A cikin wani littafi mai ban sha'awa da aka fitar a watan Satumba.Alurar riga kafi, Amin: Addinin Allura,1 Lauyan Haruna Siri ya bayyana yadda cibiyoyin da ya kamata su amince da su suka yaudari jama'ar Amurka.
Ta hanyar shari'o'i da yawa, Haruna ya kawo mutane da yawa binnewa, abubuwan da ba su dace da siyasa ba, kuma yana da gaskiya sosai, wanda ba a saba gani ba ga littattafan rigakafin. Yawancin lokaci suna da motsin rai kuma suna da matukar mahimmanci ga alluran rigakafi, ko kuma suna da inganci sosai, tare da ɗan tsakani, wanda shine inda gaskiyar take.
Ba za a iya kima da kimar lauyoyi ba. Babu wani abu mai zafi kamar gaskiya game da kiwon lafiya,2 shi ya sa muke matukar bukatar lauyoyi su tono shi. Lokacin da mai binciken manufofin miyagun ƙwayoyi Alan Cassels ya sake duba littafina na 2025, Yadda Merck da Masu Gudanar da Magunguna suka Ɓoye Mugun Illa na Alurar rigakafin HPV,3 ya kammala da cewa "Idan kuna son gaskiyar gaskiya game da kwayoyi, kar ku tambayi likitoci - ku tambayi lauyoyi."4
Wani magana a murfin littafina daga Martin Kulldorff, shugaban Kwamitin Ba da Shawarwari kan Ayyukan rigakafi (ACIP) na Cibiyar Kula da Cututtuka da Cututtuka ta Amurka (CDC): "Magungunan kwayoyi da alluran rigakafi na iya warkarwa da ceton rayuka, amma kuma suna cutar da su.
Yana da mahimmanci don fahimtar wannan. Mun san kadan game da illolin alluran rigakafin saboda yawancin bayanan sun fito ne daga gwaje-gwaje marasa inganci da nagartattun gwaje-gwajen da kamfanonin magunguna ke yi, wanda ke barin muhimman abubuwan da ba su dace ba daga littattafansu.3,5,6 kuma a guji, ba tare da keɓanta ba, don kwatanta allurar su da placebo.
A matsayina na ƙwararriyar shaida a cikin ƙarar da ake yi wa Merck, na karanta shafuka 112,452 na rahotannin bincike na sirri kuma na gano abubuwa da yawa na rashin da'a na kimiyya wanda hukumomin magunguna ke da hannu a ciki. Ya bayyana cewa Gardasil, maganin rigakafi na HPV, yana haifar da mummunar cutar da jijiya, wanda masu kula da magunguna suka musanta.
Haruna ya bayyana tun daga farko dalilin da yasa alluran rigakafi suke sacrosanct. Mutane ba su taba cewa sun yi imani da motoci ba amma da yawa sun ce sun yi imani da alluran rigakafi, ba tare da samun bayanan da ake buƙata don samar da ingantaccen ra'ayi ba. Na sami haka lokacin da na yi nazari BMJ labarai game da gyare-gyaren rigakafin da ake buƙata na Kennedy; ya kasance game da bangaskiya, ba game da kimiyya ba.2
Haruna ya yi amfani da kararraki don nuna cewa masu maganin alurar riga kafi suna da tsarin gaskatawa na ƙarfafa kai wanda akidarsa ba ta tsayawa a bincika a kotu. Daukar da ya yi na Stanley Plotkin, “babban firist” na alluran rigakafi, a lokacin da aka ba da izini babban abin alfahari ne wajen fallasa cewa sarki ba shi da tufafi lokacin da yake iƙirarin cewa allurar rigakafin yara ba su da lafiya kuma an gwada su a hankali.
Plotkin ya kasa fahimtar dalilin da ya sa yake samu na daruruwan miliyoyin daloli daga sarauta da kuma kusancinsa da muradun masana'antar na iya yin tasiri kan ra'ayinsa kan alluran rigakafin. Bai san cewa sa ido kan tsaro a wasu gwaje-gwajen ba ya wuce kwanaki 4-5 bayan alurar riga kafi, wanda ke da gajeriyar hanya don kama abubuwan da ba su dace ba. Mafi muni, Plotkin ya bayyana cewa wasu alluran rigakafi ba sa haifar da wasu lahani, ko kuma ya bayyana cewa ba su da yawa, ba tare da samun wata shaida da ke goyon bayan tunaninsa ba.
A cikin 1986, masana'antun sun sami kusan cikakkiyar rigakafi daga alhaki don raunin da alluran rigakafi suka haifar. Wannan yana nufin ba su da wani abin ƙarfafawa don tabbatar da cewa alluran sun kasance lafiya kafin a kawo su kasuwa. Mutane na iya shigar da kara kan Ma'aikatar Lafiya da Ayyukan Dan Adam (HHS), wanda saboda haka ba shi da sha'awar samun ko ɗaya daga cikin hukumominta, ciki har da CDC da Hukumar Abinci da Magunguna (FDA), buga nazarin da ke nuna cutarwar rigakafin - cikakkiyar tsari ga masana'antu.
