Wani alkali wanda a baya ya ba da shawarar shari'a ga Pfizer ya toshe ƙalubalen shari'a kan allurar Moderna's da Pfizer's mRNA Covid, tare da dakatar da ƙoƙarin tayar da ƙararrawa game da zarge-zargen kwayoyin da ba a daidaita su ba (GMOs), gami da manyan matakan gurɓatawar DNA, a cikin vials.
Korar karar da aka yi kan al'amarin tsayawa shi ne na baya-bayan nan a cikin jerin shari'o'in da ke da alaka da rigakafin cutar ta Covid da kotunan Australiya suka fitar kan fasahohin da aka fassara, suna tayar da tambayoyi game da amincin kotuna a cikin sasanta rikice-rikicen da suka shafi manyan bukatu na magunguna.
Masanin harhada magunguna na Victoria kuma Babban Likita (GP) Dr Julian Fidge ya shigar da karar a watan Yulin shekarar da ta gabata don hana Moderna da Pfizer rarraba kayayyakinsu a Ostiraliya saboda zargin suna dauke da kwayoyin halittar da ba a amince da su ba (GMOs). Babban laifi ne a karkashin hukumar Dokar Fasaha ta Gene (2000) don "ma'amala da" GMOs marasa yarda a Ostiraliya.
The karar da ake zargin cewa allurar mRNA sun ƙunshi GMOs a cikin nau'i biyu - RNA da aka gyara wanda aka nannade a cikin nanoparticles na lipid (LNP-mod-RNA complexes), da guntu na plasmid DNA gurbatawa - wanda Pfizer da Moderna ba su taɓa samun ingantaccen izini daga Ofishin Mai Kula da Fasahar Halitta (OGTR).
OGTR ya musanta cewa allurar rigakafin Pfizer da Moderna ko sun ƙunshi GMOs, ko samfuran suna buƙatar lasisi daga OGTR kafin a rarraba su a Ostiraliya, suna bayyana irin wannan iƙirarin a matsayin "bayanai" a cikin bayani wanda aka saki a watan Disambar bara.
Sai dai kuma idan har aka kai ga daukaka kara, ba za a saurari karar a Kotuna ba. A cikin hukuncin da aka yanke a ranar 1 ga Maris, Mai shari'a Rofe ya yi watsi da bukatar Dr Fidge, yana mai cewa ba shi da wani matsayi saboda ba a dauke shi a matsayin "mutumin da ya fusata" a karkashin dokar.
Amma lauyoyin Dr Fidge sun ce shawarar "ba ta ci jarabawar mashaya ba."
"Ba wai kawai an yi watsi da shari'ar ba ne bisa tsarin fasaha mai sauƙi, amma ya shafi cewa Mai Shari'a Rofe a baya ya ba da shawarar lauya ga Pfizer a matsayinta na sirri kafin nadin ta zuwa Kotun Tarayya," in ji lauya mai ba da umurni Katie Ashby-Koppens na kamfanin lauyoyi na Sydney PJ O'Brien & Associates bayan yanke hukuncin.
A matsayin daya daga cikin wadanda suka amsa karar da Dr Fidge ya shigar, Pfizer ta tsaya cin gajiyar hukuncin da mai shari’a Rofe ya yanke na yin watsi da karar. Bugu da kari, an umarci Dr Fidge ya biya kudin Pfizer da na Moderna.
Bayanan Kotun Tarayya sun nuna cewa Mai Shari'a Rofe ya ba da shawara kan ƙungiyar lauyoyin Pfizer aƙalla sau huɗu (a cikin 2003, 2004, 2005, Da kuma 2006) kafin ta kasance wanda aka nada a matsayin Alkalin Kotun Tarayya a 2021.
Ashby-Koppens ta ce, "A cikin dukkan alkalan tarayya, ba ta bukatar ta kasance a kan lamarin. Hakan ya lalata kotuna cewa an sanya Justice Rofe a kan wannan shari'a," in ji Ashby-Koppens, wadda ta yi ikirarin cewa ba a ba wa kungiyar ta lauyoyin ta shawara kan yadda mai shari'a Rofe ya yi hulda da Pfizer a baya ba a kowane lokaci a cikin aikin.
