'Yan siyasa da 'yan jarida a wasu lokuta za su karkatar da ra'ayoyin abokan adawarsu sannan su yi jayayya da wadancan zato maimakon ra'ayi na gaske. Dabarar siyasa ce da ta jarida mai arha amma tasiri. Majiyoyin labarai na likitanci sun yi amfani da wannan dabarar yayin bala'in, tare da mummunan sakamako ga amincin jama'a ga lafiyar jama'a da magunguna.
The latest misali ya fito daga Medpage A Yau, shafin yanar gizon likitanci wanda ya shahara tsakanin likitoci. Yawancin likitocin suna samun bayanan cutar su daga Medpage A Yau.
Da zarar amintattun majiyoyin da suka ba da sabbin bayanan kiwon lafiya ta fuskoki daban-daban, shafukan yanar gizo na likitanci kamar Medpage A yau sun zama maganganun siyasa ga gwamnatocin da suka sanya manufofin kulle-kullen da ba su yi nasara ba wanda ya yi sanadiyar mutuwar mutane sama da 750,000 na Covid-XNUMX da kuma babbar barna.
Al'ummar da suka firgita da saƙon lafiyar jama'a sun rufe makarantu kuma sun tsallake kulawar likita wanda ke haifar da muni da cutar kansa, cututtukan zuciya, lafiyar hankali, da sakamakon ilimi. Makullin duniya ya jawo cutar ta tsawon lokaci.
Sweden da sauran ƙasashen Scandinavia sun aiwatar da ƙarin taƙaitaccen ƙuntatawa, suna mai da hankali maimakon kare tsofaffi, ƴan ƙasa masu haɗari. Sakamakon? Scandinavia yana da ƙarancin mace-mace na Covid fiye da sauran ƙasashen Turai da ƙarancin lahani. A cikin Amurka, Florida ta canza zuwa irin wannan hanyar, wanda ya haifar da ƙarancin mace-mace na Covid da aka daidaita shekaru fiye da matsakaicin ƙasa da ƙarancin lahani.
Duniyarmu a cikin Bayanai: An ba da rahoton mutuwar Covid a cikin Sweden da sauran ƙasashen Turai.
A cikin Oktoba 2020, tare da Sunetra Gupta na Jami'ar Oxford, mun rubuta Babban Sanarwar Barrington (GBD). Tare da shawarwari masu yawa na kankare, mun yi jayayya don ingantacciyar kariya ga tsofaffi masu haɗarin gaske yayin da muke barin ƙananan yara da matasa masu rauni su rayu kusa da rayuwar yau da kullun don rage haɗarin lafiyar jama'a. Namu hanya ce ta tsakiya tsakanin kulle-kulle da dabarun bari-shi-rip.
Abin takaici, Dr. Anthony Fauci da sauran jami'an gwamnatin Shugaba Trump (ceton Dr. Scott Atlas) sun kasa yin aiki da ra'ayinmu da gaske. Fauci ya lakafta dabarun kariyar da aka mayar da hankali kan GBD "zaman banza," yana mai da'awar ba zai yuwu a aiwatar da ingantattun matakan kare tsofaffi ba.
Lallai, kulle-kulle ba su kare tsofaffi ba; kusan kashi 80 Mutuwar COVID na cikin mutane 65 da sama da haka. Madadin haka, sun kare matasa, masu ƙarancin haɗari, ƙwararrun masu aiki daga gida kamar masu gudanarwa, 'yan jarida, da masana kimiyya.
A cikin labarin kwanan nan game da sababbin kafa Cibiyar Brownstone, Medpage A Yau yana ɗaukar wannan farfagandar kulle-kulle mataki ɗaya gaba ta hanyar yin iƙirarin ƙarya cewa GBD "ta inganta yaduwar COVID-19." Wannan kamar rashin gaskiya ne kamar da'awar cewa 'yan jaridun gida-gida sun inganta yaduwar Covid-19 ta hanyar ba da umarnin isar da pizza gida.
