A cikin kallon wannan fage mai ban dariya,
mafi akasin sha'awa dole nasara.
kuma wani lokaci suna cakudu da juna a cikin tunani;
madadin raini da fushi;
sauran dariya da hawaye;
madadin zagi da tsoro.
Edmund Burke
Da na fara ganin faifan bidiyo na zanga-zangar da manoman Turawa suka yi a baya-bayan nan, ni, tare da sauran mutane da dama a fadin Tekun Atlantika, na burge sosai. Kamar masu motocin Kanada masu amfani da sinadarai, waɗannan da ake zaton ciyawa sun ba wa duniya darasi na azama, hazaka, jajircewa, da fasaha na ƙungiya fiye da babban mafarki na mugayen yahoos na gwamnati waɗanda suke ubangidansu kuma suke neman halaka su. Jita-jita na cewa shugaban Faransa Emmanuel Macron na guje wa Paris ya yi nuni da yiwuwar sakamako mai dorewa ga mafi alheri.
A cikin zanga-zangar nasu, manoman sun kuma nuna halaye da yawa na halayen ɗan adam, gami da kyakkyawan matakin kamewa daga tashin hankali, har ma da mugun yanayi. Abu ne mai ban sha'awa da ban dariya gaba daya. Kallonsu suna toshe hanyoyin zuwa manyan biranen tsawon makonni, kawai suna "fiye da hanya" a cikin taraktocinsu lokacin da aka fuskanci wadanda ake kira hukumomi, abin mamaki ne.
Lokacin da manoma suka fesa ton da tan na taki a gine-ginen gwamnati daban-daban (magana game da gilding lili!) Tambayoyi biyu sun shiga zuciyata.
Tambayata ta farko, wacce ta samo asali daga wani bangare na tausayawa talakawan ma’aikata da za su share baragurbi, ita ce:
Lokacin da ake gogewa a kan ɗimbin ɓangarorin ɓangarorin gwamnati, yaushe ake tsayawa?
Tambayata ta biyu, wacce ta fi dacewa da tsari, ina tsammanin ita ce:
Wane canji na dindindin zai zo daga duk waɗannan?
Ayyukan da Majalisar Dokokin Faransa suka yi a ranar soyayya sun amsa tambayoyina.
Ga tambayata ta farko, amsar ita ce: kar a daina gogewa.
To tambayata ta biyu, amsar ita ce: ba komai.
A ranar 14 ga Fabrairu, Majalisar Dokokin Faransa ta amince da shi labarin 223-1-2 du code pénal. Kunshe a ciki, a Mataki na ashirin da 4 na wannan doka, Robert Kogon ya rubuta:
Mataki na 4 ya gabatar da sabon laifi a cikin dokar hukunta laifuka ta Faransa: tunzura yin watsi da ko ƙin jinya ko ɗaukar magani, idan, "a halin yanzu na ilimin likitanci", yin hakan "a sarari" na iya haifar da lahani ga mutumin ko mutanen da ake tambaya. An sanya wannan laifin hukuncin daurin shekara guda a gidan yari da tarar €30,000 (£ 26,000) ko, idan "tunanin" ya yi tasiri, watau ana bin shawarar likita, shekaru uku a gidan yari da kuma tarar € 45,000 (£ 39,000).
Kogon ya lura cewa dole ne wannan ya wuce Majalisar Dattawan Faransa don zama doka. Har ila yau, wani yanki ne na doka da ke da alaƙa da rashin amincewar likita a fili.
A taƙaice, wannan matsananci ne oda a kan likitoci, sauran ma'aikatan kiwon lafiya, da kuma duk wanda ya kuskura ya yi magana game da ka'idodin likita na hukuma. A cikin manyan kalmomi masu ban tsoro, yana aikata laifuka - tare da wahala da gurgunta tara - ba da shawara ga hikimar likitanci da aka karɓa, koda kuwa ba a bi shawarar ba.
