Idan ba ku ji labarin wannan labarin da Nick Shirley da David suka gano kwanan nan ba, kuna buƙatar yin hakan. Kuna iya kallon cikakken shirin bidiyo ta danna hoton da ke ƙasa. Mutane sama da miliyan 38 ne suka kalli shi, wanda ya ninka adadin jarin da 'yan kasuwa na bogi - kamar cibiyoyin kula da yara - 'yan Somaliya ke "sarrafawa" da masu biyan haraji na Amurka ke karɓa ta hanyar zamba. Wannan ba wariyar launin fata ba ne - gaskiya ne.
An yi tambayoyi masu sauƙi a duk tsawon tafiyar: Ina yaran suke? Ina duk kuɗin ke tafiya?
Me ya sa wani ɗan ƙasar Somaliya da suka yi hira da shi bai san abin da kasuwancinsa ke yi ba? Kuma me ya sa suke da ƙarfi haka?
Tsaro sosai?
A cikin wannan labarin, ina so in mayar da hankali kan gamuwa hakan ya faru ne a ƙarshen bidiyon. Ina da tabbacin cewa sabuntawar majalisar ce ta faru a ranar 19 ga Disamba, 2025 a Majalisar Dokokin Jihar Minnesota. Idan ka danna hanyar haɗin taron ka je shafin yanar gizon, za ka ga cewa sakin layi na farko ya faɗi kamar haka:
Makonni kaɗan da suka gabata sun kasance da wahala ga al'ummarmu da ke Minneapolis da kewaye da Minnesota, waɗanda aka yi musu kallon kalaman ƙiyayya daga Donald Trump da kuma ayyukan da ba su dace ba daga wakilansa na tarayya [ICE]. A bayyane yake, yin batanci ga maƙwabtanmu 'yan Somaliya da Latino da kuma keta haƙƙin kundin tsarin mulki na 'yan Minnesota a matsayin ikirari ga ayyukan tilastawa na ICE da keta haƙƙoƙin jama'a ba wai game da tsaron jama'a ba ne. An yi nufin haifar da tsoro, rudani, da rarrabuwar kawuna.1
Daga inda nake tsaye a matsayin mai lura da manufofin da ba sa rikici, kuma ba ni da masaniya sosai game da 'yan Majalisar Dokokin Minnesota, kalaman da ke sama suna da zafi sosai, kuma suna da matuƙar rarrabuwar kawuna. Bayan na kalli hulɗar da ke tsakanin Nick da David da mutanen Somaliya da suka yi ƙoƙarin yi wa tambayoyi, da kuma harin wuka da mazan Somaliya suka kai wa David, na yi ƙarfin halin cewa bayan abin da ya faru, "labarin ƙarya" ne kawai.
A cewar Nick, a wannan taron, 'yan jam'iyyar Republican sun nuna a fili cewa ana ci gaba da zamba a Minnesota tare da bayanai da jadawali a matsayin kayan aikin gani, da kuma wanda ke cin gajiyar wannan zamba. An nuna wa membobin kwamitin takardar bayani - idan za ku iya -. Kamar yadda Nick ya lura, wakilan jam'iyyar Democrat "sun duba cikin ramin" yayin da aka isar da bayanan, yayin da musamman daya, na Majalisar Wakilai ta Minnesota Emma Greenman, ya kare zargin zamba ta hanyar bayyana cewa zamba batu ne da ba na jam'iyya ba, kuma cewa ayyana (tare da shaidar) zamba "ba gina aminci ba ne."
Ayyukan kwamitinta sun haɗa da zama Mataimakin Shugaba Ma'aikata, Ma'aikata, da Ci gaban Tattalin Arziki Kuɗi da Siyasay, Kuɗi da 'Yan Sanda na Tsaron Jama'ay, Kuɗin Zaɓe da Ayyukan Gwamnati kuma na karshe amma ba kadan ba Tsarin Rigakafin Zamba da Tsarin Kula da Hukumar JihaLauya ce mai digiri na farko a fannin kimiyyar siyasa da kuma digiri na MPA a "mulkin gwamnati."
Idan ka duba cikin Jawabin da Emma ta fitar a hukumance a Majalisar Wakilai ta Minnesota daga ranar 14 ga Fabrairu, 2025, A bayyane yake daga rubutun cewa tana matukar adawa da Trump. Kanun farko kamar haka:
"Kare Minnesota daga Ayyukan da ba su da kyau da kuma marasa kyau na Gwamnatin Trump”.