Medpage A Yau kuma ta yi iƙirarin ƙarya na Fadar White House da ta gabata "ta rungumi" Babban Sanarwar Barrington. Masana kimiyar lafiyar jama'a suna da hakki ga 'yan siyasa kowane iri. A ƙarshen watan Agusta 2020, mun sadu da Shugaba Trump, Mataimakin Shugaban kasa Pence, da sauransu a Fadar White House, ba tare da wani tasiri ba.
Gwamnatin tarayya da galibin gwamnonin sun ci gaba da dogaro da shawarar membobin Task Force na Fadar White House Drs. Deborah Birx da Fauci. Rashin mu don murkushe jami'an Fadar White House shine dalili daya da muka yanke shawarar rubuta Babban Sanarwar Barrington wata daya bayan haka.
Misali mafi haɗari na siyasa na labaran likitanci shine ƙoƙari na lalata abokan adawa da lakabin maganin rigakafi na ƙarya. Sabanin da'awar ta Medpage A Yau, fa'idodin rigakafin COVID sune "saurin m on da Brownstone yanar. "
Marubutan GBD guda uku duk sun yarda da alluran rigakafin, biyun suna da dogon aiki a matsayin masu binciken rigakafin, kuma babu wanda ya yada wani "bayanan rigakafin rigakafi." Don buga da'awar da ke yin zargin ƙarya cewa ƙungiyar rigakafin rigakafin tana da goyon bayan farfesa na likitanci da cututtukan cututtuka a Harvard, Stanford, da jami'o'in Oxford na yin illa ga amincin rigakafin. Irin wannan cajin na ƙarya bashi da alhaki sosai, yana lalata lafiyar jama'a, kuma bai cancanci Medepage a Yau ba.
Duk 'yan jarida na iya yin kuskure, amma Medpage A Yau ya ƙi gyara waɗannan kurakurai. Yawancin membobin kwamitin edita na likitoci da masana kimiyya, kamar Dr. Marty Makary da Dr. Vinay Prasad, sun rubuta kyawawan labarai yayin bala'in.
Wani abin mamaki shi ne hukumar editoci ba ta da wani cikakken bayani kan abin da ya kunsa a jarida, domin mun samu labarin cewa ma’aikatan editocin da ba na likitanci ba ne suka ki yin gyara na gaskiya. Kamar dai wanda ba masanin kimiyya ba Big Tech "Gaskiyar-Checkers" Hukumar Lafiya ta Duniya m masana kimiyyar kiwon lafiyar jama'a, 'yan jarida sun dauki nauyin yada bayanan likita, a makance suna bin umarnin Fauci.
Muna tsammanin siyasar labarun likitanci ya haifar da karuwa rashin amana a cikin lafiyar jama'a da kwararrun likitoci. Idan ana son inganta amincewar jama'a game da magani, wallafe-wallafen kasuwanci suna da alhakin samar da ingantattun bayanan likita da na kimiyya ta fuskoki daban-daban.
Mataki na farko ya kamata ya zama gyara kurakurai, ƙaramin takalifi na kowane aikin jarida mai ɗa'a. Mataki na biyu yana buƙatar ƙarin daidaiton rahoto game da cutar ta hanyar, alal misali, bayar da rahoto da gaskiya game da nasarar dabarun cutar da Florida da ƙasashen Scandinavia ke amfani da su. Madadin shine ci gaba da zubar da amana ga magunguna da lafiyar jama'a.
-
Martin Kulldorff masanin cututtukan cututtuka ne kuma masanin halittu. Shi Farfesa ne na Magunguna a Jami'ar Harvard (a kan hutu) kuma Fellow a Kwalejin Kimiyya da 'Yanci. Bincikensa ya mayar da hankali kan barkewar cututtuka da kuma lura da rigakafin rigakafi da amincin magunguna, wanda ya samar da SaTScan, TreeScan, da software na RSequential kyauta. Co-Marubucin Babban Sanarwa na Barrington.
Duba dukkan posts
-
