Dan jarida,
Domin lokacin da kuka aiko min tweet mai zuwa ta Robert Reich ba ku bayar da wani sharhi ba, ba zan iya sanin ko kun yarda ko kin yarda da abin da ke cikinsa ba, waɗanda ke cikakke:
Wataƙila akwai wani abu da ba daidai ba tare da tsarin da zai ba wani ɗan shekaru 35, ba zaɓaɓɓe ba, alkali da Trump ya zaɓa - wanda ƙungiyar lauyoyin Amurka ke ganin bai cancanta ba - ya karya dokar rufe fuska ga ƙasar baki ɗaya?
Duk da haka ganin cewa kun sami tweet na Reich a matsayin babban zargi da ake yi wa alkali Kathyrn Kimball Mizelle ta Kotun Gundumar Amurka. yanke hukunci a kan umarnin abin rufe fuska na CDC, Ina jin wajibi ne in bayyana dalilin da yasa nake tunanin Reich's tweet shine, don sanya shi a hankali, moronic.
Na farko, babu ƙayyadaddun ƙayyadaddun ƙayyadaddun shekaru don yin hidima a benci na tarayya. Joseph Story - ba a matsayin masanin shari'a ba - an nada shi a Kotun Koli na Amurka yana da shekaru 32.
Na biyu, kamar shi ko a'a, Donald Trump ya kasance shugaban kasa daga 2017 zuwa 2021, kuma daga cikin ayyukan shugaban kasa akwai nadin alkalan kotunan tarayya.
Na uku, Trump ba ya shigar da mai shari'a Mizelle a kotu ba kadai; Majalisar dattawa ta amince da ita.
Hudu, dukan alkalan kotun tarayya ba a zabe su ba.
Na biyar, wadanda kuma ba a zaba su ne duk jami'an kiwon lafiyar jama'a, ciki har da Anthony Fauci da Rochelle Walensky.
Na shida, yayin da ABA ta ɗauka da gaske Alkali Mzelle bai cancanta ba, ta yi haka ne saboda ta yi ɗan lokaci a cikin aikin doka na sirri. Idan wannan ma'auni ya isa ya sanya wanda bai dace da babban ofishin gwamnati ba, Anthony Fauci bai cancanci matsayinsa ba fiye da alkali Mizelle nata, ganin cewa Fauci ya kashe. babu lokaci a cikin aikin sirri na likita. Bayan ya kammala zama a 1968, ya ɗauki aiki tare da Cibiyoyin Kiwon Lafiya na Ƙasa.. Tun daga lokacin gwamnati ta dauke shi aiki.
Na bakwai, saboda CDC hukuma ce ta gwamnatin tarayya, ayyukanta gabaɗaya sun mamaye ƙasar gabaɗaya - hujjar da yakamata ta bayyana a fili ta fuskar diktat da ke shafar tafiye-tafiyen kasuwanci tsakanin jihohi. Da kyar mai shari'a Mizelle ta yanke hukunci kan dokar rufe fuska na wani bangare na kasar kawai.
Na takwas, Reich skate yana da ban tsoro kusa da ba da izini a kai tsaye yana ba da shawarar yanke hukunci wanda kwanan nan Fauci ya amince da shi a sarari - wato, ma'aikatan kiwon lafiyar jama'a da gwamnati ke aiki da su sun fi doka. Game da hukuncin alkali Mizelle, Fauci ya bayyana: "Mun damu da hakan - game da yadda kotuna ke shiga cikin abubuwan da ke yanke hukunci kan lafiyar jama'a ba tare da shakka ba. Ina nufin, wannan batun CDC ne; bai kamata ya zama batun kotu ba."
Don ba da shawarar hakan wani Matakin da gwamnati ta dauka ba ta da hurumin sa ido kan shari'a - wato, rashin kulawa daga masu kula da doka - shi ne bayar da shawarar cewa jami'an da suka yi wannan aikin sun fi karfin doka. Kamar yadda Dalili Eric Boehm ne ya rubuta Dangane da wannan furuci na Fauci, "Wannan ko dai cikakkiyar fahimta ce ta ainihin ayyukan tsarin Amurka ko kuma nuna kyama ga bin doka."
gaske,
Donald J. Boudreaux
Farfesan tattalin arziki
-
Donald J. Boudreaux, Babban Malami a Cibiyar Brownstone, Farfesa ne a fannin Tattalin Arziki a Jami'ar George Mason, inda yake da alaƙa da FA Hayek Shirin FA don Advanced Study a Falsafa, Siyasa, da Tattalin Arziki a Cibiyar Mercatus. Binciken nasa ya mayar da hankali kan cinikayyar kasa da kasa da dokar hana amana. Ya rubuta a Kafe Hayak.
Duba dukkan posts