A cikin wannan batu, ta yi nuni da "tashin hankalin da Shugaba Trump, Mataimakin Shugaban Kasa JD Vance, Elon Musk, da majalisar ministocinsa masu kuɗi ke yi a kullum [wanda] aka tsara don sanya wa Amurkawa rauni da kuma raunana imaninmu ga cibiyoyin dimokuradiyya da kuma bin doka da oda".
Tsarin doka, ko? To me za a ce game da zamba? Shin zamba ba ya ƙunshe da yaudara da gangan don samun fa'ida, yawanci kuɗi, wanda gwamnati za ta iya gurfanarwa a gabanta a ƙarƙashin dokokin jiha da na tarayya?2
Tana kuma nufin MAGA a matsayin "tsari" na "tsanani" a cikin Sabuntawa kan Dokoki: daga 14 ga Fabrairu, 2025.
Da wannan yarjejeniya, mun hana 'yan Republican na Majalisar Wakilai jefa ƙuri'u ga masu zaɓe na Shakopee 21,980 don aiwatar da ajandarsu ta MAGA mai tsauri.
Ina so in gode wa duk wanda ya yi magana a kan kwace iko na jam'iyyar Republican ta MAGA a Minnesota, kuma yana tsayawa tsayin daka kan dimokuradiyya da bin doka kowace rana.3
Za ku lura a ƙarshen bidiyon Nick da ke sama, cewa a taron da aka gudanar a ranar 19 ga Disamba, 2025, Wakili Greenman ya sami kyakkyawar fahimta game da zamba da ake ci gaba da yi a yanzu. Nick ya tunkare ta don ya tunkare ta kan gaskiyar cewa a cikin kwana ɗaya, shi da David sun gano dala miliyan 111,000,000 na kuɗin masu biyan haraji - waɗanda aka karɓa aka yi amfani da su don ayyukan da "cibiyoyin kula da yara na Somaliya" ba su bayar ba.
Nick ya kasance mai mayar da hankali sosai kuma ya balaga a tsarinsa, kuma kawai ya bayyana wa Greenman matsalar: Akwai zamba da ake yi kuma ba wai ba ta goyon bayan jam'iyya ba ce.
Kana ganin cewa zamba tana faruwa ne?
Kafin in ci gaba da "amsoshinta," ina so in nuna cewa zamba laifi ne na Tarayya.4,5 Bugu da ƙari, ba da damar yin zamba ta hanyar rashin aiwatar da ayyukan zamba da aka sani, samar da kariya ga rashin da'a, ko sauƙaƙe tsare-tsare na iya zama abin ɗaukar nauyi idan ayyukan sun cika sharuɗɗan zamba, cin hanci, ko wasu laifukan tarayya a ƙarƙashin 18 USC § 201.6
Bugu da ƙari, idan zamba ta ƙunshi sama da dala miliyan ɗaya (1,000,000), to ana la'akari da hakan manyan zamba kuma eh, wannan tabbas laifi ne na Tarayya.
Dokokin Tarayya 18 USC § 1031, wanda aka sani da Babban Dokar Zamba ta 1988, ta haramta makircin zamba na Amurka ko samun kuɗi ko kadarori ta hanyar karya ko zamba a cikin kowace tallafi, kwangila, ƙaramin kwangila, rance, garanti, inshora, ko wani nau'in tallafin tarayya wanda darajarsa ta kai sama da dala miliyan 1.7
Emma Greenman ta fara mayar da martani ga Nick da farko tana cewa ba ta san ko wanene shi ba, maimakon ta gaishe shi, ko kuma ta amsa tambayarsa. A matsayinta na wakiliyar Jihar Minnesota, ina tsammanin za ta fi ƙwarewa a mu'amalarta da jama'a - hakika tana zuwa wurinta da tambayoyi masu inganci. Nick ya amsa da sauri ta hanyar faɗin sunansa kawai - yana jin haushin matsayinta na rashin kunya.
Ta yi tafiyarta daga gare shi.
Ya ci gaba da yin tambayoyi masu dacewa game da dalilin da ya sa wani ya kamata ya ba da damar yin zamba, ko kuma idan tana tunanin cewa zamba tana faruwa kwata-kwata - ko dai a ƙarƙashin kulawar 'yan Republican da/ko Democrat.
"Zamba zamba ce," kamar yadda Nick ya faɗa, kuma ya maimaita cewa ba batun da ba na jam'iyya ba ne.