Ana buƙatar HHS ta mika wa Majalisa rahotannin aminci na rigakafin rigakafin shekaru biyu amma wata ƙara da aka yi ta nuna cewa ba ta aika da rahoto ɗaya ba cikin shekaru 30.
Hakanan ana buƙatar HHS ta ba da shawarwari don inganta amincin rigakafin, amma bayan rahoto guda shekaru da yawa da suka gabata, abin da kawai ta yi shi ne rushe ƙungiyar da ke da alhakin wannan. Kungiyar Haruna ta kuma gano, bayan sun koka a kotu game da sakewa a cikin imel, cewa CDC tana da kyakkyawar alaƙa da Big Pharma kuma ta tsara manufofi game da amincin rigakafin tare da kamfanonin yayin da suka ƙi yin aiki tare da ƙungiyoyin 'yan ƙasa da suka damu da aminci.
Alurar riga kafi sun ceci miliyoyin rayuka. An kiyasta cewa cutar sankarau ta kashe kusan mutane miliyan 500 a cikin shekaru 100 da suka gabata na wanzuwarta kuma rigakafin ya kawar da cutar.5 Koyaya, masu kishin rigakafin sun yi iƙirarin cewa kuma a halin yanzu, alluran rigakafin sun ceci miliyoyin rayuka a Yammacin duniya, wanda ba gaskiya ba ne. Haruna ya nuna cewa an sami raguwar mace-mace masu saurin yaduwa tsakanin 1900 da bullo da alluran rigakafin zamani, wanda ya fara da maganin diphtheria, tetanus, da pertussis (DTP) a shekara ta 1949. A cikin shekarar da ta gabaci gabatar da kowace allurar rigakafin yara 12, kusan mutane 5,000 ne kawai suka mutu daga wadannan cututtuka a Amurka, wanda hakan ke nufin cewa dole ne a hade rai kadan.
Farashin DTP
Alurar rigakafin DTP ita ce maganin da aka fi amfani da shi a duniya, amma Peter Aaby da wasu masu binciken Danish sun gano a cikin bincike da yawa cewa allurar ta kara yawan mace-mace a Guinea-Bissau. Lokacin da Haruna ya tambayi UNICEF ko suna da shaidar cewa akasin haka gaskiya ne, sun yi nuni ga rahoton WHO na 2014 wanda bai cika ba. Abin mamaki, ba su yi magana kan binciken Aaby na 2017 ba, wanda aka yi don magance matsalolin da WHO ta taso a 2014 game da karatun da ya gabata.
A cikin 2019, Haruna ya nemi in sake nazarin binciken, wanda ya bayyana.5,7 Aaby ya gano cewa maganin rigakafin DTP ya ninka mace-mace duk da cewa duk ra'ayoyin da ya rubuta a cikin binciken sa na lura ya fi son rukunin da aka yi wa allurar. Ya kuma gano cewa, duk wani binciken da ya yi nazarin bayanan da ake da su da aka tattara don wasu dalilai sun sha fama da ɓacin rai wanda ya haifar da rashin la’akari da illolin.
Na yi la'akari da binciken Aaby ya fi gamsarwa fiye da rahoton na WHO, wanda ke da manyan batutuwa. Ba a ƙyale marubutan su yi nazarin nazarin binciken ba, wataƙila saboda WHO ba ta son yin haɗarin karɓar bita na tsari wanda ke ba da shawarar cewa rigakafin DTP yana ƙara yawan mace-mace. Haka kuma, yadda kwararrun WHO suka gudanar da bayanan bai dace ba kuma bai dace ba a kimiyyance.
Ko da yake biyu daga cikin mawallafa uku na rahoton na WHO sun kasance manyan masu bincike a cikin Cochrane Collaboration, edita-in-chief Karla Soares-Weiser da statistician Julian Higgins, editan mai shafi 636. Littafin Jagora na Cochrane, wanda ya bayyana yadda za a yi amintacce sake dubawa na tsarin, sun yi amfani da ƙidayar kuri'a (nau'i nawa ne kuma nawa akasin?), Wannan hanya ce da aka ba da shawarar a cikin Littafin Jagora na Cochrane. Da gaske abin ban mamaki ne.
Aaby ya sake buga wani binciken a cikin 2018 wanda ni ma nayi sharhi wanda kuma ya nuna karuwar mace-mace. Har ila yau, UNICEF ba ta yi komai ba sai imel da aka yi musanyar da su tare da CDC sun nuna cewa hukumomin biyu sun damu da guje wa fallasa kansu ba game da ko allurar rigakafi na iya kashe yara ba. Ma'aunin nasara a fagen rigakafin ba rayuwa ko lafiyar yara ba ne amma ɗaukar rigakafin.
