Kwararrun ba su yi saurin tantancewa ba, balle a ba su hakuri, ayyukan da suka yi a lokacin Covid. Na lura, sabili da haka, lokacin da manyan cibiyoyi biyu waɗanda suka jagoranci martanin barkewar cutar suka shirya wani taron na baya-bayan nan a ranar Alhamis, 6 ga Nuwamba.
Jami'ar Johns Hopkins gida ce ga sanannen cibiyar kiwon lafiya ta duniya da Makarantar Kiwon Lafiyar Jama'a ta Bloomberg. Cibiyar Harkokin Kasuwancin Amirka na ɗaya daga cikin mafi tsufa kuma mafi girma a masana'antun manufofin jama'a na Washington, DC. Dukansu sun taimaka wajen tsara manufofin cutar da kuma hangen nesa daga farkon kwanakinsa.
Kungiyoyin biyu sun yi hadin gwiwa tun shekarar da ta gabata, kuma sun tsara nasu taron farko a ranar 6 ga Nuwamba a kusa da littafin A cikin Farkawa na Covid: Yadda Siyasarmu ta Kasa Mu, wani zargi na kulle-kulle da masana kimiyyar siyasa na Princeton biyu, Frances Lee da Stephen Macedo suka rubuta.
Dangane da dagewar da suke yi game da matsayar Covid, Hopkins da AEI sun cancanci yabo don a ƙarshe nuna adawa da ra'ayi.
Mu tuna yadda ƙungiyoyin biyu suka kasance a tsakiya a farkon zamanin, da ma a da. A cikin Oktoba na 2019, Hopkins yana da, tare da Gidauniyar Bill & Melinda Gates da Taron Tattalin Arziki na Duniya, tare da haɗin gwiwa. Taron 201, wani motsa jiki na shirye-shiryen annoba na tebur. Mahalarta daga CIA, CDC na kasar Sin, da kamfanoni daban-daban na hulda da jama'a sun tattauna yadda za su gudanar da barkewar cutar sankara ta nan gaba, tare da mai da hankali musamman kan yadda za a magance "lalata" da kuma tsara halayyar jama'a. Bayan watanni biyu kawai, Covid ya buge.
Sannan, a cikin bazara na 2020, abokin aikin AEI kuma tsohon kwamishinan Hukumar Abinci da Magunguna Scott Gottlieb tare da ƙwararrun cututtukan cututtukan Johns Hopkins. tsarin kullewa. Gottlieb babban dan Republican ne mai neman kulle-kulle. A halin da ake ciki, miliyoyin mutane suna ta farfaɗo akan taswirar dashboard ɗin Intanet na Johns Hopkins, waɗanda ke ƙididdige shari'o'in Covid "kuma sun taimaka firgita a duk faɗin duniya.
Har yanzu akwai manyan ramuka a cikin fahimtar AEI da Hopkins - musamman kan rigakafin Covid - kuma zan magance waɗanda ke cikin rabin na biyu na wannan labarin. Amma na farko, abubuwa masu kyau.
The Good
"Tsarin lokacin yaƙi ya kama," in ji Frances Lee a taron na Nuwamba 6. Saƙon shine, "'Dole ne mu haɗa kai, mun zaɓi dabara.' Ba mu sami sabis na tambayoyin da suka dace ba."
"Cibiyoyin ilimi masu ilimi," Macedo ya biyo baya, "suna tura ra'ayi wanda da alama ya cancanci a yi tambaya, kuma ba a yi tambaya sosai ba."
"Babu isassun rashin yarda a cikin lafiyar jama'a," in ji Macedo. Suna fama da "hangen nesa da tunani," Lee ya biyo baya.
Macedo a taƙaice ya soki yadda ake yin katsalandan a shafukan sada zumunta, tare da lura da cewa "Ba wani taron makarantar doka ɗaya da muka sani da aka gudanar don tattauna batutuwan Gyaran Farko dangane da magana."
Marubutan sun jaddada babban lahani na shisshigin manufofin Covid - rashin auna ba kawai fa'idodin da ake tsammani ba har ma da farashi. Masu ba da shawara na kimiyya da masu tsara manufofi kawai sun musanta duk wani yuwuwar ciniki.
