A ranar Asabar, shugaban kasar Biden ya wallafa a shafinsa na Twitter: "Daya daga cikin sana'o'in da aka fi ƙima a Amurka shine aikin jinya. Ma'aikatan jinya ba kawai taimaka muku rayuwa ba, suna sa ku sha'awar rayuwa. Wannan makon ma'aikatan jinya na ƙasa, bari mu yi murna kuma mu yaba duk abin da suke yi don ba da kulawa ta jin kai."
Sai dai lokacin da 'yan siyasa kamar Biden ke lalata rayuwarsu da ayyukansu. A cikin Satumba 2021, Biden ya ba da shawarar cewa kowane Ba'amurke da ke aiki a cikin kiwon lafiya dole ne ya sami allurar rigakafin Covid. Dubban ma'aikatan jinya sun rasa ayyukansu bayan sun ki mika wuya ga umarninsa. Ba kamar ƙasashen Turai ba, gwamnatin Biden ta zaɓi yin watsi da kariyar da mutane suka mallaka bayan murmurewa daga Covid. Madadin haka, ma'aikatan kiwon lafiya miliyan 17 da sauran ma'aikata miliyan 84 masu zaman kansu an jefa su a kan bagadin hadaya a zaman wani bangare na farfagandar Biden don nuna alluran rigakafin a matsayin kawai kariya daga Covid.
An yi wa waɗannan hukunce-hukunce a kotunan ƙararrakin ƙararrakin tarayya kafin su sauka a Kotun Koli a ranar 7 ga Janairu, 2022. A wannan lokacin, an sami ƙarin sabbin shari'o'in Covid sama da miliyan ɗaya da aka ba da rahoton kowace rana, galibi a cikin mutanen da ba su da cikakkiyar fa'ida. Lambobin shari'o'in da suka taso sun farfado da gazawar allurar. Tasirin harbin mai kara kuzari na Covid ya ragu zuwa kashi 31 a lokacin da Kotun ta saurari kararrakin.
Masanin kimiyya mai lambar yabo ta Nobel Luc Montagnier ya lura a cikin Wall Street Journal cewa allurar Moderna da Pfizer bayan kwanaki 30 ba su da "ilimin kididdiga muhimmanci sakamako mai kyau akan kamuwa da cutar Omicron, kuma bayan kwanaki 90, tasirin su bai yi kyau ba—watau mutanen da aka yi wa alurar riga kafi sun fi kamuwa da kamuwa da Omicron.” Daga baya CDC ta yarda da hakan kusan rabi Mutuwar Covid a farkon 2022 na daga cikin cikakkiyar vaxxed.
Amma shawarar da Kotun Koli ta yi game da umarnin Biden ya faru ne a cikin wata sabuwar duniyar da ta ɗauka cewa allurar rigakafin Covid ta yi aiki. Tarihi da wuce gona da iri na hadari ya dauki matakin tsakiya. Mai shari'a Sonya Sotomayor ta yi kuka: "Muna da yara sama da dubu ɗari (tare da Covid) - waɗanda ba mu taɓa samun su ba - cikin mawuyacin hali kuma da yawa suna kan na'urorin hura iska."
A zahiri, ƙasa da yara 3,500 a duk faɗin ƙasar an kwantar da su tare da Covid - ƙasa da waɗanda ake kwantar da su a asibiti kowane mako don tonsillitis. Mai shari'a Stephen Breyer ya nuna cewa alluran rigakafin na iya hana duk wasu kararraki 750,000 da ke faruwa a kullum ta hanyar mu'ujiza. Mai shari'a Elena Kagan ta bayyana cewa manufar Biden tana gaya wa masu ba da lafiya "abu daya da ba za ku iya yi ba shi ne ku kashe majinyatan ku." Dole ne ma'aikata su yi allurar rigakafi, in ji Kagan, "domin kar ku yada cutar da za ta iya kashe tsofaffi marasa lafiya na Medicare…. Ba za ku iya zama mai ɗaukar cuta ba."