Taimakawa Labarin Ƙarya ta hanyar yaudara da Ƙarya
Haruna ya ba da wasu misalan don nuna cewa cibiyoyinmu sun fi mai da hankali ga tallafa wa hukuma, labaran ƙarya fiye da ba da bayanai na gaskiya. Lokacin da bincike ya nuna cewa alluran rigakafin suna kara mutuwa, ana ganin ba za a iya dogaro da su ba, amma idan irin wannan binciken ya nuna cewa allurar tana rage mutuwa, abin dogaro ne. A lokacin Covid-19, an danganta raguwar mace-mace ga alluran rigakafi, amma lokacin da mace-mace ta karu duk da ci gaba da rigakafin, hukumomi sun cire bayanan daga idon jama'a. Wannan kuma ya faru lokacin da ya bayyana cewa yawan allurai da mutane suka karɓa, mafi girman haɗarin kamuwa da cutar ta Covid.
Kamfanonin magunguna da hukumomi sun yi ƙarya akai-akai ta hanyar iƙirarin cewa wasu alluran rigakafi, misali, na Covid, na iya hana yaduwa. GlaxoSmithKline ma yayi ƙoƙarin siyar da ƙarin alluran rigakafi ta hanyar ƙarfafa tsofaffi don yin rigakafin cutar tari don kare jikoki, amma maganin tari ba ya hana kamuwa da cuta ko yadawa. Kamfanin Haruna ya yi nasarar gurfanar da GSK a kan tallan da ya yi na karya.
Cewa mafi yawan allurar rigakafin yara kan kasa hana watsawa ya sa ya zama abin ƙyama musamman ba da izinin waɗancan rigakafin a matsayin yanayin shiga makaranta, amma duk jihohin Amurka sun ba da umarnin allurar rigakafin shiga makarantu. Hatta maganin rigakafi na HPV an ba da izini a Amurka, kodayake cutar ana daukar ta ta hanyar jima'i, wanda da fatan ba ya faruwa a cikin aji. Haruna ya yi jayayya cewa yayin da samfurin ke buƙatar tilastawa, yawancin ya kamata ya damu da wannan samfurin.
A Amurka, jarirai suna yin allurar rigakafin cutar hanta ta B a ranar farko ta rayuwa, kodayake wannan cutar yawanci jima'i ne ko masu amfani da kwayoyi ke yada allura. FDA ta amince da maganin alurar riga kafi bisa nazarin yara 147 da aka kula da su na tsawon kwanaki 5 bayan rigakafin, kuma ba tare da ƙungiyar kulawa ba.
Lokacin da Haruna ya aika da bukatar doka ga HHS game da dalilin da ya sa gwajin asibiti don rigakafin yara bai haɗa da ƙungiyar kula da placebo ba, hukumar ta yi ƙarya: "An bincika yawancin allurar rigakafin yara a gwaje-gwajen asibiti waɗanda suka haɗa da placebo." Ba a yi nazarin allurar rigakafin yara guda ɗaya akan jadawalin yau da kullun na CDC ba a cikin gwaje-gwajen da ake sarrafa wuribo kafin lasisi, amma a cikin takaddamar jama'a da Haruna, sanannen almajirin Plotkin, Paul Offit, ya yi iƙirarin cewa ana gwada duk allurar rigakafin a irin waɗannan gwaje-gwaje kafin lasisi. Har ma ya yi jayayya cewa zai zama zalunci idan aka yi amfani da maganin placebo, don haka, idan muka yarda da bayaninsa, suna nufin cewa shi, Plotkin, da abokan aikinsu suna da zalunci.
Kamar yadda Haruna ya yi bayani da hankali, a cikin gwajin da ake sarrafa wuribo, ana barin yara ba a yi musu alluran rigakafi ba na tsawon lokacin gwajin. Sabanin haka, allurar rigakafin ga miliyoyin yara a cikin yanayin da ba a kula da shi ba tare da fara tantance amincin sa a cikin gwajin da ake sarrafa placebo ba, ga kowane manufa, mai lura da hankali, mummunar ɗabi'a. Ana amfani da allurar rigakafin yara ga yara masu lafiya don amfana kaɗan. Don haka abubuwan da ake buƙata don rigakafin ya kamata su kasance mafi girma fiye da na sauran magunguna, amma kusan babu. Wannan na iya zama mafi munin rashin kulawa da muke da shi a duk fannin kiwon lafiya.
Offit ya yi ikirarin karya cewa yara 16 sun mutu a gwajin cutar shan inna kan “placebo” kamar yadda ya kira ta amma ba placebo ba kuma adadin na gaskiya ya kasance 4.
Haruna ya rubuta cewa ana kwatanta sabbin alluran rigakafin cutar guda da tsofaffin alurar riga kafi, kuma idan abubuwan da suka faru iri ɗaya ne, an kammala cewa duka biyun suna da lafiya. Wannan yana kama da cewa sigari yana da lafiya saboda yana haifar da lahani iri ɗaya kamar sigari. A bushe-bushe ya furta cewa "Wannan ba wani abu ba ne da na taɓa tunanin in yi mafarki," kuma yana riƙe da abin da ake kira masu binciken gaskiya ga wuta. Sun yi imanin cewa da'awar cewa ba a ba da lasisin allurar rigakafin yara na yau da kullun ba bisa gwajin da ake sarrafa placebo karya ne amma ba su damu ba don bincika gaskiyar a tushen farko kamar takaddun FDA na jama'a.
