Wani sabon binciken a cikin Lancet ya tabbatar da cewa rigakafi na halitta daga kamuwa da cutar COVID aƙalla azaman kariya ne kuma mai dorewa daga rikice-rikice masu tsanani kamar allurar rigakafi.
Har ila yau, wani "ka'idar makirci" ta COVID ya zama "Kimiyya™" ta yau.
Kariyar dabi'a ta dade sananne kuma an yarda da wani bangare na rigakafi, duk da yunƙurin ɓata mata rai.
Anthony Fauci da kansa ya tattauna a bainar jama'a mahimmancin rigakafin kamuwa da cuta.
Yana iya da alama ba zai yuwu a yi imani da cewa ana iya siffanta ilimin rigakafi na asali a matsayin “ka’idar” mai haɗari, amma wannan shine ainihin abin da wasu kafofin watsa labarai suka yi iƙirari yayin bala'in.
Uwar Jones, wanda ya kwatanta kansa a matsayin "Muryar hankali," da "kashi na yau da kullun na hankali," shine misalin irin wannan. A cikin Mayu 2020, sun ba da labarin wani labari, "Anti-Vaxxers Suna da Ka'idar Haɗari da ake kira 'Immunity'. Yanzu Yana Tafiya Mainstream. "
Tabbas, Dr. Fauci ya ba da gudummawa sosai ga rashin fahimta. A cikin Mayu 2021, business Insider ya bayyana yadda Fauci ke kallon rigakafi na halitta. Faɗakarwa mai ɓarna: ya kiyaye cewa allurar COVID sun fi kyau.
"Dr. Fauci yayi bayanin dalilin da yasa allurar COVID-19 ke aiki da kyau fiye da rigakafi na halitta don kare ku daga coronavirus"
Labarin ya fara ne da wata sanarwa daga babban kwararen likita na kasar.
"Dokta Anthony Fauci yana kiranta: mRNA COVID-19 alluran rigakafi na iya ba wa mutane mafi kyawun kariya daga sabbin bambance-bambancen hoto fiye da kamuwa da cutar coronavirus da ta gabata ita kaɗai."
"Alurar rigakafi, a zahiri, aƙalla dangane da SARS-CoV-2 [coronavirus] na iya yin abin da ya fi kyau fiye da yanayi," in ji Fauci, babban ƙwararren ƙwararrun cututtukan Amurka.
"Kuna da ƙarin kariya mai ban sha'awa daga bambance-bambancen damuwa."
Ko da abin da ake kira "masana" daga Johns Hopkins sun kasance masu yin watsi da rigakafi na halitta. The Uwar Jones labari ya nakalto wani masani kan cututtuka yana kawar da mahimmancin kariya daga kamuwa da cuta.
"Wannan ita ce bugu na coronavirus na imani da suka mamaye Rupali Limaye, masani kan cututtukan cututtuka na Johns Hopkins. "Mun ji daga wadanda suka damu game da alluran gardamar cewa sun gwammace su ba da damar tsarin rigakafin su ta hanyar dabi'a ga wani takamaiman cuta don samun rigakafi."
Sabbin bayanai sun fito kwanan nan da ke tabbatar da cewa gungun kwararrun gwamnati suma sun yi aiki tare don yin watsi da mahimmancin rigakafin halitta.
Ba abin mamaki ba, tsohon Mai ba da amsa na Coronavirus na Fadar White House Deborah Birx akai-akai watsi na halitta rigakafi.
akai-akai, "masu duba gaskiya" suna yiwa lakabi da "masu yaudara" don iƙirarin cewa rigakafi na halitta yana da tasiri sosai kuma yana iya ba da irin wannan kariya kamar rigakafin.
Sai dai duk an tabbatar da ba daidai ba.
The Lancet Binciken ya yi nazarin karatu 65 daga kasashe daban-daban 19 don tantance matakin kariya daga kamuwa da cuta mai tsanani daga COVID.
Kuma sun gano cewa rigakafi na halitta yana da matuƙar kariya daga ƙarin rikitarwa, har ma da sabbin bambance-bambancen.
Takaitaccen binciken ya karanta, "Kariya daga cututtuka mai tsanani ya kasance mai girma ga duk bambance-bambancen, tare da 90 · 2% (69 · 7-97 · 5) ga kakanni, alpha, da delta bambance-bambancen, da 88 · 9% (84 · 7-90 · 9) don omicron BA.1 a makonni 40."
Ba ainihin “ka’idar haɗari,” ko ba haka ba?
Alurar rigakafin COVID ba su da tasiri
Har ma mafi mahimmanci, binciken ya gano cewa rigakafi na halitta ya kasance "aƙalla" a matsayin kariya kamar rigakafi ga kowane bambance-bambancen. Kuma akai-akai fiye da haka.
"Cutar COVID-19 da ta gabata game da sake kamuwa da cuta, cututtukan cututtuka, da cututtuka masu tsanani ga kakanni, alpha, delta, ko omicron BA.1 bambance-bambancen, ya bayyana aƙalla azaman kariya azaman allurar kashi biyu tare da allurar mRNA don duk alluran rigakafi da sakamako," sakamakonsu ya bayyana.
Kuma yana samun kyau.
Bayan kasancewa mafi ƙarancin kariya, rigakafi na halitta yana da yuwuwar dorewa fiye da kariya daga allurar rigakafi.
