Bankin Silicon Valley yana da hedikwata mai nisan mil 15 daga kan titin Stanford Law, duk da haka dalibai ba su yi wata zanga-zanga a makon da ya gabata ba don nuna adawa da ceton masu kudin fasaha. Kwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun masu biyan kuɗi a ofishin “adalci” na Stanford ba su yi wata sanarwa ba game da canja wurin kuɗin jama'a ga ma'aikatan banki da ke bayan ɓangaren mafi arzikin Amurka.
Kamar yadda Craig Pirrong rubuta a cikin Brownstone, babu "Occupy Silicon Valley" ko fushi a kan "amsar da ta shafi siyasa da za ta haifar da mummunan sakamako a nan gaba." Maimakon haka, ɗalibai da masu gudanarwa sun mayar da hankalinsu kan kai hari ga wani alkali na tarayya don samun alaƙar siyasa mara kyau.
Binciken harabar ya sake afkuwa a makon da ya gabata lokacin da masu fafutuka a Stanford Law ihu kasa Alkalin Kotun Koli na biyar Stuart Kyle Duncan, wanda aka shirya zai gabatar da jawabi kan shari'o'in shari'a da suka shafi "Covid, Bindigogi, da Twitter."
Masu zanga-zangar da suka hada da Tirien Steinbach, babban jami'in Stanford don bambancin, haɗawa, da daidaito, sun aika wa ɗalibai imel kafin taron. Sun zargi Alkali Duncan da "mai-mai-mai-mai-mai-mai-mai-mai-mai-mai-mai-mai-mai-mai-mai-mai-mai-mai-na]wa da alfahari [yana yi] kiwon lafiya da haƙƙoƙin asali ga al'ummomin da aka ware, ciki har da mutanen LGBTQ+, 'yan asalin Amirkawa, baƙi, fursunoni, masu jefa kuri'a, da mata."
Masu tantancewa da kansu sun bayyana a wurin taron kuma suka yi kururuwa don hana alkali Duncan gabatar da adireshinsa. A cewar Ed Whelan at National Review, shugabannin makarantun lauya guda biyar sun halarta. Maimakon sanar da ’yan baranda cewa suna keta tsarin ‘yancin fadar albarkacin baki na makarantar ko kuma neman su daina hargitsa taron, jami’an Stanford sun kyale wannan hargitsin ya ci gaba.
A cikin kururuwa da kururuwa, DEI Dean Steinbach ya ɗauki makirufo da aka shirya wa alkali Davis. Ta gabatar da jawabai na mintuna shida na shirye-shiryen da suka kai hari ga Davis da abubuwan da ke tattare da 'yancin fadin albarkacin baki. Ta yi da'awar Alkalin "a zahiri ya musanta bil'adama." Game da batun 'yancin faɗar albarkacin baki, ta yi tambaya, "Shin ruwan 'ya'yan itace ya cancanci matsi?"
Farfesa Josh Blackman amsa ga Steinbach, "Dalibai suna halartar wata babbar jami'a kamar Stanford don koyi da kansu daga masu haske kamar alƙalan tarayya. Ta yaya waɗannan maganganun ba za su cancanci kasancewar Duncan a harabar ba?"
Ba a taɓa barin ɗalibai su ji jawabin Duncan ba. Jami’an gwamnatin tarayya ne suka rako shi daga kofar baya lokacin da ake ci gaba da tashe-tashen hankula bayan tsattsauran ra’ayi na Steinbach.
"Kada ka ji tausayina," Duncan ya gaya The Washington Free Beakon. "Ni alkali ne na gwamnatin tarayya, abin da ya ba ni haushi shi ne yadda 'yan uwa dalibai da masu kula da su ke daukar yaran kamar karnuka."
Stanford ya ja hankalin kafofin watsa labarai masu mahimmanci saboda gazawarsa na kare maganganun harabar, amma makarantar doka ba ita kaɗai ba ce a cikin fifikon fifikonta don haɓaka abubuwan siyasa na salon salon zamantakewa akan haƙƙin faɗar albarkacin baki.
Ƙarshe Daga Cikin Madaidaitan
Ran Litinin, The New York Times ruwaito akan Rikicin Penn Law na yanzu tare da Farfesa Amy Wax. Kamar Duncan's hecklers, abokan adawar Wax suna zarginta da faretin da aka saba da su na ban tsoro: kyamar baki, jima'i, wariyar launin fata, da ƙari. Penn Law yanzu yana la'akari da ko zai iya ƙone Wax duk da matsayinta na makarantar.
Theodore Ruger, Dean na Penn Law, ya shigar da kara kuma ya bukaci a saurare shi don yin la'akari da sanya "manyan takunkumi" akan Wax. TY Parks, kujera mai bada shawarwari ga Pennungiyar ofungiyar dokokin Alkal-Penn, sun fada kan lokutan cewa aikin yi ya musanta sadaukar da makarantar don "haɗa."
Wax ya amsa cewa jami'o'i suna son "kore da hukunta" duk "wanda ya kuskura ya nuna rashin amincewa, wanda ya kuskura ya fallasa dalibai zuwa ra'ayoyi daban-daban." Masu kira da a kore ta sun ki amincewa da kalaman da ta yi a baya game da shige da fice, bambancin al'adu, da kuma matakin da ya dace.