Macedo da Lee sun gano cewa kulle-kulle sun tashi sosai daga shawarwarin da aka riga aka kamu da cutar kuma ba su da tasiri wajen rage yaduwar cutar ko rage mace-mace. Amfanin sun yi wuya. Lockdowns ya yi, duk da haka, ya haifar da tsadar tattalin arziki da zamantakewa.
AEI's Roger Piekle, Jr., da alama ya amince da wasu ƙoƙarin "shawarar kimiyyar inuwa", kamar su Babban Sanarwa na Barrington, ko da yake bai yi karin haske ba.
Macedo da Lee musamman sun yi tir da tsawaita rufe makarantu, tare da lura da cewa yawancin makarantun Turai sun sake buɗewa a cikin bazara na 2020, ba tare da wata illa ba. Kafofin yada labarai na Amurka sun kyamaci bayar da rahoton hakan, in ji Macedo.
Ni kaina na shawarci tsohon gwamnan Indiana Mitch Daniels, wanda a cikin bazara na 2020 ya kasance shugaban Jami'ar Purdue. Ya so ya buɗe harabar makarantar a cikin faɗuwar 2020 kuma ya nemi tallafi mai ƙarfi. Mun tattara bayanan da ke nuna matasa suna cikin haɗarin kusan sifili, wanda ya dogara da shi a cikin Mayu 2020 don ƙarfin gwiwa. sanar, na farko a cikin dukkan manyan kwalejojin Amurka, cewa, a, Purdue zai sake buɗewa. A ƙarshen semester, Daniels ya bayyana cewa a babbar nasara.
Yawancin mahalarta taron AEI-Johns Hopkins sun yarda cewa makarantu sun daɗe a rufe. Ya zama kyakkyawan yarda ga waɗanda ke son amincewa da aƙalla wasu kuskuren manufofin Covid. Macedo ma ta amince da littafin David Zweig Yawaita Tsanani, wani mummunan rushewar rufe makarantu.
Duk da haka maraba, wannan shigar yana bayyana wani abu na "iyakantaccen hangout" - ƙaramin ikirari da ake buƙata don sake tabbatar da gaskiya yayin da yake kare manyan kurakurai masu zurfi daga fallasa da kuma ba da lissafi.
A Bad
Yayin da masana kimiyyar siyasa suka ba da sukar matsakaici game da kulle-kulle da tunanin rukuni, masana lafiyar jama'a da alama ba su koyi komai ba.
John Hellerstedt, tsohon Kwamishinan Lafiya na Texas, ya taƙaita halin. Lokacin da mai gudanarwa ya tambayi idan ya kamata a sami ƙarin "haɗin kai" zuwa madadin ra'ayi, Hellerstedt ya ƙi. "A gaskiya na damu da ra'ayin cewa ya kamata a yi muhawara, da a samu sabanin ra'ayi," in ji shi. "Dole ne wani ya yanke shawara."
Hellerstedt ya yaba wa gwamnan Texas Greg Abbott saboda "bai taba ja da baya kan kimiyya ba." Gwamnan ya ji ya yi yadda aka ce masa.
Sauran likitocin sun kasance suna zargin duk wani kuskuren da ba a fayyace ba akan gazawar “sadarwa” da “kungiyar.” Amma a wajen yaƙi, shin an taɓa samun mafi kyawun sadarwa ko tsari?
A cikin makwanni kaɗan, gungun likitocin kafofin watsa labaru sun shawo kan duniya ta rufe tare da shawo kan mutane cikin ayyukan ban dariya. Ka tuna da koren tsakiyar makarantar saxophone pods da bulldozed skate-parks? A cikin shekaru biyu, sun yi wa biliyoyin mutane allurar gwajin ƙwayoyin cuta na gaske.
“Saduwa” da “kungiyoyi” marasa kamala sau da yawa dabarun karkatar da tsarin mulki ne - duk wani abu don gujewa yarda cewa kun yi kuskure akan abu. a ilimin kimiyya.
Abin takaici, mahalarta AEI-Hopkins ba su yi kimiyya da yawa ba.
