Wata ƙungiyar 'yan jarida da ke da ban sha'awa a yanzu ta zama mai magana ga manyan na'urorin tantancewa na ƙasar. Ranar Lahadin da ta gabata, The New York Times ya gudanar da wani labari na gaba "Yadda Abokan Gaban Trump Ke Nasara Yakin Karɓar Bayanai."
Uwargidan Grey ta rufe yaƙi don Gyaran Farko a cikin sabanin tunani biyu. Kamar yadda muka rufe a ko'ina cikin Missouri da Biden (yanzu Murthy da Missouri) shari'o'i, masu tace bayanai sun musanta cewa akwai yuwuwar tantancewar yayin da suka dage cewa ya kamata mu yi godiya da hakan.
Lauyoyin gwamnati suna da jãyayya cewa masu shigar da kara sun kirkiri karar, kuma zargin da ake yi na yin katsalandan ba wani abu ba ne illa "wani nau'in maganganun da ba su dace ba da kuma zabar wasu takardu da ke gurbata bayanan don gina labari wanda kawai bayanan da ba su goyi baya ba." A lokaci guda kuma, sun dage cewa yin katsalandan ya zama dole "don hana mummunar cutarwa ga jama'ar Amurka da tsarin dimokiradiyyarmu."
Harvard Law Farfesa Larry Tribe ya bi hanyarsu, suna jayayya cewa na'urar tantance masu zaman kansu da jama'a "ka'idar makirci ce da ba ta dace ba" amma kawar da ita "zai sa mu kasa tsaro a matsayin al'umma kuma zai jefa mu cikin hadari a kowace rana."
yanzu, The New York Times da sauran kafafen yada labarai sun bi sahun masu tantaunawar. Labarin ya ba da misali da Nina Jankowicz, azzalumi mai burin da aka sani da ita Mary Poppins - jigo kiraye-kirayen cece-kuce, wanda ya yi iƙirarin "babu wata ƙaramar shaida" bayan zargin da gwamnatin Biden ta yi kira don murkushe masu adawa.
Labarin ya bayyana kayan aikin tantancewa a matsayin mafarkin zazzabi na dama-dama wanda Shugaba Trump "ya jefa kansa a matsayin wanda aka azabtar kuma mai daukar fansa kan wani babban makirci na dakile yunkurinsa." A lokaci guda kuma, marubutan sun buga misali da manyan masu fafutukar kare bayanan sirri na Amurka.
Jankowicz ya jagoranci kwamitin Ma'aikatar Tsaron Cikin Gida kan rashin fahimta har sai da gwamnatin Biden ta dakatar da Ma'aikatar Gaskiya ta Cikin Gida saboda rahotannin da ke cewa Jankowicz ya kasance wadata mai yadawa labari, gami da Dossier Steele da kwamfutar tafi-da-gidanka Hunter Biden.
Jankowicz ya koka, ba tare da ban tsoro ba, ga Times cewa juriya ga sahihancin kan layi ya haifar da "sakamako mai sanyi." Ta bayyana, "Babu wanda yake son a kama shi."
The Times Katie Starbird kuma ta nakalto Katie Starbird, wacce ta ce "mutanen da ke cin gajiyar yada labaran karya sun rufe bakin mutane da yawa da za su yi kokarin kiransu." Uwargidan Grey ba ta lura da ban haushin da Starbird ta yi ikirarin cewa an “yi shiru” kamar yadda takardar rikodin ta nakalto ta a shafin farko na bugun Lahadi ba, kuma ba ta bayyana rawar da ta taka a CISA ba, Hukumar Tsaron Cikin Gida ta CISA. a tsakiyar masana'antar sa ido.
Yayin da yake aiki a kwamitin "Bayanai & Rarrabawa" na CISA, Starbird ya koka da cewa Amurkawa da yawa suna kama da "karɓar bayanai a matsayin 'magana' kuma cikin ƙa'idodin dimokiradiyya." Hakika, waɗannan "ka'idoji" sun kasance kariya ta Farko Kwaskwarima fiye da shekaru 200. Amma CISA - karkashin jagorancin masu kishi irin su Dokta Starbird - sun nada kansu a matsayin masu sulhu na gaskiya kuma sun yi aiki tare da manyan kamfanonin watsa labarai masu karfi a duniya don kawar da rashin amincewa.
The Times, Starbird, da Jankowicz suna wakiltar ƙaƙƙarfan ƙaryar da ke ƙunshe da duk wani hadadden sahihanci: cewa gwamnati da jami'anta sun riƙe gaskiya a kan gaskiya. Adalci Kenji Brown Jackson a fili ya raba wannan ra'ayi a cikin gardama na baka don Murthy da Missouri, kamar yadda ta bayar da shawarar samun 'yancin yin magana idan gwamnati ta ba da "sha'awar jiha."
Kwaskwarimar Farko baya nuna bambanci tsakanin ra'ayoyin gaskiya da na ƙarya; yana ba da kariya ga magana ba tare da la'akari da gaskiyar ba. Amma duk da kariyar doka, Gwamnati ta kasance mafi yawan yada "lalata" a cikin shekaru hudu da suka gabata. Daga rigakafi na dabi'a, zuwa kulle-kulle, zuwa ingancin rigakafin, don rufe umarni, don hana tafiye-tafiye, zuwa adadin mace-mace, taron "amincin da kimiyya" ya rufe rashin amincewa wanda galibi ya fi daidai da umarnin gwamnati.
A cikin wannan tsari, hukumomi na hagu sun yi watsi da dabi'un su na sassaucin ra'ayi don neman mulki. Kamar yadda Brownstone ya bayyana a ciki "Duba Kusa da Takaitattun Bayanan Amici a ciki Murthy da Missouri, " Kungiyoyin da ake zato masu sassaucin ra'ayi kamar Jami'ar Stanford da Babban Lauyan Dimokuradiyya sun bukaci Kotun da ta inganta aikin tantancewa yayin da ACLU ta yi shiru.
