A cikin 'yan kwanakin nan, Cibiyar Brownstone ta buga labarin game da sabon binciken Czech wanda ke ba da haske mara daɗi game da ingancin rigakafin Covid mRNA. Binciken da kansa bai tabbatar da cewa harbe-harben ba su da tasiri, amma yana nuna ƙarfi sosai cewa iƙirarin inganci ya kasance aƙalla kaɗan, idan ba da gaske ba.
Ɗaya daga cikin marubutan binciken Czech, masanin lissafi kuma memba na Czech Ƙungiyar Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararrun Ƙwararru da Ƙididdiga (SMIS), Tomas Fürst, babban mai sukar yadda hukumomin Czech ke kula da bayanai yayin barkewar Covid-19. SMIS ta kuma yi nuni da cewa hukumomi sun yi watsi da Magungunan Shaida kuma sun kasance da kwarin gwiwa wajen tura allurar rigakafi da samfuran mRNA na gwaji.
A cikin wannan hira, Fürst kuma ni tattauna takardarsa ta kwanan nan kan Tasirin Alurar rigakafin Lafiya (HVE) da kuma abubuwan da ke tattare da tafsirin bayanai game da tasirin rigakafin Covid mRNA.
Tambaya: Tomas, yaushe kuma me yasa kai da abokan aikinka suka fara binciken bayanai daga kamfanonin inshorar lafiya na Czech?
Tun farkon barkewar cutar, muna rokon Cibiyar Watsa Labarai da Kididdigar Lafiya (IHIS) da ta fitar da bayanai masu ma'ana daga abin da za a iya gano bayanan da suka dace game da hadarin cutar da inganci da amincin matakan, musamman ma alluran rigakafin.
Abin takaici, IHIS ya yi ta bayar da bayanan da ba su cika ba, ruɗi, ko gyare-gyare na baya-bayan nan. Don ƙara zagi ga rauni, an ba da ƙarin cikakkun saiti kawai ga ƙungiyoyin bincike na "abokai", waɗanda ba sa son fahimtar bayanan, amma suna son tabbatar da labarin hukuma. IHIS ta bukaci in sanya hannu kan “yarjejeniya” da ke nuna cewa idan ina son buga duk wani sakamako da aka samu daga bayanansu, sai na fara samun amincewar su. Tabbas, na ƙi sanya hannu kan wannan, saboda ya keta ’yancin karatu na, don haka ban taɓa samun bayanan da aka nema ba.
A wani lokaci a cikin 2021, wani yana da ra'ayin tambayar babban mai inshorar lafiya na Czech - Babban Kamfanin Inshorar Lafiya (VZP) - maimakon IHIS. Abin mamaki, VZP ya ba da bayanai kan adadin adadin wadanda suka mutu a tsakanin abokan cinikinsa, wanda matsayinsu na rigakafin Covid ya rushe. Mun rubuta labarin game da wannan bayanan mai ban sha'awa a cikin Janairu 2022, mai take Elixir na Matasa. Taken ya nuna mamakinmu cewa mutanen da aka yi wa allurar rigakafin Covid da alama kusan ba su mutu ba - suna mutuwa sau biyu zuwa sau uku ƙasa da waɗanda ba a yi musu allurar shekaru masu kama da juna ba. Wannan gaskiya ne ba tare da la'akari da dalilin mutuwa ba - allurar rigakafin Covid da alama sun hana mutuwar Covid da kuma mace-mace daga abubuwan da ba su da alaƙa da Covid.
Wannan ita ce haduwarmu ta farko da Tasirin Alurar Lafiya (HVE), kuma ta ba mu mamaki. Dole ne in yarda da cewa idan na sami ƙarin ƙwarewa a cikin ilimin cututtukan cuta, da zai bayyana a gare ni cewa dole ne mu kula da wannan tasirin a cikin bayanan lura.
Mun sami bayanan suna da ban sha'awa sosai har muna son ƙarin cikakkun bayanai. Godiya ga aikin rashin gajiyawa na Angelika Bazalova, 'yar jarida mai binciken Czech. [kara karanta game da ita nan], A ƙarshe mun sami nasarar samun waɗannan cikakkun bayanan bayanan, ba daga VZP ba, amma daga wasu kamfanonin inshora na Czech da yawa. Mun sami damar yin cikakken bincike kan waɗannan cikakkun bayanai, daidai da ƙididdige yawan mace-mace na kowane wata na abokan cinikin inshora, wanda matsayinsu na rigakafin Covid ya rushe. Har ma mun sami damar raba sabbin abokan cinikin da aka yi wa alurar riga kafi da wadanda aka yi wa rigakafin a baya.