A zahiri, kusan ba a taɓa yin magana game da ilimin halitta, magani, ko bayanai ba. Babu wata muhawara kan umarnin rigakafin ko illolinsu. Babu ambaton ƙin yarda da jiyya da wuri tare da arha, aminci, magunguna na yau da kullun. Kawai taƙaitaccen ambaton CDC kuma babu ambaton FDA. Ba a ambaci binciken ƙwayar cuta mai fa'ida mai haɗari ba. Ba a ambaci yadda kato ba, ingantattun tsarin kiwon lafiya ke tsarkake likitocin kwarai da kuma fitar da injin Covid na sama.
Hakanan ba a ambaci hauhawar farashin dala tiriliyan 8 a cikin ƙarin kashe kuɗi na tarayya ba, wanda ya haɓaka tushen kasafin kuɗi na dindindin, kuma wanda, idan kulle-kulle ba su da tasiri, ba lallai ba ne.
Kusan sa'o'i uku da fara taron, Steven Teles, masanin kimiyyar siyasa a Johns Hopkins, ya yi kira ga takwarorinsa na taron don nuna gamsuwarsu.
"Ba na tsammanin yadda wannan littafin ya fusata a cikin wannan tattaunawar," in ji Teles. "Wannan littafi ne mai matukar bacin rai. Kuma a bisa ka'ida. Ina tsammanin akwai abubuwa da yawa da har yanzu ake kokarin yin watsi da yadda wannan al'umma ta yi hauka na wani lokaci."
Teles ya kasance mai ban sha'awa game da "yawan gazawar ƙwararrun waɗanda ba a sami sakamako ba" - daga Iraki zuwa Babban Rikicin Kuɗi zuwa Covid.
Idan AEI, Johns Hopkins, da sauran fitattun manufofi da cibiyoyin kimiyya suna fatan ba wai kawai su dawo da martaba ba amma kuma da gaske fahimtar abin da ya faru yayin Covid, dole ne su yi zurfi sosai. Abubuwan kimiyya na fasaha ne da zurfi.
Kuma idan kun fahimci yadda jami'an lafiyar jama'a da cibiyoyin kiwon lafiya suka yi mummunan aiki akan "kimiyya," za ku iya kammala gazawar neman gaskiya, fahimtarmu, da cibiyoyin dimokiradiyya sun fi muni fiye da yadda taron ya amince.
Kafin in ci gaba, yakamata in yarda da wasu mahallin da suka dace. A cikin 2013, na kafa shirin Binciken Fasaha a AEI. Shekaru 10, na yi nazarin manufofin Intanet da fasaha da yawa - semiconductor, bakan mara waya, tsaka tsaki na net, haɓaka yawan aiki, AI, da magana mai 'yanci, don suna kaɗan. Lokacin da na soki takunkumin Big Tech da manufofin Covid a cikin Yuli 2023 Wall Street Journal sharhin, duk da haka, AEI ta kore ni.
The Evidence
Yuval Levin ƙwararren masanin kimiyyar siyasa ne a AEI. Ya daidaita rukunin littafin farko tare da Macedo da Lee. Sanin cewa za a iya tattaunawa da yawa game da abin da ba daidai ba, ya fara taron da wata tambaya ta daban - Me muka samu daidai?
Macedo bai yi shakka ba. "Mu ba masu shakkar allurar ba ne," da sauri ya amsa. "Muna tsammanin allurar rigakafin alama ce ta nasara."
Wannan furci mai sauƙi ya tsaya a duk sauran taron, ba a ƙalubalanci ba kuma ba a bincika ba. Kawai zaci kuma maimaita.
Duwatsun shaidu sun ce a baya.
A cikin al'ummomin da aka yi wa alurar riga kafi sosai a duniya, duka biyun Covid da wadanda ba na Covid-19 sun mutu ba bayan an gabatar da harbe-harbe. A cikin 2021, Amurkawa sun ɗauki alluran rigakafi miliyan 520. Amma duk da haka mutuwar Covid-19 ta Amurka a cikin 2021 ta kasance 35% sama da na allurar rigakafin 2020. A Burtaniya, tsakanin Agusta 2021 da Maris 2022, 85% na duk mutuwar Covid na cikin waɗanda aka yi wa allurar. A cikin watanni da shekaru masu zuwa, allurar rigakafin ya kai sama da kashi 90% na mutuwar Covid ta Burtaniya.
