A watan Satumban da ya gabata, Biden ya ba da sanarwar cewa yana ba da umarnin allurar rigakafin COVID ga dukkan ma'aikatan kiwon lafiya miliyan 10 a Amurka - da kuma duk wani Ba'amurke da ke aiki da kamfani da ke daukar mutane sama da dari. A cikin wani jawabin maraice da aka watsa ta gidan talabijin, ya sanar da cewa, "Aikina a matsayina na shugaban kasa shi ne kare dukkan Amurkawa." A haƙiƙa, rantsuwar da ya yi wa kundin tsarin mulki ita ce tabbatarwa da kare tsarin mulki, amma ba komai.
Biden ya ba da kwatankwacin ayyana yaki kan Amurkawa miliyan 80 da ba a yi musu allurar rigakafi ba, yana mai bayyana su a matsayin lamba ta daya (ban da ma'aikatan gidan waya, wadanda Fadar White House ta kebe daga wa'adin sabili da yawan kungiyoyin aika wasiku).
Biden ya kalubalanci wadanda ba su da hankali: "Mun yi hakuri amma hakurin mu ya yi kasala. Kuma kin amincewa ya kashe mu duka." Sanarwar ta Biden ta yi kama da barazanar da wani dan kama-karya ke yi kafin ya mamaye wata kasar waje. Biden da yatsa: "Wannan ba batun 'yanci bane ko zaɓi na sirri ba, game da kare kanku ne da na kusa da ku - mutanen da kuke aiki da su, mutanen da kuke kulawa da su, mutanen da kuke ƙauna." Amma wa zai kare Amurkawa daga umarnin kama-karya na Biden?
Alurar rigakafin Biden karya ce
Gwamnatin Biden ta ci gaba da bayyana alluran rigakafin cutar a matsayin annoba. Jim kadan kafin ya ba da umarnin, Biden ya yi alkawarin, "Ba za ku sami COVID ba idan kuna da waɗannan rigakafin." Lokacin da ya ba da sanarwar shirin sanya wa'adin a cikin wani jawabi na Satumba 9, Biden ya bayyana cewa "akwai tabbataccen shari'a guda daya kawai a cikin Amurkawa 5,000 da aka yiwa cikakken rigakafin kowace rana. Kuna da lafiya kamar yadda zai yiwu."
Biden ya yaudari jama'ar Amurka ta hanyar yin kamar cewa allurar za ta kiyaye su ta hanyar hana duk wani yaduwa. Don warware labarin Biden, Cibiyoyin Kula da Cututtuka da Cututtuka sun daina kirga yawancin “cututtukan ci gaba” a tsakanin mutanen da aka yi wa rigakafin watanni da yawa da suka gabata. The Washington Post ruwaito Cewa CDC ta "kimanin ja-ja-jaja na tasirin allurar rigakafin a kan Delta… na iya sanya Amurkawa cikin rashin tsaro." A watan Oktoba, Biden ya maimaita da'awarsa cewa alluran rigakafi suna hana yaduwar COVID - duk da cewa CDC a karshe ta yarda da gazawarta kan wannan maki.
An baje kolin ƙa'idodin ɗabi'a da ke cikin dokar Biden a cikin fadace-fadacen kotu da yawa a ƙarshen shekarar da ta gabata. Kwanaki uku bayan jawabin wajabcin Biden, wani alkali na tarayya ya toshe wa'adin rigakafin cutar ta New York na wani dan lokaci ga duk kwararrun likitocin kiwon lafiya, wanda ya kasance madubin sabon wa'adin tarayya.
Ma’aikatan kiwon lafiya goma sha bakwai da suka yi iƙirarin keɓewar addini sun ba da tabbacin cewa wa'adin "ya fito ne a cikin yanayin tsoro da rashin hankali inda ake barazanar mayar da waɗanda ba a yi musu allurar ba zuwa wani rukunin waɗanda ba za a iya taɓa su ba idan ba za su yarda a yi musu allurar ba." Biden ya yi iya ƙoƙarinsa don ƙara haifar da ƙiyayya, yana mai tabbatar wa mutanen da aka yi wa rigakafin cewa "Na fahimci fushin ku ga waɗanda ba a yi musu allurar ba."
