[Yaffa Shir-Raz, Shay Zakov, da Peter A. McCullough ne suka rubuta wannan labarin.]
Shekaru biyu sun wuce tun bayan kawo karshen cutar ta Covid-19 a hukumance, duk da haka batun rigakafin ya kasance mai matukar muhimmanci a cikin jawaban jama'a da na kimiyya. Ƙoƙarin yin tambaya game da sahihancin yaƙin neman zaɓe na yawan jama'a ko kuma tada damuwa game da illar da za a iya samu sau da yawa tare da jan layi na ɗabi'a: da'awar da aka maimaita akai-akai cewa "Alurar rigakafin Covid-19 sun ceci miliyoyi da miliyoyin rayuka. "
Abin sha'awa, an kula da wannan ikirari a matsayin tabbataccen gaskiya ko da lokacin sauraron karar PSI na Majalisar Dattijan Amurka kwanan nan a ranar 21 ga Mayu, 2025, wanda ya mai da hankali kan illar da ke da alaƙa da rigakafin.1 Mamba mai daraja Richard Blumenthal ya buɗe sauraron karar da wannan sanarwa mai zuwa:
"Yayin da muke magana game da illar rigakafin COVID-19, ina tsammanin muna bukatar mu bayyana a fili game da mafi mahimmancin gaskiya. Ga dukkan Amurkawa, rigakafin COVID-3 ya ceci miliyoyin da miliyoyin rayuka.1
Wannan tabbataccen tabbaci ya haifar da wata muhimmiyar tambaya: Shin da gaske akwai tabbataccen tabbataccen shaidar kimiyya don tallafawa da'awar mai ƙarfi cewa yaƙin neman zaɓe na Covid-19 ya haifar da fa'ida ta miliyoyin rayuka da aka ceto?
Idan aka fuskanci wannan muhimmiyar tambaya, ƙungiyar bincikenmu ta ɗauki tsari mai tsari, mataki-mataki kimanta tushen tushe na labarin ''miliyoyin ceto''. Gina kan aikinmu na baya,2, 3 mun yi nazarin ƙididdiga na ƙididdiga na ƙididdiga waɗanda suka samar da wannan adadi mai ban mamaki, da kuma gwaje-gwajen da aka sarrafa da yawa da kuma manyan nazarin binciken da suka yi aiki a matsayin ƙwaƙƙwarar ƙididdige ingancin rigakafin da aka ciyar a cikin waɗannan samfuran.
Yanzu mun yi uploaded labarinmu mai cikakken tsayi tare da abin da muka yi imani zai zama mahimman binciken gaggawa ga uwar garken da aka fara bugawa,4 don ba da damar masana kimiyya, likitoci, da masu tsara manufofi don tantance shaidar da kanta. Domin tattaunawa mai ma’ana ta kimiyya tana bukatar a binciki bayanan da kyau, muna kira ga masu karatu da kada su dogara ga takaitaccen labarin na yanzu, amma su shiga kai tsaye tare da cikakken nazarin da aka gabatar a cikin shirinmu na farko.4
Manufarmu anan ita ce mu haskaka wasu bincike na tsakiya da yawa waɗanda, a ganinmu, suna buƙatar kulawa sosai, idan aka yi la’akari da kasancewarsu kai tsaye ga ɗaya daga cikin muhimman ayyukan kiwon lafiyar jama'a a tarihin zamani: yaƙin neman zaɓe na duniya, wanda gwamnati ke tallafawa wanda, a cikin ƙasashe da yawa, ya kasance tare da umarni da ƙuntatawa da ba a taɓa gani ba kan 'yancin ɗan adam.
Abin da ke biye shi ne taƙaitaccen bayani na mahimman bayanai daga tsarin bincikenmu wanda, a ganinmu, kowane ƙwararren kiwon lafiya, mai tsara manufofi, da ɗan ƙasa ya cancanci yin la'akari:
- Da'awar da aka ambata da yawa cewa "milyoyin rayuka sun ceci" ta hanyar allurar rigakafin Covid-19 ya dogara ne akan ƙirar ƙira waɗanda ke kan dogon jerin zato - waɗanda yawancinsu ko dai rauni ne, ba a tabbatar da su ba, ko kuma a zahiri ƙarya (duba ƙasa). A sakamakon haka, abubuwan da aka fitar daga waɗannan samfuran suna da ƙima mai tambaya kuma ba za a iya ɗaukar su azaman tabbataccen shaida ba.