Mutuwar da ba ta covid ba kuma ta ƙaru zuwa matakan da ba a taɓa yin irinsa ba. Matasa masu lafiya da masu matsakaicin shekaru sun jimre farkon shekarar cutar ta 2020 tare da nasara mai alaƙa. A cikin 2021, duk da haka, ba zato ba tsammani ya fara wahala cututtuka masu yawa (kuma sau da yawa masu mutuwa): ciwon zuciya, bugun jini, ciwon huhu, gazawar koda, har ma da cututtuka masu tsanani. Bayanan inshorar rai ba shi da tabbas.
A cikin ƙasashe daban-daban masu arziki a duk faɗin duniya, yawan mace-mace, wanda yayi sauƙi ko babu shi a cikin 2020, harbi a cikin 2021, 2022, da 2023. Jamus, Japan, Ireland, Singapore, Taiwan, Australia, Kanada, da Koriya ta Kudu - duk sun sami rashin lafiya sosai bayan isowar rigakafin.
A cikin 2021, matsayin nakasa ya fara haɓakar shekaru da yawa zuwa matakan tarihi. Daban-daban neuropathy yanayin autoimmune ya yi tashin gwauron zabo kamar ba a taɓa yin irinsa ba. Makulli na iya yin lissafin wani ɓangare na wannan faɗuwar lafiyar gabaɗaya. Amma lokaci da nau'ikan raunin da ya faru sun dace daidai da sanannun illolin rigakafin.
Wasu mahimman bayanai sun fito ne daga tsarin nakasa ta Burtaniya, wanda aka sani da PIP (Personal Independence Payments). Ed Dowd ya Abubuwan da aka bayar na Phineance Technologies shi ne ya fara haskaka shi.
Tun daga shekarar 2021, kusan kowane mai nuna alamar raunin rigakafin ya fara fashewa sama da shekaru da yawa. arrhythmias na zuciya da neuropathy kusan ninki uku. Ciwon huhu, har ma a cikin matasa, ya tashi 500%. Rashin lafiyar jini ya tashi da fiye da 400%. (Zamu iya lissafa ƙarin da yawa, kuma a zahiri, muna danganta anan zuwa da yawa Charts.) Gabaɗaya, adadin sabbin nakasassu na Biritaniya ya tashi daga matsakaicin matsakaicin matakin shekara a ƙarƙashin 500,000 zuwa sama da 750,000 a cikin 2022 da 2023.
Irin wannan mummunan yanayin ya taɓa Amurka, inda, daga 2021, adadin nakasassu ya karu da kusan miliyan 2.6, ko 45%.
A cikin yanayin da ba kasafai ba cewa jami'in kiwon lafiyar jama'a ko masu tsara manufofi sun fuskanci waɗannan alkalumman, yawanci suna yin la'akari da "dogon Covid" sannan kuma da sauri canza batun.
A gaskiya ma, akwai ɗan sirrin dalilin da ya sa hakan ke faruwa.
Muna da gawarwakin mutum. Muna da Rahoton shari'ar 4,000 da aka buga. Mun fahimci ƙananan ƙwayoyin cuta na waɗannan mutuwa da raunuka.
A takaice, a kan allurar rigakafi, biliyoyin nanoparticles na lipid nanoparticles masu ɗauke da gyare-gyaren mRNA suna shiga cikin kyallen jikin jiki. MRNA ta umurci sel ɗin ku don samar da furotin na Spike daga kwayar cutar SARS2 kuma a nuna shi a saman tantanin halitta. Tsarin rigakafin mu yana gano furotin na Spike na waje a matsayin mamaya mara maraba. Sa'an nan, kamar yadda yanayi ya yi niyya, ƙwayoyin lymphocytes masu kisa sun kai hari ga waɗancan sel masu “cututtuka” don halaka.
