An yi sabunta sha'awa a cikin asalin Covid da ka'idar leak a wannan makon biyo bayan saki na ƙarin imel tsakanin babban jami'in kiwon lafiya na Gwamnatin Amurka Dr. Anthony Fauci da sauransu yayin da suka ƙulla yarjejeniya a farkon Fabrairu 2020 don magance ka'idar da murkushe ta.
Abu na farko da za a lura shi ne cewa imel ɗin sun tabbatar da cewa waɗanda ke da hannu - Fauci, Jeremy Farrar na Wellcome Trust da CEPI, Babban Masanin Kimiyya na Burtaniya Patrick Vallance, Kristian Andersen daga Scripps, Christian Drosten na Jamus da ƙari - ba su sani ba kafin ƙarshen Janairu cewa cutar na iya kasancewa ta asali.
Tambayar ta bayyana tare da Fauci ta Andersen ta hanyar Farrar a ranar 31 ga Janairu 2020. Fauci ya ba da amsa cewa ya kamata ƙungiyar masanan juyin halitta su taru "da wuri-wuri" don bincika bayanan a hankali kuma "idan kowa ya yarda da wannan damuwa, ya kamata su kai rahoto ga hukumomin da suka dace." Musamman ma, Fauci bai san ko wanene ba, amma ya ce "zai yi tunanin cewa a Amurka wannan zai zama FBI kuma a Burtaniya zai zama MI5." Babu wata alama a nan na umarnin rufewa da aka karɓa a baya.
A ranar 2 ga Fabrairu, Fauci ya rubuta cewa, "kamar mu duka, ban san yadda wannan ya samo asali ba", kuma Farrar ya rubuta, "a kan bakan idan 0 yanayi ne kuma an saki 100 - Ni gaskiya ina 50." A ranar 4 ga Fabrairu, Farrar ya fayyace cewa a ra'ayinsa "watakila ba" injiniya ne amma yana iya fitowa daga aikin lab ta wasu hanyoyi:
"Injiniya" mai yiwuwa ba. Ya kasance ainihin yiwuwar nassi na bazata a cikin dabbobi don ba da glycans… Eddie [Edward Holmes] zai kasance gefen lab na 60:40. Ina 50:50…
Christian Drosten, a ranar 9 ga Fabrairu, ya yi mamakin inda ra'ayin ya fito da farko: "Wane ne ya fara wannan labarin a farkon? Shin muna aiki ne don karya ka'idar makircinmu?" Ya ƙara da cewa yana tsammanin manufar tattaunawar tasu ita ce ƙalubalantar “tabbatacciyar ka’idar: “Ba mu taru don ƙalubalantar wata ka’ida ba, kuma idan za mu iya, mu watsar da shi?” Wasu sun fahimci “tabbatacciyar ka’idar” ita ce alaƙar ƙwayar cuta da HIV kamar yadda aka samu a cikin bugu na Janairu 2020.
Tambayoyin Drosten suna samun amsa da sauri daga wasu membobin ƙungiyar. Edward Holmes ya bayyana abin da ƙungiyar su ke ciki (wanda, ga mahallin, ya bi bayyanar sabbin bayanai daga pangolins):
Ban san daga ina wannan labarin ya fito ba, amma ba shi da wani abu da ya shafi HIV. Don Allah kar a danganta wannan da wancan. Wannan babban labari ne.
Tun lokacin da aka fara wannan bullar an sami wasu shawarwarin cewa kwayar cutar ta kubuta daga dakin gwaje-gwaje na Wuhan, in dai kawai saboda haduwar inda cutar ta bulla da kuma wurin da dakin binciken yake. Ina yin ayyuka da yawa a kasar Sin kuma zan iya [ gaya muku cewa mutane da yawa a wurin sun yarda da wannan kuma sun yi imani ana yi musu ƙarya. Abubuwa sun yi muni lokacin da dakin binciken Wuhan ya buga jerin kwayoyin cutar bat - wani jemage da aka yi samfurin a wani lardi na daban wanda ke da tarin samfurori.
Na gaskanta makasudin/tambaya anan shine ko mu, a matsayinmu na masana kimiyya, yakamata muyi kokarin rubuta wani abu mai daidaito akan kimiyyar da ke bayan wannan? Akwai gardama akan yin hakan da kuma adawa.
