Rashin cancantar abin kunya. Wawanci mai zurfi. Kurakurai masu ban mamaki. Wannan shine yawancin manazarta - ciki har da Dr. Vinay Prasad, Dr. Scott Atlas, kuma mashahurin mai sharhin Substack eugyppius - bayyana yadda manyan ƙwararrun masana kiwon lafiyar jama'a za su iya tsara munanan manufofin mayar da martani na annoba.
Kuma gaskiya ne: waɗanda ake kira masana tabbas sun mai da kansu wauta a cikin shekaru uku da suka gabata: shugabannin kiwon lafiyar jama'a kamar su. Rochelle Walensky ne adam wata da kuma Anthony Fauci yin da'awar ƙarya, ko sabawa kansu akai-akai, a kan batutuwan da suka shafi martanin cutar, yayin da manyan masana kimiyya, kamar Peter Hotez a Amurka da kuma Kirista Drosten a Jamus, suna da saurin kamuwa da irin wannan juzu'i da karya. Sannan akwai mashahuran masu binciken likitanci na duniya, kamar Eric Topol ne adam wata, wanda akai-akai yana aikata kurakurai a bayyane a cikin fassarar binciken binciken da ke da alaƙa da Covid. [ref]
Duk waɗannan alkaluman a bainar jama'a da haɓakar manufofin kiwon lafiyar jama'a, gami da rufe fuska ta duniya, nisantar da jama'a, gwajin jama'a da keɓe masu lafiya, kulle-kulle da umarnin rigakafin.
Yana kama da shari'ar buɗe-da-kulle: Manufofin bebaye, bebaye masu kula da waɗannan manufofin.
Wannan na iya zama gaskiya a wasu ƴan lokuta na lafiyar jama'a ko shugabannin kiwon lafiya waɗanda da gaske ba su iya fahimtar ko da kimiyyar matakin sakandare. Koyaya, idan muka kalli manyan cututtukan cututtukan cututtukan cututtukan jama'a da ƙwararrun likitocin a matsayin rukuni - ƙungiyar da ta ƙunshi mafi ƙarfi, waɗanda aka buga, kuma masu bincike da masana kimiyyar da ke samun kuɗi sosai a duniya - wannan bayanin mai sauƙi yana da ƙarancin gamsarwa.
Ko da kun yi imani cewa yawancin masu binciken likitanci na kamfanonin harhada magunguna ne kuma da kyar masana kimiyya ba su sake karya wani sabon matsayi ba, ina tsammanin za ku yi wahala ku yi iƙirarin cewa ba su da ƙwarewar bincike na asali ko ingantaccen ilimin ilimi a wuraren da suka yi karatu. Yawancin likitoci da masana kimiyya waɗanda ke da manyan digiri sun san yadda ake nazarin takaddun kimiyya masu sauƙi da fahimtar bayanan asali.
Bugu da ƙari, waɗancan likitocin da ƙwararrun kiwon lafiyar jama'a waɗanda ake ganin ƙwararru ne yayin bala'in suma sun yi wayo don hawa matakan ilimi, kimiyya, da / ko matakan gwamnati zuwa manyan matakai.
Zasu iya zama marasa mutunci, sycophantic, masu haɗama, ko masu neman iko. Kuna iya tunanin sun yanke hukunci mara kyau na ɗabi'a ko ɗabi'a. Amma ya bijirewa hikimar a ce kowane ɗayansu yana fahimtar sauƙin bayanan kimiyya ƙasa da, a ce, wani kamar ni ko ku. A gaskiya, na ga cewa ya zama mai sauƙi, yanke hukunci na sama wanda ba ya kai ga tushen dalilin su na wauta, rashin cancanta.
Komawa ga wasu takamaiman misalai, zan yi jayayya cewa haka ne m gamawa, kamar yadda Dr. Prasad ya yi, cewa wani kamar Dr. Topol, Wanda ya kafa da kuma Daraktan Cibiyar Fassarar Bincike ta Scripps, wanda ya buga fiye da 1,300 da aka yi nazari a kan batutuwa kuma yana daya daga cikin manyan masu bincike na 10 da aka ambata a cikin magani.ref] ba zai iya karanta takardun bincike "a babban matakin ba." Kuma ba zai yuwu ba Anthony Fauci, wanda ya sami damar hawa kuma ya ci gaba da kasancewa a saman mafi girman ilimin kimiyya a cikin gwamnatin tarayya shekaru da yawa, yana sarrafa biliyoyin daloli a cikin tallafin bincike [ref], ya kasance bebe don sanin cewa abin rufe fuska ba ya hana ƙwayoyin cuta.