Biden bai fito da ka'idojin rigakafin sa ba har sai ranar 5 ga Nuwamba, lokacin da wadanda aka nada shi suka gabatar da wata kalma ta 150,000+ ta Tarayya wacce ke ba da sanarwar "jab ko aiki" wa'adin. Sanarwar hukuma ta nuna kashi 95% na farkon da'awar ingancin allurar COVID daga gwajin asibiti amma sun yi watsi da binciken da suka biyo baya wanda ya nuna ingancin faduwa. Sanarwar ta Team Biden ta yi bayanin cewa tana ba da umarnin yin alluran rigakafi saboda "mafi mahimmancin haɓakawa (don allurar rigakafi) shine tsoron asarar aiki." Kuma shugaban kasa yana da 'yancin rusa ayyukan mutane don amfanin jama'a - aƙalla bisa ga sabon tsarin Tsarin Mulki. Ƙarshen ya dace, a cewar sanarwar Rajista ta Tarayya, saboda "hukunce-hukuncen rigakafin gabaɗaya sun fi tasiri fiye da ƙarfafa rigakafi kawai."
A wasu kalmomi, tilastawa yana haifar da ƙaddamarwa.
Ma'aikatan kiwon lafiya suna yaki
A duk fadin kasar, an kori dubban ma'aikatan kiwon lafiya saboda kin yin allurar. Cibiyar Cleveland Clinic ta kori ma'aikata 700. A New York, wani asibiti ya rufe sashin kula da haihuwa kuma ya daina haihuwa saboda karancin ma'aikatan jinya da aka yi musu allurar. Ɗaya daga cikin tsarin kiwon lafiya ya hana zaɓe da tiyata na gaggawa da kuma rage magungunan rediyo a wani ɓangare saboda asarar ma'aikatan lafiya saboda umarnin rigakafin.
Bayan yanke hukunci masu karo da juna kan umarnin Biden a kotun daukaka kara ta tarayya, Kotun Koli ta hanzarta daukar karar. Dangane da taƙaitaccen bayani daga babban lauyoyin Missouri da Nebraska, umarnin Biden "yana barazanar lalacewar tattalin arziki da cutar da haƙuri a duk masana'antar [kiwon lafiya]" kuma "zai haifar da mummunan sakamako akan [kiwon lafiya] musamman a yankunan karkara."
Sanarwar Rajista ta Tarayya kan sabon wa'adin ta yi watsi da damuwa game da asarar ma'aikatan kiwon lafiya saboda "babu isasshen shaida don ƙididdige" tasirin. Tun da Feds sun zaɓi kada su rubuta ɓarna, matsalar ba ta wanzu. Biden ya mayar da martani ga karancin ma’aikata masu mahimmanci ta hanyar aikawa da jami’an sojan Amurka dubu don taimakawa asibitoci amma ya ba da taimako ga mafi yawan wuraren kiwon lafiya.
A cikin taƙaice ga Kotun Koli, gwamnatin Biden ta ba da sanarwar cewa wa'adin rigakafin yana da "mahimmanci don hana barkewar (COVID-19) wanda ya lalata wuraren shiga Medicare- da Medicaid a farkon cutar." Koyaya, makonni biyu kafin Kotun Koli ta saurari muhawara ta baka, CDC ta canza jagorarta ta baya game da ma'aikatan kiwon lafiya keɓe bayan gwajin inganci ga COVID-19. CDC ta yanke hukuncin cewa za a iya rage lokacin keɓewa ga ma’aikatan kiwon lafiya da suka kamu da cutar ta COVID idan akwai ƙarancin ma’aikata. An gaya wa wasu ma'aikatan aikin jinya na COVID-19 a duk faɗin ƙasar da su shigo aiki su kula da marasa lafiya ko da har yanzu suna da alamun cutar.
Mutanen da suka kamu da kwayar cutar kuma suka warke suna da rigakafi na halitta wanda daga baya ya kare su. Amma gwamnatin Biden ta yi watsi da rigakafi bayan kamuwa da cuta, watakila saboda ba ta yi komai ba ga haƙƙin fadar shugaban kasa - "harbin miliyan 100 a cikin kwanaki 100," kamar yadda Biden ya yi cara a cikin Maris 2021.