Da kaina, tare da kwayar cutar pangolin mai maɓalli na 6/6 a cikin yanki mai ɗaure mai karɓa, Ina goyan bayan ka'idar juyin halitta.
Farrar yayi karin bayani:
Ka'idar asalin [virus] ta taru sosai ba a cikin kafofin watsa labarun ba, amma yana ƙaruwa tsakanin wasu masana kimiyya, a cikin manyan kafofin watsa labarai, da kuma tsakanin 'yan siyasa.
Manufar wannan ita ce kawo wani tsaka-tsaki, girmamawa, ƙungiyar kimiyya tare don duba bayanan kuma a cikin tsaka-tsaki, hanyar da aka yi la'akari da ita don samar da ra'ayi kuma muna fatan mayar da hankali kan tattaunawa kan kimiyya, ba a kan kowane maƙarƙashiya da sauran ka'idar ba kuma don ƙaddamar da wata sanarwa mai daraja don tsara duk wani muhawara da ke gudana - kafin muhawarar ta fita daga hannun tare da yiwuwar lalacewa.
Tare da ƙarin bayani game da kwayar cutar pangolin, bayanin da ba a samu ko da sa'o'i 24 da suka gabata ba, Ina tsammanin hujjar ta fi fitowa fili.
Abin da nake so shi ne cewa wani yanki na kimiyya da aka yi la'akari da shi, a farkon fagen jama'a, zai taimaka wajen rage muhawar da ba ta dace ba. Idan ba haka ba, wannan muhawarar za ta ƙara faruwa kuma kimiyya za ta mayar da martani a kai. Ba matsayi mai kyau don kasancewa a ciki ba.
Kristian Andersen ya yarda ko da yake sun kasance suna "kokarin karyata kowane irin ka'idar lab:"
Babban aikinmu a cikin makonni biyun da suka gabata an mayar da hankali kan ƙoƙarin kwance kowane nau'i na ka'idar lab, amma muna kan tsaka-tsaki inda shaidar kimiyya ba ta isa ta ce muna da babban kwarin gwiwa a cikin manyan ka'idoji guda uku da aka yi la'akari da su ba.
Har sai jeri na pangolin ya bayyana, yarjejeniya a cikin imel ɗin sun daidaita kan shawarar cewa yayin da kwayar cutar ba ta bayyana da gangan ba zai iya haifar da "maimaita ra'ayin al'adun nama" a cikin dakin gwaje-gwaje. Yayin da Francis Collins ke jayayya wannan "bai bayyana glycans O-linked" wanda yawanci ke fitowa a gaban tsarin rigakafi, Holmes ya ce, kamar yadda ta imel da ke sama, yana yiwuwa don "labaran dakin gwaje-gwaje a cikin dabbobi don ba da glycans."
Patrick Vallance, na ɗaya, ya yi farin ciki da jin cewa jerin pangolin za su iya fuskantar "asalin hanyar wucewa:"
Godiya ga rabawa kuma godiya ga waɗanda ke da hannu don wani muhimmin yanki na aiki. Ina tsammanin wannan ya dubi kyawawan daidaito da amfani. Ina tsammanin zai zama taimako don tabbatar da cewa an haɗa bayanan jeri daga pangolins kuma don nuna abin da hakan zai iya nufi dangane da yiwuwar tsawaita lokaci na daidaitawa a cikin dabbobi. Ma'anar glycan yana da mahimmanci kuma ana iya ba da ƙarin nauyi akan asalin sashe. Da zarar an kammala ina tsammanin zai zama taimako don buga wannan.
Sakamakon wannan tattaunawar shine "Asalin kusanci” takarda in Nature a kan Maris 17th 2020. Takardar ƙarshe ta fi mayar da hankali kan shawarwarin da aka riga aka yi, kodayake ƙimanta na farko na fifiko ga asalin lab ɗin ya tafi, wanda masu yiwuwa marubutan za su danganta zuwan jerin pangolin. (Don yanayin cutar da ake yin injiniya duba nan; ga yanayin asalin lab (ko injiniyanci ko ba injiniya ba) duba nan; ga matsala tare da jerin pangolin duba nan.)
