Kafofin watsa labarai a sannu a hankali ⋆ Cibiyar Brownstone Mark Oshinskie

SHARE | BUGA | EMAIL

A farkon aikina na shari'a, na yi gwajin kwana ɗaya da yawa. Wata rana da yamma, na dawo ofis dina. Har yanzu ina sanye da kwat da jakata, na wuce kofar ofishin wani babban abokin aikina mai suna Ben. Ya kira ni, "Yaya ka yi yau?"

Na tsaya a bakin kofarsa na amsa, “Ba da kyau, na kasa samun shaidarsu ta amince da abin da nake so ya yi.”

Ben ya yi murmushi ya ce, "Kana kallon talabijin da yawa, kana tsammanin mai shaida zai rushe a tsaye kuma ya yarda da komai, kamar yadda kiɗan da ke wasa a baya. Hakan ba zai faru ba. Dole ne ku ɗauki kowane shaida mai banƙyama a matsayin wanda ya fara da ƙwaƙƙwarar ƙididdiga. hannu."

Wannan ya sa hankali. Bayan haka, na daidaita tsammanina kuma na tsara tambayoyina yadda ya kamata.

Kafofin watsa labarai da marubutan da suka haifar da Coronamania, a cikin shekaru biyu da suka gabata, suna ja da baya a hankali daga tsoro da ƙiyayya da suka fara tasowa a cikin Maris, 2020. Sun ƙididdige cewa Covid-gaji, jama'a mai ban sha'awa ba za su tuna da yawancin abin da suka faɗa a baya ba a cikin Scamdemic.

Juma'ar da ta gabata, cikin biyu, labarai guda biyu, New York Times Marubuta Apoorva Mandavilli da David Leonhardt sun ci gaba da wannan jinkirin ja da baya daga Covid ƙaryar da suka dauki nauyin. A karon farko, sun yarda cewa watakila harbin da suka yaba da ya haifar da 'yan na abin da jab-o-philic readers za su yi watsi da shi a matsayin ƙananan raunuka.

Yayin da ya fara taƙaita jigon Mandavilli, Leonhardt ya yarda cewa ra'ayin cewa raunin vaxx ya sa shi "rashin jin daɗi." Ba ya nuna rashin jin daɗi game da raunin da kansu. Ya damu cewa za a iya tabbatar da masu sukar vaxx daidai.

Me yasa wanda ya bayyana kansa "dan jarida mai zaman kansa" zai zama rashin jin daɗi ta gaskiya? Me ke da banƙyama game da kiran ƙwallaye da buge-buge? Me yasa Leonhardt ke da sha'awar tushe? Abin da ke da wuyar yarda da cewa ya yi kuskure, ba kawai game da harbe-harbe ba, amma game da dukan na Covid damuwar da shi da ma'aikacinsa suka zuga a cikin shekaru uku da suka gabata?

Yi la'akari da wannan: A farkon 2021, Leonhardt ya yi tafiya mai nisan mil 1,600 don yin allura da wuri kamar yadda zai iya. David, kinda neurotic da def ba yanayi m.

Yarda da kuskure-ko haɗa baki tare da zamba-lokacin yawan fushin Covid zai haifar da asarar fuska da gaskiya. Bayan duk lahani da kafofin watsa labarai suka yi, waɗannan sakamakon zai zama daidai kuma daidai.

Don kauce wa wannan sakamakon, kafafen yada labarai da ma’aikatan ofishin suna ja da baya sannu a hankali don kokarin canza ra’ayoyinsu ba tare da mutane da yawa sun lura ba. Yin hakan, suna ɗaukar ra'ayoyin waɗanda, kamar ni, waɗanda tun daga ranar 1, suka yi kiran tuƙin hayaniya, da abubuwan da ba su dace ba, ga Covid-XNUMX.