Don haka dole ne a sami wani dalili na daban wanda ya sa duk manyan masana kimiyya na kulle-kulle da masana kiwon lafiyar jama'a - a cikin cikakkiyar kulle-kulle - kwatsam sun fara (kuma suna ci gaba har zuwa yau) don kuskuren karatun da ba da shawarar manufofin da suka yi iƙirari a baya ba lallai ba ne, suna mai da kansu kamar wawaye.
Masana kiwon lafiyar jama'a sun kasance manzanni don amsawar biodefense
Mafi mahimmancin gaskiya guda ɗaya don sani da tunawa lokacin ƙoƙarin fahimtar hauka na lokutan Covid shine:
Kwararrun lafiyar jama'a ba su da alhakin manufofin mayar da martani ga cutar. Sojoji-hankali-biodefense jagoranci ne ya jagoranci.
A cikin labaran da suka gabata, na yi nazari dalla-dalla dalla-dalla takardun gwamnati wanda ke nuna yadda daidaitattun ka'idoji na kula da cutar amai da gudawa na jama'a ba zato ba tsammani aka jefar da su a asirce yayin Covid. Sauyawa mafi ban mamaki shine maye gurbin hukumomin kiwon lafiyar jama'a ta Majalisar Tsaro ta Kasa da Ma'aikatar Tsaron Cikin Gida a jagororin manufofin annoba da tsare-tsare.
A matsayin wani ɓangare na sauya asirce, duk hanyoyin sadarwa - waɗanda aka ayyana a cikin kowace takaddar shirin cutar ta baya a matsayin alhakin CDC - Kwamitin Tsaro na ƙasa ne ya karɓe shi a ƙarƙashin kulawar Task Force ta Fadar White House. Ba a ma ƙyale CDC ta gudanar da nata taron manema labarai ba!
As rahoton majalisar dattawa daga Disamba 2022 bayanin kula:
Daga Maris zuwa Yuni 2020, ba a ba CDC izinin gudanar da bayanan jama'a ba, duk da buƙatun da hukumar ta yi da buƙatun kafofin watsa labarai na CDC "ba a cika share su ba." HHS ya bayyana cewa a farkon Afrilu 2020, "bayan yunƙurin samun izini," Ofishin Mataimakin Sakataren Harkokin Jama'a "ya daina tambayar" Fadar White House na ɗan lokaci. (shafi na 8)
Lokacin da masana kiwon lafiyar jama'a da masana kiwon lafiya suka lulluɓe iska da Intanet tare da "shawarwari" tare da yin kira ga rufe fuska ta duniya, gwajin jama'a da keɓance mutanen asymptomatic, umarnin alluran rigakafi, da sauran manufofin kiwon lafiyar jama'a - ko kuma lokacin da suka haɓaka ingantaccen karatun da ke tallafawa. keɓewa-har zuwa-alurar rigakafin ƙwayoyin cuta – ba su yi haka ba domin bebaye ne, ba su iyawa, ko batattu.
Suna yin rawar da shugabannin tsaron ƙasa / martanin biodefense suka ba su: zama amintaccen fuskar jama'a wanda ya sa mutane su yi imani keɓe-har allurar rigakafin halaltacciyar amsawar lafiyar jama'a ce.
Me yasa shugabannin kiwon lafiyar jama'a suka tafi tare da ajandar biodefense?
Dole ne mu yi tunanin kanmu a matsayin masana kiwon lafiyar jama'a da ƙwararrun likitoci a manyan mukaman gwamnati lokacin da cibiyar sadarwar sirri-soja-biodefense ta karɓi martanin cutar.
Me za ku yi idan kun kasance ma'aikacin gwamnati, ko masanin kimiyyar da ke dogaro da tallafin gwamnati, kuma an gaya muku cewa manufar keɓewa har zuwa rigakafin ita ce kawai hanyar da za a bi don magance wannan ƙayyadaddun yuwuwar injiniyoyin bioweapon?