Musamman da aka cire daga cikin takardar da aka buga sune ambaton cewa bincike don canza coronaviruses na jemage na SARS yana faruwa shekaru da yawa a Wuhan a ƙananan matakan tsaro (watau BSL-2). Andersen ya lura a ranar 8 ga Fabrairu cewa "hanyoyin SARS-kamar CoVs suna ci gaba da gudana tsawon shekaru da yawa, kuma musamman a Wuhan a karkashin yanayin BSL-2," Yayin da Andersen ya nuna cewa babu wani sabon abu game da wannan, don haka babu wani dalili da za a yi tunanin ba zato ba tsammani ya haifar da annoba, haka ma wasu za su lura cewa a fili hatsari ne da ke jiran faruwa. Har ila yau, wa ya san sau nawa ya faru a baya, amma tare da ƙwayoyin cuta waɗanda ba su yi nisa sosai ba ko kuma sun yi yawa?
Masanan kimiyyar suna kan gaba cewa suna da himma don hana, a nakalto Farrar, "mummunan ɓarna mai lalacewa," wanda suke da alama suna nufin kansu kamar yadda suke da hannu a cikin wannan bincike da kuma fa'idar binciken ƙwayar cuta ta biodefence.
Wannan ra'ayi na rashin son buɗe 'gwangwanin tsutsotsi' na kwayar cutar da ke fitowa daga binciken kwayar cutar da ke da alaƙa da Amurka ya zama ruwan dare ga faɗuwar hanyar kare ƙwayoyin cuta ta Amurka da ƙawayenta. A cikin labarin Yuni 2021 in girman kai Fair, mun same shi yana girma har ya kawo cikas ga binciken asalin kwayar cutar akai-akai.
Tsawon watanni girman kai Fair Bincike, hirarraki da mutane sama da 40, da kuma nazarin ɗaruruwan shafuka na takaddun gwamnatin Amurka, gami da bayanan cikin gida, mintunan taro, da wasikun imel, sun gano cewa rikice-rikice na sha'awa, wanda ya samo asali daga babban tallafi na gwamnati na tallafawa binciken binciken ƙwayoyin cuta, ya kawo cikas ga binciken Amurka game da asalin COVID-19 a kowane mataki. A wani taro da ma'aikatar harkokin wajen Amurka ta yi, jami'an da ke neman neman bayyana gaskiya daga gwamnatin kasar Sin sun ce abokan aikinsu sun gaya musu karara cewa kada su binciko ayyukan da cibiyar nazarin halittu ta Wuhan ta yi, domin hakan zai jawo hankalin da ba a so ba ga tallafin da gwamnatin Amurka ke bayarwa.
A cikin memo na ciki da aka samu Girman kai Fair, Thomas DiNanno, tsohon Mataimakin Mataimakin Sakatare na Ofishin Kula da Makamai, Tabbatarwa, da Biyayya, ya rubuta cewa ma'aikata daga ofisoshin biyu, nasa da Ofishin Tsaro na Kasa da Kasa, "sun yi gargadin" shugabannin da ke cikin ofishinsa "kada su ci gaba da bincike kan asalin COVID-19" saboda zai "bude gwangwani idan ya ci gaba."
Christopher Park, Darakta na Ma'aikacin Ma'aikatar Harkokin Halittu ta Ma'aikatar Harkokin Wajen Amurka a Ofishin Tsaro na kasa da kasa da hana yaduwar cutar, yana daya daga cikin mutane da yawa da suka yada irin wannan gargadi.
Park, wanda a cikin 2017 ya shiga cikin ɗaga dakatarwar da gwamnatin Amurka ta yi kan bayar da tallafi don gudanar da bincike, ba ita kaɗai ce jami'in da ya gargaɗi masu binciken Ma'aikatar Harkokin Wajen Amurka game da tona a wurare masu mahimmanci ba. Yayin da kungiyar [Ma'aikatar Jiha] ta binciko yanayin leak, a tsakanin sauran yuwuwar, an sha shawartar mambobinta da kada su bude "akwatin Pandora," in ji wasu tsoffin jami'an Ma'aikatar Harkokin Wajen Amurka hudu da suka yi hira da su. Girman Banza. Shawarwarin “sun yi wari kamar rufawa,” in ji Thomas DiNanno, “kuma ba zan kasance cikin sa ba.”