Labari na CNN daga Yuni 2025 yana da "mai ban sha'awa musamman." Ya jera bincike 258 a lokacin (yanzu ya lissafa sama da 1,000) kuma Dokta Jake Scott daga Jami’ar Stanford ya yi iƙirarin cewa 153 sun gwada alluran rigakafi daga placebos. Amma, kamar yadda Sakatare Kennedy ya bayyana a cikin martanin da ya mayar, babu ɗayan waɗannan binciken da ya haɗa da placebo ko kuma FDA ta dogara da ita don yin lasisin rigakafi akan tsarin CDC na yau da kullun na yara.
Moderna ya watsar da ci gaban rigakafinta na RSV bayan gwaje-gwajen da aka sarrafa na placebo ya nuna ƙarin cututtukan cututtukan numfashi a cikin ƙungiyoyin rigakafin.8 Akwai matsaloli a baya. Wani gwajin rigakafin RSV a cikin 1960s ya aika da kashi 80 cikin 100 na yaran da aka yiwa rigakafin zuwa asibiti kuma biyu sun mutu. A bayyane yake, maganin ya haɓaka tsarin garkuwar jikinsu ta yadda yayin kamuwa da cuta, amsawar ƙwayoyin T cell ɗin ba su da kyau kuma an samar da matakan rigakafi masu yawa waɗanda ba su da tasiri, waɗanda ke haifar da hadarurruka masu toshe hanyoyin iska.
Alurar rigakafin dengue, da aka yi amfani da ita a cikin wurare masu zafi, wani misali ne na dalilin da ya sa ba za mu iya ɗaukan allurar rigakafi ba.5 Ya yi aiki da kyau ga yaran da suka riga sun kamu da cutar, amma a cikin sauran yara, ya ƙara haɗarin kamuwa da cuta mai tsanani, wanda zai iya zama m. An bayyana hakan ne kawai saboda ana sarrafa gwajin wuribo kuma saboda ana kula da aminci har tsawon shekaru biyar.
Haruna ya bayyana yadda kusan dukkanin munanan abubuwan da suka faru a cikin gwaje-gwajen rigakafi ba tare da kula da placebo ba masu bincike kan biyan albashin kamfanonin magunguna ba su da alaƙa da maganin, wanda ba za su iya sani ba, saboda ba su san abin da ke cutar da sabon allurar rigakafi ba. Irin wannan yaudara ya zama ruwan dare a cikin gwaji na Gardasil na Merck.3
Haruna ya yi ƙaulin wata wasiƙa da ta yi nuni da wasu bincike da ke danganta alluran rigakafi da Autism, waɗanda na ke da ra'ayi game da abin da ba zan tattauna a nan ba, saboda wannan batu yana buƙatar tsattsauran bita na binciken. Amma na yi watsi da sanannen ra'ayin a cikin da'irar rigakafin rigakafin cewa CDC ta yi wani abu ba daidai ba a cikin binciken inda ba su sami wata alaƙa da allurar MMR ba; Na bayyana dalilin da ya sa Andrew Wakefield ya janye binciken a cikin Lancet ya kasance mai zamba, a kan abubuwa da yawa;5 kuma na buga maganganu masu mahimmanci akan ɗayan binciken autism.9,10
Babu shakka, yana da mahimmanci a yi bincike mai inganci akan wannan batu. Ko da yake da yawa daga cikin haɓakar cututtukan cututtukan Autism na wucin gadi ne, wanda ke haifar da raguwar mashaya don yin ganewar asali da kuma ƙarin kulawa, hakanan gaskiya ne. lokuta na zurfin Autism sun karu.11
Ba za a iya jayayya cewa alluran rigakafi na iya haifar da mummuna, wani lokacin m, cutarwa,1,3,5,8,12 wanda aka tabbatar a cikin rahotanni daga Cibiyar Magunguna.1 Duk da haka, cibiyoyinmu sun gaza mu da kyau, kuma nazari na yau da kullun daga 2014 na Hukumar Bincike da Inganta Lafiya shine kyakkyawan misali na wannan.13
Binciken ya kasance game da amincin rigakafin amma ainihin makasudin shine a ƙara yawan allurar rigakafi: "ƙaramar adadin rigakafin yana da matukar mahimmanci," wanda ba daidai ba ne don nazarin illolin rigakafin. Bugu da ƙari, marubutan sun bayyana cewa dole ne sababbin alluran rigakafi su fuskanci matakai masu tsauri kafin samun amincewa kuma sun cika "ma'auni masu mahimmanci don aminci," wanda ba daidai ba ne cewa yana kama da takarda na farfaganda daga kamfanin magunguna.
