ya gargaɗi Amirkawa: "Waɗanda za su ba da mahimmancin 'Yanci, don siyan Tsaron ɗan lokaci kaɗan, ba su cancanci 'Yanci ko Tsaro ba."Donald McNeil's cred maimakon, shine Yi Don su, Kulle Su Cikin Gine-ginen Konewa Ko da, Kawai Ka Tsare Ni!
Mutum zai iya fatan cewa mutumin na gaba wanda Times da'awar ita ce Rahoton Kimiyya ba mutum ne wanda tsoro ko sha'awar sa ba zai iya haifar da kowane rahoto kan cututtuka masu yaduwa ba. Kimiyya na buƙatar ware hankali don farawa da, kuma Kimiyya ta wuce kwari masu ban tsoro. Hakanan zai taimaka wajen samun Times a ƙarshe sun kasance a wurin kafin zamba na gaba irin na Zika mai ba da rahoton Kimiyya wanda a zahiri yana aiki azaman a Gaskiya Vigilante da kuma kalubalantar "gaskiyar" da jami'an kiwon lafiyar jama'a suka tabbatar maimakon yin biyayya ga masu karatu.
-
Dokta Randall Bock ya sauke karatu daga Jami'ar Yale tare da BS a cikin ilmin sunadarai da kimiyyar lissafi; Jami'ar Rochester, tare da MD. Ya kuma binciki abin ban mamaki 'kwanciyar hankali' da ya biyo bayan cutar ta Zika-Microcephaly ta Brazil ta 2016 da firgita, a ƙarshe ya rubuta "Juyar da Zika."
Duba dukkan posts