Dokta Fidge ya nuna rashin jin dadinsa kan hukuncin da Justice Rofe ya yanke na cewa ba shi da tsayawa a matsayin "mutumin da ya fusata" don gabatar da shari'ar Pfizer da Moderna. A cikin takardun shari'a, Dr Fidge ya bayar da hujjar cewa yana da matsayi a cikin ƙwararru, na sirri, na sirri, da kuma damar jama'a.
"An yi min allurar rigakafin mRNA Covid-19, kuma na yi wa dubban marasa lafiya, ciki har da 'ya'yana," Dr Fidge. ya ce a lokacin yin rajista, a cikin Yuli 2023.
"Yana da wuya a fahimci yadda ni ba mai fushi ba ne, lokacin da na kasa biyan bukatuna na doka, ɗabi'a da ɗabi'a don ba da izini ga duk majiyyata cewa za su karɓi GMOs a cikin waɗannan alluran rigakafin," in ji shi yayin da yake mayar da martani ga korar da aka yi masa.
Mai shari'a Rofe ya yanke shawarar cewa Dr Fidge ba shi da matsayi saboda gudanar da GMOs ba "ma'amala" ba ne da Dokar ta rufe, kuma "mai nema dole ne ya tabbatar da cewa korafe-korafen da zai sha a sakamakon cin zarafi ya wuce na talakawan jama'a kuma ya wuce damuwa ta tunani ko tunani."
Ashby-Koppens ya damu da cewa shawarar ta soke al'adar doka ta hanyar gabatar da tsayawa don yin watsi da wani babban matakin farar hula da aka kai kan wani kamfani saboda aikata ba daidai ba.
"Wannan ita ce yanke shawara ta baya-bayan nan a tsarin inda kotuna kawai ke kin sauraron shaida ta hanyar jefa abubuwa a farkon matakin farko," in ji ta.
"Abin da ya shafi cewa idan an gabatar da kararraki game da manyan bukatu na magunguna, kotuna ba sa barin kararrakin su wuce tushe na farko."
Laifin shari'a ɗaya ne daga cikin jerin shari'o'in da ke da alaƙa da rigakafin cutar ta Covid waɗanda membobin ƙungiyar lauyoyin Dokta Fidge suka kawo waɗanda Kotuna suka yi watsi da su kan fasahar tsari.
A kara neman soke amincewar wucin gadi na maganin rigakafin SPIKEVAX na Moderna ga jarirai da yara an yi watsi da su, a cikin wani yanke shawara da ba a taba ganin irinsa ba, a kan cewa zai “juyar da Kotun daga manyan ayyukanta,” a cikin Maris 2023.
wani kara Kotun Tarayya ta kori neman hana gudanar da allurar rigakafin Pfizer ga yara masu shekaru biyar zuwa 11 a kan batun tsayawa, a watan Yuni 2022.
Ashby-Koppens ya ce: "Irin waɗannan hukunce-hukuncen, musamman lokacin da Alƙalan da ba su bayyana rigingimun da za su iya faruwa ba, ba sa ƙarfafa bangaskiya ga kotuna."
An tuntubi Kotun Tarayya don jin ta bakinta amma ba ta amsa ba har zuwa wa’adin buga.
Tawagar lauyoyin Dr Fidge ta ce suna nazarin hukuncin mai shari'a Rofe kuma suna nazarin daukaka kara.
-
Rebekah Barnett 'yar'uwa ce ta Cibiyar Brownstone, 'yar jarida mai zaman kanta kuma mai ba da shawara ga Australiya da suka ji rauni da rigakafin Covid. Ta sami BA a cikin Sadarwa daga Jami'ar Western Australia, kuma ta rubuta wa Substack dinta, Dystopian Down Under.
Duba dukkan posts