A cewar masu tsara manufofin Biden, ya fi kyau majinyata na asibiti su kula da masu fama da zazzabi na COVID-19 ma'aikatan jinya (waɗanda rigakafin COVID-XNUMX ya kasa kare su daga ƙwayar cuta) fiye da ma'aikatan jinya da ba su da rigakafin cutar. Zenei Triunfo-Cortez, shugaban kungiyar ma'aikatan jinya ta kasa, ya ce sabuwar manufar "za ta haifar da ci gaba da yaduwa, rashin lafiya da mutuwa."
Jim kadan kafin Kotun Koli ta saurari karar, Biden ya ba da sanarwar cewa "kusan duk wanda ya mutu daga COVID-19 a cikin watanni da suka gabata ba a yi masa allurar rigakafi ba." Amma cikakken rigakafin ya kai kashi 21% zuwa 27% na mace-macen COVID-19 a Oregon daga Agusta zuwa Nuwamba da 40% zuwa kusan kashi 75% na mace-mace a Vermont daga Agusta zuwa Oktoba. Bayanan sun zama abin kunya ga gwamnatin Biden har CDC ta dakatar da buga bayanan rigakafi kan mutuwar COVID a watan Oktoba.
Biden ya yarda "babu mafita ta tarayya"
Biden ya kuma yarda a karshen Disamba cewa "babu wata mafita ta tarayya (ga COVID-19). Ana magance wannan a matakin jiha." Hakan ya kasance mai nisa daga alkawarin da ya yi a muhawarar karshe da ya yi da Donald Trump a watan Oktoba na 2020, lokacin da Biden ya yi alkawarin: "Zan kula da wannan, zan kawo karshen wannan. Zan rufe kwayar cutar, ba kasar ba." Biden "babu mafita na tarayya" ya ba da cikakkiyar hujja ga Kotun Koli ta ki amincewa da umarnin Biden.
A ranar 7 ga Janairu, Kotun Koli ta saurari muhawara ta baka a cikin mafi munin cutar ta COVID da ta taba faruwa. Editan Yahoo Javier David ya ce "Dokokin sun dakile kusan komai ban da COVID-19." Ko da yake kusan kashi biyu bisa uku na al'ummar Amurka an yi musu cikakken rigakafin, fiye da sabbin shari'o'in COVID miliyan ana gano su kowace rana a farkon Janairu. Amma wannan karuwar ba ta yi wani abin da zai hana Biden yin magana game da "cutar marasa lafiya ba."
A yayin muhawara ta baka, mai shari'a Elena Kagan ta bayyana cewa manufar Biden tana gaya wa masu ba da lafiya "abu daya da ba za ku iya yi ba shi ne kashe majinyatan ku." Dole ne ma'aikata su yi allurar rigakafi, in ji Kagan, "domin kar ku yada cutar da za ta iya kashe tsofaffi marasa lafiya na Medicare…. Ba za ku iya zama mai ɗaukar cuta ba."
Sai dai idan masu ɗauke da cuta sun amince da CDC, kamar yadda na USA Today op-ed a safiyar ranar muhawarar kotu ta lura. A wannan lokacin, fiye da rabin ma'aikatan kiwon lafiya sun riga sun kamu da cututtukan COVID-19, kuma sama da kashi 99+% na su sun tsira. Koyaya, umarnin Biden ya ɗauka cewa alluran rigakafin sune kawai tushen ingantaccen lafiya da kariya kuma sun yi watsi da rigakafin kamuwa da cuta saboda fahimtar “rashin tabbas… dangane da ƙarfi da tsayin (na halitta) rigakafi.” Koyaya, wani babban binciken Isra'ila a watan Agusta ya gano cewa mutanen da ke da COVID-19 suna da mafi kyawun kariya daga bambance-bambancen Delta fiye da mutanen da suka karɓi allurar rigakafin COVID-19 da yawa.