"Bugu da ƙari, duk da cewa kariya daga kamuwa da cuta da ta gabata yana raguwa a tsawon lokaci, matakin kariya daga sake kamuwa da cuta, cututtukan cututtuka, da cututtuka masu tsanani ya bayyana aƙalla kamar yadda yake dawwama, idan ba haka ba, fiye da wanda aka bayar ta hanyar allurar rigakafi guda biyu tare da rigakafin mRNA don kakanni, alpha, delta, da omicron BA.1 bambance-bambancen," binciken ya ce.
Alkaluma daga binciken sun nuna cewa kamuwa da cutar da ta gabata ta fi karewa sosai a duk fannonin kariya daga kowane bambance-bambancen, na tsawon lokaci fiye da allurar rigakafi.
Mafi zurfi kuma mafi mahimmancin hoto shine kwatancen rigakafin Omicron.
Dangane da bambance-bambancen da ke da rinjaye a halin yanzu, kamuwa da cuta da ya gabata ya fi na Moderna da Pfizer's mRNA allurar rigakafi a cikin sake kamuwa da cuta da kuma alamun bayyanar cututtuka.
Ba shi yiwuwa a yi kuskure fiye da Fauci, Birx, Uwar Jones, korar "masana" da "masu binciken gaskiya" sun kasance a cikin 'yan shekarun nan.
Tare da gaisuwa ga masks, fasfo na rigakafi, rufe makarantu, kulle-kulle da rigakafi na halitta, ga kowace annoba ta tambaya 'masana' sun tsara amsar da ba ta dace ba.
Dokokin Alurar da Ba a Kula da Kariya ta Halitta
Kamar abin ƙyama, wanda ba a yarda da shi ba umarnin rigakafi ya yaɗu a cikin al'umma, wani abu na gama-gari, mara daɗi ya kama tsakanin ƙungiyoyin Amurka: yin watsi da rigakafi
CDC da Gudanar da Biden har yanzu ƙin karɓar rigakafi na halitta ga matafiya na ƙasashen waje da ke shigowa ƙasar.
Novak Djokovic, wanda kwanan nan aka ba shi damar yin gasa a cikin COVID-marubucin Ostiraliya, har yanzu ba a ba shi izinin shiga Amurka ba duk da ya kamu da cutar a baya.
Hatta sauran ƙasashe masu tsattsauran ra'ayi irin su Kanada sun ja da baya, suna karɓar kariyar da take bayarwa.
{Asar Amirka ta ci gaba da jajircewa wajen yin watsi da kimiyance, don neman inganta allurai masu kara kuzari. Ƙara yawan allurai wanda ba ya aiki musamman da kyau.
Hatta mawallafin wannan binciken sun yarda cewa Amurka ta yi fice a duniya wajen yin watsi da rigakafi.
"Na biyu, ƙuntatawa na motsi da samun damar zuwa wuraren da ya dogara da matsayin rigakafi da kuma umarnin rigakafin ga ma'aikata ya kamata su yi la'akari da rigakafi da aka ba da shi ta hanyar rigakafi da kuma wanda aka samar ta hanyar kamuwa da cuta," sun rubuta.
An tilastawa adadi mai yawa na mutane bin umarnin rigakafin. Wasu da dama kuma an kore su ko kuma an hana su dama saboda sun ki bin umarnin. Duk bisa ƙaryar cewa rigakafi na halitta shine "ka'idar makirci," ko ƙasa da kariya fiye da allurar rigakafi.
Duk da haka wasu takardu kamar su Babban Sanarwa na Barrington ya nuna mahimmancin kamuwa da cuta na halitta don haɓaka rigakafi. Kawai don a yi watsi da su a taƙaice.
"Mafi kyawun tsarin jin kai wanda ke daidaita haɗari da fa'idodin isa ga garkuwar garken garken, shine a ba wa waɗanda ke cikin haɗarin mutuwa su yi rayuwarsu ta yau da kullun don haɓaka rigakafi ga ƙwayar cuta ta hanyar kamuwa da cuta ta dabi'a, tare da mafi kyawun kare waɗanda ke cikin haɗari mafi girma. Muna kiran wannan Kariyar Mai da hankali."
Fauci, ajin kula da lafiyar jama'a, da manyan cibiyoyi daga baya sun fito da wani kamfen na ban tsoro, rashin jajircewa, suna neman a yiwa kowa allurar. Sannan ya kara karfi. Sa'an nan kuma ƙara ƙarfafawa. Sannan an haɓaka tare da niyya, kashi bivalent.
Sun yi watsi da rigakafi na halitta saboda ya ci karo da halin da suke son tilastawa. An sake tabbatar da ba daidai ba.
Amma idan kuna fatan wannan zai haifar da rashin amincewa na dindindin na waɗannan cibiyoyi da "ƙwararrun masana," kar ku riƙe numfashinku.
Ofaya daga cikin mafi daidaiton fasalulluka na zamanin COVID shine "masana" yin ƙarya ga jama'a, yayin da suke ƙin yarda da cewa sun yi kuskure.
Sake bugawa daga marubucin Mayarwa
-
Ian Miller shine marubucin "Ba a rufe ba: Kasawar Duniya na Dokokin COVID Mask." An nuna aikinsa a watsa shirye-shiryen talabijin na kasa, wallafe-wallafen labarai na kasa da na duniya da kuma ambatonsa a cikin mafi kyawun littattafan sayar da kayayyaki da suka shafi cutar. Ya rubuta wasiƙar Substack, kuma mai suna "Ba a rufe ba."
Duba dukkan posts