Alkalan Kotun Koli ba su damu da ci gaba da bayyana manufofin Covid na tarayya ba. Na zayyana wadancan gazawar da rashin hankali na umarnin rigakafin a cikin wani USA Today wani yanki wanda ya bayyana a safiyar ranar muhawarar baka ta Kotun Koli:
Ma'aikatan jinya masu cutar COVID suna a asibitocinmu. Amma umarnin Biden ya hana wadanda ba a yi musu allurar ba.
The A ranar Juma'a ne kotun koli za ta saurari kalubale ga umarnin Shugaba Biden na rigakafin, gami da umarninsa na sama da miliyan 10 ma'aikatan kiwon lafiya don samun allurar rigakafin COVID-19. Ana kalubalantar wannan wa'adin manyan lauyoyin jihar da yawa. Wannan shari'ar na iya zama abin damuwa kan makomar 'yancin ɗan adam yayin da kuma bayan cutar ta COVID-19.
Gwamnatin Biden ta ci gaba da bayyana alluran rigakafin cutar a matsayin annoba. A watan Yuli, Biden alkawari, "Ba za ku sami COVID ba idan kuna da waɗannan rigakafin." A lokacin da ya bayyana shirin sanya wa'adin a wani jawabi na ranar 9 ga Satumba, Biden ayyana "akwai guda daya kacal da aka tabbatar da inganci a cikin Amurkawa 5,000 da aka yi wa cikakkiyar allurar rigakafin kowace rana. Kuna da lafiya kamar yadda zai yiwu."
Biden ya yi nuni da ingancin rigakafin a wani bangare saboda Cibiyar Kula da Cututtuka da Cututtuka ta daina kirga yawancin cututtukan cututtukan da suka faru watanni da yawa da suka gabata. The Washington Post ruwaito cewa CDC's "mafi yawan kididdigar rosy na tasirin allurar rigakafin cutar kan delta… na iya sanya Amurkawa cikin rashin tsaro."
Alurar rigakafi ba za su kawo karshen wannan annoba ba
Sama da rabin ma'aikatan kiwon lafiya sun riga sun kamu da cututtukan COVID-19 kuma fiye da kashi 99 daga cikinsu sun tsira. Koyaya, umarnin Biden ya ɗauka cewa alluran rigakafi sune tushen ingantaccen lafiya da kariya kuma an yi watsi da rigakafin cutar bayan kamuwa da cuta saboda gane "rashin tabbas… dangane da ƙarfi da tsayin (na halitta) rigakafi."
Duk da haka, babban binciken Isra'ila a watan Agusta an gano cewa mutanen da ke da COVID-19 suna da mafi kyawun kariya daga bambance-bambancen Delta fiye da mutanen da suka sami allurar rigakafin COVID-19 da yawa.
Bisa ga taƙaitaccen bayani daga jihohin Missouri da Nebraska, umarnin Biden "yana barazanar lalacewar tattalin arziki da cutar da haƙuri a ko'ina cikin masana'antar (kiwon lafiya)" da "zai haifar da mummunan sakamako akan (kiwon lafiya) musamman a cikin yankunan karkara." Babban Lauyan Louisiana Jeff Landry ya caccaki gwamnatin Biden saboda baiwa ma'aikatan kiwon lafiya "jab ko aiki” ultimatum.
Sanarwar Rajista ta Tarayya game da sabon wa'adin ta yi watsi da damuwa game da asarar ma'aikatan kiwon lafiya saboda "babu isassun shaida don ƙididdigewa"Tasirin. A duk faɗin ƙasar, dubban ma'aikatan kiwon lafiya An kori saboda ƙin yin allura, gami da da yawa waɗanda ke da rigakafi na halitta bayan sun tsira daga cututtukan COVID-19. A New York, wani asibiti ya rufe dakin haihuwa da kuma daina haihuwa saboda karancin ma’aikatan jinya da aka yi musu allurar. Kuma tsarin kiwon lafiya daya shine rage zaɓe da tiyatar gaggawa da rage maganin rediyo a wani bangare saboda asarar ma'aikatan lafiya saboda umarnin rigakafin.