Idan waɗannan ƙwayoyin da aka lalata suna cikin tsokar ku na deltoid, kuna samun ciwon kafada. Pfizer cikin kuskure ya tabbatar mana da cewa shine mafi munin abin da zai faru. Sun kuma ce mRNA zai narke cikin kwana ɗaya ko biyu. Abin takaici, maganin yana yaduwa kuma yana canza sel a ko'ina. Yana iya tsayawa har tsawon watanni, ko shekaru. Idan tsarin garkuwar jikin ku yana kashe sel a cikin zuciyar ku, kwakwalwa, ko koda, sakamakon zai iya zama mummunan rauni ko mutuwa.
Masana kimiyya sun yi nuni da wannan cutar ta rigakafin mRNA da kyau bayanan salula. Ƙungiya ɗaya ta samo sunadarin Spike daga maganin rigakafi kuma ta kai hari ga ƙwayoyin T a cikin kwakwalwar wadanda suka kamu da bugun jini Watanni 17 bayan alurar riga kafi. Wani hoto mai girman gaske binciken, da aka buga a Yanayin Biotechnology, ya nuna cewa mRNA Spike ya kai ga nama na zuciya, yana haifar da "kunna garkuwar jiki da lalacewa ta hanyar jini." (Ga su 60 nunin faifai tare da tukwici da aka buga.)
A halin yanzu, ƙungiyar likitocin Turai, jagorancin marigayi Dr. Arne Burkhardt, an yi 75 gawarwakin mutum a kan Jamusawa da suka mutu jim kaɗan bayan yin rigakafi. Sun sami furotin na mRNA Spike duka da kuma kai hari ga lymphocytes a cikin kwakwalwa, huhu, zuciya, kodan, glanden adrenal, ovaries, testes, hanta, thyroid, prostate, splin, da jini manya da ƙanana, daga aorta zuwa capillaries.
Daga cikin 75 da suka mutu, sun yanke hukunci cewa aƙalla 58, ko 77%, sun mutu daga rigakafin mRNA. Talatin da daya daga cikin wadanda suka kamu da cutar sun mutu kwatsam - 16 daga lalacewa ta hanyar jini da 15 daga myocarditis. Kadan daga cikin wadanda abin ya shafa samari ne, wadanda ake zaton su kadai ne ke fama da cutar sankarau. Babu ɗayan lamuran da aka fara bayar da rahoton mutuwar allurar rigakafi, balle myocarditis, wanda ke taimakawa nuna ƙimar ƙima da ke haifar da ƙin yarda da cutar mRNA.
Wani labarin da ba a bayar da rahoto ba shi ne barkewar cutar koda tun bayan bullar rigakafin. John Beaudoin, injiniyan lantarki daga Massachusetts, ya sami fayilolin shaidar mutuwa ta dijital daga jihohi da yawa tun shekaru goma. Bayan sanannun bugun jini da lalacewar zuciya, ya sami sigina mafi ƙarfi na cutarwar alurar riga kafi - ƙimar astronomical na mummunan rauni na koda (AKI), wanda kuma aka sani da gazawar renal. Duba ginshiƙi na kusa na mutuwar koda a Florida.
Masana kimiyyar Koriya ta Kudu sun ɗauki sigina mai ƙarfi iri ɗaya. Sun duba rikodin miliyan 120 fiye da shekaru 50 kuma samu cutar koda da yawa da ke da alaƙa da rigakafin mRNA Covid - karuwa 138% a cikin matsanancin gazawar renal, haɓaka 1,241% a cikin glomerulonephritis, da haɓaka 143% a cikin tubulointerstitial nephritis.
Da yake fadada bincikensa zuwa duk jihohi 50, Beaudoin ya kiyasta cewa mutuwar koda kwatsam da ke da alaƙa da allurar Covid a cikin kusancin Amurka 250,000. Wannan yana nufin kusan miliyan 1.25 a duk duniya.
Shaida ta ci gaba da zubowa.
- Wani sabon nazari na zahiri daga Jamus, ta Christof Kuhbandner da Matthias Reitzner, sun sami "kyakkyawar dangantaka" tsakanin rigakafin Covid da kuma mace-mace. A cikin a binciken da ya gabata, sun nuna yawan mace-macen Jamusanci, bayan rashin jin daɗi na 2020, ya karu ga kusan dukkanin ƙungiyoyin shekaru a cikin 2021 da 2022 - wato, bayan an fara rigakafin.