Haruna ya bayyana yadda wannan babban bita ya kasance (shafukan 740). Kusan duk binciken da aka haɗa da kamfanonin magunguna ne ko kuma mutanen da suka ba da kuɗi ne suka gudanar da su, kuma ikirari da hukumar ta yi na cewa suna da ƙungiyar da ba a yi musu alluran rigakafi ba daidai ba ne, domin mutane ma sun sami alluran rigakafin a cikin rukunin.
Ƙarin Dabarar Datti ta CDC da FDA
A cikin 2013, HHS ta umurci Cibiyar Nazarin Magunguna don sake duba lafiyar jadawalin yara na CDC ciki har da faruwar asma, cututtuka na autoimmune, autism, da sauran cututtuka na ci gaban neurodevelopmental. Cibiyar ba ta iya samun binciken ko daya da ya kwatanta sakamakon lafiya a cikin yaran da aka yi wa alurar riga kafi da wadanda ke cikin yaran da ba su samu wani alluran rigakafi ba. Sun bayyana ra'ayinsu a cikin ƙarshe, wanda ba shi da kyau: "Babu wata shaida cewa jadawalin ba shi da aminci." Na gani. Don haka, idan ba a taɓa gwada birki a cikin sabon ƙirar mota ba, ƙarshe mai ƙarfafawa zai kasance: “Babu wata shaida cewa birkin baya aiki.”
Cibiyar ta tabbatar da cewa, za a iya kwatanta wadanda aka yi musu allurar da yaran da ba a yi musu allurar ba ta hanyar amfani da rumbun adana bayanai irin su Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD) da CDC ta kafa.
Zai kasance da sauƙi CDC ta yi irin wannan binciken amma ba su taɓa yin ba, ko aƙalla ba su taɓa buga shi ba, idan sun yi ɗaya amma ba sa son sakamakon. Maimakon haka, sun ba da rahoto mai shafi 64 game da yadda ya kamata a yi irin wannan nazari.
Lokacin da masana kimiyya da ke amfani da VSD suka gano cewa alluran rigakafi suna haifar da lahani iri-iri, CDC ta matsar da bayanan zuwa ƙungiyar kasuwanci ta masana'antar kiwon lafiya don guje wa buƙatun Dokar 'Yancin Bayanai da kuma tabbatar da cewa binciken da ya amince da shi ya tabbatar da cewa alluran rigakafi ba su da lafiya.
Zai zama da sauƙi a bayyana bayanan sirri da kuma sanya bayanan a bainar jama’a amma, kamar yadda Haruna ya ce, “ba haka addinin ke aiki ba.”
Yana da matukar nauyi a ba da rahoton abubuwan da ba su da kyau ga bayanan da ake da su (VAERS) kuma an ba da rahoton ƙasa da 1%. Lokacin da masu binciken Harvard suka ɓullo da tsarin bayar da rahoto kai tsaye, wanda kuma zai samar da adadi - adadin mutanen da aka yi wa alurar riga kafi - CDC ta kashe aikin duk da cewa wata hukumar 'yar'uwar CDC ta ba da kuɗi, kuma CDC ta ƙi yin magana da masu binciken.
Lokacin da CDC ta yi wani bincike wanda ya bayyana manyan alamun aminci ga allurar rigakafin Covid-19, idan aka kwatanta da sauran alluran rigakafi (ta amfani da ma'auni na rahotanni), sun yi ƙarya game da shi. Kamfanin Haruna ya nemi bayanan, amma CDC ta ce ba su yi binciken da suka shirya yi ba. Sai bayan matsin lamba daga Sanata Ron Johnson (R-WI) ne CDC ta yarda cewa suna da bayanan.
Kamfanin Haruna ya kai karar CDC don samun bayanan, wanda ya nuna cewa CDC na kansa bakin kofa don haifar da siginar aminci an busa shi don yawancin munanan abubuwan da suka faru, gami da abubuwan da suka faru na zuciya, cututtukan kumburin tsarin multisystem, da mutuwa.
Bari in yi bayani, a sarari da sauƙi: CDC ta damfari jama'ar Amurka. Kuma lokacin da suka ƙaddamar da kayan aikin wayar hannu, V-lafiya, wanda jama'a za su iya amfani da su don ba da rahoton illar rigakafin Covid, sun kuma yaudari mutane zuwa ga abin da ba za a iya yarda da su ba. Akwai alamomi guda 10 da aka lissafa waɗanda suka faru a cikin makon farko bayan alurar riga kafi, waɗanda suka saba faruwa da alluran rigakafi. CDC ba ta haɗa da sanannun ko lahani na rigakafin Covid a cikin jerin abubuwan dubawa, gami da myocarditis da bugun jini, wanda, a gani na, rashin ɗa'a na kimiyya ne.
Jama'a na iya ba da rahoton tasirin tasirin lafiyar mako-mako na makonni 6 na farko, da kuma bayan watanni 3, 6, da 12. CDC ta buga sama da karatun 40 dangane da V-lafiya amma a cikin su duka, bayanan tasirin lafiyar su ne kawai waɗanda aka ruwaito a cikin makon farko bayan alurar riga kafi. Wannan ma zamba ne. CDC ta kuma yi iƙirarin cewa bai kamata a fitar da bayanan rubutu na kyauta ba saboda suna ɗauke da bayanan sirri masu kariya. Wannan hujja ce mara inganci, saboda ana iya ɓoye bayanan.