Sakamakon a bayyane kuma cikakke ya nuna ingantaccen Tasirin Alurar Lafiya. Ko da a cikin watannin bazara na 2021, lokacin da kusan babu mace-mace masu alaƙa da Covid, yawan mace-macen da aka yi wa allurar ya ninka sau da yawa fiye da na waɗanda ba a yi musu allurar ba. Wannan gaskiya ne a kowane rukuni na shekaru. Adadin alurar riga kafi zuwa mace-macen da ba a yi wa allurar ba bai canza sosai ba tare da karuwar mutuwar masu alaƙa da Covid a cikin kaka na 2021, wanda ke haifar da shakku kan iƙirarin ingancin rigakafin.
Bugu da kari, bayanai sun nuna a fili cewa da shigowar kowane sabon allurar rigakafin, kungiyar da aka yi wa allurar riga-kafin da ta gabata ta raba zuwa wadanda ke da lafiya kuma sun ci gaba da samun kashi na gaba, da wadanda ba su da lafiya kuma sun kasance tare da kashi na baya. Don haka, mace-macen mutane "dade bayan kashi na farko" ya tashi daidai lokacin da aka fara gudanar da kashi na biyu. Don allurai na gaba, yanayin ya kasance iri ɗaya.
Shin wasu ƙungiyoyin 'yan jarida sun yi ƙoƙarin samun bayanai iri ɗaya?
Idan kuna nufin kafafen yada labarai, abin takaici ba haka bane. Angelika Bazalova ita kadai ce ta yi aiki tukuru don samun bayanan. Kuma da ta samu, ta tuntubi mutanen da za su iya tantance shi. Abin kunya ne cewa Angelika ita kaɗai ce! Sauran 'yan jaridar da suka ba wa juna kyaututtukan "bayanan jarida" da "tunani mai mahimmanci" galibi suna farfagandar hukuma kuma suna haskaka duk wanda ya kalubalanci labarin hukuma.
Shin tasirin rigakafin lafiya yana faruwa a wasu karatu da labarai?
Wannan shine batun. Ana samun wannan tasirin a ciki dukan nazarin lura; wato nazarin inda muka bar mutane su yanke shawara da kansu ko suna son a yi musu rigakafin ko a'a sannan mu lura da sakamakon lafiyarsu. Koyaya, duk bayanan da muke da su kan tasirin rigakafin Covid tun farkon yaƙin neman zaɓe sun fito ne daga irin waɗannan karatun. Gwajin da aka sarrafa bazuwar - waɗanda ba sa fama da HVE - an gudanar da su a ƙarshe a cikin 2020, lokacin da bambance-bambancen Wuhan na kwayar cutar (wanda aka haɓaka rigakafin) har yanzu yana yawo kuma lokacin kusan babu wanda ke da rigakafi bayan kamuwa da cuta. Don haka binciken da suka yi bai yi mana bayani sosai ba game da ingancin alluran rigakafin a yau.
Na ga abin ban sha'awa ne cewa mun yi wa biliyoyin mutane allurar gwaji a duniya, amma duk da haka ba mu san kusan komai ba game da tasirinsa. Yana iya zama tabbatacce, maras kyau, ko ma mara kyau. Wannan ba a ce komai ba na ɗayan ɓangaren haɗarin haɗarin-amfani - illar waɗannan samfuran. A nan ma, HVE ya zo cikin wasa, saboda lokacin da ake kimanta lafiyar maganin alurar riga kafi, dole ne mu yi la'akari da cewa alurar riga kafi sun fi lafiya fiye da asali, don haka abin da ya faru na "al'ada" na abubuwan da ba su da kyau ya rigaya ya zama abin tuhuma. Kuma babu wanda yayi la'akari da wannan.
Yaya Czech ko ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙasashen waje suka yi game da binciken ku?
Kwararrun ƙwararrun jama'a na Czech sun amsa daidai da daidaitaccen hanya - tare da cikakken shiru. Baya ga ƴan raɗaɗin haskawa akan bayanan martaba na Facebook na SMIS da Angelika Bazalová, Ban lura da martani ɗaya daga kowa ba a cikin kafuwar Czech Covid. Amma mun saba da haka: A duk lokacin da ake fama da cutar, ba mu taɓa yin nasarar shigar da wani daga kafa a cikin tattaunawa ba. Mun gayyace su sau da yawa, duka don gabatar da mu a Majalisar Dattijai da Majalisar Dokokin Czech da kuma wasu abubuwa da yawa. Ba wanda ya taɓa zuwa. Kafofin watsa labarai na yau da kullun ba su taimaka ba. Tun daga farkon annobar, sun yi mana lakabi da "masu yada labaran karya" kuma sun yi fushi da duk wanda ya kuskura ya ambace mu.