Amma yayin da suke ƙara canza sassan saƙonsu, suna riƙe da tsakiya, labarin karya cewa Covid mummuna cuta ce da ta kashe miliyoyin mutane ba tare da nuna bambanci ba. Covophobes sun ci gaba da yin la'akari da allurar Covid don "ceton miliyoyin rayuka" da kuma "hana bakin ciki mara iyaka."

Times masu karatu su ne skewed, pro-jab samfurin. Don haka, kusan rabin masu sharhi 1,000+ sun ɗauki tatsuniyar Mandavilli da Leonhardt cewa, ko da harbin ya ji wa mutane rauni, sun kasance masu inganci a cikin duniyar da ke fuskantar mugun kisa na duniya. Dogaro da wannan jigo na ƙarya, waɗannan masu rubutun ra'ayin yanar gizo da masu sharhi sun tabbatar da cewa babu wani saƙon likita da ba shi da haɗari kuma babu makawa ƴan kwai kwai kwai sun karye yayin da ake yin omelet na alurar riga kafi. A ganinsu, irin wannan raunin da ya faru, tsadar kasuwanci ce.

Da farko, a ina aka sami irin wannan haɗarin / lada lokacin da aka sanya kulle-kulle da rufe makarantu?

Bugu da ƙari, da Times Marubuta da mafi yawan masu sharhi kan al'amuran jaba suna da'awar rigar "Kimiyya" da rashin dacewa. Ga mutane da yawa, maganin zamani addini ne kuma "alurar rigakafi" sacrament ne. Bangaskiyarsu ta pro-vaxx ba ta girgiza. Amma waɗannan masu ba da ilimin kimiyya masu ƙima ba tare da dalili ba sun yi watsi da mafi kyawun yanayin yanayin Covid: SARS-CoV-2 ya yi. ba barazana ga lafiya, wadanda ba tsofaffi. Don haka, bai kamata a sanya matakan da ba na magunguna ba ("NPIs") ko harbe-harbe a kan waɗanda ba su cikin haɗari. NPI da masu goyan bayan harbi ba Masana Kimiyya ba ne. Su ne Pseudo-Scientists.

The Zamani m, apocalyptic labari na Covid labari da pro-vaxx saƙon bai taɓa yin daidai da abin da na gani da idona ba. Bayan shekaru hudu a cikin Covid Ground Zero, New Jersey mai girma, kuma duk da samun babban yanki na zamantakewa, har yanzu ban san wanda ya mutu daga wannan kwayar cutar ba. I a kaikaice san biyar kacal-'yan uwan sani-ya ce da an kashe shi. Kowanne wanda aka zalunta da kwayar cutar kwaroron roba ya dace da bayanin martaba wanda ke bayyane tun Fabrairu, 2020: tsufa sosai kuma mara lafiya, yana mutuwa. tare da, ba daga, bayyanar cututtuka na kowa zuwa dukan cututtukan ƙwayoyin cuta na numfashi, bin gwajin ganowa wanda ba abin dogaro ba ne.

Da yake tinkarar masu goyan bayan harbin, daruruwan masu sharhi kan labarin Mandavilli sun bayyana raunin da suka samu jim kadan bayan yi musu allura. Amma duka labaran biyu, da masu sharhi da yawa ga labarin Mandavilli, sun jaddada cewa "haɗin kai ba dalili bane."

Yawan lallashin alaƙa ana tambaya ne kawai lokacin da mutum zai fi so a zahiri ba a shafa reza na Occam kuma a yi amfani da mafi sauƙin bayani game da alamomin da suka fara jim kaɗan bayan allura. Ina tsammanin cewa, a cikin mu'amalarsu na sirri, waɗanda ke cewa "haɗin kai ba dalili ba ne" ba safai suke yarda da daidaituwa ba.