Biden amsa ga karancin ma'aikata masu mahimmanci ta hanyar shirin tura sojojin Amurka 1,000 don taimakawa asibitoci.
Hukuncin hauka
A cikin takaitaccen bayani ga Kotun Koli, gwamnatin Biden ta bayyana cewa rigakafin umarni ya kasance "mahimmanci don hana barkewar (COVID-19) wanda ya lalata wuraren shiga Medicare- da Medicaid a farkon cutar."
Koyaya, makonni biyu da suka gabata, CDC ya canza jagorarsa ta baya game da ma'aikatan kiwon lafiya da ke ware bayan gwajin inganci na COVID-19, kuma sun ce za a iya rage lokacin keɓe idan akwai ƙarancin ma'aikata. Yanzu, wasu Ma'aikatan jinya masu COVID-19 a duk fadin kasar ana gaya wa su shigo aiki su yi wa marasa lafiya magani, ko da har yanzu suna da alamun cutar.
Dangane da manufofin gwamnatin Biden, yana da kyau ga marasa lafiya a asibiti a yi musu magani Ma'aikatan jinya da ma'aikata masu inganci na COVID (wanda rigakafin COVID-19 ya kasa kare su daga cutar) fiye da na ma'aikatan jinya da ba su da rigakafin cutar ba tare da COVID-XNUMX ba.
Sabuwar manufar ta harzuka ma'aikatan jinya a fadin kasar. Zenei Triunfo-Cortez, shugaban ma'aikatan jinya na kasa United, ya yi tir da sabuwar manufar: "Raunana jagorar COVID-19 a yanzu, ta fuskar abin da zai iya zama mafi muni na COVID-19 tukuna, zai kasance. kawai yana haifar da ƙarin watsawa, rashin lafiya da mutuwa. "
Matsayin rigakafin ya tafi daga zama wakili don lafiya zuwa zama madadin manufofin kula da lafiya mai hankali.
Manufar Biden ta COVID-19 ta ci gaba da yin watsi da kwararar shaidun da ke ƙarƙashin hurumin sa.
Biden kwanan nan ayyana cewa "kusan duk wanda ya mutu daga COVID-19 a cikin watanni da yawa da suka gabata ba a yi masa allurar ba." Amma da Cikakken allurar rigakafin ya kai kashi 21 zuwa kashi 27 na mace-macen COVID-19 a Oregon daga Agusta zuwa Nuwamba; Kashi 40 zuwa kusan kashi 75 na mace-mace a Vermont daga Agusta zuwa Oktoba.
A cikin wata hira ta talabijin kwanan nan, Biden ya bayyana, "Yaya game da ku tabbatar an yi muku alurar riga kafi, don haka kada ku yada cutar ga wani." Amma Daraktan CDC Rochelle Walensky shigar da shi a cikin Agusta: "Abin da (alurar rigakafin COVID-19) ba zai iya yi ba shine hana yaduwa."
Biden kwanan nan amsa zuwa adadin rikodin sabbin shari'o'in COVID ta hanyar cewa "babu wanda ya ga (bambance-bambancen Omicron) yana zuwa." Da yawa masana kimiyya sun yi gargadin sabbin bambance-bambancen, amma wannan a fili bai taba nunawa akan allon radar fadar White House ba. Rikicin da ya barke a cikin kararraki ya karu da gazawar Biden cika alkawarinsa don samun sauƙin zuwa gwajin COVID-19….
Kusan shekara guda da ta gabata, Biden ya yi alkawari a jawabinsa na farko ga "shawo kan wannan cuta mai kisa.” Biden shigar a watan da ya gabata cewa babu "babu mafita na tarayya (ga COVID-19) ana magance wannan a matakin jiha." Shigar da Biden ya ba da cikakkiyar hujja ga Kotun Koli don yin watsi da sabon bugun daji na Biden don kawo karshen cutar.