Sai dai labarin namu ya samu martani a kasashen waje wanda ya ba ni mamaki matuka. Martin Neil, wanda ya kafa kungiyar HART ta Burtaniya. nakalto shi kuma yayi sharhi akai Substack dinsa "Ina lambobin?" Wannan yana da mahimmanci a gare mu saboda ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙasashen waje da yawa sun karanta wannan Substack, kuma ƙungiyar HART ta Biritaniya ta kasance abin ƙarfafawa ga SMIS. Daga baya, sharhi mai kyau ya kasance wallafa Eyal Shahar, Farfesa Emeritus na Kiwon Lafiyar Jama'a a Jami'ar Arizona, akan dandalin Skeptic Daily, wanda miliyoyin mutane ke karantawa a duniya, sannan Cibiyar Brownstone ta sake buga shi, wanda shine abin alfahari a gare mu. Yawancin masana kimiyya na kasashen waje sun tuntube mu tare da tambayoyi masu haske, kuma wasu haɗin gwiwar masu ban sha'awa na iya fitowa daga wannan.
Shin tasirin rigakafin lafiya yana taka rawa a binciken Steve Kirsch na bayanan New Zealand?
Ee, kuma mai ban sha'awa sosai. Idan na fahimci Steve daidai, yana tsara adadin wadanda suka mutu tare da adadin kwanakin da suka wuce tun daga allurar. Kuma ya nuna cewa wannan jadawali yana da ci gaba a cikin 'yan makonnin farko. Ya ƙarasa da cewa wannan shaida ce ta mace-macen rigakafin. Amma a ganina, wannan wata alama ce ta HVE - ƙungiyar da aka yi wa alurar riga kafi ta fi lafiya fiye da wanda ba a yi ba, amma wannan "amfani" yana raguwa a kan lokaci, kuma mutuwar masu yin rigakafin sannu a hankali ya koma tushe. Wannan yana haifar da haɓakar haɓakar da Steve ke gani a cikin bayanan. Don haka ba na jayayya cewa allurar Covid ba sa haifar da mutuwa, amma ina ganin yana buƙatar nuna ta ta wata hanya dabam.
Gabaɗaya, HVE yana haifar da ruɗi uku a cikin bayanan lura: (1) hasashe na ingancin rigakafin da na bayyana a sama, (2) ruɗin "ƙarashin tasirin maganin alurar riga kafi" wanda HVE ke raguwa a kan lokaci, da (3) mafarkin mace-macen rigakafin da Steve Kirsch ke gani a cikin bayanan. Wani abin sha'awa shi ne, ruɗi biyu na farko masu goyon bayan allurar sun kyamaci, na uku kuma yana harzuka masu shakkar maganin.
Kuna shirya wani nazari na gaba?
Ina fatan buga binciken na yanzu zai ƙarfafa sauran ƙasashe don a ƙarshe fitar da bayanan matakin mutum ɗaya. A iya sanina, babu wata kasa da ta taba yin haka, duk da cewa ‘yan majalisar da dama sun bukaci kungiyar ONS ta Biritaniya da ta nemi a ba su wannan bayanai. Na tabbata cewa lokacin da wannan bayanan ya fito, zai tabbatar da yawan kasancewar HVE a wasu ƙasashe, kuma.
Mun kuma ba da sanarwar cewa, bayan shekaru da yawa, a ƙarshe mun sami bayanan matakin mutum-mutumi daga IHIS, don haka za mu iya maimaita wannan bincike akan dukan jama'ar Czech. Tuni a cikin takarda na yanzu, mun gabatar da samfurin lissafi don ƙarin fahimtar HVE. A halin yanzu muna shirya wata takarda inda za mu yi bayanin yadda HVE ke haifar da ruɗi uku da na ambata a sama.
A lokaci guda, muna kuma magance ɗayan ɓangaren nazarin fa'idar haɗari - abubuwan da suka faru (AEs) waɗanda ke da alaƙa da rigakafin Covid. Anan, ina fata cewa a cikin makonni za mu iya gabatar da wani littafin da aka yi bita na takwarorinsu, wanda a cikinsa muke bayyana bambancin ban mamaki na adadin AEs da aka ruwaito a cikin batches na rigakafin. Muna aiki akan wannan batu tare da wani ɗan jarida mai bincike na Czech, Petr Sourek.
-
Cecílie Jílková marubuciya ce ta Czech. Bayan littafinta na farko, Cesta na Drromm (2010), feuilletons don Lidové noviny, labarai na mujallar likitanci Sanquis da rubutun jerin shirye-shiryen TV Kriminálka Anděl, ta sadaukar da shekaru goma masu zuwa musamman ga batun cin abinci mai kyau kuma ta buga littattafai huɗu akan batun. A halin yanzu tana bugawa akan dandamali Substack kuma sabon aikinta shine juyin halittar TV VOX Digital (R). Cecílie tana zaune a Prague.
Duba dukkan posts
