Waɗannan ba ɗigon ruwa bane da kuke nema.
Tare da kaɗa hannunsa, Obi-Wan Kenobi ya sa tunani da zato suka ɓace.
Idan ya zo ga Covid, shine abin da ƙungiyar magunguna ke ƙoƙarin yi a yanzu.
Da kyau, a'a.
A cikin wani yanki na kwanan nan a cikin New York Times, Dr. Rachel Bedard - wanda ya ƙware a "maganin magani da shari'ar laifuka" - ya ce duniya na bukatar ci gaba daga dukkan bala'in Covid, da martanin cutar, da kuma lalata 'yanci.
A cikin gunaguni game da yiwuwar cewa Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. za a nada ta wani - tsoro! - Mai yuwuwar gwamnatin Donald Trump, tana da wannan cewa:
Kwayar cutar ta Covid-19 ta kasance rikicin rarrabuwar kawuna ga Amurkawa. Ina damuwa cewa nada Mista Kennedy a babban aikin kiwon lafiya zai haifar da hauka, rashin amfani, halayen halayen mutum wanda ya mamaye siyasar lafiya da likitanci a farkon rabin farkon wannan shekaru goma, musamman bayan-Covid…
Tabbas nan gaba za ta kawo rikice-rikicen kiwon lafiyar jama'a da za a iya tsinkaya da kuma ba zato ba tsammani waɗanda za su buƙaci sanyi, gogaggen, jagoranci mara fa'ida. Idan aka nada Mista Kennedy a gwamnatin tarayya, da wuya ya yi amfani da karfinsa wajen rage zafi. Ya kamata mu koya daga abin da annoba ta bayyana game da rarrabuwar kawuna na al'adunmu. Idan Mista Kennedy yana cikin gwamnati, ina tsoron ba za mu taba yin hakan ba.
Girman kai a gefe, ra'ayin Bedard yana kururuwa tilasta mantuwa. Yayin da ta iya da'awar matsayinta game da samun damar "koyi" daga cutar, maganganunta sun musanta hakan.
Sigar koyonta game da koyan yadda za a amince da rukunin lafiyar jama'a wanda ya yi wa duniya ƙarya na tsawon shekaru biyu - da ƙirgawa - shekaru game da haɗari, asali, da yuwuwar jiyya ga Covid.
Bedard ya yarda cewa an buga siyasa da yawa da yawa kuma watakila irin maganganun maganganun da aka yi daga irin su Anthony Fauci sun kasance masu "rubutu" maimakon "lallashi," wanda ita ce hanya mafi kyau don gudanar da tattaunawa a tsakanin kowace matsalar lafiyar jama'a, daga annoba. zuwa ban mamaki go bayyana a cikin jama'a pool.
Ta ce kalaman RFK, Jr. game da iko ne maimakon “launi” da ake buƙata don haka bai dace da ofishin ba.
Mutum yana ɗaukan mutum zai iya maye gurbin "nuance" da 'Ina bin umarni ne kawai,' amma, ko ta yaya, Bedard whitewashes laifi sannan - saboda dalilai masu fa'ida kawai - ya shiga cikin tantanin halitta game da ɗanyen madara.
Pejorative saboda yana ganin cewa mutanen da suka wuce yarda da zamantakewa "gona zuwa tebur" da "marasa GMO" da "ƙwararrun kwayoyin halitta" don neman ra'ayoyin abinci masu tsabta su ne mutanen da ba su da hankali waɗanda ke jefa sauran jama'a cikin haɗari, ko da yake sauran jama'a za su iya tsayawa tare da abubuwa kamar pasteurized moo juice.
Yana da wani ja maras sequitur herring, da gangan hada da kokarin dunkula iri-iri iri-iri na zayyana mahaukata mutane tare.
Nadin Kennedy, Bedard frets, zai haifar da mutane su tuna abin da ya faru yayin bala'in kuma yana iya haifar da bincike kan ainihin dalilin da ya sa hakan ya faru.
Kuma hakan zai zama mummunan saboda ba zai ba da izinin tilasta yin afuwa ba, buƙatar Babban Mantawa.
Kafin wannan, mutanen da suka yi kyau sosai yayin bala'in sun nemi "Ayi afuwa" ga kwararrun masana kiwon lafiyar jama'a wadanda suka jagoranci kokarin da ma'aikatansu masu ban tsoro wadanda suka yi abubuwa kamar yi wa mutanen da ba sa sanya abin rufe fuska kuma suka ki barin dangin su halarta. Godiya idan ba a yi musu allurar ba.
Hujjar - masanin tattalin arziki na Jami'ar Brown Emily Oster, wanda babu wanda ya taɓa jin labarin kafin barkewar cutar - don yin afuwa shine "kowa ya yi iya ƙoƙarinsa, babu wanda ya yi wani abu da gangan da gangan, mun fi sani da kyau, mu ba mugaye ba ne, ba mu sani ba da gaske..."
Wato, mun yi iya ƙoƙarinmu, mun yi kyau, ba za mu iya yin jituwa ba?