- Babban zato da ke ƙarƙashin waɗannan samfuran shine cewa allurar rigakafin Covid-19 sun ba da kariya mai ƙarfi da dorewa daga kamuwa da cuta da watsawa. Ka yi la'akari da ainihin bayanin Dr. Anthony Fauci, sannan babban mai ba shugaban Amurka shawara kan kiwon lafiya: “Lokacin da aka yi muku allurar ba kawai kare lafiyar ku kawai ba… amma kuma kuna ba da gudummawa ga lafiyar al'umma ta hanyar hana yaduwar cutar a cikin al'umma… mutuƙar cutar” (ƙara mai ƙarfi).5 Wannan zato-wanda yayi aiki a matsayin ginshiƙin yaƙin neman zaɓe na gama gari-ya zama ƙarya. Bayanai na zahiri sun nuna da sauri cewa tasirin maganin rigakafi na kamuwa da cuta yana da rauni kuma yana da ɗan gajeren lokaci, kuma ba a taɓa yin nazarin tasirin watsawa kai tsaye ba.
- Abin mamaki, duk da rugujewar wannan labarin na asali (maki na 2), yaƙin neman zaɓe ya ci gaba a ƙarƙashin wata hujja da aka sabunta: cewa alluran rigakafin suna ba da kariya mai ɗorewa daga rashin lafiya mai tsanani da mutuwa, ko da bayan ɗan gajeren lokaci tasirin su akan kamuwa da cuta ya ragu. Yana da mahimmanci a gane cewa wannan da'awar da aka sabunta ta dogara ne akan rarrabuwar ra'ayi tsakanin waɗannan nau'ikan inganci guda biyu - rabuwa wanda, kamar yadda muke nunawa akai-akai. preprint mu labarin, ba a taɓa inganta shi ta zahiri ba.
- A haƙiƙa, bayanan da ake da su sun nuna cewa kariya daga kamuwa da cuta da kariya daga cututtuka masu tsanani ko mutuwa suna da alaƙa ta kut-da-kut, suna bin irin wannan yanayin na raguwa a kan lokaci. Bambanci ya ta'allaka ne da farko a cikin lokaci, tare da jinkirin yanayi tsakanin kamuwa da cuta na farko da haɓaka sakamako mai tsanani.
- Don tantance ingancin wannan bambance-bambancen da ake tsammani tsakanin kariya daga kamuwa da cuta da kariya daga cututtuka mai tsanani, mun bincika yiwuwar yanayin rashin lafiya mai tsanani tsakanin mutanen da suka kamu da cutar a cikin manyan bincike da yawa. Sakamakon ya bayyana a sarari: kariyar da ke fitowa daga sakamako mai tsanani ta kasance mai yuwuwa sakamakon kariya ta ɗan gajeren lokaci daga kamuwa da cuta. Babu wani bincike mai tasiri da muka bincika da ya nuna mai zaman kansa ko kariyar mai dorewa daga rashin lafiya mai tsanani ko mutuwa.
- Musamman ma, wasu nazarin sun dakatar da bin diddigin sakamako mai tsanani a daidai lokacin da ake sa ran kariya ta alluran za ta ragu-daidai da raguwar rubuce-rubucen kariya daga kamuwa da cuta da kuma jinkirin da aka saba tsakanin kamuwa da cuta da farkon rashin lafiya ko mutuwa da aka ambata a sama. Wannan tsarin yana haifar da damuwa mai tsanani game da yiwuwar ɓarna ko zaɓen rahoton binciken bincike.