Yaya za ku yi idan wani abin da ba a taɓa ganin irinsa ba a tarihin ɗan adam ya faru a kan agogon ku: ƙwayar cuta da aka ƙirƙira a matsayin yuwuwar makaman bioweapon tana yaduwa a duniya, kuma mutanen da suka tsara ta sun gaya muku cewa tsoratar da daukacin jama'a don kullewa da jiran rigakafin ita ce kawai hanyar da za ta hana ta kashe miliyoyin mutane?
Mafi na yau da kullun, idan matsayinku da ikonku sun dogara ne akan tafiya tare da duk wani abin da ke cikin NSC da DHS suka ce ku yi - idan aikinku da rayuwar ku sun kasance a kan layi - shin za ku saba wa labarin kuma kuyi haɗarin rasa duka?
Kuma, a ƙarshe, a cikin banza mai yawa: menene idan kun tsaya don samun kuɗi da yawa da / ko iko ta hanyar ba da shawara ga manufofin da bazai zama ma'auni na zinariya na lafiyar jama'a ba, amma kun gaya wa kanku zai iya kawo manyan sababbin abubuwa (alurar rigakafi / maganin rigakafi) wanda zai ceci bil'adama daga cututtuka na gaba?
Mun san yadda fitattun “masana” Covid suka amsa waɗannan tambayoyin. Ba don sun kasance bebe ba, amma saboda suna da abubuwa da yawa da za su yi hasara da / ko riba mai yawa ta hanyar tafiya tare da labarin biodefense - kuma an gaya musu miliyoyin za su mutu idan sun kasa yin haka.
Me yasa fahimtar dalilan shugabannin kiwon lafiyar jama'a yayin Covid yana da mahimmanci
A zahiri, ɗaukar ƙwararrun lafiyar jama'a wawa da rashin cancanta a zahiri yana ƙarfafa labarin yarjejeniya: cewa kulle-kulle da alluran rigakafi wani ɓangare ne na shirin lafiyar jama'a. A cikin wannan karatun, mai yiwuwa martanin ya kasance mai muni, ko kuma ya ɓace, amma har yanzu wawa ne kawai tsarin kula da lafiyar jama'a wanda jagororin kiwon lafiyar jama'a marasa cancanta suka tsara.
Irin wannan ƙaddamarwa yana haifar da kira don ɓatar da mafita ba lallai ba ne: Ko da mun maye gurbin kowane ma'aikacin HHS ko mu kare HHS ko ma WHO gaba ɗaya, ba za mu warware matsalar ba kuma za mu kasance a shirye don sake maimaita cutar ta fiasco gaba ɗaya.
Hanya daya tilo da za a guje wa irin wannan maimaitawar ita ce gane bala'in Covid ga abin da ya kasance: kokarin yaki da ta'addanci na kasa da kasa wanda ya mai da hankali sosai kan kulle-kulle da alluran rigakafi, zuwa kebe duk ka'idojin kiwon lafiyar jama'a na gargajiya da na lokaci-lokaci.
Ya kamata mu farka da gaskiyar cewa, tun bayan harin ta'addanci na 9/11 (idan ba a baya ba), mun mika ragamar kula da hukumomin da ya kamata su kasance masu kula da lafiyar jama'a ga kungiyar soja ta kasa da kasa da kuma leken asiri.
Wannan "haɗin kai na jama'a da masu zaman kansu" na masana ta'addanci da masu haɓaka rigakafi ba su da sha'awar kiwon lafiyar jama'a ko kaɗan, sai dai a matsayin abin fakewa ga ainihin sirrin bincikensu mai fa'ida mai fa'ida da haɓaka haɓaka.
An ware lafiyar jama'a a gefe yayin barkewar cutar ta Covid, kuma an yi amfani da shugabannin kiwon lafiyar jama'a a matsayin amintattun "kwararrun masana" don isar da ka'idojin biowarfare ga jama'a. Haɗin gwiwarsu baya nuna wauta ko rashin iya aiki. Yin irin waɗannan ikirari yana ba da gudummawa ga ɓoye ɓarna mafi muni da haɗari na mika mulki wanda dabi'unsu na wauta da ake son ɓoyewa.
-
Debbie Lerman, 2023 Brownstone Fellow, yana da digiri a Turanci daga Harvard. Ita marubuciyar kimiyya ce mai ritaya kuma ƙwararren mai fasaha a Philadelphia, PA.
Duba dukkan posts