'Yan jarida - wadanda aka taba yi wa lakabi da Estate na Hudu - sun hada kai da gwamnatin don tozarta masu kalubalantar ta. A ciki Slate, Mark Joseph Stern ake kira to Murthy da Missouri kamar "inane" da "kwakwalwa mai narkewa." Bai yi ƙoƙarin bayar da rahoton ɗaruruwan shafukan da aka gano ba wanda ya bayyana kamfen ɗin haɗin gwiwar da aka tsara daga Fadar White House, Ƙungiyar Intelligence, da Big Tech, kuma bai yi yaƙi da jerin wanki ba da ya bunƙasa a ƙarƙashin tallafin gwamnati, gami da Yaƙin Iraki, kulle-kullen Covid, ko kwamfutar tafi-da-gidanka na Hunter Biden.
Madadin haka, ya ayyana tabbatacciyar cewa gwamnatin Biden - wacce ke alfahari da yin watsi da umarnin Kotun game da lamunin dalibai tare da neman a yi wa abokan gabanta na siyasa aiki - ta yi aiki a cikin ikonta don mayar da martani ga "annoba a cikin ƙarni."
Wadannan maganganun ƙarshe, waɗanda aka ware daga gaskiya, ba sabon abu ba ne ga Stern, wanda aikinsa ya nuna shi ya zama ɗan ƙaramin kakakin jam'iyyar Democratic Party. A cikin karar tabbatar da Brett Kavanaugh, ya da ake kira Karin bincike kan zargin da Julie Swetnick ta yi cikin sauki cewa Kavanaugh shi ne jagoran zobe na kungiyar masu fyade a makarantar sakandare. Shi aka bayyana Christine Blasey Ford, makaryaci serial wanda yake babu shaida ta taɓa saduwa da Kavanaugh, a matsayin "jarumin jama'a a hagu na sauran lokaci." Shi azabtarwa masu shari'a don rashin sanya abin rufe fuska har zuwa ƙarshen 2022 da ba'a nazarin shari'a na na banza wajibcin abin rufe fuska na jirgin sama a matsayin shaida na tsarin "ƙarar mulki mai buguwa" da "mummunan karya" tsarin.
Kamar yawancin masu mulkin da suka rage, babu wani bambanci ko iri-iri ga gambits masu neman iko. Daga jefa kuri'a na wasiku to umarnin rigakafi to ƙuntatawa to Elon Musk to m mataki, da Slate marubucin yana tafiya a kulle tare da garken marasa hankali.
Stern ba ta wata hanya mai ban mamaki, amma yana wakiltar sauyin hagu na Amurka, wanda ya haifar da sabon zamanin mulkin kama-karya wanda aka zana cikin harshen ci gaba. Kamar Justice Jackson, kerkeci yana zuwa cikin tufafin tumaki, sanye da ingantattun ka'idojin siyasa na tabbatar da aiki da siyasa iri-iri. Amma rigar bakan gizo ba za ta iya shawo kan mummunar barazana ga jamhuriyarmu ba.
Hukumomin gwamnatin tarayya sun yi awon gaba da cibiyoyin sadarwar mu domin kare muradunsu. Sun danne ƙin yarda don dawwamar da ikonsu, kuma jaridu na yau da kullun sun durƙusa ga Leviathan. Alkalan Kotun Koli, watakila layin karshe na tsaro a kan burin azzalumai na canza tsarin mulkin kama-karya zuwa doka, ya bayyana a matakin yin watsi da Kwaskwarimar Farko.
Hukunci ga gwamnati a Murthy da Missouri zai iya canza al'umma har abada, dangantakar dake tsakanin gwamnati da 'yan kasuwa masu zaman kansu, da 'yancin Amurkawa na samun bayanai. Har ma da firgita, zai nuna cewa tsarin da ya dace ya daina yin sarauta bisa son kai na siyasa.
A cikin Robert Bolt Mutum Na Duk Lokaci, Thomas More ya tambayi surukinsa, William Roper, ko zai baiwa Iblis kariyar doka. Roper ya amsa cewa zai "yanke kowace doka a Ingila" don isa ga Iblis.
"Oh? Kuma lokacin da doka ta ƙarshe ta ƙare, kuma Shaidan ya juyo a kan ku, ina za ku ɓoye, Roper, dokokin duk suna kwance?" Ƙarin tambaya. “Kasar nan tana da kambi da dokoki, tun daga bakin teku zuwa bakin teku, Dokokin mutum, ba na Allah ba! Idan kuma kuka sare su… shin da gaske kuke ganin za ku iya tsayawa tsayin daka a cikin iskar da za ta kada a lokacin? E, zan ba Shaidan amfanin doka, don kare kaina!”
Mai shari'a Jackson, Hukumar Biden, Katie Starbird, da abokansu a cikin kafofin watsa labaru na iya yarda cewa suna da aikin allahntaka don tantance bayanan da ake zargi, cewa sake reincarnation na Iblis ya ɗauki nau'i da yawa a cikin jikin RFK Jr., Alex Berenson, Jay Bhattacharya, da sauransu; a karkashin Kundin Tsarin Mulkin mu, duk da haka, masu girman kai na ayyukansu ba su ba da uzuri na cin zarafi na Gyaran Farko ba.
Mu yi fatan Kotu ta gane tsananin barazanar.
-
Labarai daga Cibiyar Brownstone, ƙungiyar sa-kai da aka kafa a watan Mayu na 2021 don tallafawa al'umma da ke rage rawar tashin hankali a rayuwar jama'a.
Duba dukkan posts
