A ranar 24 ga Janairu, 2023, Dr. Michael V. Callahan ya buga wani ra'ayi a cikin The New York Times mai suna "Hanyoyin kai tsaye da Amurka za ta iya Taimakawa China don guje wa bala'in Covid."
Idan muka ɗauka cewa wani fitaccen likita ne ya rubuta wannan a asibitin da ke da alaƙa da Harvard - ƙwararren ilimi wanda ya dogara da ra'ayinsa akan ingantattun ka'idodin likita da ilimin kimiyya - ba shi da ma'ana ko kaɗan. A gaskiya abin kunya ne ga marubuci da kuma cibiyar da yake wakilta.
Idan, duk da haka, mun gane cewa wannan shine kawai sabon a cikin keɓe-har zuwa allurar rigakafi farfaganda yakin a Wakilin CIA kuma saman memba na biosecurity, komai ba zato ba tsammani yana da cikakkiyar ma'ana. A zahiri, yawancin abubuwan da ke cikin taswirar labarin suna da kyau akan taimakon Robert Blumen grid farfaganda.
Wadannan su ne almara na likitanci da na kimiyya (ko, idan kun fi so, karya) wanda likitan-cuta-likita Callahan ya ba da shawarar, sannan bayanin dalilin da yasa wakilin CIA-Agent/propagandist biosecurity-propagandist Callahan zai so yada su:
Fiction #1: Zero Covid yana aiki
Callahan ya buɗe labarin nasa da wata sanarwa mai ƙarfi: "Kasar Sin ta dawo da dabarunta na bala'in cutar korona, 'sifili,' wanda ya kare ƙasar kusan shekaru uku." Kamar yadda da yawa, harda kaina, sun lura, babu wata shaida - sai dai maimaita maganganun mutane kamar Callahan da kulle-kulle-bayanai-inganta manyan latsa - don gaskiyar cewa dabarun "sifili Covid" kare kowa daga komai.
Callahan, wanda ya yi aiki ga kungiyar leken asiri a Asiya, ya san (kamar yadda ya kamata mu duka) cewa bayanan da aka samu daga Jam'iyyar Kwaminisanci ta kasar Sin (CCP) ba abin dogaro ba ne, ko kadan. Don haka, babu wani dalili da zai sa a yi tunanin ya yi imani da iƙirarin rashin hankali na CCP na cewa babu wani mutuwar Covid a cikin China tsawon shekaru uku godiya ga kulle-kulle.
To me yasa wannan jagoransa? Domin injin farfagandar halittu dole ne ya kiyaye tunanin cewa kulle-kulle, aƙalla zuwa wani mataki, yana da tasiri, kuma kawo ƙarshen su ko ta yaya ba a so.
Fiction #2: Sabuwar Lunar China lokaci ne mai ban tsoro
Callahan ya koma wurin da aka fi so na keɓe-har zuwa rigakafin rigakafi daga daidai shekaru uku da suka gabata: Sabuwar Lunar a China. Saboda balaguron “babban” balaguro, “tsarin zirga-zirgar ababen hawa, yanayin hunturu da kuma taron jama’a iri-iri,” Callahan ya gaya mana “Sabuwar Shekarar Lunar wani siminti ne na tebur na gama gari don horar da jami’an kiwon lafiyar jama’a.” Me game da ainihin duniyar? Shin muna da wata hujja cewa ta yi bala'i a 2020? kamar yadda manyan kafafen yada labarai suka yi gargadin, ko zai zama bala'i a 2023?
Bugu da ƙari, idan Sabuwar Shekarar Lunar ta yi balaguro a cikin 2020 an riga an fitar da Covid zuwa ko'ina (mun san cewa a lokacin da aka fara kulle-kullen a China a ranar 23 ga Janairu, 2020, kwayar cutar ta riga ta yadu zuwa kusan kowane lardin kasar Sin, da sauran ƙasashe da yawa) - menene amfanin kulle-kulle a cikin takamaiman yanki ɗaya ko biyu don ɗaukar yaduwarsa a duniya? Kuma idan ya bazu ko'ina, gami da a cikin China, duk da kulle-kulle, ta yaya za mu yarda da mutuwar mutuwar shekaru uku?
