Sakonnin leken asiri daga Disamba 13, 2020, sun nuna tsohon Sakataren Lafiya na Burtaniya Matt Hancock yana shirin "tura sabon bambance-bambancen" a cikin saƙon Covid don "firgita wando daga kowa" don "samu canjin halayya mai kyau" a cikin bin jama'ar Birtaniyya da matakan kullewa.
Sabon yoyon shine mafi munin wahayi da zai zo ya zuwa yanzu daga cikin Jaridar Daily Telegraph kwanan nan-sanarwa'Fayilolin Kullewa,' wanda ya samo asali ne daga tarin saƙonni sama da 100,000 da aka aika tsakanin Hancock da sauran jami'ai. 'Yar jarida Isabel Oakeshott da alama ta sami saƙonnin WhatsApp don taimakawa tare da wani littafi game da Hancock, wanda ya ƙunshi mafi girman bayanan gwamnatin Burtaniya cikin sama da shekaru goma da kuma ba da sabon haske game da kulle-kullen Burtaniya, umarni, da aika saƙon tsoro.
Kamar yadda tangarahu taƙaitaccen:
Fayilolin Lockdown - sama da saƙonnin WhatsApp 100,000 da aka aika tsakanin ministoci, jami'ai da sauransu - sun nuna yadda Gwamnati ta yi amfani da dabarun tsoratarwa don tilasta bin doka da turawa ta hanyar kulle-kulle.
A cikin wani sakon Simon Case, Sakataren Majalisar, ya ce "babban tsoro/laifi" yana da "muhimmanci" a "inganta saƙon" a lokacin. kulle kasa ta uku a watan Janairu 2021.
A watan da ya gabata, Hancock, sakataren lafiya na lokacin, ya bayyana yana ba da shawarar a cikin sakon daya cewa sabon nau'in Covid da ya bulla kwanan nan zai taimaka wajen shirya kasa don kulle-kullen, ta hanyar. tsoratar da mutane wajen bin doka.
A wata tattaunawa ta WhatsApp a ranar 13 ga Disamba, wanda ya samu tangarahu, Damon Poole - daya daga cikin masu ba da shawara kan harkokin yada labarai na Mista Hancock - ya sanar da maigidansa cewa 'yan majalisar Tory sun "fusata da fatan" matakan tsauraran matakai na Covid kuma ya ba da shawarar "za mu iya jujjuya filin tare da sabon nau'in."
Sharhin ya ba da shawarar cewa sun yi imanin cewa nau'in na iya taimakawa wajen shirya ƙasa don kulle-kullen nan gaba da tsauraran hani yayin da ake zuwa Kirsimeti 2020.
Daga nan Mista Hancock ya amsa da cewa: "Muna tsoratar da wando ga duk wanda ke da sabon nau'in."
Mista Poole ya yarda, yana mai cewa: "Eh shine abin da zai sami canji mai kyau na bahviour [sic]."
Masana ilimin halayyar dan adam sun riga sun yi gargadin cewa wasu saƙon Gwamnati yayin Covid, gami da yin amfani da zargin "dabarun tsoro" a cikin fastoci da kamfen na kiwon lafiya, sun kasance "marasa ɗa'a sosai" kuma hakan ya haifar da matakan tsoro ya ba da gudummawa ga yawan mace-mace marasa Covid da kuma ƙara tashin hankali…
Bayan watanni hudu, a cikin Oktoba 2020, Mista Poole ya ba da shawarar a cikin wata tattaunawa ta rukuni cewa yanke shawarar dakatar da buga jerin abubuwan da ake kira jerin sunayen wuraren da cutar ta fi kamari zai taimaka wa Gwamnati, saboda hakan zai sa kowane yanki na kasar ya damu da yaduwar Covid a karo na biyu.
"Yana taimakawa labarin cewa abubuwa sun yi muni sosai idan ba mu buga ba," in ji Mista Poole.
