A cikin labaran biyu da suka gabata, na duba cikin yanayi mara kyau game da nadin Deborah Birx ga Kwamitin Ba da Amsa na Coronavirus na Fadar White House da abin dariya rashin hakikanin kimiyya a bayan ikirarin da ta yi amfani da shi don tabbatar da gwajin ta, rufe fuska, nisantar da manufofinta.
Idan aka yi la’akari da wannan duka, tambayoyin sun taso: Wane ne ainihin mai kula da Deborah Birx kuma wa take aiki tare?
Amma na farko: Wane ne ya damu?
Anan ne dalilin da ya sa nake ganin yana da mahimmanci: Idan za mu iya nuna cewa Birx da sauran waɗanda suka sanya dokar hana gwajin kimiyya gabaɗaya, masking, nisantar da jama'a, da manufofin kulle-kulle, sun san daga tafiya cewa waɗannan manufofin ba za su yi aiki da kwayar cutar numfashi ta iska ba, amma duk da haka sun sanya su don dalilai SAURAN LAFIYAR JAMA'A, to babu wani matakan da za a iya yarda da su.
Bugu da ƙari, duk wani tsaunuka na kimiyya mara kyau da aka haɗa don tantance waɗannan matakan su ma sun cika tudu. Maimakon mu shiga cikin kowane bincike na bogi don nuna rashin amfaninsa na kimiyya, za mu iya jefa dukan tulin tulin cikin datti na tarihi, inda yake, kuma mu ci gaba da rayuwarmu.
A cikin kyakkyawan fata na, Ina kuma fatan cewa ta hanyar fallasa tushen rashin kimiyya, rashin lafiyar jama'a na bala'in Covid, za mu iya rage yiwuwar sake faruwa.
Kuma yanzu, koma Birx.
Ba ta yi aiki ko tare da Trump ba
Mun san tabbas Birx ba ta aiki tare da Shugaba Trump, kodayake tana kan wata rundunar da ke wakiltar Fadar White House. Trump bai nada ta ba, haka nan kuma shugabannin Task Force ba su yi ba, kamar yadda Scott Atlas ya fada a cikin littafinsa na wahayi kan hauka na Fadar White House, Annoba A Gidanmu. Lokacin da Atlas ya tambayi membobin Task Force yadda aka nada Birx, ya yi mamakin ganin cewa "babu wanda ya sani." (Atlas, shafi na 82)
Duk da haka, ko ta yaya, Deborah Birx - tsohuwar mai bincike kan cutar AIDS na soja kuma jakadan gwamnati ba tare da horo, gogewa ko wallafe-wallafe a cikin ilimin cututtukan cututtuka ko manufofin kiwon lafiyar jama'a ba - ta sami kanta tana jagorantar Rundunar Task Force ta Fadar White House wanda a kai ta ke da ikon ruguza bayanan manufofin Shugaban Amurka.
Kamar yadda ta bayyana a ciki Mamaye SilentBirx ya girgiza lokacin da "a tsakiyar tsakiyar kwanaki 15 namu don rage yakin neman zabe, Shugaba Trump ya bayyana cewa yana fatan za a dauke duk takunkumin ranar Lahadi." (Birx, shafi na 142) Ta ma firgita sa’ad da “kwanaki kaɗan bayan shugaban ƙasar ya sanar da tsawaita wa’adin kwanaki 152 na yaƙin neman zaɓe na Slow the Spread ga jama’ar Amirka” ya fusata kuma ya ce mata “Ba za mu ƙara rufe ƙasar ba.’” (Birx, shafi na XNUMX)
A bayyane yake, Trump ba ya cikin kulle-kullen, kuma duk lokacin da aka tilasta masa tafiya tare da su, sai ya fusata kuma ya zagi Birx - mutumin da ya yi imani yana tilasta shi.
Birx ta yi kuka cewa "daga nan gaba, duk abin da na yi aiki zai kasance da wahala - a wasu lokuta, ba zai yiwu ba," kuma ta ci gaba da cewa dole ne ta yi aiki a bayan fage a kan Shugaban kasa, tare da "daidaita don kare kasar sosai daga kwayar cutar da ta riga ta mamaye ta." (Birx, shafi na 153-4)
Wanne ya dawo da mu ga tambayar: A ina Birx ta sami jijiyar wuya kuma, mafi ban mamaki, ikon yin hakan cikin ɓacin rai a cikin adawa kai tsaye ga shugaban da ya kamata ta yi aiki, kan batutuwan da suka shafi rayuwar dukan jama'ar Amurka?