Fiction #3: mafi haɗari subvariant
Tun daga Delta, bambance-bambancen karatu da sauye-sauye sun samar tushen tsoro mara ƙarewa don keɓe kai-har zuwa rigakafin junta. A cikin op-ed nasa, Callahan yayi da'awar da ba ta da tabbas cewa "XBB1.5" shine "mafi kamuwa da cuta har zuwa yau." Babu magana, don haka ban tabbata daga ina bayanin ya fito ba. na samu likita daya a Arewacin Carolina yana mai cewa "da alama shine ya fi kamuwa da cuta" ba tare da wani bayanai masu ma'ana don tallafawa da'awar ba. Wani jami'in WHO ya ce shi ne "mafi watsawa" (kuma, babu lambobi ko bayanai) amma ya kara da "babu wata alama da ke sa mutane su fi rashin lafiya fiye da na baya."
Kamar yadda ya kasance gaskiya ga SARS-CoV-2 da kowane ɗayan maye gurbinsa, kuma kamar yadda yake ga kowace cuta mai yaduwa da ɗan adam ya taɓa fuskanta: Idan ba ta da kisa sosai ga yawancin mutane, tana iya kamuwa da al'ummar duniya gaba ɗaya yayin da ke haifar da ƙarancin cuta ko mutuwa.
Dr. Callahan ya san haka. Callahan mai yada farfaganda yana amfani da gwada da gaskiya biodefense network's dabara na yawan ambaton manyan lambobi (ba tare da la'akari da rashin lafiya ko mutuwa ba) don aika kafofin watsa labarai da jama'a cikin fargaba.
Fiction #4: alluran rigakafi suna aiki
Na gaba, Callahan ya ce Amurka tana da yawan allurar rigakafi ta amfani da "maganin rigakafi." Idan yana nufin cutar ta SARS-CoV-2 ta asali, Callahan na iya tono wasu shaidu (ko da yake yana da matukar fa'ida). Amma idan yana nufin a kan wannan subvariant, ba shi da wata hujja, kuma ya sani.
Fiction #5: wasu alluran rigakafi (namu) sun fi wasu (nasu)
"Ayyukan da aka yi a cikin gida na kasar Sin," in ji Callahan, "na iya ba da kariya mai ɗorewa daga kwayar cutar da bambance-bambancen ta."
Tun da ya ce "maiyuwa," wannan a fili kawai hasashe ne. Tunda mun san alluran rigakafinmu suna bayarwa a mafi yawan 'yan watanni na kariya daga nau'in asali (sake, bayanin da za a iya yin takara) kuma babu ɗaya daga kowane bambance-bambancen ko rabe-rabe bayan haka, ma'anar "ƙananan kariyar dawwama" asali ita ce "kasa da sifili," wanda kuma ba shi da ma'ana.
Koyaya, a matsayin memba na keɓancewar-har zuwa hanyar rigakafin ƙwayoyin cuta, Callahan yana amfani da wannan yanki na farfagandar don ƙarfafa lamarin da ke aiki da kulle-kulle da alluran rigakafin.
Yadda kowa zai yarda da irin wannan almara mai ruɗi asiri ne.
Rubutun wasiƙar: ba labari mai ban tsoro sosai
Faɗin faɗaɗa na sa ido gabaɗaya, da nazarin halittu musamman, yana ɗaya daga cikin manyan nasarorin da al'umma suka samu a lokacin Covid, kuma Callahan yana sarrafa haɗa da filogi don ƙarin:
A watan Disamba, aƙalla wani kantin magani na kan layi a China ya fara siyar da maganin Covid Paxlovid, wanda kamfanin harhada magunguna na Amurka Pfizer ya yi, kai tsaye ga marasa lafiya. Kantin sayar da kantin sayar da Paxlovid ga duk wani dan kasar Sin da ke da ingantaccen gwajin coronavirus. Idan gwamnatin Beijing za ta ɗaure tsarin bayar da rahoton sakamakon gwajin gida na gwamnati ga masu ba da isar gida na Paxlovid na kasuwanci, za a iya ceton rayuka da yawa.
Idan wani yana mamakin dalilin da yasa yake da mahimmanci a yi karya da fallasa duk almara da farfagandar ajanda na Covid biosecurity, wannan ƙaramin taga cikin hangen nesa mai ban tsoro da suke da shi game da makomarmu ita ce amsar.
-
Debbie Lerman, 2023 Brownstone Fellow, yana da digiri a Turanci daga Harvard. Ita marubuciyar kimiyya ce mai ritaya kuma ƙwararren mai fasaha a Philadelphia, PA.
Duba dukkan posts