Kai tsaye na san mutane shida waɗanda suka sami koma baya na kiwon lafiya jim kaɗan bayan ɗaukar allurar, gami da mutuwa ɗaya. Waɗannan suna kama da juna da yawa. Bugu da ari, menene zai ba da tabbaci mai gamsarwa na sanadin rauni na vaxx? Gawawwakin gawarwaki, watakila bisa dabara, ba kasafai ba ne. Bayan sun yi ƙara, na san masana koyaushe za su yi sabani game da dalilin idan an biya su da kyau. Kuma a ƙarshe, binciken “miliyoyin ceto” da aka ambata ba ya ɗauka cewa alaƙar is sanadi?

Duk da yake furucin da aka yi na cewa harbe-harbe sun ceci miliyoyin rayuka suna da matukar tambaya kuma ba a tallafa musu ba, da yawa waɗanda suka karanta waɗannan maganganun za su faɗi waɗannan a matsayin bishara saboda “miliyoyin” abin tunawa ne, albeit hasashe ne da ƙima, kuma saboda, da kyau, New York Times yace haka!

Yayin da masu rubutun ra'ayin yanar gizon ke amfani da wannan ƙididdiga na batsa don tabbatar da yawan allurar rigakafi, ɗaya kawai cikin dubu biyar na waɗanda suka kamu da cutar - kusan dukkansu tsoffi ne da/ko marasa lafiya ko kuma aka kashe su ta hanyar jima'i - sun mutu "na Covid" kafin VaxxFest ya fara. Yawancin wadanda suka mutu suna iya mutuwa nan ba da jimawa ba, kwayar cuta ko a'a.

Don haka, ta yaya mutum zai ce harbin ya ceci miliyoyin rayuka? Domin har yaushe sun tsira? Kuma shin wadanda suka gudanar da binciken “miliyoyin mace-mace” da aka ambata sun yi imanin cewa za su sami tallafi a nan gaba-jinin ƙwararrun rayuwa idan sun ba gano cewa harbe-harbe ceci miliyoyin rayuka?

Bugu da ari, Mandavilli da Leonhardt ba su taɓa yarda ba—kuma maiyuwa ba ma sani na-ƙididdigar sleight-of-hannu wanda masu turawa jab suka yi amfani da su. Na bayyana waɗannan dabaru a cikin rubuce-rubucen da suka gabata. Misali, akwai “kyakkyawan ra’ayin alluran rigakafi:” waɗanda suka gudanar da allurar da dabara sun ƙi yin allurar waɗanda suke da rauni sosai har girgizar tsarin na iya kashe su. Kuma wadanda suka yi allurar ba a kidaya su a matsayin “vaxxed” har sai kwanaki 42 bayan harbinsu na farko. Kamar yadda harbin farko kashe rigakafi da rushe jikin mutum, ya kamata a yi tsammanin harbe-harbe ƙara mace-mace a cikin makonni bayan fara tsarin harbe-harbe. Allurar da suka mutu a cikin wannan kwanaki 42 na farko an rarraba su azaman "marasa ƙarfi."

FWIW, ni da matata da duk sauran marasa vaxxers da na sani tabbas mun yi kyau. Harbin bai ceci ko daya daga cikin rayukanmu ba ko kuma ya hana mu zuwa asibiti. Tsarinmu na rigakafi ya yi. Mummunan kisa na "Virus" ya wuce gona da iri.

Kuma ƙarin sa baki na likita ba lallai ne ya inganta lafiya ba. Sabanin haka, kuma musamman game da harbe-harbe, ƙananan ya fi yawa.

Duk da yake Mandavilli da sauransu suna zargin "vitriolic" anti-vaxxers don hana vaxx da haɓaka haɓakawa, gazawar vaxx da kanta ta fi ƙarfin hana allurar fiye da wani abu da wani anti-vaxxer ya faɗi. Gwamnati da kafafen yada labarai sun sha yin la'akari da harbe-harben a matsayin "aminci da inganci" kuma sun ba da tabbacin cewa za su "dakatar da kamuwa da cuta da yada." Ƙirar waɗannan shirye-shiryen bidiyo na iya kasancewa har yanzu akan gidan yanar gizo. Duk da haka, alluran da ba su da yawa—har da duk allurar da na sani—sun yi rashin lafiya, sau da yawa kowanne.