A cikin labarin na biyu kan sabon wahayi, da tangarahu ya ci gaba:
A duk tsawon lokacin barkewar cutar, jami'ai da ministoci sun koka kan yadda za a tabbatar da cewa jama'a sun bi dokar hana kulle-kullen da ke canzawa koyaushe. Daya makami a cikin ma'ajiyar su tsoro ne.
"Muna tsoratar da wando daga kowa," Matt Hancock ya ba da shawarar yayin wani sakon WhatsApp tare da mai ba shi shawara kan harkokin yada labarai.
Sakataren lafiya na lokacin ba shi kadai a cikinsa sha'awar tsoratar da jama'a don bin doka. Saƙonnin WhatsApp da aka gani tangarahu nuna yadda da yawa daga cikin tawagar Mista Hancock suka tsunduma cikin wani nau'in "Tsoron Aikin," wanda a cikinsa suka yi magana game da yadda ake amfani da "tsoro da laifi" don sa mutane su yi biyayya ga kulle-kulle.
Wani bincike na Kwalejin Imperial na London game da cututtukan Covid a cikin al'umma - wanda ake kira shirin React da jagoranci ta fitaccen farfesa Lord Darzi - ya ba da labarai "tabbatacce" ga Mista Hancock da tawagarsa… Amma lokacin da kafofin watsa labarai suka mayar da hankali kan wani rahoton daban na Kiwon Lafiyar Jama'a na Ingila da Jami'ar Cambridge da ke nuna yawan watsawa a wasu sassan kasar - lamarin da ya haifar da jita-jitar cewa kulle-kullen cikin gida na iya biyo baya - Mista Hancock ya ce: "Wannan ba wani abu ba ne." Sir Patrick Vallance, Babban Mashawarcin Gwamnati kan Kimiyyar Kimiyya, ya yarda.
Tare da rikodin shari'o'in Covid yanzu zuwa 689 kawai, Gwamnati ta rage kwanaki sake buɗe mashaya, gidajen abinci da wuraren gyaran gashi.
Amma a ranar 30 ga Yuni 2020, Leicester ta shiga cikin kulle-kullen gida. A cikin wata kungiya ta WhatsApp da ake kira "Kwamitin Aiki na gida," Emma Dean, mai ba da shawara na musamman na Mista Hancock kan manufofi, ya ba da rahoto ga kungiyar wani jita-jita cewa Milton Keynes na iya zama gari na gaba da ya shiga cikin kulle-kullen gida.
Jamie Njoku-Goodwin, mashawarcin Mista Hancock kan harkokin yada labarai, ya amsa da cewa ba zai zama "mara amfani" ba ga jama'a su yi tunanin za su iya zama na gaba.
Sun yarda cewa ƙananan gyare-gyare, kamar hana angling, za su zama "parodied galore" - don haka yanke shawarar cewa “Tsoro” da/ko “laifi” kayan aiki ne masu mahimmanci wajen tabbatar da bin doka.
Suka tattauna yin abin rufe fuska wajibi ne a cikin "duk saituna" saboda yana da "tasiri a bayyane sosai."
Tare da yaƙin neman zaɓen ta'addancin Hancock akwai wasu bayyananniyar buɗe ido da dama. A cikin wata tattaunawa guda, Firayim Minista Boris Johnson ya ƙi ɗaukar hane-hane bayan an gaya masa cewa sake buɗewa shine "yayi nisa kafin ra'ayin jama'a. "
Daga baya Johnson ya nuna nadama game da shawarar da ya yanke na aiwatar da kulle-kulle na biyu bayan an sanar da shi cewa an kafa shawarar ne bisa "ba daidai ba” bayanan mutuwa.
A wani lamarin kuma, an sanya wa yaran makarantar Biritaniya takunkumin rufe fuska a karon farko bayan babban jami’in kula da lafiya Chris Whitty ya ce batun shine "bai cancanci jayayya ba"tare da Ministan Farko na Scotland da kuma mai ba da shawara na kulle-kulle Nicola Sturgeon.