Tattaunawar Kotun Koli ta faru ne a cikin duniyar imani wacce a hankali ta ɗauka cewa har yanzu allurar rigakafin ce ta mu'ujiza da 'yan siyasa kamar Biden suka yi da'awar farko. Amma tasirin harbin mai kara kuzari na COVID ya ragu zuwa 31%, a cewar CDC. Masanin kimiyya na Nobel Luc Montagnier ya lura a cikin Wall Street Journal cewa allurar Moderna da Pfizer bayan kwanaki 30 ba su da "kyakkyawan tasiri mai kyau game da kamuwa da cutar Omicron, kuma bayan kwanaki 90, tasirin su ya tafi mara kyau - watau, mutanen da aka yi wa alurar riga kafi sun fi kamuwa da kamuwa da Omicron." Binciken da aka yi daga baya ya tabbatar da cewa alluran rigakafi da masu haɓakawa sun ƙara ƙima na kwangilar Omicron. Daga baya CDC ta yarda cewa kusan rabin mutuwar COVID a farkon 2022 na cikin wadanda aka kashe. A ranar 11 ga Janairu, shugabar riko na FDA ta Biden Janet Woodcock ta fada wa kwamitin majalisar dattijai cewa "mafi yawan mutane za su sami COVID." To mene ne amfanin alluran rigakafin dole?
SCOTUS maganin alurar riga kafi yana yanke hukunci gauraye jakar
A ranar 13 ga Janairu, kotu ta kada kuri'ar amincewa da dokar rigakafin ga dukkan ma'aikatan kiwon lafiya da kuri'u 5 zuwa 4. (Wani hukunci na daban ya soke umarnin Biden na ma'aikatan manyan kamfanoni.) Hukuncin wa'adin kiwon lafiya na kotun ya bayyana, "Tabbatar da cewa masu samar da kayayyaki sun dauki matakai don guje wa yada kwayar cuta mai hatsari ga majiyyatan su ya yi daidai da ainihin ka'idar aikin likita: na farko, kada ku cutar da su."
Abin takaici, an keɓe masu tsara manufofin tarayya daga gargaɗin "kada ku cutar da su". Masu shari'a sun yi watsi da ko kuma sun kasa fahimtar yadda tabarmar maraba da gwamnatin Biden ga ma'aikatan jinya na COVID-tabbatacce ya shafe duka shari'ar shari'a da ɗabi'a na umarni.
Jim kadan bayan yanke hukuncin. The Lancet, ɗaya daga cikin mujallun likitanci da ake girmamawa a duniya, an tsara shi cewa ma'aikatan kiwon lafiya waɗanda suka murmure daga COVID yakamata a keɓe su daga ƙa'idodin vax.
Alurar rigakafin COVID na iya taimakawa rage haɗarin sakamako mai tsanani daga COVID tsakanin tsofaffi da mutanen da ke fama da rashin lafiya. Amma babu wani dalili na kimiyya don tilasta kowane ma'aikacin kiwon lafiya ko kowane Ba'amurke don samun jab na gwaji wanda ya yi muni tare da kowane sabon motsi na COVID-19.
Dokokin rigakafin Biden wani rushewa ne na 'yanci wanda ba ya yin komai don kawo karshen cutar da aka fi amfani da ita ta siyasa a tarihin Amurka. Amma gwamnati ba ta da wani alhaki kan allurar da ta ba da umarni ko kuma ’yancin da ta ke lalatawa. Ga masu mulki da 'yan siyasa, samun mulki da mika wuya sun isa nasara, koda kuwa manufofinsu sun kasa cin nasara kan kwayar cutar. Har yaushe ’yan siyasa za su yi riya cewa ’yan sandansu na ƙarfe ne harsashin sihiri?
An rubuta shi daga FFF
-
James Bovard, 2023 Brownstone Fellow, marubuci ne kuma malami wanda sharhinsa ya yi niyya ga misalan sharar gida, gazawa, cin hanci da rashawa, cin hanci da rashawa da cin zarafi a cikin gwamnati. Shi mawallafin USA Today ne kuma mai yawan ba da gudummawa ne ga The Hill. Shi ne marubucin littattafai goma, gami da Haƙƙin Ƙarshe: Mutuwar 'Yancin Amurka.
Duba dukkan posts