An biya hubris na hujjar Oster ta hanyar kallo mai sauƙi game da abin da cutar ta yi:
Girman lalacewar tarbiyya. Barnar tattalin arziki, ta hanyar kulle-kulle da kuma yanzu ci gaba da bala'in kasafin kudi da ke addabar al'umma sakamakon ci gaba da daukar matakin gwamnatin tarayya. Mummunan lalacewa ga haɓaka ƙwarewar zamantakewar yara ta hanyar rufe fuska da tsoro. Rushe amanar jama'a ga cibiyoyi saboda gazawarsu da yaudara a lokacin bala'in. Babban lalacewar 'yancin ɗan adam. Wahalhalun da suke haifarwa kai tsaye sakamakon wajabcin allurar rigakafi da sauransu a qarqashin da’awar qarya ta taimakon makwabci. Fashewar ci gaban Wall Street da aka gina akan lalata Main Street. Bayyanar rabuwar al'umma zuwa sansanoni biyu - waɗanda za su iya samun sauƙi cikin sauƙi yayin bala'in da waɗanda rayuwarsu ta inganta gaba ɗaya. Shaidanun duk wanda ya kuskura ya yi ko da tambayoyi na asali game da ingancin martanin, walau alluran rigakafin su kansu, rufe makarantun gwamnati, asalin kwayar cutar, ko rashin amfani da gidan wasan kwaikwayo na jama'a wanda ya kunshi yawancin shirin. Rikicin da aka haifar a cikin al'umma da kuma cutar da mu'amalar da ke tsakanin dangi da abokai. Zagi da hargitsin sana'a da fitattun masana suka jure (duba littafin Babban Sanarwa na Barrington) kuma kawai mutane masu hankali suna so Jennifer Seyi don jajircewa don ba da hanyoyi daban-daban, hanyoyin - kamar mai da hankali kan mafi rauni - waɗanda ke da an gwada kuma an yi nasara a baya.
Abin da Oster ya manta - da kuma abin da Bedard ke son kowa ya manta da shi har abada - shi ne gaskiyar cewa, duk da jarumtakar ƙoƙarin kafa lafiyar jama'a, har yanzu mutane miliyan sun mutu.
Lura game da amfani da adadi miliyan ɗaya:
Gaskiya ne cewa adadin mutanen da suka mutu "daga Covid" kadai kuma / ko da farko, ba shakka, babu kusan miliyan daya - tabbas tabbas ko CDC gefen-baki ce ta yarda da hakan a yanzu.
Cututtuka da kuma tsufa sun taka rawar gani sosai a cikin adadin da kwayar cutar ta yi, sannan kuma akwai mutanen da suka mutu a wani hatsarin mota kuma aka gwada lafiya a asibiti kuma an jera su a matsayin masu mutuwa na Covid, da sauransu.
Wannan batu wani babban abin kunya ne da ba za mu san ainihin gaskiya ba tsawon shekaru.
Amma na zaɓi adadin miliyan ɗaya saboda abin da suke - masana, "masana kimiyya," jami'an kiwon lafiyar jama'a, masu kamuwa da cutar, kafofin watsa labaru, da dai sauransu da / ko duk mutanen da suka yi wa jama'a ƙarya kuma suka haifar da rushewar al'umma - suna amfani da shi azaman adadi.
Kuma tun da su - Oster ba ita kaɗai ke tunani kamar yadda ta yi ba - suna da'awar cewa sun yi iyakar abin da za su iya, suna da kyakkyawar niyya, sun yi ƙoƙari sosai don haka don Allah kada ku zalunce mu, yana buƙatar tambaya: idan mutane miliyan ɗaya, kamar yadda kuka ce, sun mutu yayin da kuke yin iya ƙoƙarinku, daidai yadda kuka kasance a wurin aikinku, me zai sa wani ya amince da ku game da wani abu har abada, kuma me yasa kowa zai yi amfani da wannan tsarin kuma ya gafarta masa. kalma daidai – dissembling? Kuma wannan ba ma la'akari da gaskiyar cewa yanzu kun yarda kun SAN barnar da ba dole ba da ku ke haifarwa yayin da kuke yin ta?
A takaice dai, idan za su yi da'awar cutar ta yi tsanani sosai ta yi asarar rayuka miliyan, hakan ya sa bukatar "afiya" ta fi rashin fahimta.
Kuma kar a manta cewa mutanen da suka nemi afuwa kuma, lokacin da aka yi dariya daga ginin, yanzu suna neman afuwa, kuma, sun yi kyau yayin bala'in.
Oster ta rike aikinta. Oster ya shahara. Cutar ta yi kyau ga Oster.
Barkewar cutar ta kuma yi kyau ga ma'aikata, 'yan ƙasa da yawa, ƙwararrun masana, kafofin watsa labarai marasa tunani, da zagin intanet. Yana da kyau a farke manya masu son zama yara, yana da kyau ga tsaro na masana'antu na ƙasa, yana da kyau ga fakewa, yana da kyau don faɗaɗa ikon al'umma.
Bai yi kyau ga mutane ba.
Dr. Bedard - ba za mu taba mantawa da hakan ba. Kuma kar a sake tambaya.
-
Thomas Buckley shine tsohon magajin garin Lake Elsinore, Cal. Babban Aboki a Cibiyar Siyasa ta California, kuma tsohon mai ba da rahoto na jarida. A halin yanzu shi ne ma’aikacin karamar cibiyar sadarwa da shawarwari kuma ana iya samunsa kai tsaye a planbuckley@gmail.com. Kuna iya karanta ƙarin aikin nasa a shafin Substack ɗin sa.
Duba dukkan posts