- Kasar Japan da wasu kasashe da dama da aka yiwa allurar riga-kafi sun sha wahala kusan iri ɗaya (duba jadawali).
- Nazarin UK data ya gano cewa "idan aka kwatanta da marasa alurar riga kafi, alurar riga kafi tare da allurai guda ɗaya ko biyu sun nuna, a cikin lokacin Afrilu 2021-Mayu 2023, haɗarin da ke tattare da duk wani sanadi da mutuwar COVID-19."
- Masana kimiyar Najeriya suna kallo bayanan WHO na duniya ya sami "ƙarin haɓakawa a cikin mutuwar COVID-19 na duniya tare da ɗaukar rigakafin."
- Masu bincike na Italiya sun bincika duk mazauna 245,000 na lardin Pescara da samu Muhimman adadin haɗarin mace-mace na 2.40 (140% mafi muni) da 1.98 (98% mafi muni) ga waɗanda aka yiwa alurar riga kafi da allurai ɗaya da biyu, bi da bi, tare da waɗanda ba a yi musu allurar ba. Sun kammala: “An yi wa batutuwan alluran rigakafi biyu ya rasa kashi 37% na tsawon rai idan aka kwatanta da yawan mutanen da ba a yi wa allurar rigakafi ba yayin da aka yi la'akari da bi-bi-bi-bi."
Ba mu ma tattauna (1) mummunan gurɓatawar DNA na alluran mRNA guda biyu ba da haɗarin haɗar mai tallata SV40 a cikin maganin Pfizer; (2) yaduwa dysregulations na rigakafi, ciki har da "haƙuri na rigakafi" da "haƙuri" saboda IgG4 class-switching; ko (3) fashewar m cancers, mafi bayyana a cikin matasa masu lafiya. Matsalolin baya ƙarewa.
Gabaɗaya, rigakafin mRNA na iya haifar da mutuwar 500,000 zuwa 800,000 kai tsaye a cikin Amurka da miliyan 3-5 a duk duniya. An cutar da ƙarin dubun-dubatar.
Shin wani maganin rigakafi ya haifar da irin wannan kisan gilla? Shin AEI, Johns Hopkins, da manyan manufofin jama'a da al'ummomin kiwon lafiya suna sha'awar miliyoyin mutuwar da ba a san su ba? Suna iya yin hasashen illar da ke haifar da wasu dalilai. Amma shin bai kamata a kalla su yi nazari, muhawara, da ba da shawarar wasu zato ba?
Maimaitawa
Tsohon kwamishinan FDA Scott Gottlieb ya fito fili a cikin rashi daga taron na Nuwamba 6. Kafin barkewar cutar, Gottlieb ya bar FDA, ya shiga kwamitin gudanarwa na Pfizer, kuma ya koma AEI, inda ya kasance abokin aiki tun 2007.
Wataƙila babu wani jami'in kiwon lafiyar jama'a da ya cece Anthony Fauci da ya yi fice sosai wajen tura munanan manufofin cutar a cikin manyan saitunan. Mai ba da shawara ga tsawaita kulle-kulle, masking na wajibi na jarirai, da allurar rigakafi, Gottlieb ya rubuta wasu sharhin Covid 36 a cikin Wall Street Journal kuma ya yi wasu bayyanuwa 185 na talabijin akan CNBC da CBS's Fuskantar da Kasa. Shekaru da yawa a cikin Covid, mun koyi cewa Gottlieb ya yi haɗin gwiwa a asirce tare da Biden White House don cin zarafi ga kamfanonin Big Tech don yin la'akari da masu sukar maganin Pfizer.
Kamar yawancin masu gine-ginen bala'in Covid, duk da haka, Gottlieb ya ci gaba zuwa sabbin labarun kiwon lafiya, yayin da ake jiran lissafi.
-
Bret Swanson ɗan'uwa ne na Cibiyar Brownstone kuma shugaban kamfanin bincike na fasaha Entropy Economics LLC, babban ɗan'uwa a Cibiyar Kasuwancin Amurka, kuma ya rubuta Infonomena Substack.
Duba dukkan posts