The girman kai Fair Labarin ya bayyana a sarari cewa kasar Sin ita ma tana rufe ta a fili, kuma darektan CDC na Amurka Robert Redfield ya kasance cikin shakku nan take.
A ranar 3 ga Janairu, 2020, Dr. Robert Redfield, Daraktan Cibiyar Kula da Cututtuka da Cututtuka ta Amurka, ya samu kiran waya daga takwaransa Dokta George Fu Gao, shugaban cibiyar kula da rigakafin cututtuka ta kasar Sin. Gao ya bayyana bayyanar wani sabon ƙwayar cutar huhu, da alama ya iyakance ga mutanen da aka fallasa a wata kasuwa a Wuhan. Redfield nan da nan ya ba da tayin aika ƙungiyar kwararru don taimakawa bincike.
Amma lokacin da Redfield ya ga rugujewar lamuran farko, wasu daga cikinsu gungun dangi ne, bayanin kasuwa bai da ma'ana. Shin 'yan uwa da yawa sun kamu da rashin lafiya ta hanyar hulɗa da dabba ɗaya? Gao ya ba shi tabbacin cewa ba a yada kwayar cutar daga mutum zuwa mutum, in ji Redfield, wanda duk da haka ya bukace shi da ya kara gwadawa a cikin al'umma. Kokarin da yayi ya sa aka sake kiran waya cikin kuka. Yawancin lokuta ba su da alaƙa da kasuwa, Gao ya yarda. Kwayar cutar ta bayyana tana tsalle daga mutum zuwa mutum, lamarin da ya fi ban tsoro.
Redfield nan da nan ya yi tunanin Cibiyar Nazarin Kwayoyin cuta ta Wuhan. Tawaga za ta iya kawar da ita a matsayin tushen barkewar cutar a cikin 'yan makonni kadan, ta hanyar gwada masu bincike a can don maganin rigakafi. Redfield a hukumance ya sake nanata tayin nasa na aika kwararru, amma jami'an kasar Sin ba su mayar da martani kan matakin nasa ba.
Ƙungiyar leƙen asiri (IC) na Amurka da kawayenta sun dage sosai a cikin wannan rufa-rufa. A ranar 30 ga Afrilu, 2020 ofishin Daraktan Leken Asiri na Amurka (wanda a wancan lokacin yake kan kujerar) ya ba da sanarwar. bayani cewa: "Al'ummar Leken asirin kuma sun amince tare da ɗimbin ijma'i na kimiyya cewa cutar ta COVID-19 ba ta mutum ta yi ba ko kuma an canza ta ta hanyar gado." A ranar 5 ga Mayu, 2020 CNN ruwaito wani taƙaitaccen bayani daga majiyar leƙen asiri ta Ido Biyar wanda ya kai ga goyon bayan ka'idar rigar kasuwa ta jam'iyyar Community Party (CCP).
Leken asirin da aka raba tsakanin kasashe biyar na Ido ya nuna cewa "ba shi yiwuwa" barkewar cutar sankarau ta barke sakamakon wani hatsari a dakin gwaje-gwaje amma ta samo asali ne a kasuwar China, a cewar wasu jami'an kasashen Yamma biyu wadanda suka kawo wani kima na leken asiri wanda da alama ya sabawa ikirarin Shugaba Donald Trump da Sakataren Harkokin Wajen Mike Pompeo.
Wadannan bayanan sirri sun ci karo da juna kai tsaye iƙirarin da aka yi a lokacin ta Shugaba Trump cewa ya ga shaidar da ta ba shi "babban kwarin gwiwa" COVID-19 ya samo asali ne daga dakin gwaje-gwaje a Wuhan. Sakataren harkokin wajen Amurka Mike Pompeo ya ce ya amince da kimar Trump:
Akwai shaida mai yawa cewa daga nan ne wannan ya fara. Tun da farko mun ce wannan kwayar cuta ce da ta samo asali daga Wuhan na kasar Sin. Mun dauki baƙin ciki da yawa game da hakan daga waje, amma ina tsammanin duk duniya za ta iya gani yanzu… akwai adadi mai yawa na shaida cewa wannan ya fito ne daga dakin gwaje-gwaje a Wuhan.
