Asusun Kare 'Yanci na Lafiya (HFDF), Malaman California don 'Yancin Likitanci, da daidaikun masu shigar da kara sun yi nasarar daukaka karar su a zagaye na tara a kan Dokar Alurar rigakafin Ma'aikata ta LAUSD.
Asusun Tsaron 'Yancin Lafiya et. al, karkashin jagorancin ƙwararrun ƙungiyar lauyoyi na John Howard da Scott Street a JW Howard Attorneys, sun sami gagarumar nasara a zagaye na tara, wanda ya sauya korar karar da suka yi na kalubalantar manufar rigakafin tilas ta Los Angeles Unified School District ("LAUSD") ga duk ma'aikata.
Komawa shawarar da Babban Gundumar California ta Los Angeles, mafi rinjaye na tara ya ɗauka cewa, na farko, shari'ar ba ta haifar da soke dokar LAUSD ba bayan wata gardama ta baka a watan Satumbar da ya gabata, 2023. Mafi rinjaye sun kira wasan kwaikwayo na LAUSD don abin da ya kasance - yunƙurin fuskantar fuska na guje wa wani mummunan hukunci ta hanyar ƙoƙarin haifar da matsala.
Abin takaici ga LAUSD, sun riga sun yi wannan sau ɗaya a kotun shari'a. Yin amfani da koyaswar dakatarwa na son rai, yawancin sun yi shakkar gaskiyar LAUSD na soke wa'adin nan da nan bayan wata gardamar baka da ba ta dace ba a watan Satumba na bara.
A kan cancantar, yawancin sun yanke hukuncin cewa kotun gundumar ta yi amfani da hukuncin da Kotun Koli ta yanke a shekara ta 1905. Jacobson da Massachusetts lokacin da ta yi watsi da karar LAUSD bisa hujjar cewa wa'adin yana da alaƙa da hankali ga halaltacciyar maslaha ta ƙasa. A ciki Jacobson, Kotun Koli ta amince da kundin tsarin mulki na dokar rigakafin cutar sankara saboda yana da alaƙa da “hana yaɗuwar” cutar sankarau.
Yawancin, duk da haka, sun lura cewa HFDF ta yi zargin a cikin karar cewa Covid jabs ba rigakafin "gargajiya" bane saboda ba sa hana yaduwar Covid-19 amma kawai suna nufin rage alamun Covid a cikin mai karɓa. Wannan, HFDF ta yi zargin a cikin korafinta, ya sanya Covid jab magani ne, ba maganin rigakafi ba.
Kotun ta gane cewa rage alamun cutar maimakon hana yaduwar cutar “bambanta Jacobson, don haka gabatar da wata sha'awa ta gwamnati daban." Dangane da wannan dalili, yawancin sun ki amincewa da hujjar kotun da ke shari'ar cewa, ko da jabs ba su hana yaduwar ba, "Jacobson har yanzu yana ba da shawarar cewa umarnin rigakafin yana ƙarƙashin, kuma yana tsira, gwajin tushe na ma'ana."
Kotun ta ce “[t] ya yi kuskure Jacobson,” wanda “ba ta ƙunshi da’awar da aka yi amfani da allurar da aka tilasta ‘tsara don rage bayyanar cututtuka a cikin masu karɓar rigakafin cutar maimakon hana yaɗuwa da kamuwa da cuta ba.”’ Jacobson ba, yawancin sun kammala, ya kai ga “maganin tilastawa” don amfanin mai karɓa.
Kotun ta ki bayar da duk wata magana ga sanarwar da CDC ta yi cewa "alurar rigakafin Covid-19 suna da aminci da tasiri." Kamar yadda kotu ta yi tambaya cikin rarrabuwar kawuna, “lafiya da inganci” ga me? Yawancin sun yi nuni ga zargin HFDF cewa CDC ta canza ma'anar "alurar rigakafi" a cikin Satumba 2021, tare da buga kalmar "kariya" daga wannan ma'anar. Kotun ta kuma lura da ambaton HFDF ga bayanan CDC cewa allurar ba ta hana yaduwa ba, kuma rigakafi na halitta ya fi alluran rigakafin.
A wata ma'amala ta daban, Alkali Collins ya rubuta cewa kotun gundumar "ta kara yin kuskure ta hanyar kasa fahimtar cewa zargin (HFDF) yana nuna wani yanki na Kotun Koli na kwanan nan" don ba da shawarar cewa "wanda ya cancanta yana da sha'awar 'yanci ta tsarin mulki na ƙin yarda da magani maras so [.]" Yana ambaton hukuncin Kotun Koli. Washington da Glucksberg, Alkali Collins ya lura cewa 'yancin ƙin yarda da magani maras so ya yi daidai da tarihin wannan ƙasa da al'adun tsarin mulki," da kuma zargin HFDF a cikin wannan harka "sun isa don kiran wannan haƙƙin na asali."
Hukuncin zagaye na tara a yau ya nuna cewa kotu ta ga ta hanyar kasuwancin biri na LAUSD, kuma ta yin haka, ta bayyana a sarari cewa haƙƙin da Amurka ke da shi na yancin kai, gami da haƙƙin yancin cin gashin kai na jiki a cikin lamuran lafiya, ba za a iya sasantawa ba. Wannan babban nasara ce ga gaskiya, ladabi, da abin da yake daidai.
-
Leslie Manookian, MBA, MLC Hom shugaba ne kuma wanda ya kafa Asusun Kare 'Yanci na Lafiya. Ita tsohuwar shugabar kasuwancin Wall Street ce mai nasara. Aikinta na kudi ya dauke ta daga New York zuwa London tare da Goldman Sachs. Daga baya ta zama Darakta na Alliance Capital a Landan suna gudanar da ayyukan Gudanar da Fayil na Ci gaban Turai da Bincike.
Duba dukkan posts