Emma ta amsa:
Ban tsammanin kowa yana ba da damar yin zamba. Emma Greenman
Wani mutum mai sha'awar da ya ba da shaida a taron kwamitin - mai fafutukar kare nakasa - ya ci gaba da yin wasu tambayoyi masu dacewa game da dalilin da ya sa ba ta yin hakan. Tim Walz Ta kuma yi masa rashin kunya sosai.
Kawai sai ya tambaye ta:
Yaushe za ka ɗora wa Gwamna Walz alhakin wannan? [Ka] wakili ne na Jihar Minnesota, eh ko a'a?
Ta farka a hankali sannan ta mayar masa da martani kamar haka:
'Ka yi haƙuri? Idan za ka yi min magana haka? … da sauransu…
Wannan wata alama ce bayyananniya da ke nuna cewa za ta fi son ta yi kamar ta ɓata wa wani mutum rai da tambaya mai inganci maimakon ta amsa tambayar da ba ta da zafi: Shin kai wakili ne na Jihar Minnesota?
Emma ta sa wata mata da ba a ambaci sunanta ba ta kare kanta a lokacin wannan musayar ra'ayi. Mace da ba a ambaci sunanta ba ta yi ƙoƙarin kare kanta lokacin da mai fafutukar kare nakasa ya nemi amsar tambayoyinsa daga Emma. Yadda ta yi ƙoƙarin shiga abin lura ne: cike da murmushin da ba shi da gaskiya wanda aka tsara don rage kumburi (ba don jawo farin ciki, farin ciki, ko natsuwa ba), da kuma hannun dama da aka miƙa tare da shiga gaba. Harshen jikinta yana ba da labari mai haske.
Na gode da bayar da shaida a yau … uh…
Duk da haka, wannan musayar ta kasance a baya don ci gaba da 'musanya' tsakanin Emma da Nick.
Emma ta tafi ta tattara kayanta yayin da Nick ya ci gaba da yi mata tambayar da ta dace: Me yasa gwamnati ke ba da damar yin zamba? Sai ta nuna cewa bai saurari zaman sauraron shari'o'insu ba, kuma ta umarce shi da ya gaya masa cewa sun yi zaman sauraren ƙara sau 10 kan zamba kuma "akwai bayanai masu kyau daga mutanen da ke aiki a cikin gwamnati - duka 'yan Democrat da na Republican." Bayanai masu kyau kwarai da gaske! Kai! Yana kama da ... babu komai.
Nick ya yi daidai da wannan a cikin wani yunƙuri na jajircewa don dakatar da yunƙurinta na ɗora alhakin hakan ga (har ma da wani ɓangare) 'yan Republican:
Wannan zamba ta faru ne a zamanin shugaban jam'iyyar Democrat Tim Walz.
Ta mayar da martani ta hanyar yin suka ga Trump - tana zarginsa da laifin duk wani zamba da ake yi a yanzu.
Ta ƙi amsa tambayoyinsa kai tsaye. Ta yi magana da ƙarfi sosai game da abin da zan kira lafazi da salati kawai. Har ma Nick ya sake yin magana a wani lokaci.
Shirin ya ƙare da mai fafutukar kare nakasa yana faɗin a bayyane:
Mutanena suna shan wahala. Ina jin tsoron ƙanina kuma waɗannan mutanen sun yi tafiyarsu. Muna da Gwamna wanda ba ya damuwa da shi. Mutane nawa ne za a yi safarar su a cikin tsarinmu na ban mamaki?
Kuma wannan, abokaina, shine babban al'amari.
Mutane suna buƙatar zuwa gidan yari.
1 https://www.house.mn.gov/members/profile/news/15552/41085
2 https://dictionary.findlaw.com/definition/fraud.html
3 https://www.house.mn.gov/members/Profile/News/15552/40105
4 https://www.gao.gov/blog/fraud-and-its-consequences-who-steals-federal-programs-and-whats-cost
5 https://www.thefederalcriminalattorneys.com/major-fraud
6 https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?path=/prelim@title18/part1/chapter11&edition=prelim
7 https://www.criminaldefenselawyer.com/crime-penalties/federal/federal-fraud.htm
An sake bugawa daga marubucin Mayarwa
-
Dokta Jessica Rose ma'aikaciyar Cibiyar Brownstone ce kuma tana da BSc. a cikin Ƙwararren Lissafi, MSc. a cikin Immunology, PhD a cikin Biology na Kwamfuta da alƙawura biyu na digiri na biyu a cikin Kwayoyin Halitta da Biochemistry. Jessica tana aiki don wayar da kan jama'a game da bayanan VAERS.
Duba dukkan posts