Lallai akwai shaidu da yawa, amma da yawa daga cikin wadanda suka samu damar yin hakan sun yi iyakacin kokarinsu wajen binne ta. Sakamakon ya kasance duk da nacewar Trump da Pompeo, kuma watakila a wani bangare saboda shi, ka'idar leak ta kasance ba a bincika ba kuma ba a ambata ba har zuwa sauran 2020, kamar yadda kafofin watsa labarai da masu binciken gaskiya suka danne shi a matsayin 'ka'idar makirci.'
A watan Agusta 2021, duk da haka, kuma tare da sabon shugaban ƙasa a matsayi, leken asirin Amurka ya buga wani rahoton da ba a bayyana ba wanda ya taƙaita bayanan sirri na Amurka na yanzu akan kowace ka'ida. Wannan rahoton ya kasance, duk da haka, har yanzu yana karkata zuwa ga ka'idar asalin halitta. "Yawancin masu sharhi na IC suna tantancewa tare da ƙaramin kwarin gwiwa cewa SARSCoV-2 ba a yi amfani da kwayoyin halitta ba," in ji shi.
Ba wata kwayar cuta ce ta yau da kullun da ake amfani da ita a cikin dakin gwaje-gwaje ba: "Abubuwan IC guda hudu, Majalisar Leken Asiri ta Kasa, da wasu manazarta a abubuwan da ba za su iya yin hadin gwiwa kan ko wane bayani ba" sun dawo da ka'idar asalin halitta tare da "ƙananan kwarin gwiwa," in ji shi. Har ila yau, ta yi watsi da yaduwar cutar da wuri, tana mai cewa mai yiwuwa kamuwa da cuta ta farko ta faru ne "ba da watan Nuwambar 2019 ba," tare da "sanannen gungu na COVID-19 na farko da ya tashi a Wuhan, China a watan Disamba 2019." Ya yi watsi da haɓakar shaidar samfuran banki da aka gwada tabbatacce tun kafin wannan, yana mai cewa tabbas ba za a iya dogaro da su ba.
Rahoton ya kuma ce hukumar ta IC ba ta ganin China ta san da cutar kafin karshen watan Disamba.
IC ta kimanta jami'an kasar Sin mai yiwuwa ba su da masaniyar cewa SARS-CoV-2 ta wanzu kafin masu binciken WIV su ware ta bayan fahimtar jama'a game da kwayar cutar a cikin jama'a. Saboda haka, idan cutar ta samo asali daga wani lamari mai alaƙa da dakin gwaje-gwaje, mai yiwuwa ba su san a farkon watannin cewa irin wannan lamarin ya faru ba.
Abin da ya sa waɗannan ƙin yarda da yaɗuwar farko, sanin gabanin China da asalin lab shine cewa sun saba da rahotanni da yawa daga ƙungiyar leken asirin Amurka da kanta. Tabbas, rahoton ya lura cewa wata hukumar leken asiri, NCMI, ta tantance cewa lebur ne da "madaidaicin kwarin gwiwa." Me ya sa zai iya ganin shaidar da sauran ba za su iya ba?
Michael Callahan, wanda Robert Malone yake da shi aka bayyana a matsayin "babban ƙwararren ƙwararren gwamnatin Amurka/CIA a duka biowarfare da samun aikin bincike," in ji a cikin wata hira da Rolling Stone a watan Agusta 2020 ya kasance riga Bayan kamuwa da cutar a watan Nuwambar 2019, abokan aikinsa na kasar Sin sun sanar da shi, har ma ya tafi Singapore don nazarin barkewar "kwayar cuta mai ban mamaki" a can.
A farkon watan Janairu, lokacin da rahotannin farko masu ban tsoro na sabon barkewar cutar sankara ke fitowa daga Wuhan, China, wani likitan Ba’amurke ya riga ya dauki bayanan. Michael Callahan, kwararre kan cututtukan cututtuka, yana aiki tare da takwarorinsa na kasar Sin kan hadin gwiwa da aka dade a kan mura a watan Nuwamba lokacin da suka ambaci bayyanar wata sabuwar kwayar cuta. Ba da daɗewa ba, ya tashi zuwa Singapore don ganin marasa lafiya a can waɗanda suka nuna alamun ƙwayar cuta iri ɗaya.
