A zaman tabbatar da ita, Mai shari'a Ketanji Brown Jackson ta yi ikirarin cewa ba ta da kwarewar da za ta ayyana "mace." Shekaru biyu kacal bayan haka, ba ta yi jinkirin sake fasalin gyare-gyaren Farko da kuma 'yancin faɗar albarkacin baki ba yayin da take ba da shawara ga gwamnatin da ta ɓata ƴancin mu na Kundin Tsarin Mulki muddin sun ba da isassun hujjoji masu tsafta.
A muhawarar baka ta ranar Litinin a Murthy da Missouri, Jackson ta ce "babban damuwarta" ita ce umarnin, wanda ya haramtawa Gwamnatin Biden hada baki da Big Tech don tantance Amurkawa, na iya haifar da "Kwaskwarimar Farko ta durkusar da Gwamnati."
Wannan, a fili, ya fi damuwa da Jackson fiye da ayoyin da Ƙungiyar Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙware suka yi suka yi da kamfanonin sadarwar zamantakewa don daidaita bukatun su, cewa Fadar White House ta bukaci a yi watsi da 'yan jarida a fili, kuma Ma'aikatar Tsaron Cikin Gida ta kasance mai mahimmanci wajen yin amfani da 'yan kasa kafin zaben shugaban kasa na 2020.
Amma bisa ga ra'ayin Jackson, waɗannan abubuwan na iya zama abin ƙarfafawa. Ta tsawatar da lauyan, "Wasu na iya cewa a zahiri gwamnati na da alhakin daukar matakan kare 'yan kasar nan."
Tsarin Jackson yana jujjuya tsarin yancin tsarin mulki. Kundin tsarin mulki bai takaita ikon ‘yan kasa ba; yana hana zababbun jami’an mu daga cin zalin zalunci. Doka ce ke “mulkin waɗanda ke mulkinmu,” kamar yadda farfesa a fannin shari’a Randy Barnett ya bayyana.
Abubuwan da ke kawo cikas ga ikon jihohi ba aibi ba ne a cikin tsarin; su ne ainihin zane. Amma Jackson ba ya ba da ladabi ga waɗannan hane-hane na tsarin mulki. Madadin haka, ta bayyana cewa, "Ina matukar damuwa da…Gwargwadon Farko da ke aiki a cikin yanayi na barazana."
Tabbas, an tsara gyare-gyaren Farko don yanayin yanayi na barazana. Tarihin Amurka yana ba da ƙarancin barazanar da za a iya ba da hujja don rage ƴancin mu - daga Kwalara da Zazzabin Rawaya zuwa cutar shan inna da mura na Sipaniya; daga Red Coats da XYZ Affair zuwa Red Army da War on Terror; daga cin galaba a yamma zuwa kayar da Nazis.
Framers sun fahimci barazanar da ba za a iya kawar da ita ba da ikon ke haifarwa ga 'yanci, wanda shine dalilin da ya sa suka kasance ba shakka cewa Gwamnati ba za ta iya "kare" maganganun da tsarin mulki ya kayyade ba, komai tabbacin halin kirki na masu sharhi.
A wasu lokuta, kasar ta kasa cika wannan alkawari, amma ba kasafai ake bayyana wadannan al’amura ba. Ƙaunar Jackson ga gaggawa ko "lala'i masu barazana" shine ainihin ma'anar da Kotun ta yi amfani da ita don shigar da Jafananci da kuma daure Eugene Debs. Kwanan nan, masu yin sharhi sun yi kira ga wannan sanannen ubanci don tabbatar da tantance asalin Covid da kuma gaskiyar kwamfutar tafi-da-gidanka ta Hunter Biden.
Amma Kundin Tsarin Mulki yana buƙatar wata hanya ta dabam, kamar yadda Babban Lauyan Louisiana Benjamin Aguinaga ya bayyana a martani ga Jackson. Zaɓin tsakanin 'yanci da aminci shine binary na ƙarya. "Gwamnati ba za ta iya kawai gudanar da matsananciyar matsin lamba ga dandamali don tantance maganganun sirri," in ji Aguinaga.
Gwamnatin Biden na iya inganta abubuwan da take so, gabatar da jawabanta, da siyan PSAs ɗin da ta fi so. Ba za ta iya ba, duk da haka, ta yi amfani da ɓangarorin ɓangarorin ɓangarorin uba don ƙwace Kwaskwarimar Farko.