- A ƙarshe, babban gwajin da aka sarrafa bazuwar da ya kai ga Izinin Amfani da Gaggawa (EUA) na maganin Pfizer bai nuna wani bambanci mai ma'ana tsakanin allurar da ƙungiyoyin placebo ba wajen hana: (1) alamun mura, (2) Covid-19 mai tsanani, ko (3) duk- sanadin mace-mace. Bambanci mai mahimmanci kawai an lura dashi a cikin sakamakon da ba na asibiti ba - dakin gwaje-gwaje ya tabbatar da kamuwa da cutar ta Covid-19 - har ma wannan sakamakon ya dogara ne akan bayanai daga sama da kashi 8.24% na mahalarta, waɗanda aka tattara ta hanyar nuna son kai, kamar yadda cikakken bayani preprint mu.
- Musamman ma, ba a sami rahoton mutuwar da ke da alaƙa da Covid-19 a cikin babban gwaji na Pfizer ba. Wannan rashi yana haifar da tambayoyi masu mahimmanci game da ko an cika ƙa'idodin doka da na likita don ba da izinin amfani da gaggawa.
- Ko da mafi mahimmanci, gwaji na watanni shida na Pfizer ya ba da rahoton mutuwar mutane 15 a cikin rukunin rigakafin (n = 21,720), idan aka kwatanta da 14 a cikin rukunin placebo (n = 21,728). Idan aka yi la'akari da girman samfurin, wannan rashin fa'idar mace-mace yakamata ya zama mahimmin ginshiƙi ga kowane ƙirar ƙira ko tattaunawa mai tushe dangane da fa'idar gabaɗayan rigakafin.
Waɗannan binciken sun ƙalubalanci ra'ayin cewa allurar rigakafin Covid-19 ya ceci miliyoyin rayuka. Haka kuma, zurfafan bincikenmu ya bankado mafi faffadan kurakuran hanyoyin da suka jefa shakku kan gaba daya dogaran tushen shaidar da ke akwai. Waɗannan sun haɗa da: (a) lokutan bin diddigin da suka kasance gajeru sosai kuma ba a saba amfani da su a cikin ƙungiyoyi ba; (b) Siginonin ingancin inganci da ba za a iya sanin su ba suna bayyana kusan nan da nan bayan allurar rigakafi—da kyau kafin cikakken rigakafin zai iya faruwa ta hanyar ilimin halitta; da (c) dogaro mai nauyi akan bayanan lura masu rauni ga Kishin Lafiyar Alurar riga kafi, ƙimar gwaji daban, da sauran abubuwa masu ruɗani da yawa.
A dunƙule, waɗannan abubuwan da suka shafi hanya da ƙwaƙƙwaran ba wai kawai suna lalata tushen labarin “miliyoyin ceto” ne kawai ba, har ma suna tayar da tambaya mai zurfi: Idan shaidar tana da iyaka kuma tana da lahani, ta yaya wannan labarin ya sami irin wannan rinjaye a cikin maganganun kimiyya da na jama'a?
Batun ba shine ko an ga wani matakin ingancin maganin a wasu lokuta ba (misali, duba misali mai ban sha'awa a cikin preprint mu na Bar-On et al. nazari a kan mai ƙarfafawa na biyu), sai dai yadda irin waɗannan abubuwan lura suka zo don tsara mafi fa'idar labari na jama'a. An ɗaukaka wuraren da aka keɓance da keɓancewa, yayin da la'akari masu mahimmanci-kamar (a) rigakafin rigakafi, (b) ƙarancin fa'idar mace-mace da aka nuna, (c) kamuwa da cututtukan cututtukan da ke haifar da asibiti ko mutuwa, da (d) ƙarin ƙarfi na shaida akan illar da ba ta dace ba-an kasance cikin tsari (Hoto 1).
Hoto 1. Nuna Zaɓan Mayar da Hankali akan Sati mai Kyau Mai Sauƙi Yayin Yin watsi da Bayanai
Wannan kunkuntar mayar da hankali - leken asiri ta hanyar mabuɗin nasara guda ɗaya na wucin gadi - ya ba da damar da'awar da ba ta da ƙarfi ta ƙulla ƙaƙƙarfan labari mai ƙarfi, ƙarfafa ta hanyar hukumomi, daidaiton zamantakewa, da murkushe muryoyin da ba su yarda da shi ba (ciki har da namu ƙwarewar sa ido, kamar yadda cikakken bayani a cikin namu) bita).