Bayan fiye da shekaru biyu na buƙatun doka da shari'ar tarayya, Haruna ya kama bayanan da suka ɓace. Sun nuna cewa kashi 8% na masu amfani da V-aminci suna buƙatar kulawar likita bayan rigakafin, a matsakaicin sau 2-3, kuma 75% sune kulawar gaggawa, dakin gaggawa, ko asibiti. Ƙarin 25% ya ba da rahoton ɓacewar makaranta ko aiki ko rashin iya yin ayyukan yau da kullun.
Ba za mu iya ma aminta da gwaje-gwajen da bazuwar ba, saboda su ma ba su la'akari da illar rigakafin ba.3,5,6 Lokacin da matata ta sami maganin rigakafin AstraZeneca Covid, ta kamu da rashin lafiya mai tsanani, tare da rashin barci, zazzabi, ciwon kai mai tsanani, ciwon tsoka, tashin zuciya, juwa, da rashin ci.6 Ta bukaci kwana hudu ta zauna a gida daga aiki. A rana ta uku, an yi mata sannu a hankali ta yadda ba mu taɓa samun irinsa ba. Abokan aikin 13 na farko a sashin asibitinta (ita ce farfesa a fannin ilimin halittar jiki) suma sun kamu da rashin lafiya daga allurar har suna buƙatar hutun rashin lafiya. Ta hanyar ma'anar, lokacin da ba za ku iya aiki ba, yana da mummunar tasiri. Don haka, 100% a cikin sashinta yana da mummunan tasiri da maganin alurar riga kafi ya haifar, amma a cikin rahoton gwaji na AstraZeneca a cikin Lancet, kawai 1% sun sami mummunan sakamako.14
Ban taɓa ganin bambanci mai girma irin wannan ba tsakanin abin da kamfani ke bugawa da abin da mutane ke fuskanta. Ya zuwa yanzu akasarin wadanda aka yiwa alurar riga kafi 35 a sashenta suma sun kamu da rashin lafiya har suna bukatar hutun rashin lafiya.
FDA kuma tana zaluntar jama'ar Amurka. Lokacin da Haruna ya yi ƙoƙarin samun bayanai kan cutarwar rigakafin Covid daga FDA (bayanan Bayesian na zahiri), hukumar ta ƙi ba da su, tana mai da'awar ƙarancin albarkatu. Kararsa na tarayya ya zuwa yanzu kusan shekaru uku "ba tare da ƙarewa ba yayin da FDA ke yaƙi kamar jahannama don ɓoye bayanan."
FDA ta lalace sosai15,16 wanda na kira shi Amincewa da Magungunan Kisa. Idan FDA ta kare 'yan ƙasa maimakon masana'antar magunguna, magungunan mu ba zai zama babban dalilin mutuwa ba, gaba da cututtukan zuciya da ciwon daji.17
Ina kuma kiran FDA da Hukumar Jawo Ƙafar. Lokacin da ƙungiyar masana kimiyya suka nemi FDA a cikin 2021 don samar da bayanan da Pfizer ya gabatar don rigakafin Covid, FDA na son amincewar kotu don samun sama da 75. shekaru don bayyana wannan bayanin a bainar jama'a a cikin saurin shafuka 500 a wata.18,19 Haruna ya kai karar FDA kuma alkali ya ba da umarnin a fitar da takardun.
Ko da bayan an umarce shi da ya samar da komai ta hanyar kotun tarayya, FDA ta riƙe bayanan da ke da alaƙa kai tsaye da izinin amfani da gaggawa na maganin Pfizer, wanda aka kiyasta kusan shafuka miliyan ɗaya.19 Haruna ya lura cewa “Waɗanda suka damu da gaskiya kaɗai suke neman ɓoye shaida.”
Nazarin Henry Ford
Filmmaker Del Bigtree ya kafa Informed Consent Action Network (ICAN), wanda ta hanyar gudummawa ya ba wa Haruna damar ƙaddamar da ƙararraki da yawa game da gaskiya da haƙƙoƙin da suka shafi alluran rigakafi. Bigtree ya shawo kan Dokta Marcus Zervos cewa ya kamata ya yi nazarin da CDC ba ta taba yi ba, kwatanta wadanda aka yi wa alurar riga kafi tare da yara marasa rigakafi. Zervos yana aiki a Henry Ford Health wanda ke da bayanan da ake buƙata don irin wannan binciken a shirye.
Manufar binciken ita ce kawar da alluran rigakafi a matsayin dalilin da zai haifar da rashin lafiya na dogon lokaci don tabbatar da lafiyar iyaye gaba ɗaya na rigakafin. Sa’ad da Haruna ya ce a buga binciken ko da menene sakamakon ya nuna, Zervos “ya dubi idanunmu sosai kuma ya tabbatar mana cewa shi mutum ne mai aminci kuma zai buga sakamakon, duk abin da aka samu.”