A ranar 13 ga Janairu, 2022, Kotun ta kada kuri'a 6 zuwa 3 don soke umarnin Biden na rigakafin ga duk ma'aikata masu zaman kansu na manyan kamfanoni. Koyaya, Kotun ta kuma kada kuri'ar amincewa da wa'adin rigakafin ga ma'aikatan kiwon lafiya miliyan 17 da kuri'u 5 zuwa 4. Hukuncin ya ayyana, “Tabbatar da cewa masu samar da kayayyaki sun dauki matakai don guje wa yada kwayar cuta mai hatsari ga majiyyatan su ya yi daidai da ka’idar aikin likitanci: na farko, kada ku cutar da su.” Amma an keɓance masu tsara manufofin tarayya daga gargaɗin "kada ku cutar da su" sun yi watsi da shawarar Biden ga ma'aikatan jinya na Covid waɗanda suka shafe shari'ar doka da ta ɗabi'a jim kaɗan bayan sanarwar. The Lancet, ɗaya daga cikin mujallun likitanci da ake girmamawa a duniya, an tsara shi cewa ma'aikatan kiwon lafiya da suka murmure daga Covid ya kamata a keɓe su daga umarnin vax.
Ma'aikatan jinya waɗanda aka kora saboda ƙin allurar rigakafin Covid sun kasance waɗanda ba a yi su ba na manufofin Biden na Covid. Tsakanin 2020 zuwa 2022, daya cikin biyar lafiya ma'aikatan kulawa sun bar aikinsu. Wani bincike na Ƙungiyar Lauyoyin Amurka na Yuli 2022 ya lura cewa "ma'aikatan jinya na iya samun ɗaya daga cikin mafi girman jinkirin rates don maganin. Manyan dalilan ƙin yarda sune damuwa game da amincin maganin, inganci, da illolinsa. Har ila yau, akwai rashin amincewa a cikin gwamnati da kamfanonin magunguna… "An tabbatar da ma'aikatan jinya na wary tare da bayyanar illolin maganin rigakafi da kuma yaudarar gwamnati.
Wautar masu tsara manufofin yin watsi da rigakafi ta dabi'a ta bayyana a fili har ga mutanen da a baya da himma suka goyi bayan manufofin Covid. Dokta Leana Wen, a Washington Post marubuci, ya rubuta a watan Disamba, "Binciken Lancet ya gano cewa wadanda aka yi wa allurar rigakafin amma ba su taba samun cutar ta covid ba sun ninka sau 4 suna fama da mummunar rashin lafiya da ke haifar da asibiti ko mutuwa idan aka kwatanta da wadanda ba a yi musu allurar ba da suka murmure." Amma hakan ba ta’aziyya ba ne ga mutanen da suka yi hasarar sana’arsu domin sun ƙi yin biyayya ga dokar tarayya da ba ta dace ba.
Gwamnatin Biden za ta yi kawo karshen wa'adin rigakafin ga ma'aikatan kiwon lafiya a ranar 11 ga Mayu. Amma kada ku yi tsammanin 'yan siyasa da masu mulki za su girmama dokar "Farko, Kada ku cutar da ita" a nan gaba. A cikin Beltway, dokar tarayya za ta iya ci gaba da kasancewa "kusa da aikin gwamnati" ga manufofin kula da lafiya.
-
James Bovard, 2023 Brownstone Fellow, marubuci ne kuma malami wanda sharhinsa ya yi niyya ga misalan sharar gida, gazawa, cin hanci da rashawa, cin hanci da rashawa da cin zarafi a cikin gwamnati. Shi mawallafin USA Today ne kuma mai yawan ba da gudummawa ne ga The Hill. Shi ne marubucin littattafai goma, gami da Haƙƙin Ƙarshe: Mutuwar 'Yancin Amurka.
Duba dukkan posts