Saboda haka, jabbers sun ji ƙarya. Dangane da irin waɗannan bayanan da ake iya gani kai tsaye na gazawar vaxx da fuskantar ko ganin raunin vaxx, kuma ba tare da karanta karatun ko gudanar da shari'ar kotu ba, jama'a sun yi nasu abubuwan lura kuma sun yanke hukunci mara kyau game da inganci da aminci na vaxx ta hanyar rage vaxx "masu ƙarfafawa." Bayan haka, idan anti-vaxxers sun yi irin wannan iko a kan ra'ayin jama'a da za su iya hana mutane ɗaukar abubuwan ƙarfafawa, gargaɗin farko da suka yi zai hana mutane yin harbin farko.

Mahimmanci, kuma ta tsawaita, kamar yadda mu masu shakka suka yi gaskiya game da harbe-harbe, mu ma mun yi daidai lokacin da muka soki kulle-kulle, rufe makarantu, abin rufe fuska, da gwaje-gwajen da suka kasance labarin bangaskiyar Coronamanic. Wani binciken CDC na kwanan nan don haka ya ƙare.

Yawancin NPI da masu goyan bayan harbe-harbe sun fake cikin "Ba za mu iya-san-sani ba." Amma miliyoyin, ciki har da ni, yi sani, bisa ga yaɗuwar bayanai, cewa NPIs da harbe-harbe ba su da kyau. Kuma kamar yadda we sun san cewa tsofaffi da marasa lafiya ne kawai ke cikin haɗari kuma NPIs za su haifar da babbar illa, waɗanda suka yarda da jinkirin cewa "an yi kurakurai" ba wai kawai ba. iya sun sani; su kamata sun sani. Rashin saninsu yana bayyana ko dai da gangan, dama, rashin kula da bayanan da ake gani a bayyane ko kuma rashin hankali.

A cikin Scamdemic, Mandavilli da Leonhardt sun yi jinkiri, da ƙara canza ra'ayoyinsu marasa tushe. Madadin nasu da ba za a iya jurewa ba shine su dage tare da gazawar labari a sarari da kasuwanci a cikin kwakwalwan amincin su, al'amari-ta-ba-dama. Amma suna yin haka a hankali don guje wa alhakin yin kuskure lokacin da ya dace.

Misali, na tsawon shekaru biyu, Mandavilli ya goyi bayan sanya yaran makaranta a gida. Hakanan, watanni 41 bayan fara Scamdemic, Leonhardt ya nakalto, tare da bayyananniyar mamaki, wani “kwararre” wanda ya ce mutuwar Covid tana da alaƙa da tsufa. A lokacin da suka yi wannan rangwame, yawancin jama'a sun riga sun san cewa ra'ayoyin masu rubutun ba daidai ba ne.

Hakanan ya ɗauki Leonhardt watanni 41 don yarda cewa mutuwar Covid ta yi yawa sosai. Amma, kamar lokacin da direbobin da ke fitar da matakin barasa na jini na 0.25% sun ce "suna da giya biyu kawai," ba Leonhardt da sauran masu sha'awar Covid-crazed ba za su yarda. yaya da yawa Waɗannan lambobin sun yi ƙarfi sosai.

Har ila yau Leonhardt ya goyi bayan Paxlovid, wanda tun da dadewa ake rage darajarsa.

Kuma Leonhardt ya yarda da jinkirin cewa rigakafi na halitta ya biyo bayan kamuwa da cuta kuma yana ba da rigakafi: na farko ga mutane, sannan ga rukuni. Ta hanyar yarda da hakan, kawai yana tabbatar da ainihin ƙa'idar cututtukan cuta - rigakafin garken garken - wanda aka yarda da shi sosai kafin Maris, 2020 amma, daga 2020-22, ana amfani da shi don tozarta waɗanda suka faɗi hakan.