Washegari bayan da NYT yanki, Brownstone wallafa "Cin hanci da rashawa na Georgetown Law," wanda ya mayar da hankali ga GULC ta kwanan nan jayayya da suka shafi 'yancin magana. Misalai kaɗan sun haɗa da na makaranta fitarwa na Ilya Shapiro a shafinsa na twitter yana sukar matakin da Shugaba Biden ya yanke na takaita hukuncin Kotun Koli ga mata bakar fata. Ƙarewa na Sandra Sellers don lura da bambancin launin fata, da ta yanke shawara su dakatar da ni kuma su tilasta ni yin gwajin tabin hankali don tambayar manufofin su na Covid.
Shari'o'in ukun ba iri ɗaya ba ne: Kakin zuma yana da sanannen tarihin maganganu masu kawo gardama fiye da alkali Duncan; Kasawar Georgetown don kare faɗar ƴancin kai ya bayyana tsari fiye da kin Penn ga Wax; Dean Stanford's DEI ya nuna kyama ga 'yancin magana, har ma da ƙa'idodin harabar 2023. Amma, a zahiri, kowannensu shine na ƙarshe a cikin daidaitattun dalilai.
A jigon su, akwai wani nau'i na ɗalibai da masu gudanarwa na kai hari ga 'yan adawa waɗanda ke yin barazana ga tunanin rukuni na jami'a.
A Long Way daga 1964
Sabanin shekaru hamsin da suka gabata, daliban da ke zanga-zangar a yau ba sa nuna kyama ga hukuma. Da kowace cece-kuce, sun bi sahun masu karfin fada a ji a kasar wajen yin kira da a kara yin katsalandan, da rage ‘yancin walwala, da kuma rashin hakuri da ra’ayoyin da ba su dace ba.
Kalmomin dalibai da masu gudanarwa ba su bambanta ba. A Stanford, DEI Dean Steinbach ya jagoranci ɗaliban a cikin ƙwaƙƙwaran da suka yi da alkali Davis. A Georgetown, Farfesa Josh Chafetz barata masu zanga-zangar sun mamaye gidajen Alkalan Kotun Koli “lokacin da ’yan tawayen suka yi gaskiya.” A Penn, Dean Theodore Ruger ya yi kira ga baiwar da ta yi la'akari da "babban takunkumi" na Wax kafin ta yi korafin cewa kalamanta na baya sun kasance "wariyar launin fata, jima'i, kyama, da kuma luwadi."
Kwatanta hakan da Sabiya Ahamed, ɗalibin Lauyan Georgetown wanda ihu da kururuwa Har sai da aka tilasta wa mukaddashin sakataren tsaron cikin gida daga filin wasa a Dokar Georgetown a 2019. Ahamed ya fada The New York Times "Babu wani abu da za a yi muhawara," don haka sai ta nada kanta ta censor a cikin harabar kuma ta hana takwarorinta sauraron jami'in gwamnati. Ko kuma a yi la'akari da Hamsa Fayed, kuma dalibin Lauyan Georgetown, wanda ya bukaci cewa makarantar ta soke haƙƙin farfesa na gudanar da maki a cikin kwasa-kwasanta don gudanar da jarabawar “ƙiyayyar Islama da wariyar launin fata.” A matsayin hujjar tuhumar da ake masa, ya gabatar da tambayoyin jarrabawar da ta wuce da suka kwatanta 'yancin mata a kasashen yammacin Turai da kuma kasashen musulmi.
Steinbach, Ahamed, Ruger, Fayed, da tawagarsu tsuntsaye ne na fuka-fuki, suna bin manyan manufofi iri ɗaya na kawar da rashin yarda da neman taimako.
A kallo na farko, ɗalibai, hukumomin jami'a, da kamfanoni na ƙasa da ƙasa kamar baƙon ƴan gado ne. Zai yi kama da Mario Savio yana kira ga UC Berkeley da ta hana ƙungiyoyin siyasa da ba sa so ko ɗaliban jihar Kent da ke yin tattaki don kare gadon Henry Kissinger.
Georgetown, Stanford, da Penn suna da haɗin gwiwar dala biliyan 60. Matsakaicin bashi dauka Dalibai sun haura $170,000 a Dokar Georgetown, sama da $160,000 a Penn Law, kuma sama da $150,000 a Dokar Stanford. Wai jam’iyyu su zama ‘yan adawa. A maimakon haka, akwai tsarin 'yan amshin shata. Dalibai suna biyan kuɗi don halartar waɗannan makarantu kuma suna kai farmaki ga masu adawa da juna, suna amfanar cibiyoyin da suke taimakawa wajen ingantawa.
GK Chesteron ya rubuta, "Alamar ta musamman na duniyar zamani ba wai tana da shakku ba, amma cewa akida ce ba tare da saninsa ba." Maimakon kalubalantar hukumomi da gurbatattun tsarin wutar lantarki na kasa, daliban shari'a da ke gabar tekun biyu yanzu sun fusata tare da na'ura, suna kai hari ga daidaikun mutane ko kadan. Suna kara karfin tsarin da dalibai a da ke adawa da su, suna lalata al'adun fadin albarkacin baki da suka haifar da jami'o'in da suke ruguzawa.
-
William Spruance lauya ne mai aiki kuma wanda ya kammala digiri na Cibiyar Shari'a ta Jami'ar Georgetown. Ra'ayoyin da aka bayyana a cikin labarin gaba ɗaya nasa ne ba lallai ba ne na ma'aikacinsa.
Duba dukkan posts