Ta kowane ma'auni, da Telegraph's Fayilolin Lockdown suna ba da sabon haske mai ƙima da ban mamaki game da zurfin da Gwamnatin Burtaniya da takwarorinta a duk faɗin duniya suka nutse yayin da suke auna fahimtar waɗannan matakan da ba a taɓa gani ba, marasa ilimin kimiyya, marasa amfani a kan ra'ayin ɓangaren jama'a da ke ƙara firgita da tashin hankali na jama'a waɗanda ke ci gaba da neman ƙari daga cikinsu, yayin da suke neman ƙarin dabaru. na jama'a don yin biyayya.
Har yanzu, masu sukar lamarin tangarahu suna da ingantattun dalilai na shakku. Yayin da tangarahu ya bayyanar da hujjoji masu ban mamaki abin da Ya faru yayin martanin Covid na Biritaniya, bayan rufewar farko na bazara na 2020, har yanzu ba a bayyana wani bayani game da dalilin da ya sa waɗancan makullin farko sun faru.
Wannan babban sa ido ne, kamar yadda jaridar Telegraph da kanta, da yawancin 'yan jaridunta, suka goyi bayan kulle-kullen farko na bazara na 2020. Bugu da ƙari, kamar yadda wani binciken da Jami'ar Cardiff ya nuna, farkon abin da yawancin 'yan ƙasa suka yanke hukunci barazanar Covid ita ce shawarar da gwamnatinsu ta yanke na sanya tsauraran matakan kulle-kulle. Matakan don haka sun haifar da madaidaicin martani wanda kulle-kullen da kansu suka shuka tsoron da ya sanya 'yan kasar su yi imani da hadarin mutuwa daga Covid ya ninka sau ɗaruruwan fiye da yadda yake da gaske, wanda hakan ya sa su ba da ƙarin tallafi, umarni, da hani.
Don haka, masu sharhi masu tunani tayi imani cewa yanke shawarar yadda aka yanke shawarar farko na kulle-kullen a cikin bazara na 2020 ya kasance mafi mahimmancin tambaya game da duk labarin Covid. Komai ya kasance a ƙasa daga ta'addancin da ba a taɓa yin irinsa ba wanda wannan shawarar ta farko ta shuka. Kuma, saboda ana iya amfani da ta'addanci da yawa a matsayin uzuri ga duk shawarar da ta biyo baya, ayyukan da ya haifar da kullewar farko yanke shawara a cikin bazara 2020 na iya zama kaɗai a ciki aikata laifuka mai yiwuwa a samu.
Don haka, gwargwadon yadda tangarahu ya kasa ba da haske kan ayyukan da suka haifar da kulle-kulle na farko a cikin bazara na 2020, ƙimar Fayilolin Lockdown don samun adalci ga martani ga Covid za a iyakance shi sosai.
Wannan ya ce, wasu daga cikin Telegraph's wahayi na abin da ya faru-kamar sha'awar Hancock na "aikar da sabon bambance-bambancen" don " tsoratar da wando daga jama'a" - yana da matukar damuwa da fatan jama'a za su fara ɗaukar tambayar da mahimmanci. dalilin da ya sa wannan duka ya faru.
An sake bugawa daga marubucin Mayarwa
-
Michael P Senger lauya ne kuma marubucin Man Maciji: Yadda Xi Jinping Ya Rufe Duniya. Tun daga Maris 19 ya kasance yana binciken tasirin jam'iyyar kwaminisanci ta kasar Sin game da martanin da duniya ke bayarwa game da COVID-2020, kuma a baya ya rubuta kamfen yada farfagandar kulle-kulle ta duniya da The Masked Ball of Cowardice a cikin Mujallar Tablet.
Duba dukkan posts