Don haka muna kira ga al'ummomin kimiyya da na likitanci da su dau mataki na baya, su fadada ruwan tabarau, da komawa ga ka'idar magani: kowane sa hannu, ko ta yaya alƙawarin, dole ne a ci gaba da yin kimantawa bisa tushen shaida na duka fa'idodinsa da illolinsa. A iyakar saninmu, irin wannan ma'auni kuma mai tsauri har yanzu ba a yi amfani da shi ga allurar Covid-19 ba.
Bisa ga hujjojin da aka yi bitar a cikin rubutun mu, mun kammala cewa da'awar cewa "Alurar rigakafin Covid-19 ya ceci miliyoyin rayuka"1 ba a goyan bayan kwararan hujjoji. Duk da yake waɗannan alluran rigakafin an haɓaka su sosai a matsayin amintattu kuma masu tasiri, tattara rahotanni na munanan abubuwan da suka faru-kamar myocarditis, pericarditis, thrombosis, da alamun jijiya-an yi rubuce-rubuce da yawa a cikin tsarin kula da magunguna da kuma a cikin binciken da aka yi nazari da yawa (misali, 6-16), da yawa tare da marubucin ƙarshe na labarin yanzu.
Musamman ma, an gudanar da wannan sa baki ta hanyar ilimin halitta akai-akai ta hanyar ƙarfafawa, wanda hakan ke haifar da haɗarin haɗari - galibi a cikin yawan jama'a da ke da haɗarin mutuwa mai alaƙa da Covid, kamar yara. Haɗe tare da rashin ingantaccen ingantaccen aiki na dogon lokaci da aka gabatar a ciki preprint mu,4 Shaidun da ke akwai suna nuna cewa ma'aunin fa'ida-hadari na rigakafin Covid-19 na iya, a zahiri, ya karkata zuwa ga mummunan ƙarshen wannan ma'auni na likitanci.17, 18
References
1. Tsaron gida. Cin hanci da rashawa na Kimiyya da Hukumomin Lafiya na Tarayya: Yadda Jami'an Lafiya suka Rage Wasa da Boye Myocarditis da sauran Mummunan Al'amura masu alaƙa da allurar COVID-19.
2. Ophir Y, Shir-Raz Y, Zakov S, McCullough PA. Ingantacciyar Maganganun rigakafin COVID-19 akan Mummunan Cuta da Mutuwa: Gaskiyar Kimiyya ko Labari mai Faɗi?. Jaridar Likitocin Amurka da Likitoci. 2023; 28 (1). doi: https://www.jpands.org/vol28no1/ophir.pdf.
3. Ophir Y. Brick na Karshe a cikin Labarin Ingantaccen Magani ⋆ Cibiyar Brownstone. 2023.
4. Ophir Y, Shir-Raz Y, Zakov S, McCullough PA. Kimanta mataki-mataki na iƙirarin Cewa allurar COVID-19 sun ceci miliyoyin rayuka. Binciken Bincike (preprint). 2025. doi: 10.13140/RG.2.2.12897.42085.
5. LABARAN C. Rubutun: Dr. Anthony Fauci akan "Face Al'umma", Mayu 16, 2021.
6. Rose J. Rahoto kan Tsarin Ba da Rahoto Mara Kyau na Amurka (VAERS) na COVID-1 9 Messenger Ribonucleic Acid (mRNA) Biologicals. Kimiyya, Manufar Kiwon Lafiyar Jama'a, da Doka. 2021; 2: 59-80.
7. Fraiman J, Erviti J, Jones M, et al. Mummunan al'amuran da suka faru na ban sha'awa na musamman biyo bayan rigakafin mRNA COVID-19 a cikin gwajin da bazuwar a cikin manya. Alurar riga kafi. 2022;40(40):5798–5805. doi: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2022.08.036.
8. Shir-Raz Y. Breaking: Bidiyon Leaked Yana Nuna Mummunan Tasirin Tasirin Alurar Pfizer COVID-19 da MOH ta Isra'ila ta rufe. 2022.
9. Witberg G, Barda N, Hoss S, et al. Myocarditis bayan Alurar rigakafin Covid-19 a cikin Babban Kungiyar Kula da Lafiya. N Engl J Med. 2021;385(23):2132–2139. doi: 10.1056/NEJMoa2110737.