Atlas ya yi nadamar abin da yake tunanin shi ne "kuskuren hukunci" na Shugaba Trump. Ya yi jayayya cewa Trump ya yi aiki da "ba da son zuciyarsa" da kuma "wakilta ikon ga ma'aikatan kiwon lafiya, sannan ya kasa gyara wannan kuskuren." (Atlas, shafi na 308)
Kodayake na yi imanin manyan kurakurai a cikin hukunci ba sabon abu bane ga Shugaba Trump, ban yarda da Atlas akan wannan ba. Game da Ƙungiyar Task Force Response Task Force, Ina tsammanin akwai wani abu mafi banƙyama a wasa.
Trump ba shi da iko akan Birx ko martanin cutar
Dokta Paul Alexander, kwararre kan cututtukan cututtuka kuma kwararre kan hanyoyin bincike wanda aka dauka don ba wa gwamnatin Trump shawara kan manufofin cutar, ya ba da labari mai ban tsoro. a wata hira da Jeffrey Tucker, wanda jami'ai a Sashen Lafiya da Ayyukan Jama'a (HHS) da lauyoyi daga ma'aikatar shari'a suka gaya masa ya yi murabus, duk da umarnin kai tsaye daga Shugaba Trump da Fadar White House: "Muna so ka fahimci cewa Shugaba Trump ba shi da iko," kamar yadda aka ruwaito sun gaya wa Alexander. "Ba zai iya gaya mana abin da za mu yi ba."
Alexander ya yi imanin cewa waɗannan ma'aikatan sun wakilci "jihar mai zurfi" wanda, an gaya masa akai-akai, ya yanke shawarar da farko kada ya yi haya ko biya shi, sa'an nan kuma ya rabu da shi. Alexander kuma ya rubuta a cikin fallasa mai zuwa cewa tsarin mulkin gwamnati, musamman a NIH, CDC, da WHO, sun yi amfani da martanin cutar don lalata damar Shugaba Trump na sake tsayawa takara.
Shin duk martanin da aka yi na kin jinin kimiya na kimiya, a duk duniya, wani yunkuri ne na siyasa don kawar da Trump? Yana yiwuwa. Zan yi gardama, duk da haka, cewa siyasa ta kasance hanya ce kawai ga babban abin da ya faru: ƙwanƙwasa injin ƙwayar cuta da ɓoyewa. Na yi imani da "zurfin yanayi" Alexander akai-akai butted up a kan ba kawai tushen tsarin mulki, amma wani abu ma zurfi da kuma karfi.
Wanda ya dawo da mu zuwa zurfin mace gaban mace Deborah Birx.
Bayan koka da tawagar Trump ga "ma'aikatan aikin jinya," Scott Atlas ya kuma yi nuni ga sojojin da suka wuce ikon Trump. Atlas ya ce, "An kira Task Force 'Task Force ta White House Coronavirus Task Force," in ji Atlas, "amma ba ta yi daidai da Shugaba Trump ba, Mataimakin Shugaban kasa Pence ne ya ba da umarni." (Atlas, shafi na 306) Duk da haka, duk lokacin da Atlas ya yi ƙoƙari ya yi tambayoyi game da manufofin Birx, an umurce shi ya yi magana da Pence, wanda ya kasa magance wani abu da Birx:
"Ganin cewa VP ya kasance mai kula da Task Force, shin bai kamata shawarar da ke fitowa daga gare ta ta dace da manufofin gwamnati ba? Amma ba zai taba yin magana da Dr. Birx ba ko kadan. A gaskiya ma, (Marc) Short [Shugaban Ma'aikata na Pence], a fili yana wakiltar bukatun VP fiye da kowa, zai yi akasin haka, yin waya da wasu a Yammacin Turai don guje wa Dr. Birx." (Atlas, shafi na 165-6)
tuna cewa Pence ya maye gurbin Alex Azar a matsayin darektan Task Force a ranar 26 ga Fabrairu, 2020 da nadin Birx a matsayin mai gudanarwa, bisa yunƙurin Asst. Mai Ba Kasa Shawara Kan Tsaro Matt Pottinger, ya zo a ranar 27 ga Fabrairu. Bayan waɗannan alƙawura guda biyu, Birx ne ya kasance mai kula da manufofin coronavirus na Amurka yadda ya kamata.
Me ke kawo wannan manufar, da zarar ta karbi mulki? Kamar yadda Birx ta rubuta, NSC (Majalisar Tsaro ta Kasa) ce ta nada ta, ta hanyar Pottinger, kuma aikinta ne ta "karfafa gargadin su" - wanda, na ci gaba da hasashe, sun kasance masu alaƙa da sakin haɗari na haɓakar ƙwayar cuta mai yuwuwar kamuwa da cuta daga wani Lab da Amurka ke bayarwa a Wuhan.
Wataƙila an sanar da Trump game da wannan, kamar yadda aka tabbatar ba kawai ta maimaita ambatonsa ba, amma ta me Time Mujallar ta kira rashin hali nasa ya ki bayyana dalilin da ya sa ya gaskata hakan. Mujallar ta ambato Trump yana cewa "Ba zan iya gaya muku hakan ba," lokacin da aka tambaye shi game da imaninsa game da ledar dakin gwaje-gwaje. Kuma ya sake cewa, "Ba a yarda in gaya muku haka ba."
Me ya sa a duniya ba a yarda Shugaban Amurka ya yi watsi da mai binciken AIDS / diflomasiyya Birx kan manufofin kulle-kulle ko bayyana wa jama'a dalilin da ya sa ya yi imani da akwai lebur?
Amsar, na yi imani, ita ce, Trump ya ja da baya ba tare da wani hali ba saboda an gaya masa (Birx, Pottinger da sojoji / leken asiri / kare lafiyar halittu wadanda suka yi aiki) cewa idan bai bi manufofinsu da sanarwarsu ba, miliyoyin Amurkawa za su mutu. Me yasa? Saboda SARS-CoV-2 ba kawai wata kwayar zoonotic ba ce. Kwayar cuta ce da aka kirkira wacce ke buƙatar ƙunshe da komai.
Kamar yadda Dokta Atlas ya ci gaba da lura da baƙin ciki sosai: “Likitocin Task Force sun daidaita kan ra’ayi mai ra’ayi ɗaya wanda zai Dole ne a dakatar da duk shari'ar COVID ko kuma miliyoyin Amurkawa za su mutu.” (Atlas, shafi na 155-6) [FUSKAR FUSKA]
Wannan shine babban sakon, wanda aka yi amfani da shi da karfi da nasara kan Trump, gwamnatinsa, 'yan jaridu, jihohi, da jama'a, don murkushe duk wani adawa da manufofin kulle-kulle. Amma duk da haka sakon ba shi da ma'ana idan kun yi imani SARS-CoV-2 kwayar cuta ce da ta yi tsalle daga jemage zuwa mutum a cikin rigar kasuwa, yana cutar da galibin mutanen da suka tsufa da nakasa. Yana da ma'ana kawai idan kuna tunani, ko kuka sani, cewa an ƙirƙira ƙwayar cutar ta zama mai saurin yaduwa ko kuma mai kisa (koda kuwa halayenta a cikin jama'a a kowane lokaci na iya ba da hujjar matakin ƙararrawa).
Amma, kuma, kafin yin ƙarin hasashe, bari mu koma Birx. Wacece kuma (da ma'aikatanta na boye) suka yi bijimillah?
Ta zayyana manufofin ga dukkan gwamnatin Trump
A cikin littafinsa, Atlas ya lura da mamaki da mamaki cewa, kodayake Pence shine babban darektan Task Force, Deborah Birx ita ce mai kula da: "An aiwatar da manufofin Birx a duk faɗin ƙasar, a kusan kowace jiha guda, ga cutar gaba ɗaya - ba za a iya hana wannan ba; ba za a iya jujjuya shi ba. " (Atlas, shafi na 222)
Atlas ya kasance "bakin ciki game da rashin jagoranci a Fadar White House," wanda, "Shugaban yana faɗin abu ɗaya yayin da wakilin Kwamitin Tsaro na Fadar White House ke faɗi wani abu daban-daban, wanda ya saba wa juna" kuma, kamar yadda ya lura, "babu wanda ya taɓa daidaita ta [Birx] a kan aikinta." (Atlas, shafi na 222-223)
Ba wai kawai wannan ba, amma ko ta yaya Trump, ko wani a cikin gwamnatin, bai yarda da Birx ba, "An yi garkuwa da Fadar White House game da matakin da Dr. Birx ya dauka" kuma "ba za a taba ta ba, lokaci." (Atlas, shafi na 223)
Ɗaya daga cikin bayanin da ba za a iya taɓa ta ba, Atlas ya nuna, shine Birx da manufofinta sun zama sananne ga manema labarai da jama'a cewa gwamnati ba ta son "jiki jirgin" ta hanyar maye gurbin ta kafin zaben. Wannan bayanin, duk da haka, kamar yadda Atlas da kansa ya gane, ya rushe a gaban abin da muka sani game da Trump da kuma kiyayyar kafofin watsa labarai a gare shi:
"Su (masu ba da shawara na Trump) sun shawo kansa ya yi daidai da abin da zai iya yi a kowane yanayi - don yin watsi da hankalinsa da kuma ba da damar shawarar siyasa marar kuskure ta yi nasara. ... sanarwar, makusantan ‘yan siyasa sun yaudare shi duk saboda tsoron abin da ba makawa ko ta yaya — skewering daga kafofin yada labarai masu adawa da juna. (Atlas, shafi na 300-301)
Ina ba da shawarar, kuma, dalilin da ya sa da alama ba za a iya fayyace rashin cin hanci da rashawa a bangaren Trump na kawar da Birx ba ba siyasa ba ne, amma dabarun bayan fage na (don fitar da moniker) leak cabal.
Wanene kuma ya kasance wani ɓangare na wannan cabal tare da ɓoyayyun manufofinsa da kuma tasirin manufofinsa? Hankalin mu a dabi'a yana komawa ga sauran membobin Task Force waɗanda ke yiwuwa suna haɓaka manufofin kulle-kulle tare da Birx. Wahayi masu ban mamaki sun bayyana.
Babu troika. Babu shirin kulle Birx-Fauci. Duk Birx ne.
An ɗauka a duk faɗin duniya, ta wurin masu goyon baya da waɗanda ke adawa da ka'idojin manufofin Task Force, cewa Dr. Deborah Birx, Tony Fauci (shugaban NIAID a lokacin) da Bob Redfield (darekta na CDC a lokacin) sun yi aiki tare don tsara waɗannan manufofin.
Labarun da Birx da kanta da mai shigar da kara na Task Force Scott Atlas suka bayar suna nuna akasin haka.
Kamar kowa, a farkon littafinsa, Atlas ya ce: "Masu gine-ginen dabarun kulle-kullen Amurka su ne Dr. Anthony Fauci da Dr. Deborah Birx. Tare da Dr. Robert Redfield ... (Atlas, shafi na 22)
Amma yayin da labarin Atlas ya bayyana, yana ba da ƙarin fahimta game da ƙarfin ƙarfin aiki akan Task Force:
"Matsayin Fauci ya fi ba ni mamaki. Yawancin ƙasar, haƙiƙa duk duniya, sun ɗauka cewa Fauci ya mallaki aikin darekta a cikin Task Force na gwamnatin Trump. Na kuma yi tunanin hakan daga kallon labarai," in ji Atlas. Duk da haka, ya ci gaba da cewa, "Zaton jama'a na matsayin jagorancin Dr. Fauci akan Task Force kanta… ba zai iya zama kuskure ba.. Fauci ya gudanar da babban taro tare da jama'a, amma ba shi da alhakin wani takamaiman wani abu na Task Force. Ya yi aiki musamman a matsayin tashar don sabuntawa kan gwajin alluran rigakafi da magunguna. " (shafi na 98) [FUSKAR FUSKA]
A ƙarshen littafin, Atlas ya sake duba ƙimar farko ta farko, yana mai da hankali sosai cewa, a zahiri, Birx ne da farko kuma shine ya tsara da yada manufofin kullewa:
"Dokta Fauci ya kasance yana shari'a a gaban jama'a a kullun, sau da yawa da yawa suna kuskuren rawar da ya taka na shugabancin. da gaske Dr. Birx ne ya bayyana manufofin Task Force. Duk shawarwarin da Task Force zuwa jihohin suka fito daga Dr. Birx. Dukkan shawarwarin da aka rubuta game da manufofinsu na kan-kasa sun fito ne daga Dr. Birx. Dr. Birx ya gudanar da kusan dukkanin ziyarar jahohi a madadin Hukumar Task Force.” (Atlas, shafi na 309-10) [FUSKAR FUSKA]
Yana iya yin sauti mai ban tsoro kuma ba zai yuwu ba, idan aka yi la'akari da fahimtar jama'a game da Fauci, kamar yadda Atlas ya lura. Amma a cikin littafin Birx hoton da ba a zata ba ya bayyana.
Methinks matar ta nuna rashin amincewa da yawa
Kamar yadda yake tare da ita kalamai masu cin karo da juna akan yadda aka dauke ta aiki, da ita da'awar kimiyya na bogi a fili, Labarin Birx game da kusancin zuciyarta tare da Fauci da Redfield sun rabu kan jarrabawar kusa.
A cikin littafinta, Birx ta yi da'awar cewa ta amince da Redfield da Fauci "a kai tsaye don taimakawa wajen daidaita martanin Amurka game da sabon coronavirus." (Birx, shafi na 31) Ta ce tana da “kowane kwarin gwiwa, dangane da ayyukan da suka yi a baya, cewa duk hanyar da kwayar cutar ta bi, Amurka da CDC za su kasance kan gaba a lamarin.” (Birx, shafi na 32)
Sa'an nan kuma, kusan nan da nan, ta zubar da mutuncin wadanda ake zaton ta amince da su, ta nakalto Matt Pottinger yana cewa "'ya kamata ta karbi ayyukan Azar, Fauci, da kuma Redfield, saboda kun kasance jagora fiye da su." (Birx, shafi na 38-9).
Watakila kawai ta dan yi wa kanta tabo a baya, wani mai iya ba da shawara ba tare da laifi ba. Amma jira. Akwai ƙari sosai.
Birx ta yi iƙirarin cewa a cikin wani taro a ranar 31 ga Janairu, "duk abin da Dr. Fauci da Redfield suka faɗa game da tsarinsu yana da ma'ana dangane da bayanan da nake da su a wancan lokacin," kodayake "ba ɗaya daga cikinsu ya yi magana" game da batutuwan biyu da ta fi damu da ita: "Bazuwar shiru [da kuma] gwajin rawar da yakamata ya taka a cikin martanin." (Birx, shafi na 39)
Sannan, kodayake ta ce "ba ta yi karatu da yawa a cikin wannan tsallakewar ba," (shafi na 39) makonni biyu kacal bayan haka, "a farkon 13 ga Fabrairu" Birx ta sake ambata "rashin jagoranci da jagoranci a cikin CDC da Kwamitin Task Force Coronavirus na Fadar White House." (shafi na 54)
Don haka Debi ta amince da shugabancin Tony da Bob ko ba ta yi ba? Amsar ita ce ƙarin ɓarna mai cin karo da juna.
Birx ta firgita cewa babu wanda ke daukar kwayar cutar da mahimmanci kamar yadda ya kamata: "sai na ga Tony da Bob suna maimaita cewa hadarin ga Amurkawa ya yi kadan," in ji ta. "A ranar 8 ga Fabrairu, Tony ya ce damar kamuwa da kwayar cutar ta kasance 'raguwa.'" Kuma, "a ranar 29 ga Fabrairu, ya ce, 'A yanzu, a wannan lokacin, babu buƙatar canza wani abu da kuke yi a kullun.'" (Birx, shafi na 57)
Wannan baya kama da irin jagoran Birx zai iya amincewa. Da zuciya ɗaya ta yi ƙoƙarin ba da uzuri ga Redfield da Fauci, tana mai cewa "Yanzu na yi imani cewa kalmomin Bob da Tony sun yi magana da taƙaitaccen bayanan da suke da damar yin amfani da su daga CDC," sannan, a wani lokacin bulala, "wataƙila suna da bayanai a Amurka waɗanda ban yi ba."
Shin Tony da Bob sun ba da gargaɗin da ba su da ƙarfi saboda rashin isassun bayanai ko don suna da ƙarin bayanai fiye da Birx? Ba ta taɓa fayyace ba, amma ko ta yaya, ta tabbatar mana cewa ta “amince su” kuma “ta sami kwanciyar hankali kowace rana tare da su a kan aikin.” (Birx, shafi na 57)
Idan na damu da cewa ba a ɗauki kwayar cutar da mahimmanci ba, rahotannin Birx game da Bob da Tony ba za su kasance masu ƙarfafawa ba, a faɗi kaɗan.
A fili itama Birx ta ji haka. "Na ɗan yi takaicin cewa Bob da Tony ba sa ganin halin da nake ciki kamar yadda nake," in ji ta, lokacin da suka ƙi yarda da kimantawar da ta faɗa game da bazuwar asymptomatic. Amma, ta kara da cewa, "aƙalla adadinsu ya goyi bayan imanina cewa wannan sabuwar cuta ta fi mura. Ba zan tura su ba har sai na tura CDC." (Birx, shafi na 78)
Shin wanda bai yarda da kimar ku ba har ya kamata ku tura su a kan hanyar ku kuma wanda kuka "amince da kai tsaye" zai jagoranci Amurka ta cikin bala'in?
A fili, ba haka ba.
Duk da cewa ta amince da Redfield kuma tana barci da kyau da daddare ta san yana kan Task Force, Birx ba ta da komai sai kyama da suka ga CDC - kungiyar Redfield ce ke jagorantar.
"A kan gwaji mai tsanani na yi shirin samun Tom Frieden [Daraktan CDC a karkashin Obama] ya taimaka wajen kawo CDC," in ji ta. "Kamar ni, CDC tana son yin komai don dakatar da kwayar cutar, amma hukumar na bukatar yin jituwa tare da mu kan gwaji mai tsanani da kuma yada shiru." (shafi na 122) Abin da ya sa mutum ya yi mamaki: Idan tana da kusanci sosai da Redfield, shugaban CDC, me yasa Birx ta buƙaci kawo tsohuwar darekta - a ƙalubalen kai tsaye ga wanda ke zaune - don "kawo CDC tare?" Wanene "mu" idan ba Birx, Fauci da Redfield ba?
Masks wani batu ne na bayyanar gardama. Birx ta yi takaici saboda CDC, wacce ta ke jagoranta "muna-na-bayan juna" bestie, Bob Redfield (Birx, shafi na 31), ba za ta fitar da isassun jagororin rufe fuska ba. A zahiri, ta yi ta jefa kungiyar Bob a karkashin motar bas, a zahiri tana zarginsu da haddasa mutuwar Amurkawa: "Makonni da watanni masu zuwa," in ji ta, "Na yi takaici game da rayuka nawa da za a iya ceton idan CDC ta amince da jama'a don fahimtar cewa… (Birx, shafi na 86)
A bayyane yake, Fauci bai kasance a cikin abin rufe fuska ba, kamar yadda Birx ya ce "samun likitocin, gami da Tom [Frieden] da Tony, su amince da ni game da yaduwar asymptomatic ya ɗan rage fifiko. Kamar yadda yake da abin rufe fuska, na san zan iya komawa wannan batun da zarar na sami siyan su akan shawarwarinmu. " (Birx, shafi na 123)
Wanene ke ba da "shawarwarinmu" idan ba Birx, Fauci da Redfield ba?
Tatsuniyar troika
Ko ta amince da su ko a'a (kuma yana da wuya a yarda, dangane da asusun nata, cewa ta yi), a fili yana da mahimmanci ga Birx cewa ita, Fauci da Redfield sun bayyana a matsayin ƙungiya ɗaya ba tare da wani sabani ba.
Lokacin da Scott Atlas, baƙon waje ba ya san ko wane irin iko da ke faruwa akan Task Force, ya shigo, kasancewarsa a fili ya girgiza Birx (Atlas, shafi na 83-4), kuma saboda kyakkyawan dalili. Nan da nan Atlas ya lura da abubuwan ban mamaki. A cikin littafinsa, ya yi amfani da kalmomi kamar "m," "m" da "marasa hankali" don kwatanta yadda Fauci, Redfield da Birx suka kasance. Musamman ma, ba su taɓa yin tambaya ko rashin jituwa da juna ba a taron Task Force. Ba koyaushe ba.
"Sun raba tsarin tunani da ra'ayoyi ga wani uncanny matakin," Atlas ya rubuta, sannan ya sake nanata cewa "kusan babu sabani a tsakaninsu." Abin da ya gani “daidai ne mai ban mamaki, kamar an yi yarjejeniya da juna” (Atlas, shafi na 99-100) “Kusan ko da yaushe sun yarda, a zahiri ba a taɓa ƙalubalantar juna ba.” (shafi na 101) [FUSKAR FUSKA]
Matsalolin da aka amince da su? Yarjejeniya maras kyau? Dangane da duk rashin jituwar da Birx ta bayar da kuma yawan tambayarta da kuma tauye ikon Bob da Tony, ta yaya za a bayyana wannan?
Zan yi iƙirarin cewa don ɓoye girman abin da Birx kaɗai ke kula da manufofin Task Force, an tilasta wa sauran likitocin gabatar da facade na cikakkiyar yarjejeniya. In ba haka ba, kamar kowane adawa ga, ko ma tattaunawa, yuwuwar illolin manufofin kulle-kulle, "miliyoyin Amurkawa za su mutu."
An ƙarfafa wannan ƙima ta ci gaba da bacin rai da damuwa na Atlas game da yadda Task Force - musamman likitocin / masana kimiyya waɗanda ke da ƙima suna tsara manufofin bisa bayanai da bincike - aiki:
"Ban taba ganinsu suna aiki kamar masana kimiyya ba, suna shiga cikin lambobi don tabbatar da ainihin abubuwan da suka samo asali na maganganun manufofinsu. Ba su zama kamar masu bincike ba, suna amfani da tunani mai zurfi don rarraba kimiyyar da aka buga ko kuma bambanta dangantaka da wani dalili. (Atlas, shafi na 176)
Atlas ya yi mamaki, da gaske ya cika da mamaki, cewa "Babu wanda ke cikin Task Force ya gabatar da wani bayani" don tabbatar da kulle-kulle ko kuma ya saba wa shaidar cutarwar da Atlas ya gabatar. (Atlas, shafi na 206) Ƙari na musamman, ba a taɓa gabatar da bayanai ko bincike ba (sai dai ta Atlas) don sabawa ko tambayar wani abu da Birx ya faɗa. "Har sai na isa," in ji Atlas, "babu wanda ya kalubalanci duk wani abu da ta fada a cikin watanni shida da ta yi a matsayin mai kula da aikin.” (Atlas, shafi na 234) [FUSKAR FUSKA]
Atlas ba zai iya bayyana abin da yake shaida ba. "Wannan duk wani bangare ne na wuyar warwarewar likitocin Task Force," in ji shi. "Akwai karancin ilimin kimiyya a cikin tarurrukan da na halarta. Ban taba ganin suna tambayar bayanan ba. Daidaiton daidaiton ra'ayi na Birx, Redfield, Fauci, da (Brett) Giroir [tsohon Admiral da Task Force"Czarar gwaji") ba wani abu bane kamar abin da na gani a cikin aikina a likitancin ilimi. " (Atlas, shafi na 244)
Ta yaya za mu iya bayyana wuyar wuyar warwarewa na wannan ɓoyayyen ɓoyayyen ɓoyayyen ɓarna ta Task Force troika?
Methinks jami'in leken asirin kuma yana nuna rashin amincewa da yawa
Alamu mai ban sha'awa ta fito daga jerin labaran da suka ƙunshi Lawrence Wright's New Yorker labarin “Shekarar annoba.” Wright ya rubuta cewa Matt Pottinger (mai haɗin gwiwar NSC ga Birx) ya yi ƙoƙarin shawo kan membobin Task Force cewa rufe fuska na iya dakatar da kwayar cutar "matattu a cikin hanyoyinta" amma ra'ayinsa "sun tayar da martani mai ban mamaki daga sashin lafiyar jama'a." Wright ya ci gaba da bayar da rahoton cewa "A ra'ayin Pottinger, lokacin da Redfield, Fauci, Birx, da (Stephen) Hahn suka yi magana, yana iya zama kamar tunani na rukuni," yana nuna cewa waɗannan membobin "tashin lafiyar jama'a ne" waɗanda ba su yarda da ra'ayoyin masking na Pottinger ba.
Amma jira. Mun dai lura da takaicin Birx, da gaske nadama mai zurfi, cewa CDC karkashin jagorancin Redfield, da Fauci (har ma da Frieden) ba su yarda da ra'ayoyinta game da yaduwar asymptomatic da rufe fuska ba. Don haka me yasa Pottinger ke nuna cewa ita da "tashin lafiyar jama'a" na Task Force suna tunanin wannan batun a kansa?
Ina ba da shawarar cewa kawai hanyar da za a iya fahimtar waɗannan sabani a cikin labarin Birx da tsakaninta, labarun Atlas da Pottinger, shine idan muka fahimci "daidaita tare da mu" da "shawarwarmu" don komawa ba ga tsinkayyar Birx-Fauci-Redfield troika ba, amma ga Birx-Pottinger-Lab leak cabal wanda a zahiri ke gudanar da wasan kwaikwayon.
A gaskiya ma, Birx da Pottinger sun yi ƙoƙari sosai wajen dagewa a kan haɗin kai na troika, ko da ya saba wa maganganun nasu, cewa babu makawa tambaya ta taso: menene za su samu daga gare ta? Fa'idar dagewa cewa Birx yana da alaƙa da Fauci, Redfield da "kungiyar kiwon lafiyar jama'a" akan Task Force, zan yi jayayya, shine wannan yana kawar da hankali daga kawancen kiwon lafiyar jama'a na Birx-Pottinger-cabal.
Ikonta da manufofinta sun samo asali ne daga boyayyun tushe
Bayanin da Atlas ya fahimci "abin mamaki na Likitocin Task Force" wanda ya fi ma'ana a gare ni shi ne Deborah Birx, akasin haka kuma sau da yawa a adawa da sauran likitocin da ke cikin Task Force, suna wakiltar bukatun abin da nake kira da leak cabal: waɗanda ba kawai a cikin Amurka ba amma a cikin leken asirin ƙasa da ƙasa / al'umman halittu waɗanda ke buƙatar rufe matakan da za su iya lalata lambobi. duniya bata taba sani ba.
Wanene ainihin su kuma dalilin da yasa suke buƙatar kulle-kulle batutuwa ne na ci gaba da bincike.
A halin yanzu, da zarar mun raba Birx da Trump, da sauran jami'an gwamnati, da sauran masu aikin Task Force, za mu iya ganin ta a fili. mai tunani guda daya da kuma a kimiyance na banza An mai da hankali kan yaduwar shiru da gwajin asymptomatic zuwa ga manufa guda: don tsoratar da kowa da kowa cewa kulle-kulle zai zama manufa mai ma'ana. Wannan ita ce dabarar da aka yi, a ra'ayina, ba zato ba tsammani, an aiwatar da kusan har zuwa wasiƙar a kusan kowace ƙasa a duniya. Amma wannan shine labarin na gaba.
Zan rufe wannan babi na kacici-kacici na Birx wanda aka lullube da wani sirri a cikin wani abin mamaki, tare da rahoton Scott Atlas na tattaunawar rabuwarsa da Shugaba Trump:
"'Kun yi gaskiya game da komai, duk a hanya," in ji Trump ga Atlas. "'Kuma ka san me? Kai ma kana da gaskiya game da wani abu daban. Fauci ba shine babbar matsalar su ba. A gaskiya ba shi bane. Kun yi gaskiya game da hakan.' Na tsinci kaina ina yin noma yayin da na rike wayar a hannuna,” in ji Atlas. "Na san ainihin wanda yake magana akai." (Atlas, shafi na 300)
Kuma yanzu, haka mu ma.
-
Debbie Lerman, 2023 Brownstone Fellow, yana da digiri a Turanci daga Harvard. Ita marubuciyar kimiyya ce mai ritaya kuma ƙwararren mai fasaha a Philadelphia, PA.
Duba dukkan posts
