Yayin da gaskiya game da tsawaita rufe makarantu da kuma tilasta wa yara kanana rufe fuska ya zama abin da ba za a iya musantawa ba, hare-haren da ake kaiwa kan mu da muka yi magana da wuri kuma sau da yawa a kan waɗannan halaye masu tayar da hankali sun tsananta. Matata, Jennifer Sey, ta gamu da wannan abin farin ciki kwanan nan.
A ranar 28 ga Afrilu, Bloomberg Businessweek ya buga wani turgid buga yanki wanda da alama an rubuta shi ne don kawai dalilin sa Jennifer ya zama "masu hankali" da yaudara, da kuma kwatanta ra'ayoyinta a matsayin "mafi girma."
Marubuciyar ita ce Claire Suddath, wacce kwanan nan ta tweeted cewa Jennifer "ya kashe cutar ta hanyar tweeting wasu kyawawan abubuwa."
A gaskiya ma, Jennifer kashe annoba tweeting game da mahimmancin mahimmancin kula da bukatun yara, musamman ma wadanda ba su da galihu. Babban abin da ta fi mayar da hankali a kan tweet din ta shine bayar da shawarar bude makarantu da bude wuraren wasa, da kuma adawa da aljanu da rufe bakin kananan yara.
Ga biyu daga cikin tweets na Jennifer waɗanda aka gabatar a cikin labarin don nuna cewa ra'ayoyinta suna "a can:"
"Yin shafa ɗan shekara 2 yana tabbatar da cewa jarirai suna da haɗari kuma abin tsoro."
"Sanya abin rufe fuska a kan yaro 'sigina ga duniya da yaran da kansu cewa suna da haɗari, rashin ƙarfi, da za a rufe su kuma a guje su.'"
Har ila yau, mafi kwanan nan, wannan:
A daya bangaren kuma, abin da Ms. Suddath, marubuciyar labarin, ta wallafa a shafinta na twitter a lokacin bala'in, makonni kadan kafin ta kai ga Jennifer ta nemi tattaunawa:
"Yarinya na annoba yana koyon magana kawai kuma ɗaya daga cikin kalmominta na farko shine "mask." Ba za ta iya faɗi haka ba tukuna amma ta ƙi sanya ɗaya [sic] kafin mu bar gidan, idan za ta iya yin hakan, za ku iya samun ƙarin tsawon jiran rigakafin fiye da yadda nake fata.
Ko wannan:
Zan bar muku shi don yanke shawarar wanne daga cikin biyun yake da ra'ayi da ke "a wajen."
Dangane da ra'ayoyin Jennifer game da mahimmancin bude makarantu, akwai a yanzu ijma'i da yawa cewa rufe makarantun jama'a na tsawon watanni 17 na California, mafi tsayi a cikin al'umma, sun kasance masu adawa da yara, marasa ilimin kimiya, masu girman kai, da kuskure.
Ms. Suddath ba za ta kasance cikin wannan yarjejeniya ba, amma yawancin masu jefa ƙuri'a na San Francisco sun zama kamar sun yarda, lokacin da suka tuno mambobin Hukumar Makaranta 3 watanni biyu da suka gabata a wani zaɓe na musamman da ba a taɓa yin irinsa ba. Shin duk waɗannan masu jefa ƙuri'a na San Francisco "a can" ma?
Idan aka yi la’akari da yadda marubuciyar ta nuna son kai ga ra’ayin Jennifer, ba ta ga kamar wanda ya dace ya rubuta wannan labarin ba, idan manufar ita ce gaskiya da amincin aikin jarida. Amma burin a maimakon haka shi ne, a fili, don samar da wani nau'i mai ban sha'awa, kuma a cikin wannan Ms. Suddath ta yi nasara.
Bloomberg ya buga labarin da ke cike da kurakurai, ƙetare, da ɓarna, manya da ƙanana. Waɗannan kurakurai, tsallakewa, da ɓarna duk suna tafiya a hanya ɗaya - duk suna da alama an tsara su don sa Jennifer ta yi kyau.
Misali, Jennifer duka sun yi kuma sun bayyana a cikin shirin Dan wasa A, wani fim mai ban sha'awa wanda ya fallasa cin zarafin yara a cikin manyan wasannin motsa jiki. Dan wasa A ta sami nasarar Emmy don Fitaccen Littafin Bincike, kuma shigar Jennifer ya nuna cewa tana da dogon tarihin bayar da shawarwari da aiki don tallafawa matasa. Dan wasa A an sake shi a watan Yuni na 2020, kuma Jennifer ta lashe Emmy saboda rawar da ta taka wajen samar da shi a watan Oktoba na 2021. Me ya sa ba a ambaci ɗayan waɗannan a cikin labarin da ke da tsayin kalmomi kusan 54,000 kuma ya ƙunshi ainihin lokacin rayuwar Jennifer?
Labarin ya tattauna wani muhimmin ganawar sirri tsakanin Jennifer da Shugabar Lawi Chip Bergh. Jennifer ta yi magana kuma ta rubuta wa Ms. Suddath sau da yawa game da wannan taron. Mista Bergh bai taba yin magana a bainar jama'a game da abin da ya faru ba.
A cewar labarin, bai yi magana da shi ba Kasuwanci kwata-kwata. To, menene “bisa ga na Lawi” yake nufi a nan? Lawi ba zai iya magana ba. Wanda a Lawi ya yi magana da Kasuwanci game da taron? Ta yaya wannan mutumin ko mutane za su san abin da ya faru a taron? Ina suke Businessweek's matsayin aikin jarida?
A cikin himmarsu na bata sunan Jennifer a bainar jama'a, Ms. Suddath da Bloomberg sun yi watsi da kowane irin ka'idojin aikin jarida. Don haka, na rubuta cikakken wasiƙar ƙara zuwa Editan Matsayi na Duniya na Labaran Bloomberg. Ta amsa cewa "sun tsaya kan labarin kamar yadda aka buga."
Ina jin ku, Bloomberg Standards. Kuna tsayawa kan ikirarin Claire Suddath mara tushe a farkon labarin da Jennifer Sey ta yi ta tweeted "karya mai kumburi." Da kyau a sani.
Irin wannan mummunan gazawar na bin ƙa'idodin aikin jarida ya kamata ya shafe mu duka. Tsawaita abin da muka gani a duk lokacin bala'in, saboda yawancin 'yan jarida sun kasa yin aikinsu yadda ya kamata.
Maimakon su kalubalanci sanarwar gwamnati, kiwon lafiya, da jami'an kamfanoni, sun sanya masu rashin amincewa a matsayin dodo. Maimakon su yi tambayoyi da labaran da suka yi yawa, sai suka yi ta yin katsalandan ga duk wani sabani da aka saba da shi a zamanin. Maimakon su yi aiki a matsayin masu ba da shawara ga mutane, sun yi aiki a matsayin kuyangi na masana'antar harhada magunguna. Maimakon yin tambayoyi, sai suka sake farfaganda.
Idan 'yan jarida kaɗan sun gabatar da sanarwar manema labarai daga CDC da Pfizer kamar dai su Dokoki Goma ne, watakila da makarantun jama'a na California sun buɗe shekara guda a baya, kamar makarantu masu zaman kansu na California.
-
Daniel Kotzin tsohon lauya ne a California kuma likitan yaki a cikin Sojojin Isra'ila. A halin yanzu shi uban zama ne a gida kuma mai kare hakkin dan adam a Colorado. Ga nasa substack
Duba dukkan posts