Wannan ya bayyana karara cewa Amurka da China suna sane da barkewar cutar a watan Nuwamba na 2019, dalla dalla da suka yi daidai da sauran rahotannin leken asirin har yanzu ba su yi hannun riga da bayanan rahoton rahoton watan Agustan 2021 game da kimanta bayanan leken asirin Amurka ba.
A kwanan nan Rahoton majalisar dattijai, wanda ake kyautata zaton ya dogara ne aƙalla a kan bayanan leƙen asirin Amurka, ya bayyana cewa CCP ta yi wani babban tsoma baki na aminci a WIV a ranar 12 ga Nuwamba, 2019, kuma da alama binciken rigakafin SARS-CoV-2 na China ya fara a lokacin. Sauran rahotanni Majiyoyin leken asirin Amurka sun bayyana cewa sun sami labarin bullar cutar a China a watan Nuwamban 2019 daga lura da cibiyoyin lafiya da hanyoyin sadarwa da aka katse, kuma an yi wa NATO da sojojin Isra’ila bayani a karshen watan Nuwamba.
Abin sha'awa, Michael Callahan da kansa da farko ya gaya Robert Malone a farkon watan Fabrairun 2020 cewa kwayar cutar ta dabi'a ce, yana mai cewa "mutanena sun yi nazari a hankali a kan tsarin, kuma babu wata shaida da ke nuna cewa an kirkiro wannan kwayar cutar ta kwayoyin halitta." Amma ta Satumba 2021, biyo bayan fitar da rahoton leken asirin da aka fitar, yana nuna cewa a zahiri yana tunanin kwayar cutar ta fito ne daga dakin binciken Wuhan kuma kasar Sin tana rufe ta. Shin ya canza ra'ayinsa ne, ko kuwa ya fara faɗin ainihin tunaninsa ne?
Hoton yana ƙara zuwa cikin hankali. Gwamnatin kasar Sin, Fauci & Co da da yawa daga cikin kungiyar leken asirin Amurka da cibiyar sadarwa ta biodefence suna rufe asalin kwayar cutar da kokarin yin takaici don bincikar ta saboda su kansu suna da hannu a cikin binciken da watakila ya haifar da shi kuma saboda ba sa son a bata sunan binciken biodefence.
Ba, duk da haka, cikakken makirci ne kamar yadda ba duka sun yarda ba: wasu har yanzu suna matsawa don bincikar ka'idar leak kuma suna yarda da ka'idar da kansu. Duk da haka, isassun a cikin waɗannan cibiyoyin sadarwa suna da isassun ƙwarin gwiwa don rufewa da hana binciken don yin nasara sosai a ɓoye.
Inda ruɗin kai ya tsaya kuma aka fara ƙaryar hankali yana da wuyar faɗi. Saƙonnin imel na Fauci sun bayyana masana kimiyya a lokaci guda suna tantance shaida 'da gaske' da kuma yin niyyar wani ƙarshe. Ga alama suna ƙoƙarin shawo kansu kamar kowa, kuma mai yiwuwa sun yi nasarar shawo kan kansu - kodayake hakan bai sa su dace ba. Ba a fayyace yadda har sun san yaudarar wasu, da kuma yadda har suka yi magana da kansu don gaskata wani abu mai dacewa amma ƙarya ko kuma ba cikakken hujja ba akan shaida.
Ƙarshe na gaba ɗaya daga waɗannan imel ɗin da sauran shaidun shine cewa babban matakin ɓarna da ƙin yarda a kusa da murfin leken asiri yana nuna cewa bai zo da yawa kamar diktat daga sama ba, ko kuma daga Babban Jagorar Puppet, amma daga ilhami na gabaɗaya wanda ke mamaye cibiyar sadarwar Amurka ta biodefence saboda wannan hanyar sadarwar tana da rauni sosai kan binciken ƙwayar cuta mai haɗari.
An rubuta shi daga DailySceptic