10. Chua GT, Kwan MYW, Chui CSL, et al. Annobar Cutar Myocarditis/Pericarditis a cikin Matasa na Hong Kong Biyo bayan Alurar riga kafi. Cutar cututtuka na asibiti. 2021: gaba989. doi: 10.1093/cid/ciab989.
11. Hulscher N, Alexander PE, Amerling R, et al. NAZARI na Tsare-tsare na binciken Gawawwaki a cikin mace-mace bayan rigakafin covid-19. Forensic Sci Int. 2024: 112115. doi: 10.1016/j.forsciint.2024.112115.
12. Oster ME, Shay DK, Su JR, et al. An Ba da rahoton Cutar Myocarditis Bayan Alurar COVID-19 na tushen mRNA a cikin Amurka Daga Disamba 2020 zuwa Agusta 2021. JAMA. 2022;327(4):331–340. doi: 10.1001/jama.2021.24110.
13. Takada K, Taguchi K, Samura M, et al. SARS-CoV-2 mRNA da ke da alaƙa da maganin rigakafi na myocarditis da pericarditis: Bincike na bayanan Rahoton Rahoton Magungunan Magunguna na Jafananci. Jaridar Kamuwa da Cutar Kwayoyin cuta. 2024.
14. McCullough P, Rogers C, Cosgrove K, et al. Ƙungiya tsakanin Alurar COVID-19 da Yanayin Neuropsychiatric. 2025.
15. McCullough PA, Hulscher N. Haɗarin haɗari don kama zuciya na gaba bayan rigakafin COVID-19. Duniya J Cardio. 2025;17(2):103909. doi: 10.4330/wjc.v17.i2.103909.
16. Hulscher N, Hodkinson R, Makis W, McCullough PA. Binciken gawarwaki a cikin lamuran myocarditis mai cutar COVID-19 mai kisa. ESC gazawar Zuciya. 2024; n/a. doi: 10.1002/hf2.14680.
17. Mead MN, Seneff S, Wolfinger R, et al. COVID-19 Gyaran mRNA “Alurar rigakafi”: Darussan da Aka Koya Daga Gwaje-gwajen Asibiti, Alurar rigakafi, da Rukunin Magungunan Halitta, Sashe na 1. Jarida ta Duniya na Ka'idar Alurar riga kafi, Ayyuka, da Bincike. 2024;3(2):1112–1178. doi: 10.56098/fdrasy50.
18. Mead MN, Seneff S, Rose J, Wolfinger R, Hulscher N, McCullough PA. COVID-19 Gyaran mRNA “Alurar rigakafi”: Darussan da Aka Koya Daga Gwaje-gwajen Asibiti, Alurar rigakafi, da Rukunin Magungunan Halitta, Sashe na 2. Jarida ta Duniya na Ka'idar Alurar riga kafi, Ayyuka, da Bincike. 2024;3(2):1275–1344. doi: 10.56098/w66wjg87.
-
Dokta Yaakov Ophir shi ne Shugaban Cibiyar Harkokin Kiwon Lafiyar Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararru (CHIA) a Jami'ar Cambridge. Bincikensa ya bincika ilimin ilimin halin ɗan adam na zamani, AI da VR nunawa da tsoma baki, da kuma ilimin halin ƙwaƙwalwa mai mahimmanci. Littafinsa na baya-bayan nan, ADHD Ba Cuta ba ne kuma Ritalin Ba Magani bane, yana ƙalubalantar babban tsarin ilimin halittu a cikin ilimin tabin hankali. A matsayin wani ɓangare na ƙaddamar da ƙaddamar da alhakin ƙididdigewa da amincin kimiyya, Dokta Ophir ya yi nazari sosai game da nazarin kimiyya da ke da alaka da lafiyar hankali da aikin likita, tare da kulawa na musamman ga matsalolin ɗabi'a da tasirin abubuwan sha'awar masana'antu. Har ila yau, ƙwararren masanin ilimin halayyar ɗan adam ne mai lasisi wanda ya ƙware kan ilimin yara da na iyali.
Duba dukkan posts