Mai shari'a Alito ya bayyana yana gani ta hanyar dalilai na tantancewa a cikin tambayarsa Brian Fletcher, Mataimakin Lauyan Janar na Biden. Ya tambaya:
"Lokacin da na ga cewa Fadar White House da jami'an tarayya sukan yi ta cewa Facebook da gwamnatin tarayya su zama 'abokan tarayya,' [ko] "muna tare." [GOMNATI] Jami'ai suna neman amsoshi, 'Ina son amsa ina son ta nan take.' Lokacin da ba su ji dadi ba, sai su la'ance su...Dalilin da ya sa hakan ke faruwa shi ne, gwamnatin tarayya ta samu Sashe na 230 da rashin amincewa a aljihunta...Haka kuma ta dauki Facebook da sauran manhajoji kamar na karkashinsu. Shin za ku yi hakan ga New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, Associated Press, ko wata babbar jarida ko sabis na waya?"
A halin yanzu, Jackson ba zai iya fahimtar ainihin ƙa'idodin Canjin Farko ko magana na 'yanci ba. Madadin haka, ta tsorata da tambayoyi marasa hankali na ko Jiha tana da sha'awar hana matasa daga "tsalle daga tagogi."
A cikin haka, Jackson ta bayyana niyyarta na kare gyare-gyaren Farko tare da ƴan matasan da aka kashe. “Babban damuwarta” ita ce Kwaskwarimar Farko na iya hana gwamnatin neman mulki, kamar yadda aka tsara ta.
Azzalumi ta dade tana lullube kanta cikin rigar lafuzza masu kyau. Ana nufin bangaren shari’a ne don kare ’yancinmu daga azzalumai masu son azzalumai, ko da sun amince da shiboleth na zamani na zamani. Jackson ba kawai sauke wannan alhakin ba; ta bayyana ta kyamace ta. Dole ne mu yi fatan takwarorinta na Kotu su ci gaba da rantsuwa da Kundin Tsarin Mulki.
Abu ne mai ban sha'awa musamman ga mutane da yawa da ke sauraron waɗannan gardama don sanin rashin ƙwarewa na ban mamaki daga wasu daga cikin waɗannan alkalan, musamman Jackson, da wasu sun sami lokacinsu.
Hanyoyin da ke wajen kotun sun cika makil da kwararru na gaske, mutanen da suka bibiyi wannan shari'a tun daga farkonsa, wadanda suka rutsa da su a rukunin masana'antar ta cece-kuce, da kuma mutanen da suka karanta kowane takaitaccen bayani kuma suka binciki hujjoji.
Waɗannan ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƴan ƙasa waɗanda suka san gaskiyar ciki da waje sun tsaya a kan titina a wajen shari’ar yayin da lauyan masu ƙara ya yi birgima cikin ƙayyadaddun lokaci don gabatar da batun, mai yiyuwa a karon farko, ga waɗannan maza da mata waɗanda ke riƙe makomar ’yanci a hannunsu.
Ba tare da sani ba, su kansu Alkalan suna fama da rukunin masana'antu na censorship. Da su kansu sun kasance masu shigar da kara a wannan lamarin, tunda su ma masu amfani da bayanai ne ta hanyar amfani da fasaha. Amma duk da haka, idan aka yi la’akari da matsayinsu da matsayinsu, sai sun yi kamar sun fi kowa, sanin abin da wasu ba su sani ba, duk da cewa ba su sani ba.
Al'amarin takaici ne, in kace.
Abin baƙin ciki, gardama ta baka ta koma cikin ɗan lokaci kaɗan game da tsayawar masu ƙara, takamaiman kalmar wannan ko waccan imel, da wasu ra'ayoyi masu ban tsoro, da kuma karkatar da hannu kan abin da zai zama tasirin magajin mu idan umarnin ya faru. Rasa a cikin wannan rudani shine babban abin da ya fi girma: bayyanannen buri a bangaren gudanarwa na kasa da kasa na zama babban mai kula da Intanet don murkushe dukkan alkawurran da aka yi na samar da fasahar sadarwa ta dimokuradiyya da kuma bullo da cikakken sarrafa tunanin jama'a.
Kotu da ta fayyace za ta ruguza duk wani buri. Hakan ba zai faru ba, a fili. Wannan ya ce, watakila alama ce mai kyau cewa aƙalla, kuma bayan shekaru da yawa na wannan tsoma baki a cikin bayanai, batun ya ɗauki hankalin kotun koli.
Bari wannan rana ta zama mai zazzagewa ga abin da ake buƙata mafi yawa: samuwar ƙwararrun ƴan ƙasa masu fa'ida waɗanda kwata-kwata suka ƙi tafiya tare da tantance ko menene.
-
Labarai daga Cibiyar Brownstone, ƙungiyar sa-kai da aka kafa a watan Mayu na 2021 don tallafawa al'umma da ke rage rawar tashin hankali a rayuwar jama'a.
Duba dukkan posts