Bugu da ari, yayin da Leonhardt da Mandavilli ke ci gaba da siyar da labarin batsa na "Cutar Cutar da Ba a yi maganin Alurar riga kafi" ba, fiye da yadda mutane marasa lafiya suka mutu tare da Covid.

A bayyane, Mandavilli da Leonhardt suma sun kasa ambaton cewa ɗaruruwan dubunnan sun sami raunuka na vaxx ko kuma mutuwar daga bugun zuciya, shanyewar jiki, ko ciwon daji kuma gabaɗayan mutuwar sun karu a cikin ƙasashe masu ɓarna. Don haka, idan mutum yayi la'akari dukan musabbabin mutuwar, harbe-harben da aka yi kamar sun haifar da raga asara, ba riba, a tsawon rayuwa.

The Times Marubuta sun yi watsi da dubun dubatan mutuwar Amurkawa bayan vaxx da aka jera a cikin rashin abokantaka na mai amfani, don haka rashin amfani da su, bayanan VAERS da wuce gona da iri na mutuwa yana ƙaruwa a cikin mafi yawan ƙasashe masu ɓarna a cikin 2021-22. Ba kamar vaxx da suka ji rauni, waɗanda har yanzu suna raye, matattun allurar rigakafi ba su ba da labari ba. Haka kuma yawancin waɗanda suka tsira ba su yi ba domin, kamar yadda yake da iyalai da suka yi rashin saurayi a yaƙi, waɗanda aka bar su don makoki ba sa son su gaskata cewa ƙaunatacciyarsu ta mutu ba zato ba tsammani ko a banza. Rashin son danganta mace-mace ga harbe-harbe yana da zafi musamman idan wanda aka kashe ya kwadaitar da wanda ya rasu ya yi allurar.

Yayin da Mandavilli da Leonhardt yanzu suka ba da rahoton cewa harbe-harbe na iya faruwa ba, duk da duk tallace-tallace da kuma tabbacin bureaucratic, sun kasance lafiya bayan duk, yarda cewa harbe-harbe sun yi. kashe mutane gada ce mai nisa. Akalla don yanzu.

Amma an buɗe taga Overton. Don haka, koma bayan kafofin watsa labaru za su ci gaba, ko da sannu a hankali. Raunin Vaxx da lalacewar da NPI ta haifar ba su Emery trends. Suna Kafa abubuwan da suka cancanci ɗaukar hoto fiye da yadda aka samu. Magoya bayan kulle/mask/ gwaji/vaxx sun yi kuskure sosai. Ba su da sauran guntun gaskiya.

Ina samun ɗan gamsuwa daga kallon pro-vaxx/NPI case crumble. Da fari dai, ba kamar a cikin ɗakin shari'a ba, inda alkalai da alkalai suke, aƙalla a ka'ida, sun mai da hankali kan abin da shaidu ke faɗi, yawancin hankalin mutane ya warwatse don lura da koma bayan masu tsoron Covid. Ja da baya da kafofin watsa labarai ya faru a hankali. Kamar yadda masu tayar da hankali suka yi ƙididdige ƙididdigewa, gajiyar Covid na jama'a za ta huce fushin kafofin watsa labarai.

Na biyu, rangwamen wa]annan kafofin watsa labarai ya yi nisa da yawa don samun fa'ida mai yawa. Manufofin zamantakewa, tattalin arziki, da siyasa na ƙungiyar Mania an cika su a cikin 2020-22. Abin baƙin ciki, wannan lalacewa ta dindindin.

Duk da haka, don hana ƙarin lafiyar jama'a, siyasa, da tattalin arziƙi da zalunci, dole ne mu ci gaba da faɗin me ke gaskiya: Scamdemic babban rashi ne, cin zarafi wanda yawancin mutane suka yi butulci don kamawa.

Gaskiya tana da kima sosai. Ba tare da la’akari da sakamako ba, faɗin gaskiya wajibi ne a kan zuriya.

An sake bugawa daga marubucin Mayarwa

Shiga cikin tattaunawar: