Janairu 11, 2022
Dr. Henry I. Miller
Dokta Miller:
Kafin a yi magana - in "Ƙaddamar da Ƙarfafawa na Jami'ar Stanford ga Kimiyya (Sashe na 1)"- sukar ku da suka dace game da abin da kuke kira na Stanford na "dadewa, dabi'un kimiyya," ku da kanku kun yi watsi da dabi'ar anti-kimiyya ta hanyar daukar hoto a Stanford Medical School Farfesa Jay Bhattacharya. wani hira cewa yayi wannan a watan Satumba da ya gabata tare da Wall Street JournalGerry Baker ne.
Yi la'akari da korafinku cewa Farfesa Bhattacharya ya bayyana maganin rigakafin cutar a matsayin "wanda aka yi masa yawa." Idan ka karanta hirar da kuka danganta da ita, za ku gane cewa mai tambayoyin, a cikin tambayar da “oversold” ta fara bayyana, ya ce wa Farfesa Bhattacharya (an ƙara da cewa):
Daga nan ya bayyana a zahiri, musamman tare da waɗannan bambance-bambancen COVID-19, wanda a zahiri yana nufin waɗannan allurar ba su da ingantaccen kariya daga kamuwa da cutar. Amma ina tsammanin har yanzu hujjar ta kasance kuma har yanzu tana nan, ina tsammanin shaida, kuma kun gaya mani shaidun har yanzu suna da ƙarfi sosai cewa suna da tasiri wajen kariya daga cututtuka masu tsanani.
Farfesa Bhattacharya ya yarda cewa alluran rigakafi suna da tasiri wajen rage haɗarin mummunan sakamako na covid; Ya ce game da rigakafin - kuma, a cikin ainihin hirar da kuka danganta - cewa "Yana kare kariya daga mummunan cuta da mutuwa, musamman ma mutuwar COVID." Abin da aka “yi oversold,” a cikin kiyasin Farfesa Bhattacharya, shine ikon rigakafin rigakafi. watsa. Kuma a cikin wannan al'amari Farfesa Bhattacharya yayi daidai. Ko da Daraktan CDC Rochelle Walensky ya yarda cewa allurar ba za su iya hana yaduwa ba.
Yanzu ka yi la'akari da tuhumar da kake yi cewa Farfesa Bhattacharya "ya musanta tasirin abin rufe fuska." Ga wani bangare na amsar da ya bayar ga tambayar da Mista Baker ya yi game da rufe fuska – amsar da ke da ma’ana kuma tana da tushe a kimiyya:
Idan an horar da ku kuma an gwada lafiyar ku a cikin saitunan asibiti, zai iya zama da amfani na ɗan gajeren lokaci, sa'o'i kaɗan. Amma a matakin yawan jama'a tare da mutanen da ba a horar da su don amfani da su ba, ta amfani da isassun na'urori, abin rufe fuska, abin rufe fuska na tiyata tare da gibi, N95s tare da gibi da sharar gida N95s, datti da aka sake amfani da su akai-akai. Babu wata dama ta zahiri ta yi nasara wajen rage yaduwar. Sannan kuma an yi bincike-bincike guda goma sha biyu kafin barkewar cutar a kan abin rufe fuska da mura, wanda bai sami wata shaida da ke nuna cewa a matakin yawan jama'a yana yin komai ba. Watakila ma ya kara dagula al'amura saboda tsofaffi sun shiga jama'a sanye da abin rufe fuska suna tunanin an kare su lokacin da ba haka ba. Kuma wataƙila sun ɗauki haɗari fiye da yadda ya kamata a yi yayin bala'in cutar.
A mai kyau da yawa of shaida yana goyan bayan matsayin Farfesa Bhattacharya akan masking.
Mafi girman zargin ku na kuskure, duk da haka, shine Farfesa Bhattacharya - mai yiwuwa saboda ya rubuta rubutun. Babban Sanarwa na Barrington - shine, kamar yadda kuka bayyana, "mai muryar murya, mai ba da ra'ayi mara kyau na 'bar ta rip' manufofin cutar."
Wannan tuhumar banza ce, kamar yadda za ku sani idan za ku karanta a hankali ko da hirar da kuka danganta da ita. (Ko da mafi kyau zai kasance a gare ku kuma ku karanta Babban Bayanin Barrington, da kuma sauran nau'o'in - kimiyya da mashahuri - wanda Farfesa Bhattacharya ya rubuta a cikin shekaru uku da suka gabata.) Bayanin yaudara na manufofin da aka tsara a cikin GBD a matsayin "bari ya tsage" dabarun da aka yi amfani da shi ta hanyar manufa - ko watakila rashin sani - batancin GBD ta Francis Collins da Anthony Fauci.
Farfesa Bhattacharya yayi kira don kada a bar kwayar cutar ta “rip,” amma, a maimakon haka, don Kariyar Mayar da hankali. Mai da hankali kan albarkatu, kulawa, da kulawa ga mutanen da ke da rauni yayin ƙin tsarin kulle-kullen da ba a taɓa yin irinsa ba na kulle dukkan al'ummomi yana da mahimmanci. ba dabarar "bari ta rip".
Farfesa Bhattacharya ya bayyana wannan gaskiyar a fili a cikin sauran wurare da dama. rubutun Nuwamba 2020 cewa ya rubuta tare da masu haɗin gwiwar GBD, Sunetra Gupta da Martin Kulldorff. A can sun bayyana Kariyar da aka mayar da hankali a matsayin "tsakiyar tsaka-tsaki tsakanin kulle-kulle da 'bari ta tsage'" - yana nuna cewa ba su da goyon bayan "bari ya tsage" fiye da yadda suke goyan bayan kulle-kulle.
A ƙarshe, kare ku ga hanyar kimiyya daga son zuciya mara kyau, fasfo na siyasa masu dacewa, sigina na kirki, da jahilcin gaskiya yana raunana sosai da ku da kanku da kuka faɗa kan munanan ayyukan da kuke adawa da su.
gaske,
Donald J. Boudreaux
Farfesan tattalin arziki
da kuma
Martha da Nelson Getchell Shugaban Nazari na Jari-hujja na Kasuwa Kyauta a Cibiyar Mercatus
George Mason University
Fairfax, VA 22030
Rubuta daga KafeHayek
-
Donald J. Boudreaux, Babban Malami a Cibiyar Brownstone, Farfesa ne a fannin Tattalin Arziki a Jami'ar George Mason, inda yake da alaƙa da FA Hayek Shirin FA don Advanced Study a Falsafa, Siyasa, da Tattalin Arziki a Cibiyar Mercatus. Binciken nasa ya mayar da hankali kan cinikayyar kasa da kasa da dokar hana amana. Ya rubuta a Kafe Hayak.
Duba dukkan posts