Haruna ya karbi rahoton binciken a farkon 2020. Sakamakon ya kasance daidai da na sauran nazarin da ke da ƙungiyar kulawa da ba a yi ba. Lokacin da ya tambayi marubucin Zervos, Lois Lamerato, dalilin da ya sa ba su gabatar da shi don bugawa ba, ta amsa cewa manyan masu girma a Henry Ford ba sa son a buga shi.
Duk marubutan biyu sun yi tsammanin binciken nasu ya yi kyau, amma Zervos ya bayyana wa Bigtree - wanda ya yi fim tare da kyamarar ɓoye don kyakkyawan shirinsa na gaskiya, Nazari mara dadi,20 cewa baya son rasa aikinsa.
Bayan Haruna ya wallafa littafinsa, rahoton binciken Henry Ford ya fito fili a ranar 9 ga Satumba 2025 yayin sauraron sauraron karar da Majalisar Dattawa ta yi kan "Lalacewar Kimiyya."22 Na yi bayani23 cewa ka'ida ta asali a cikin magungunan shaida shine ya kamata mu yi amfani da mafi kyawun shaida idan muka yanke shawara, kuma kamar yadda binciken Henry Ford shine kawai wanda aka kwatanta da marasa lafiya tare da yara da aka yi wa alurar riga kafi don ci gaba da cututtuka masu tsanani kuma wanda ya yi la'akari da rikice-rikice, yana da matukar muhimmanci mu bincika wannan binciken a hankali don ingancinsa.
Na yi haka,23 wanda ba zan sake maimaitawa a nan ba, kuma akwai amsoshi masu taimako ga sukar binciken a shafin farko na fim ɗin.20 Batun ƙasa shine cewa binciken yana sama da matsakaicin inganci. Marubutan sun yi mamakin sakamakonsu da gaske kuma sun yi nazarin hankali don gwada ƙarfinsu. Sun kuma ba da tattaunawa mai ban sha'awa game da batutuwan da za su iya bayyana abubuwan da suka gano, wanda suka sanya a cikin mahallin. Wannan shine abin da muke kira kimiyya mai kyau.
Yaran da aka yi wa alurar riga kafi suna da adadin "kowace cuta mai tsanani" sau 2.5 idan aka kwatanta da yaran da ba a yi musu rigakafi ba. Haɗarin ya ninka sau huɗu don cutar asma, sau uku mafi girma ga yanayin apiczema kamar eczema da zazzabin hay, kuma sau biyar zuwa shida mafi girma ga cututtukan autoimmune da neurodevelopmental. Ana sa ran wannan don cutarwar rigakafin. Masu binciken sun rubuta cewa cututtukan yara sun bayyana suna ba da kariya mai mahimmanci daga atopy.
Na rubuta sau biyu zuwa Zervos da Lamerato tare da lura cewa ina da wasu bayanan da ke goyan bayan binciken su kuma suna kira gare su da su fito fili su zama wani ɓangare na tarihi. Basu amsa ba. Sun gwammace su kare kansu maimakon miliyoyin yaran da alluran rigakafi ke cutar da su. Ba ni da tausayi ga irin wannan halin matsorata kuma an lura a cikin labarina23 cewa suna da hakki na ɗabi'a don fitar da bayanansu ta hanyar da ba a sani ba akan ingantaccen dandamali don ba da damar sauran masu bincike suyi aiki tare da su don amfanin gama gari.
karshe
Haruna ya yi kashedin cewa “Tarihi ba zai yi kyau ga ɓatattun jami’ai da mutanen da ke neman korar yara daga makaranta, korar mutane daga aiki, da kuma hukunta mutane don ƙin wani magani.” A saman wannan, ba a gwada samfuran da kyau don aminci ba! Wannan kamar tuƙin mota ne ba tare da sanin ko birki ya yi kyau ba.
Har ila yau, Haruna ya lura cewa, lokacin da ba za su iya shawo kan abin da ya dace ba, azzalumai suna shiga cikin tilastawa, tantancewa, umarni, da azabtarwa, wanda ke zubar da mutane. Abin baƙin ciki, zan buƙaci yarda cewa a nan ne Amurka, kuma aƙalla, Turai, take a yau dangane da alluran rigakafi.
Dole ne wannan ya canza sosai. Don haka muna bukatar mu goyi bayan Kennedy gwargwadon iyawarmu, kasancewar shi ne jagoran gyare-gyaren da muke bukata.
References
- Siri A. Vaccines, Amin. Addinin Alurar riga kafi. Injecting Freedom LLC; 2025.
- Gøtzsche PC. Rubutun BMJ na Gyaran Alurar rigakafin Kennedy Yakai Kisan Hali. J Acad Publ Lafiya 2025; Nuwamba 10.
