Ci gaba da cin hanci da rashawa na tsarin mulkin Covid yana jin kamar shan ruwa daga wuta. Yawan zamba, saurin sabon bincike, da faɗin ayyukan suna da yawa. Wannan ya sa ya zama wajibi ga ƙungiyoyi kamar Cibiyar Brownstone su narkar da ta'addancin bayanai da kuma sadar da jigogi masu mahimmanci da bayanai masu ma'ana, musamman idan aka yi la'akari da rugujewar kafofin watsa labarai na yau da kullun.
A ranar Litinin ne kwamitin shari’a na majalisar ya saki rahoton kan yadda Hukumar Tsaro ta Yanar Gizo da Tsaro (CISA) ta “yi haɗin gwiwa tare da Big Tech da abokan hulɗar 'disinformation' don bincikar jama'ar Amirkawa," ƙara zuwa ga hose na bayanai da muke aiki don imbibe.
Rahoton mai shafuka 36 ya kawo batutuwa guda uku da aka saba da su: na farko, ’yan wasan gwamnati sun yi aiki tare da wasu kamfanoni don soke gyare-gyaren Farko; na biyu, masu tace bayanai sun fifita labaran siyasa a kan gaskiya; na uku kuma, wani tsarin mulki da ba a iya lissafinsa ya sace al'ummar Amurka.
- Hadin gwiwar CISA don Juyar da Gyaran Farko
Rahoton House ya bayyana cewa CISA, reshe na Ma'aikatar Tsaron Cikin Gida, ta yi aiki tare da dandamali na kafofin watsa labarun don tantance sahihancin saƙon da ta yi la'akari da ɓarna, rashin fahimta, ko ɓarna. Brian Scully, shugaban tawagar CISA ta censorship, ya yarda cewa wannan tsari, wanda aka fi sani da "switchboarding," zai "samu daidaita abun ciki."
Bugu da ƙari, CISA ta ba da tallafin EI-ISAC mai zaman kanta a cikin 2020 don haɓaka ayyukan sa ido. EI-ISAC ya yi aiki don bayar da rahoto da bin diddigin "bayanai marasa fahimta a duk tashoshi da dandamali." A cikin ƙaddamar da ƙungiyoyin sa-kai, gwamnati ta yi alfahari da cewa tana “yin amfani da[d] dangantakar DHS CISA tare da ƙungiyoyin kafofin watsa labarun don tabbatar da fifikon kula da rahotannin da ba su da tushe.”
Shirye-shiryen allo kai tsaye sun saba wa rantsuwar shaida daga Daraktan CISA Jen Easterly. "Ba mu sanya ido kan wani abu… ba ma nuna wani abu ga kungiyoyin kafofin watsa labarun kwata-kwata," Esterly ya fada wa Majalisa a watan Maris. "Ba ma yin wani sharhi." Maganar ta ya wuce karya; ya tsallake kafa tsarin da ta musanta. Shirye-shiryen hukumar sun dogara ne da tsarin haɗin gwiwa na haɗin gwiwar jama'a da masu zaman kansu da aka tsara don murkushe bayanan da ba a amince da su ba.
Wannan ya kamata sauti saba.
Alex Berenson ya sami damar yin amfani da dubban sadarwar Twitter wanda fallasa tabbataccen shaida 'yan wasan gwamnati - ciki har da mai ba da shawara na White House Covid Andy Slavitt - sun yi aiki don ba da izini don sukar manufofin Covid na Biden.
Shugaban Fadar White House na Dabarun Digital Rob Flaherty na sirri lobbied Kungiyoyin kafofin watsa labarun don cire bidiyon Tucker Carlson yana ba da rahoton alakar da ke tsakanin allurar Johnson & Johnson da gudan jini.
Facebook yayi aiki tare da CDC don tantance posts mai alaƙa da Covid “lab-leak” hasashe. Ma'aikatan kamfanin daga baya sun sadu da Ma'aikatar Kiwon Lafiya da Ayyukan Dan Adam don kawar da tsarin "disinformation dozin," rukuni ciki har da Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.
Waɗannan ba misalai ne da aka zabo ba - sun kasance wani ɓangare na haɗin kai na cibiyoyi don kwacewa Amurkawa haƙƙoƙin Gyaran Farko. 'Yan jarida Michael Shellenberger da Matt Taibbi sun fallasa labarin "Complex Masana'antu Tace Tace," tarin manyan hukumomin gwamnati na duniya, kungiyoyi masu zaman kansu, da kamfanoni masu zaman kansu wadanda suka yi aiki tare don rufe bakin haure.
Kotun Koli ta yanke hukuncin cewa "axiomatic" ne cewa gwamnati ba za ta iya "jawo, karfafawa, ko inganta mutane masu zaman kansu don cim ma abin da tsarin mulki ya haramta a cim ma." Duk da haka, CISA ta shiga cikin ɗabi'a mai ban tsoro na haɗin gwiwar jama'a da masu zaman kansu da aka tsara don hana 'yancin Amurkawa na bayanai da 'yancin faɗar albarkacin baki.
- Ma'aikatan Siyasa
Na biyu, waɗannan shirye-shiryen ba yunƙurin inganta gaskiya ba ne; An ƙididdige shirye-shiryen da aka ƙera don kawar da labarun da ba su dace ba amma na gaskiya.