Ba ya ɗaukar likita, lauya, ko masanin ilimin likitanci don tunanin tasirin wannan zai yi akan aikin likita. A taqaice, wannan doka za ta lalata dangantakar likita da haƙuri.
A duk faɗin Covid, ya bayyana a fili yadda yarda da wahalar aikin likitancin ke fuskantar matsin lamba daga sama. An bayyana Likitoci a matsayin gungun masu daidaitawa sosai. Wannan abu ne mai fahimta (ko da yake ba uzuri ba) idan aka yi la'akari da yanayin horarwarsu, yanayin ƙwararru, da tsarin aikin yi.
Tare da wannan doka akan littattafan, 'yan kaɗan waɗanda ba su yarda da su ba dole ne su yi mamaki, duk lokacin da suka ba da shawara ga majiyyaci ko ba da oda wanda ya saba wa kowane jadawalin allurar "hukuma", ƙa'idar aikin al'umma, ko ka'idar asibiti, idan za a kai rahoto ga hukuma, kuma a ƙarƙashin hukuncin laifi, lokacin kurkuku, da babban hukuncin kuɗi.
Dangane da Covid, wannan dokar tana nuna ɗabi'a mai banƙyama, mai tsauri ga ƴancin likita. A bayyane gwamnatin Macron ba ta koyi komai daga Covid ba, sai dai don daidaita abubuwan da suka wuce gona da iri a matsayin samfura don ci gaban ikon gwamnati.
A sakamakon zanga-zangar da manoman suka yi, sai ya zama kamar balon gwaji. Gagarumin zanga-zangar da manoman suka shirya, an ce sun samu rangwame. Mutum mai hankali zai yi tunanin irin wannan tashe tashen hankula da ta addabi gwamnatin Faransa daga yunkurin wani mummunan hari kan 'yancin jama'a nan da nan. Wataƙila gwamnati ta yi wauta don ganin haɗin. Bayan haka, me ya hada manoma da likitoci?
Abin farin ciki, jajirtattun masu fafutuka kamar Annie Arnaud (@arnaud_annie26a Faransa da Kat Lindley (@klveritas) a Amurka, da sauransu, sun kawo batun a kan gaba a duniya.
Shin Likitocin Faransa za su yi yaƙi da Mataki na 4? Shin talakawan Faransa za su yi yaƙi da shi? Don 'yancin likita, kuma ga dangantakar likita da haƙuri, wannan lamari ne na ruwa. Tasirin al'ummar Faransa zai kasance mai zurfi da lalata, watakila ma fiye da manufar mugayen wawayen da suke turawa.
Idan Mataki na 4 ya zama doka, gwamnatin Faransa za ta fito fili ta ayyana kanta a matsayin mai mulkin kama karya. Tasirin zai mamaye ko'ina cikin Turai. Tun shekaru aru-aru, tun kafin Tarayyar Turai, makomar Turai sau da yawa ta kasance kamar jerin gwanaye, inda Faransa ko Jamus ke kan gaba. Za a iya ceto Faransa - da Turai? Ko kuwa da gaske Burke annabci ne lokacin da ya rubuta, a cikin 1790s, cewa
…Shekarun chivalry sun tafi. Na sophisters, masana tattalin arziki, da lissafi sun yi nasara; kuma daukakar Turai ta ƙare har abada.
Ga masu tsaftace bayan zanga-zangar manoma, ina ba da shawara guda ɗaya mai sauƙi. Kar a daina gogewa, ina amis. Kar a daina gogewa.
-
CJ Baker, MD, 2025 Brownstone Fellow, likita ne na likitancin ciki tare da karni na kwata a aikin asibiti. Ya gudanar da alƙawura na likita da yawa, kuma aikinsa ya bayyana a cikin mujallu da yawa, ciki har da Journal of the American Medical Association da New England Journal of Medicine. Daga 2012 zuwa 2018 ya kasance Mataimakin Farfesa na Clinical Associate of Medical Humanities da Bioethics a Jami'ar Rochester.
Duba dukkan posts