- Gøtzsche PC. Yadda Merck da masu kula da magunguna suka ɓoye munanan lahani na rigakafin HPV. New York: Skyhorse; 2025.
- Cassels A. Dauntless Daunt Yana Bayyana Bangaran Duhun Alurar rigakafin HPV. Jaridar Brownstone 2025; Satumba 1.
- Gøtzsche PC. Alurar rigakafi: gaskiya, karya, da jayayya. New York: Skyhorse; 2021.
- Gøtzsche PC. Kwayar cutar ta Sin: ta kashe miliyoyin da 'yancin kimiyya. Copenhagen: Cibiyar 'Yancin Kimiyya; 2022.
- Gøtzsche PC. Tasirin allurar rigakafin DTP akan mace-mace a cikin yara a cikin ƙasashe masu karamin karfi. Rahoton Masana 2019; Yuni 19.
- Cohen J. 'Siginar aminci' a cikin binciken rigakafin RSV na Moderna ya dakatar da gwajin wasu alluran rigakafin kashe yara. Kimiyya 2024; Dec 13.
- Gøtzsche PC. Bude Peer Review na: Alurar riga kafi da rashin lafiyar ci gaba: nazarin yara masu shekaru tara da suka shiga Medicaid. J Acad Publ Lafiya 2025; Maris 3.
- Gøtzsche PC. Marubuta sun kasa magance zargi na da gabatar da sabbin kurakurai. J Acad Publ Lafiya 2025; Maris 3.
- Hughes MM, Shaw KA, DiRienzo M, et al. Yawaitu da Halayen Yara masu Ciwon Autism, Shafukan 15, Amurka, 2000-2016. Wakilin Kiwon Lafiyar Jama'a 2023;138:971-80.
- Gøtzsche PC, Demasi M. Mummunan illar rigakafin COVID-19: bita na tsari. Copenhagen: Cibiyar 'Yancin Kimiyyar Kimiyya 2023; Maris 22.
- Maglione MA, Gidengil C, Das L, et al. Tsaron Alurar riga kafi da ake amfani da su don rigakafin yau da kullun a Amurka. Rockville (MD): Hukumar Bincike da Ingancin Lafiya (US) 2014; Yuli. (Rahoton Shaida / Ƙididdigar Fasaha, Lamba 215.)
- Voysey M, Clemens SAC, Madhi SA, et al. Aminci da ingancin maganin ChAdOx1 nCoV-19 (AZD1222) akan SARS-CoV-2: nazarin wucin gadi na gwaje-gwajen da bazuwar sarrafawa guda huɗu a Brazil, Afirka ta Kudu, da Burtaniya. Lancet 2021; 397: 99-111.
- Brownlee S, Lenzer J. Kimiyya Na Siyarwa: Yadda Masu Magungunan Magunguna Suka Kama FDA. Lever 2025; Nuwamba 7.
- Gøtzsche PC. Magunguna masu mutuwa da laifukan da aka tsara: Yaya babban pharma ya lalata tsarin kiwon lafiya. London: Radcliffe Publishing; 2013.
- Gøtzsche PC. Magungunan magani sune kan gaba wajen mutuwa. Kuma magungunan tabin hankali sune na ukun da ke haddasa mutuwa. Jaridar Brownstone 2024; Afrilu 16.
- Siri A. Me ya sa wani Alkali ya umarci FDA da ta saki bayanan Covid-19 Pronto. Dokar Bloomberg 2022; Janairu 18.
- Demasi M. FDA ta yaudari bangaren shari'a game da takaddun rigakafin Pfizer. Shekarar 2024; Dec 13.
- Bigtree D. Nazarin mara dadi. Documentary fim 2025; Oktoba 12.
- Lamerato L, Chatfield A, Tang A, Zervos M. Rubutun da ba a buga ba. Tasirin Alurar Yara kan Gajeru da Sakamako na Lafiya na Tsawon Lokaci a Yara: Nazarin Ƙungiyar Haihuwa. Tsarin Lafiya na Henry Ford, Detroit MI.
- Demasi M. Ciki da takaddamar rigakafin rigakafin Henry Ford. Shekarar 2025; Oktoba 15.
- Gøtzsche PC. Shin Jadawalin Jadawalin Alurar riga kafi na Amurka yana da lahani? Jaridar Brownstone 2025; Oktoba 22.
-
Dokta Peter Gøtzsche shi ne ya kafa Cochrane Haɗin kai, wanda da zarar an yi la'akari da babbar ƙungiyar bincike ta likita mai zaman kanta ta duniya. A cikin 2010 Gøtzsche an nada shi Farfesa na Tsarin Bincike na Clinical da Bincike a Jami'ar Copenhagen. Gøtzsche ya buga fiye da 100 takardu a cikin "manyan biyar" mujallolin likita (JAMA, Lancet, New England Journal of Medicine, British Medical Journal, da Annals of Internal Medicine). Gøtzsche ya kuma rubuta litattafai kan al'amuran kiwon lafiya da suka hada da Magungunan Mutuwa da Laifukan Tsara.
Duba dukkan posts