Rahoton ya fayyace yadda CISA ta yi la'akari da "lalata - bayanai na gaskiya wanda, a cewar gwamnati, na iya ɗaukar yuwuwar yaudara." Daga baya ɗan jarida Lee Fang ya rubuta cewa yaƙin neman zaɓen “ba wai kawai babban ikon da gwamnatin tarayya ke da shi na tsara abubuwan siyasa da jama’a ke da su ba, har ma da kayan aikin da ta dogara da su don iyakance bincike a cikin ka’idojin magana.”
A cikin wannan tsarin, bayanan da ba a tantance su ba suna da amincewar gwamnati ta hankali, wanda ya kai tsarin yada farfaganda.
"Jami'an zaben jihohi da na kananan hukumomi sun yi amfani da kudin EI-ISAC da CISA ke bayarwa a wani yunƙuri na dakatar da suka da rashin amincewar siyasa," in ji rahoton. "Alal misali, a cikin watan Agusta 2022, Loudon County, Virginia, jami'in gwamnati ya ba da rahoton wani Tweet wanda ke nuna wani faifan bidiyo na wani jami'in gundumar 'saboda an buga shi a matsayin wani ɓangare na babban kamfen don tozarta kalmar' waccan jami'in. yunƙurin sanya ido."
Jami'an da ke goyon bayan wannan aiki sun kasance ba su tuba ba a manufarsu ta ciyar da manufofin siyasa gaba. Dr. Kate Starbird, mamba na kwamitin CISA na “Bayanai da Rarrabawa”, ta koka da cewa Amurkawa da yawa suna ganin “sun yarda da rashin fahimta a matsayin ‘magana’ kuma cikin ka’idojin dimokiradiyya.”
Tabbas shirin ya saba wa Kundin Tsarin Mulki karara. Kwaskwarimar Farko baya nuna wariya dangane da gaskiyar magana. "Wasu maganganun karya ba makawa ne idan ana so a bayyana ra'ayi a bayyane da karfi a cikin tattaunawa na jama'a da na sirri," Kotun Koli ta yanke hukunci a cikin Amurka v. Alvarez. Amma CISA - karkashin jagorancin masu kishi irin su Dokta Starbird - sun nada kansu a matsayin masu sulhu na gaskiya kuma sun yi aiki tare da manyan kamfanonin watsa labarai masu karfi a duniya don kawar da rashin amincewa.
Wannan wani bangare ne na babban yakin neman zabe.
Kwamfutar tafi-da-gidanka ta Hunter Biden, rigakafi ta dabi'a, ka'idar leak, da illolin allurar duk an tantance su bisa ga umarnin gwamnati. Ba a maganar gaskiyar rahotannin; maimakon haka, sun gabatar da labarun da ba su dace ba don ajin siyasar Washington, wanda daga nan ne suka yi amfani da lakabin Orwellian na "lalata" don ba da lamuni don kawar da Kwaskwarimar Farko.
- Ta'addancin Gwamnatin Jihar
Na uku, rahoton ya fallasa yadda ake kara samun karfin mulki a jihar. Ma’aikatan gwamnatin tarayya sun dogara da rashin sanin sunansu da kuma rashin sani. Ma'aikatan masana'antu masu zaman kansu ba za su taɓa kula da bala'i kamar martanin Covid da kiyaye ayyukansu ba. Zai zama kamar idan shugaban tsaro na BP mai kula da mashigin tekun Mexico ya sami talla bayan malalar mai.
Amma jami'an da ba a zaba ba kamar jami'an CISA suna jin daɗin ci gaba da ƙaruwa a rayuwar Amurkawa ba tare da sun amsa bala'o'insu ba. Suzanne Spaulding, memba na Kwamitin Ƙarfafawa da Rarrabawa, ya yi gargaɗin cewa "wani lokaci ne kawai kafin wani ya gane cewa akwai mu kuma ya fara tambaya game da aikinmu."
Sharhin Spaulding na nuna irin karfin da CISA ke amfani da shi da kuma fa'idar da take samu daga rashin bayyanar da jama'a. Yawancin Amurkawa ba su taɓa jin labarin CISA ba duk da tasirin da yake da shi game da kulle-kulle.
A cikin Maris 2020, CISA rabu ma'aikatan Amurka zuwa nau'ikan "masu mahimmanci" da "marasa mahimmanci." A cikin sa'o'i kadan, California ta zama jiha ta farko da ta fitar da dokar "zauna a gida". Wannan ya fara wani hari mara misaltuwa a baya akan 'yancin jama'ar Amurkawa.
Rahoton gidan ya nuna cewa CISA ta kasance babban ɗan wasan kwaikwayo don yin la’akari da sukar gwamnatin Covid a cikin watanni da shekaru masu zuwa. Hukumar ita ce wakiliyar kwamitin bincike da jami'an da ba a kula da su ba da ke cikin kawancen jama'a da masu zaman kansu da aka tsara don sanya mu cikin duhu.
-
Labarai daga Cibiyar Brownstone, ƙungiyar sa-kai da aka kafa a watan Mayu na 2021 don tallafawa al'umma da ke rage rawar tashin hankali a rayuwar jama'a.
Duba dukkan posts
